₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,233 members, 8,521,880 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 08:09 AM

Toggle theme

Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer - Politics (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer (2142 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:51am On Dec 03, 2024
helinues:
Abia dont need to wait for shared VAT. Companies can now be remitting directly into Abia state account as long as they are operating in that state. They produce waste, they ply the roads, they make use of some government facilities as a company in the state. They out to remit something even if they will be sending more to their headquarters.

All states VAT collection will improve even for lazy governors.
Abia depends on shared VAT. Let's not be calling them lazy here because they're an oil producing state, and most of their state oil revenue is shared by other states using the same (lazy) VAT sharing formula. In fact, FG takes 52% of their oil revenue, but wants to take only 10% of VAT.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by helinues: 10:52am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
Abia depends on shared VAT. Let's not be calling them lazy here because they're an oil producing state, and most of their state oil revenue is shared by other states using the same (lazy) VAT sharing formula. In fact, FG takes 52% of their oil revenue, but wants to take only 10% of VAT.
Should I write in pidgin?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by starpower(m): 10:53am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
If you say that Tinubu’s proposed VAT reform will be better for states like Abia generating very little in VAT compared to states like Lagos, it means you fully understand this VAT reform, so this should be easy for you to answer.

In August 2024, Abia generated N663 million in VAT but they received N5 billion after the VAT revenue was shared among all states.

Since the new VAT proposal is supposed to help states like Abia receive more VAT revenue, tell me, for the month of August, rather than generate only N663 million, how much (estimated) would Abia have generated if companies had paid VAT to Abia and not their headquarters in Lagos? And how much would Abia have received after sharing the revenue among states based on this new proposal?

Since you fully understand this VAT reform and claim that this new bill helps states generate and earn more VAT revenue, please answer this simple question.
By the time the supreme Court grant lagos, delta, rivers there wish we will know the answer. I don't like tinubu but supreme
court judgement on gambling licence levy will go same as vat and there won't be anything to benefit. Mtn, airtel, dangote, banks and oil Co and some few others pays this VAT and also port authority. Sir they account for more than 80% of that money. Where do you think there headquarters are. If the supreme Court judgement follow by aligning with the constitution intention of favouring true federalism. The states can negotiate that derivation %, which I know there will be consention. Nothing to fight over they will negotiate it out just the beauty of democracy.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Mrfeel: 10:54am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
Abia generates N633 million and gets N5 billion after the revenue is shared. The bill proposes that it will help them get more, which means Abia should be expecting more than N5 billion after this bill is passed. Show me how you came about that claim, or did you manufacture it from thin air? Are we going to pass the bill and wake up tomorrow to see Abia getting only N2 billion in VAT revenue when they were happy with the N5 billion? I don't think Abians want to be tricked like that

cc helinues
Generating something is different from receiving something, if Abia can generate 2 billion instead of 633 million that's a good thing, instead of receiving 5 billion they didn't work for that's been a liability to the government, let Abia and every other state learn to catch fish themselves instead of receiving free fish ,
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by ALTERNATEID: 10:56am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
I think we all know what you expressed here. As a proponent of this bill, don’t you care to validate the claim that this bill will be better for states like Abia?

Do you know Abia is an oil producing state? Do you know that most of their oil revenue is distributed to states using the same current (lazy) distribution formula? But when it comes to VAT you suddenly remember that states like Abia are lazy?
I really don’t get your point. Where in my post did I say Abia is lazy? I thought we wanted to discuss how the proposed law will affect states like Abia without bringing primordial sentiments and beer parlor argument.

Abia is an oil producing state and currently gets 13% of income from all oil wells located in the state. In addition, Abia is also part of the Niger Delta Development Commission. So, I don’t understand the point or nexus between Abia as an oil producing state and the proposed tax bill.


I have explained how consumption will be the basis for calculating VAT generated by each states with the company headquarter issue now eliminated. That way, every state can get 60% of what they actually and truly generated. If you have any other reasonable question, I will be willing to respond to you.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 10:57am On Dec 03, 2024
Mrfeel:
Generating something is different from receiving something, if Abia can generate 2 billion instead of 633 million that's a good thing, instead of receiving 5 billion they didn't work for that's been a liability to the government, let Abia and every other state learn to catch fish themselves instead of receiving free fish ,
Did other states work for Abia oil revenue? or you forgot other states are receiving oil revenue from states like Abia based on the same current VAT sharing formula? You forgot FG takes 52% of oil revenue from states like Abia, but proposing to collect only 10% of VAT?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by helinues: 10:58am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
Did other states work for Abia oil revenue? or you forgot other states are receiving oil revenue from states like Abia based on the same current VAT sharing formula?
Can all the oil in Abia state full a coke cap?

