From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted - Christianity Etc (3) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted (3972 Views)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Reply (Go Down)
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 2:07pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Make I balance well, this thread dey sweet wella. |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 2:10pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:Your statement contains several logical fallacies that weaken your argument. First, it commits a straw man fallacy by misrepresenting my views of Revelation 12, oversimplifying my position to suggest that these events must have occurred before the creation of man. This misrepresentation distracts from the actual complexities of the interpretation. Additionally, your assertion presents a false dichotomy by implying that the events either happened before the creation of man or not at all, ignoring the possibility of alternative interpretations, such as viewing these events as symbolic or existing outside of a linear timeline. Furthermore, the question begs the issue by presupposing a specific chronological order that aligns with human history, which is not necessarily applicable to apocalyptic literature. Overall, these fallacies detract from a meaningful discussion about the interpretation of Revelation 12 and its implications. Your statement reveals several logical fallacies that undermine your argument If you keep committing these fallacies, there is no way to have a sane, meaningful conversation. Don't just hastily generalize 🤦 |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 2:15pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:As far as the bible is concerned, From the Torah we see only the high priest could enter the holy of holies and from the speech of Lucifer he makes the remark: "he wants to ascend up into heaven"🥱. If Lucifer was already in heaven then why the need to ascend up above! Because from Jewish traditions there are seven heavens and God resides in the seventh, the holy of holies! So as far as that verse is concerned it's doesn't corroborate your assertion! But suggests that evil forces after being cast out of heaven where God resides. They roamed in others! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 2:17pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:I don't need to answer because both scripture negates your premise and that is enough for me! I just wanted to show the world the flaw and hasty generalization you have exhibited in handling scripture!!! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by gohf: 2:37pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:I have been reading your posts and I am not saying Gabrielshow24 is right, but what is your point Is it that satan is in heaven right now? By the way heavenly realms there doesn't mean heaven as in where God's throne is, it references spiritual realms. |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by gohf: 2:39pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:Your issue is, using language and logic and improper understanding and use of scripture. He is having a field day with you because your responses are not with certainity |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by gohf: 2:43pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:gabrielshow24 this is one of the examples of him having a field day with you Previously okcornel asked you, when does the sign In Revelation 12:1-9 occur And you seem to give one answer and then another and then no answer. Is it Israel, humanity or what? Such response is somehow. |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 2:44pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
gohf:Evidence to the contrary! I was showing him the logical flaws he was committing, prominently hasty generalization. He failed to take other verses into account and from Revelation 12 concluded Satan is still heaven! I didn't give a definite answer; my intent is to show his flaws nothing more! I used oversimplification to sell my case! Also simple logic suggests that "a contradiction defeats an absolute statement" |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 2:46pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
gohf:It's not, I said " some argue", I made it clear that it's subject to interpretation and there is no one consensus as to what this means. I brought up different interpretations that are valid in their own right! Which is to show my intent from the very beginning; which was to bring forth contradictions that shows his logical flaws! and the verse itself didn't warrant an absolute statement! Which op failed to take into account before making such an absolute statement! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by gohf: 2:48pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:if you use a wrong means do you expect to get a right result? Asking you this question base on logic Helping whoever is following this conversation the truth is actually more important than trying to "show him his flaw" |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by gohf: 2:49pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:What did you infer when he made such a statement, did you state the truth clearly enough? |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 2:50pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
gohf:In some cases to get to the truth you have to use the law of contradictions/non-contradiction! It's well laid out in Philosophy and Mathematics!!! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by gohf: 2:50pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:Are you still here or have you left? |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by gohf: 2:52pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:You yourself said, "I used oversimplification to sell my case!" What I call this is CONFUSION |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 2:53pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
