₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,862 members, 8,519,874 topics. Date: Monday, 16 November 2026 at 11:59 PM

Toggle theme

Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer (2141 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op):
If you say that Tinubu’s proposed VAT reform will be better for states like Abia generating very little in VAT compared to states like Lagos, it means you fully understand this VAT reform, so this should be easy for you to answer.

In August 2024, Abia generated N663 million in VAT but they received N5 billion after the VAT revenue was shared among all states.

Since the new VAT proposal is supposed to help states like Abia receive more VAT revenue, tell me, for the month of August, rather than generate only N663 million, how much (estimated) would Abia have generated if companies had paid VAT to Abia and not their headquarters in Lagos? And how much would Abia have received after sharing the revenue among states based on this new proposal?

Since you fully understand this VAT reform and claim that this new bill helps states generate and earn more VAT revenue, please answer this simple question.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op):
Here is my post about how the newly proposed VAT revenue sharing compares with oil revenue sharing

https://www.nairaland.com/8284004/how-proposed-vat-revenue-sharing
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by caleboxylic: 9:43am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
If you say that Tinubu’s proposed VAT reform will be better for states like Abia generating very little in VAT compared to states like Lagos, it means you fully understand this VAT reform, so this should be easy for you to answer.

In August 2024, Abia generated N663 million in VAT but they received N5 billion after the VAT revenue was shared among all states.

Since the new VAT proposal is supposed to help states like Abia receive more VAT revenue, tell me, for the month of August, rather than generate only N663 million, how much would Abia have generated if companies had paid VAT to Abia and not their headquarters in Lagos? And how much would Abia have received after sharing the revenue among states based on this new proposal?

Since you fully understand this VAT reform and claim that this new bill helps states generate and earn more VAT revenue, please answer this simple question.
Vat will no longer be centralised as we have it now. VAT will be paid by consumers at the point of consumption, and not companies/manufacturers paying from source.
Abia will generate more, likewise Anambra, kano and rivers. Lagos VAT will be reduced as most companies will pay states before dropping any products manufactured in different states.

My only fear on this VAT is double taxation as Lagos will force the company to pay, likewise the receiving states and also consuming states.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 9:43am On Dec 03, 2024
nlfpmod can you help me find someone who can answer this question?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 9:45am On Dec 03, 2024
caleboxylic:
Vat will no longer be centralised as we have it now. VAT will be paid by consumers at the point of consumption, and not companies/manufacturers paying from source.
Abia will generate more, likewise Anambra, kano and rivers. Lagos VAT will be reduced as most companies will pay states before dropping any products manufactured in different states.

My only fear on this VAT is double taxation as Lagos will force the company to pay, likewise the receiving states and also consuming states.
We have all heard these sentiments over and over, but your answer shows you don’t fully understand the bill yourself, because you can’t answer the question. So why the hurry to pass a bill you don’t fully understand?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by aswani(m): 9:48am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
If you say that Tinubu’s proposed VAT reform will be better for states like Abia generating very little in VAT compared to states like Lagos, it means you fully understand this VAT reform, so this should be easy for you to answer.

In August 2024, Abia generated N663 million in VAT but they received N5 billion after the VAT revenue was shared among all states.

Since the new VAT proposal is supposed to help states like Abia receive more VAT revenue, tell me, for the month of August, rather than generate only N663 million, how much would Abia have generated if companies had paid VAT to Abia and not their headquarters in Lagos? And how much would Abia have received after sharing the revenue among states based on this new proposal?

Since you fully understand this VAT reform and claim that this new bill helps states generate and earn more VAT revenue, please answer this simple question.
The new bill gives Abia state the impetus to go and find ways to get even more VAT for themselves instead of taking a share from a central pot.

With proper planning, focus, thinking outside the box and direction, Abia could be pulling in more than that 5 billion.

The current system allows for extreme laziness knowing you don't have to lift a finger to receive 5billion.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 9:50am On Dec 03, 2024
aswani:
The new bill gives Abia state the impetus to go and find ways to get even more VAT for themselves instead of taking a share from a central pot.

With proper planning, focus, thinking outside the box and direction, Abia could be pulling in more than that 5 billion.

The current system allows for extreme laziness knowing you don't have to lift a finger to receive 5billion.
I understand all what you’re expressing here. But I need an answer to the question. The thing is how you guys are supporting this bill without fully understanding it. You can’t even answer this question. So why the hurry?

You talk about extreme laziness, do you know that Abia is an oil producing state? After distributing most of their oil revenue among FG and states like Lagos and Kano based on population and other factors, you now want high VAT generating states like Lagos to keep most of their VAT and call states like Abia lazy. Is that fair?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Bobodee09: 9:57am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
So far nobody has been able to answer this simple question but they’re all claiming the reform will favor states generating less in VAT like Abia.
This were answers lies.