Talk something different and stop going back and forth

Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by starpower(m): 10:59am On Dec 03, 2024
FG is trying to settle the wahala through executive bill and legislation instead of waiting for the judiciary. FG has been advised by there lawyers and hinted by the judges too. If supreme court reads it judgement each state will only keep what it remits by 100% derivation no population and no equity.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Mrfeel: 11:03am On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
Did other states work for Abia oil revenue? or you forgot other states are receiving oil revenue from states like Abia based on the same current VAT sharing formula? You forgot FG takes 52% of oil revenue from states like Abia, but proposing to collect only 10% of VAT?
Every oil producing state receive higher than none oil producing state
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 12:25pm On Dec 03, 2024
ALTERNATEID:
I really don’t get your point. Where in my post did I say Abia is lazy? I thought we wanted to discuss how the proposed law will affect states like Abia without bringing primordial sentiments and beer parlor argument.

Abia is an oil producing state and currently gets 13% of income from all oil wells located in the state. In addition, Abia is also part of the Niger Delta Development Commission. So, I don’t understand the point or nexus between Abia as an oil producing state and the proposed tax bill.

I have explained how consumption will be the basis for calculating VAT generated by each states with the company headquarter issue now eliminated. That way, every state can get 60% of what they actually and truly generated. If you have any other reasonable question, I will be willing to respond to you.
13% derivation doesn't compare to the newly proposed VAT revenue sharing formula. I can provide you with the numbers if you want to have that argument.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Ritchiee:
givedemwotowoto:
I understand all what you’re expressing here. But I need an answer to the question. The thing is how you guys are supporting this bill without fully understanding it. You can’t even answer this question. So why the hurry?

You talk about extreme laziness, do you know that Abia is an oil producing state? After distributing most of their oil revenue among FG and states like Lagos and Kano based on population and other factors, you now want high VAT generating states like Lagos to keep most of their VAT and call states like Abia lazy. Is that fair?
lol
How much oil does Abia produce,sir?
All SE states combined oil is not up to Ondo state portion.
As per the question you asked.Somebody has answered you.
Let me just help you a little bit.
VAT is just part of FAAC,there are still money from customs,port etc.
The #5 billion was not exclusively for VAT,other monies were included.
The proposed tax bill will give Abia more VAT + your #5 billion or whatever from the other goodies.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by StarRiderr: 2:06pm On Dec 03, 2024
helinues:
Instead of waiting for VAT from Lagos, Abuja e.t.c to be shared amongst states, the companies can now pay directly to any state they are operating without remitting everything to the headquarters

In USA, if you are operating a business, you pay 2 tax, state and federal. The federal is the remitance to the headquarters
So what you're saying in essence is there will be multiple taxation to the companies in Nigeria if I have to go with this your explanation that's means there will
be massive exodus of companies leaving Nigeria in nearest future
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by helinues: 2:09pm On Dec 03, 2024
StarRiderr:
So what you're saying in essence is there will be multiple taxation to the companies in Nigeria if I have to go with this your explanation that's means there will
be massive exodus of companies leaving Nigeria in nearest future
The headquarters pay to the FG while the production in the state also remit something. There is a working formula for that. So it won't be double taxation
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by ALTERNATEID: 2:35pm On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
13% derivation doesn't compare to the newly proposed VAT revenue sharing formula. I can provide you with the numbers if you want to have that argument.
So what’s your argument? VAT should also be 13% derivation or oil should be increased to 60% derivation?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 2:40pm On Dec 03, 2024
ALTERNATEID:
So what’s your argument? VAT should also be 13% derivation or oil should be increased to 60% derivation?
For every N100 billion that Rivers generates from oil, it gets only 19 billion after revenue sharing. With this new VAT reform, for every N100 billion that Lagos generates from VAT, it gets about N36 billion. Is that fair? https://www.nairaland.com/8284004/how-proposed-vat-revenue-sharing