gohf:It's littered in my write-ups where I appealed to him that there's not sufficient grounds to make such an absolute claim. Why do you think I was pointing "hasty generalization" to him? When he refused to see his mistakes, I brought simple verses and reflected his logic back to him! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 2:56pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
gohf:It's just to reflect the same logic to make him see the error. It's similar to what I do when Muslims say Jesus was a prophet because he bowed dow. His head to pray! I use this simple logical fallacy of undistributed middle to make them see their errors. "I say this: Pagans circled the Kaaba. Muhammad circled the Kaaba. Muhammad is a pagan!" It's a logical tool don't blame me! Some cases warrant you use either oversimplification or exaggeration to show the writer his/her flaws! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 2:57pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:You've just been shouting fallacies and yet you haven't told us how it is possible for Satan and his Angels to be cast out of heaven prior to the existence of the woman (Israel) in Revelation 12 or the occurrence of the great tribulation in Revelation 12 v 17. Cognitive dissonance at its best |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:03pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:From the bolded, kindly read Isaiah 14 v 12-13 in the context of that chapter and tell us where Isaiah shifted his attention from the King of Babylon to Satan. Please just show us. Typical example of picking few verses and interpreting it out of the context of the passage. Very very faulty eisegesis. |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:04pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
gohf:He is clearly confused |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:04pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
gohf:I'm here |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 3:04pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:🤦This doesn't make any sense. Your entire statement hinges on the fact that "it was because of Israel" Lucifer was cast out! Why then was he cast out because of Israel? Secondly the great tribulation like I said earlier is semi-vague, different doctrinal sects can argue that it was the "persecution of the Church", some say persecution or conquest of Jerusalem and finally others argue it's yet to come! So it's subject to different interpretations either symbolic or literal!!! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:08pm On Dec 15, 2024*. Modified: 3:25pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
gohf:My position is Satan and his Angels still have their place in heaven - Ephesians 6 v 12 They will lose their place in heaven after the war with Angel Michael and the other Angels - Revelation 12 v 8. Their expulsion to earth will lead to a series of event which will spark off the time of Jacob's trouble - Revelation 12 v 14 This will then snowball into the great tribulation - Revelation 12 v 17 and Revelation 13. All these are future events yet to happen. |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:10pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:You haven't said anything and you are hiding behind the position of different doctrinal sects with conflicting views. Are you telling us the war in heaven happened before the creation of earth and man? If yes, how is it possible without any shred of evidence the dragon pursued the woman into the wilderness for 1,260 days or the occurrence of the great tribulation? What is your position on the events of Revelation 12? Tell us in a clearly without hiding under the interpretation of others. You don't seem to be certain in your position, but at the same time you are somehow sure Satan and his Angels have been kicked out of heaven! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 3:12pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:Really, I could say the same of specific verses in Revelation. The bible has always used Babylon as a metaphor for sin/oppression and has alluded to satan being the "ruler" of this country. So either you take the literal interpretation and incline yourself to the king of that time or you take the metaphorical route that implies Satan! Which buttresses my point that the bible is subject to literal and metaphorical meanings! And you don't just pull out one verse and just allude to its metaphorical meaning and posit it as an absolute statement! Also I was expecting you to throw out Jesus' statements out the window! 🤔 Or perhaps him alluding to Satan being a murderer from the very beginning🤧. Irrespective both don't help your cause, next time you won't hasty generalize. Now the burden of proof is on you to start throwing out counter verses🤧. I have come to a conclusion a long time ago that you have formed a dogmatic epistemic closure! And it's futile exchanging words hence I will display your logical inconsistencies!!! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:14pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:So where did Isaiah shift his attention from his taunt to the king of babylon and spoke of Satan in Isaiah 14? Are you also telling us Satan is a man as per Isaiah 14 v 16-17? Are you also telling us Satan has a tomb as per Isaiah 14 v 19? As per Satan has a corpse?! |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:19pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:Nah...you don't have an answer to this. It already exposes the flaws in your argument. You can't tell us when exactly Satan and his Angels were cast out of heaven. If you say it's before the creation of earth and man, was Jesus then referring to a different Satan that fell like lightening from heaven centuries after in Luke 10 v 18? Now you are faced with having to explain yourself on how Satan got back to heaven prior to Luke 10 v 18 if indeed he was cast out of heaven before the creation of earth and man. Fatal blow... too bad |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:21pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:You are just blowing empty words. Explain to us how Satan fell from heaven like lightening in Luke 10 v 18 if he was cast out of this same heaven prior to the creation of earth and man. |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 3:22pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:Let me ask you this question The 1260days you mentioned are they literal or metaphorical? I want to see your standpoint! Also I want you to consider very well the logical implications of your reply!!!