The governors against this bills are only fighting against one thing......New sharing formula

Non is against the increase in VAT percentage...they aren't against citizens paying more.
They are only fighting for there own pockets and not you.

The more people in abia state consume goods that are VAT on it, the more money for abia government at the end of the month.....simple as ABC
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by psucc(m): 9:58am On Dec 03, 2024
There's no way such question can be answered with figures because
1. no one can actually know the amount or quantity of products consumed in Abia State,

2. how many companies operating in Abia State but have their hqtrs in Lagos or elsewhere.

3. The financial status of such companies.

4. There's no directive or policy of the FG requesting such companies to relocate their hqtrs to the state of operations.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:00am On Dec 03, 2024
Bobodee09:
This were answers lies.

The governors against this bills are only fighting against one thing......New sharing formula

Non is against the increase in VAT percentage...they aren't against citizens paying more.
They are only fighting for there own pockets and not you.

The more people in abia state consume goods that are VAT on it, the more money for abia government at the end of the month.....simple as ABC
Do you understand the question? I don’t think so. If you fully understand this new VAT proposal and how it favors states more, give me numbers, I a not asking for sentiments.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:03am On Dec 03, 2024
psucc:
There's no way such question can be answered with figures because
1. no one can actually know the amount or quantity of products consumed in Abia State,

2. how many companies operating in Abia State but have their hqtrs in Lagos or elsewhere.

3. The financial status of such companies.

4. There's no directive or policy of the FG requesting such companies to relocate their hqtrs to the state of operations.
FIRS has the data. The people proposing this reform know how much (estimates) companies in various states paid to their headquarters in Lagos as opposed to the states they’re operating in. They have data of VAT generated across various states. Why are in such a hurry to pass a bill you don’t understand?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Bobodee09: 10:03am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
Do you understand the question? I don’t think so. If you fully understand this new VAT proposal and how it favors states more, give me numbers, I a not asking for sentiments.
Oooo I see.


I guess you know your way to Abuja.....you be attended to very well.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:04am On Dec 03, 2024
Bobodee09:
Oooo I see.

I guess you know your way to Abuja.....you be attended to very well.
So you mean as a supporter of the bill, you don’t know exactly how it will affect revenue accruing to states, you just like the sound of it?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Napata77: 10:08am On Dec 03, 2024
OP I swear even all those your calculations dey give person headache.

Una sabi maths sha..
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:12am On Dec 03, 2024
Napata77:
OP I swear even all those your calculations dey give person headache.

Una sabi maths sha..
lol na simple question I ask o. The proponents of the bill claim they’re trying to help. If they can simply provide the answer, end of discussion
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by ALTERNATEID: 10:12am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
If you say that Tinubu’s proposed VAT reform will be better for states like Abia generating very little in VAT compared to states like Lagos, it means you fully understand this VAT reform, so this should be easy for you to answer.

In August 2024, Abia generated N663 million in VAT but they received N5 billion after the VAT revenue was shared among all states.

Since the new VAT proposal is supposed to help states like Abia receive more VAT revenue, tell me, for the month of August, rather than generate only N663 million, how much would Abia have generated if companies had paid VAT to Abia and not their headquarters in Lagos? And how much would Abia have received after sharing the revenue among states based on this new proposal?

Since you fully understand this VAT reform and claim that this new bill helps states generate and earn more VAT revenue, please answer this simple question.
Calculation of VAT generated per state will no longer be based on state of payment but on actual consumption that took place in the state. That is, the fact that MTN paid through MTN headquarters in Lagos doesn’t mean all the payment will be attributed to Lagos. Data showing what each states consumed will be generated and that will be the basis of the calculation. When this is done, Abia state VAT generation will definitely no longer be N663m. It should move up very well since there are lots of trading activities and consumption that attracts VAT payment in the state. The state will then collect 60% of what they generated.

Again, the purpose of the reform is also to stimulate economic growth in each states. As a governor, the new law incentivizes you to put in the needed work to expand your local economy for improve consumption because it will bring in more revenue to the state.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Bobodee09: 10:13am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
So you mean as a supporter of the bill, you don’t know exactly how it will affect revenue accruing to states, you just like the sound of it?
Is waste of time explaining to someone with a close mind.

You think the bill is bad.

I think the bill is good.

I don't need to convince you to change your mind neither do you need to do likewise.