So my point is, if you want to implement VAT reforms, include oil revenue reforms to match the proposed VAT reforms as well so it's fair for everyone.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by ALTERNATEID: 3:01pm On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
For every N100 billion that Rivers generates from oil, it gets only 19 billion after revenue sharing. With this new VAT reform, for every N100 billion that Lagos generates from VAT, it gets about N36 billion. Is that fair? https://www.nairaland.com/8284004/how-proposed-vat-revenue-sharing

So my point is, if you want to implement VAT reforms, include oil revenue reforms to match the proposed VAT reforms as well so it's fair for everyone.
Is River’s complaining? Is it not one after the other? VAT and oil are not the same and they are not governed by the same law. If tax reform is facing this kind of stiff opposition, what do you expect from any changes to oil revenue sharing?

Beside, Rivers and other oil producing states are fully backing the tax reform. In fact, it was Rivers state that first went to court to ask for states to keep their VAT revenue by 100%. This tax reform is more like a political solution to the court case. Again, oil is a natural resources given by God and all natural resources belongs to the federation. Consumption is not God given. It is by level of economic development. You can’t compare both.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 3:07pm On Dec 03, 2024
ALTERNATEID:
Is River’s complaining? Is it not one after the other? VAT and oil are not the same and they are not governed by the same law. If tax reform is facing this kind of stiff opposition, what do you expect from any changes to oil revenue sharing?

Beside, Rivers and other oil producing states are fully backing the tax reform. In fact, it was Rivers state that first went to court to ask for states to keep their VAT revenue by 100%. This tax reform is more like a political solution to the court case. Again, oil is a natural resources given by God and all natural resources belongs to the federation. Consumption is not God given. It is by level of economic development. You can’t compare both.
I see. Oil is a gift from God so it belongs to everyone. So I Will pollute your land (farmland) and water (fishing activities) and use the money to develop my own land, then keep my revenue to myself because it’s my money.

Ok I get your point.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by ozo13(m): 3:14pm On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
If you say that Tinubu’s proposed VAT reform will be better for states like Abia generating very little in VAT compared to states like Lagos, it means you fully understand this VAT reform, so this should be easy for you to answer.

In August 2024, Abia generated N663 million in VAT but they received N5 billion after the VAT revenue was shared among all states.

Since the new VAT proposal is supposed to help states like Abia receive more VAT revenue, tell me, for the month of August, rather than generate only N663 million, how much (estimated) would Abia have generated if companies had paid VAT to Abia and not their headquarters in Lagos? And how much would Abia have received after sharing the revenue among states based on this new proposal?

Since you fully understand this VAT reform and claim that this new bill helps states generate and earn more VAT revenue, please answer this simple question.
same question was Asked in that town hall meeting yesterday organized by channels Tv and Oyedele did answer it with a power point slide
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by aswani(m): 4:15pm On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
I understand all what you’re expressing here. But I need an answer to the question. The thing is how you guys are supporting this bill without fully understanding it. You can’t even answer this question. So why the hurry?

You talk about extreme laziness, do you know that Abia is an oil producing state? After distributing most of their oil revenue among FG and states like Lagos and Kano based on population and other factors, you now want high VAT generating states like Lagos to keep most of their VAT and call states like Abia lazy. Is that fair?
The point is the VAT that Lagos are currently cornering will now be in open play, whilst possession is nine tenths of the law (so to speak), there will be nothing stopping Abia making a play for as much of it as possible.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 4:25pm On Dec 03, 2024
aswani:
The point is the VAT that Lagos are currently cornering will now be in open play, whilst possession is nine tenths of the law (so to speak), there will be nothing stopping Abia making a play for as much of it as possible.
So long story short, your answer is, “I don’t know if the newly proposed revenue will increase the revenue share of low VAT states like Abia as FG is claiming, so I can’t ascertain if their claim is true or not”?

Does that summarize your answer correctly?
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by kunle4toyeyaho: 4:29pm On Dec 03, 2024
caleboxylic:
Vat will no longer be centralised as we have it now. VAT will be paid by consumers at the point of consumption, and not companies/manufacturers paying from source.
Abia will generate more, likewise Anambra, kano and rivers. Lagos VAT will be reduced as most companies will pay states before dropping any products manufactured in different states.

My only fear on this VAT is double taxation as Lagos will force the company to pay, likewise the receiving states and also consuming states.
Why would Lagos force anyone? VAT is not within the purview of states but rather handled by FIRS
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by owunabastard: 4:33pm On Dec 03, 2024
Mrfeel:
Generating something is different from receiving something, if Abia can generate 2 billion instead of 633 million that's a good thing, instead of receiving 5 billion they didn't work for that's been a liability to the government, let Abia and every other state learn to catch fish themselves instead of receiving free fish ,
There will be an equity if states should control their natural resources and pay little percentage to federal coffers. It should not be only VAT. I think that is what OP is trying to narrate
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by aswani(m): 4:43pm On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
So long story short, your answer is, “I don’t know if the newly proposed revenue will increase the revenue share of low VAT states like Abia as FG is claiming, so I can’t ascertain if their claim is true or not”?

Does that summarize your answer correctly?
If you are looking for a guarantee that Abia state would fare better by folding its arms and doing nothing, then you won't get one.

Based on what I have read, Abia can either be the new Lagos or the new Zamfara (apologies to Zamfara people), the choice is up to how ineffective the state government wants to be.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Samajogs: 4:51pm On Dec 03, 2024
We are making progress from BAT to VAT
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by Solsix(m): 5:11pm On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
We have all heard these sentiments over and over, but your answer shows you don’t fully understand the bill yourself, because you can’t answer the question. So why the hurry to pass a bill you don’t fully understand?
Nah you wey no know wetin you ask. He gave a detailed explanation for anyone asking genuine questions to understand.
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by SporaD8: 7:21pm On Dec 03, 2024
givedemwotowoto:
So long story short, your answer is, “I don’t know if the newly proposed revenue will increase the revenue share of low VAT states like Abia as FG is claiming, so I can’t ascertain if their claim is true or not”?

Does that summarize your answer correctly?
Your criticism or should I say contention is based on the claim by FG that Low VAT state will have more revenue share under the proposed TAX bill.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but what the economic team actually mean is that Low VAT state will generate more VAT revenue not More total Revenue Shared by FG.
You should stop confusing independently generated TAX revenue with FG shared revenue gift.
And finally, your title and question is about TAX revenue, stop derailing your thread with oil revenue sharing formula (that's an argument for another thread)
Re: Simple Question That VAT Reform Supporters Have Been Unable To Answer by givedemwotowoto(op): 8:09pm On Dec 03, 2024
SporaD8:
Your criticism or should I say contention is based on the claim by FG that Low VAT state will have more revenue share under the proposed TAX bill.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but what the economic team actually mean is that Low VAT state will generate more VAT revenue not More total Revenue Shared by FG.
You should stop confusing independently generated TAX revenue with FG shared revenue gift.
And finally, your title and question is about TAX revenue, stop derailing your thread with oil revenue sharing formula (that's an argument for another thread)
Question is not that low VAT states will generate more VAT if companies paid their VAT to states instead of their headquarters. The question here is the change in revenue sharing formula, and the claim that came with it that it was meant to help states get more revenue share. We need to see how they came about such conclusion.

Without fully understanding that, we might wake up tomorrow to see that low VAT states had a slight increase in VAT revenue based on the reforms, but their revenue after sharing actually dropped, which means they tricked us.

Let me explain this. Abia generated N663 million for August for example but they received N5 billion after revenue sharing. Now assuming they agree to this proposal. Next month, their VAT revenue increases from N663 million to N5 billion, but after revenue sharing, they get only N1 billion based on the new sharing formula. Do you see the problem there? Abia has been tricked.

Now consider that Abia is an oil producing state. FG takes most of their oil revenue and shares to other states, but when it comes to VAT, other states are keeping their own VAT. How fair is that?

The point is, if truly their claim that this VAT proposal will help low VAT states get more share of VAT, how did they come about that conclusion? Let's see the data that they used to arrive at that claim.
1 2 Reply

"APC Supporters Have Been Attacking Me For Supporting Obi" — Mr. Macaroni • Sarki: Peter Obi's Supporters Have Offered To Sponsor His Campaign In The North • Adamawa Becomes First Northern State To Support VAT Reform • 2 • 3 • 4

Peter Obi Is Becoming Dangerously Loved.... Photos • Debt Forgiveness: Nigeria Ready for a showdown! • We Can Learn From Venezuela's 'PetroCaribe' Oil Export Deal