God bless.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by helinues: 10:13am On Dec 03, 2024
You people should stop making everything about you and you ... Is Abia the only state in Nigeria? The tax reform is national politics not local politics

We have over 200 tribes in Nigeria fcs
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:16am On Dec 03, 2024
ALTERNATEID:
Calculation of VAT generated per state will no longer be based on state of payment but on actual consumption that took place in the state. That is, the fact that MTN paid through MTN headquarters in Lagos doesn’t mean all the payment will be attributed to Lagos. Data showing what each states consumed will be generated and that will be the basis of the calculation. When this is done, Abia state VAT generation will definitely no longer be N663m. It should move up very well since there are lots of trading activities and consumption that attracts VAT payment in the state. The state will then collect 60% of what they generated.

Again, the purpose of the reform is also to stimulate economic growth in each states. As a governor, the new law incentivizes you to put in the needed work to expand your local economy for improve consumption because it will bring in more revenue to the state.
I think we all know what you expressed here. As a proponent of this bill, don’t you care to validate the claim that this bill will be better for states like Abia?

Do you know Abia is an oil producing state? Do you know that most of their oil revenue is distributed to states using the same current (lazy) distribution formula? But when it comes to VAT you suddenly remember that states like Abia are lazy?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by psucc(m): 10:17am On Dec 03, 2024
I don't say they don't know or have data on these. Our problem is distrust. They can never divulge such data to the public. They'll rather manipulate or falsify it in favour of the companies.
That Tinubu wants this tax reforms so badly, means there's something we are not told nor know. Something so sinister! That reform has a hidden agenda. That's just the reason it's being pushed with such energy and urgency



givedemwotowoto:
FIRS has the data. The people proposing this reform know how much (estimates) companies in various states paid to their headquarters in Lagos as opposed to the states they’re operating in. They have data of VAT generated across various states. Why are in such a hurry to pass a bill you don’t understand?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:20am On Dec 03, 2024
Bobodee09:
Is waste of time explaining to someone with a close mind.

You think the bill is bad.

I think the bill is good.

I don't need to convince you to change your mind neither do you need to do likewise.

God bless.
We have both read the bill. I have a simple question and I asked this simple question. All I need is the answer. You on the one hand is supporting the bill but don’t fully understand it. So who’s being ignorant here?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Mrfeel: 10:20am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
FIRS has the data. The people proposing this reform know how much (estimates) companies in various states paid to their headquarters in Lagos as opposed to the states they’re operating in. They have data of VAT generated across various states. Why are in such a hurry to pass a bill you don’t understand?
If you know the data is available, why are you asking questions here? Let companies pay taxes to the actual location where the consumption of goods and services took place not to headquarters, if Abia gets less than 5 billion then that's what they deserve to get, you get according to your consumption period
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:23am On Dec 03, 2024
Mrfeel:
If you know the data is available, why are you asking questions here? Let companies pay taxes to the actual location where the consumption of goods and services took place not to headquarters, if Abia gets less than 5 billion then that's what they deserve to get, you get according to your consumption period
The proponents of the bill said that it will help states that generate less VAT to generate and earn more because VAT will be paid to them and not Lagos. Did they throw such claim from thin air? They should provide evidence of that claim. Let’s have some educated argument here

I have used Abia as an example to show how much they currently generate and earn after revenue is shared. Show me your own data that validates the claim that it will favor them
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by helinues: 10:26am On Dec 03, 2024
caleboxylic:
Vat will no longer be centralised as we have it now. VAT will be paid by consumers at the point of consumption, and not companies/manufacturers paying from source.
Abia will generate more, likewise Anambra, kano and rivers. Lagos VAT will be reduced as most companies will pay states before dropping any products manufactured in different states.

My only fear on this VAT is double taxation as Lagos will force the company to pay, likewise the receiving states and also consuming states.
The issue of double taxation was addressed by Oyedele. Infact a commission to look into the matter within 14 days is also part of the proposed tax bill.

Infact, they already have solid plan for 1 year on how the program will work as time is not in our side
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:29am On Dec 03, 2024
helinues:
You people should stop making everything about you and you ... Is Abia the only state in Nigeria? The tax reform is national politics not local politics

We have over 200 tribes in Nigeria fcs
Abia was used as an example here because it’s among the top 10 lowest VAT states. I can change the state if you want, or pick among the states below with the lowest VAT, then answer the question if you can:

26. Yobe State: ₦1.71 billion
27. Katsina State: ₦1.68 billion
28. Jigawa State: ₦1.59 billion
29. Nasarawa State: ₦1.47 billion
30. Ondo State: ₦1.45 billion
31. Enugu State: ₦1.08 billion
32. Cross River State: ₦1.08 billion
33. Bauchi State: ₦691.28 million
34. Kebbi State: ₦665.17 million
35. Abia State: ₦663.42 million
36. Zamfara State: ₦432.80 million
37. Imo State: ₦235.41 million
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by helinues: 10:32am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
Abia was used as an example here because it’s among the top 10 lowest VAT states. I can change the state if you want, or pick among the states below with the lowest VAT, then answer the question if you can:

26. Yobe State: ₦1.71 billion
27. Katsina State: ₦1.68 billion
28. Jigawa State: ₦1.59 billion
29. Nasarawa State: ₦1.47 billion
30. Ondo State: ₦1.45 billion
31. Enugu State: ₦1.08 billion
32. Cross River State: ₦1.08 billion
33. Bauchi State: ₦691.28 million
34. Kebbi State: ₦665.17 million
35. Abia State: ₦663.42 million
36. Zamfara State: ₦432.80 million
37. Imo State: ₦235.41 million
Instead of waiting for VAT from Lagos, Abuja e.t.c to be shared amongst states, the companies can now pay directly to any state they are operating without remitting everything to the headquarters

In USA, if you are operating a business, you pay 2 tax, state and federal. The federal is the remitance to the headquarters
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Mrfeel: 10:33am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
The proponents of the bill said that it will help states that generate less VAT to generate and earn more because VAT will be paid to them and not Lagos. Did they throw such claim from thin air? They should provide evidence of that claim. Let’s have some educated argument here

I have used Abia as an example to show much they currently generate and earn after revenue is shared. Show me your own data that validates the claim that it will favor them
You said Abia genarate N663 million, ? Will Abias revenue still be N663 million if companies are to pay taxes directly to Abia and not to do headquarters?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Bobodee09: 10:34am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
We have both read the bill. I have a simple question and I asked this simple question. All I need is the answer. You on the one hand is supporting the bill but don’t fully understand it. So who’s being ignorant here?
People like you just want argue unnecessary.

If abia generate 600bilion at the end of the month it will get 60% back with the new bill.

Currently if abia generate 600billion at the end month it will barely get 20%.

This how low I can go and I truly hope you understand.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by helinues: 10:35am On Dec 03, 2024
Mrfeel:
You said Abia genarate N663 million, ? Will Abias revenue still be N663 million if companies are to pay taxes directly to Abia and not to do headquarters?
Very good question
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:40am On Dec 03, 2024
Bobodee09:
People like you just want argue unnecessary.

If abia generate 600bilion at the end of the month it will get 60% back with the new bill.

Currently if abia generate 600billion at the end month it will barely get 20%.

This how low I can go and I truly hope you understand.
Just tell me you don't understand the question rather than get very defensive.

I don't need "ifs" here. There is a claim by the proponents that the bill was proposed to help states generating low VAT. Where is the data to support that claim? Abia state (the example used here) currently earns N5 billion from VAT after revenue is shared. Based on this proposal, they should be earning more right? Where did that data come from? Show it to us and this discussion is over!
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:44am On Dec 03, 2024
Mrfeel:
You said Abia genarate N663 million, ? Will Abias revenue still be N663 million if companies are to pay taxes directly to Abia and not to do headquarters?
Abia generates N633 million and gets N5 billion after the revenue is shared. The bill proposes that it will help them get more, which means Abia should be expecting more than N5 billion after this bill is passed. Show me how you came about that claim, or did you manufacture it from thin air? Are we going to pass the bill and wake up tomorrow to see Abia getting only N2 billion in VAT revenue when they were happy with the N5 billion? I don't think Abians want to be tricked like that

cc helinues
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by helinues: 10:48am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
Abia generates N633 million and gets N5 billion after the revenue is shared. The bill proposes that it will help them get more, which means Abia should be expecting more than N5 billion after this bill is passed. Show me how you came about that claim, or did you manufacture it from thin air? Are we going to pass the bill and wake up tomorrow to see Abia getting only N2 billion in VAT revenue when they were happy with the N5 billion? I don't think Abians want to be tricked like that

cc helinues
Abia dont need to wait for shared VAT. Companies can now be remitting directly into Abia state account as long as they are operating in that state. They produce waste, they ply the roads, they make use of some government facilities as a company in the state. They ought to remit something even if they will be sending more to their headquarters.

All states VAT collection will improve even for lazy governors. The states just need to get good auditor to check balance the companies operating in the state
1 2 Reply

"APC Supporters Have Been Attacking Me For Supporting Obi" — Mr. Macaroni • Sarki: Peter Obi's Supporters Have Offered To Sponsor His Campaign In The North • Adamawa Becomes First Northern State To Support VAT Reform • 2 • 3 • 4

Pro-wike Law Makers Pray With Tension As They Pray And Begs Fubara To Let Them S • Wike Will Be Disgraced Like Ekweremadu • We Can Learn From Venezuela's 'PetroCaribe' Oil Export Deal