🤧 |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:24pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:A literal future event. Now what is your position on the 1,260 days. And don't signpost me to different doctrinal views. |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by Gabrielshow24: 3:24pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
OkCornel:Are you looking to me for an explanation? Can't you read from context or perhaps the literal chronological sequence of the verse? Anyway it's Jesus words😊 |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by gohf: 3:28pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
For the sake of those who have read so far, hopefully you read this Revelation 12 comes after Revelation 11, after the seventh trumpet Rev.11.15 Then the seventh angel sounded: And there were loud voices in heaven, saying, "The kingdoms of this world have become the kingdoms of our Lord and of His Christ, and He shall reign forever and ever!" (NKJV) But the first part of Revelation 12 is not an occurrence but a vision of the past, a sign, infact after that sign had ended Rev.12.9 So the great dragon was cast out, that serpent of old, called the Devil and Satan, who deceives the whole world; he was cast to the earth, and his angels were cast out with him. (NKJV) WAS CAST OUT and the result was Rev.12.10 Then I heard a loud voice saying in heaven, "Now salvation, and strength, and the kingdom of our God, and the power of His Christ have come, for the accuser of our brethren, who accused them before our God day and night, has been cast down. I don't know when you all think salvation and God's kingdom came, or when the power of Christ came upon the church but it is not a futuristic statement because Jesus himself said if I cast out demons then the kingdom of God has come. Matt.12.28 But if I cast out demons by the Spirit of God, surely the kingdom of God has come upon you. Rev.12.11 And they overcame him by the blood of the Lamb and by the word of their testimony, and they did not love their lives to the death. (NKJV) They will overcome? Is that what is written? NO They OVERCAME... Love new living translation of Rev.12.1 Then I witnessed in heaven an event of great significance. I saw a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon beneath her feet, and a crown of twelve stars on her head. (NLT) HE WAS CAST OUT the next verse after the vision ended, Rev.12.13 - Now when the dragon saw that he had been cast to the earth, he persecuted the woman who gave birth to the male Child. Rev.12.17 - And the dragon was enraged with the woman, and he went to make war with the rest of her offspring, who keep the commandments of God and have the testimony of Jesus Christ. That's why the question is, who will... Rom.8.33 - Who shall bring a charge against God's elect? It is God who justifies. Rom.8.34 - Who is he who condemns? It is Christ who died, and furthermore is also risen, who is even at the right hand of God, who also makes intercession for us. There is no one accusing God's people before God anymore. What happened to Job, happened to the Joshua the priest and others like prince of Persia etc, happened before Jesus dead and rose Col.2.15 And having disarmed the powers and authorities, he made a public spectacle of them, triumphing over them by the cross. (NIV) Jesus came, he died and overcame, there are other verses in NT So is satan in heaven now? NO, can he gain access there? NO So since he can't accuse us, what does he do He fights God's people And he fights because Eph.1.3 Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ, (NKJV) Eph.6.12 For we do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this age, against spiritual hosts of wickedness in the heavenly places. (ALL) Now what are heavenly places? Or heavenly realms? This realm is a realm of spiritual warfare and without the authority given to Jesus we cannot prevail, without the word of testimony given to us we cannot overcome nor resist Eph.1.19 - and what is the exceeding greatness of His power toward us who believe, according to the working of His mighty power Eph.1.20 - which He worked in Christ when He raised Him from the dead and seated Him at His right hand in the heavenly places, Eph.1.21 - far above all principality and power and might and dominion, and every name that is named, not only in this age but also in that which is to come. Eph.1.22 - And He put all things under His feet, and gave Him to be head over all things to the church, We are to replace the forces and powers of darkness be thrown out, Eph.2.4 - But God, who is rich in mercy, because of His great love with which He loved us, Eph.2.5 - even when we were dead in trespasses, made us alive together with Christ (by grace you have been saved), Eph.2.6 - and raised us up together, and made us sit together in the heavenly places in Christ Jesus, Eph.2.7 - that in the ages to come He might show the exceeding riches of His grace in His kindness toward us in Christ Jesus. By declaring God's word Eph.3.10 - to the intent that now the manifold wisdom of God might be made known by the church to the principalities and powers in the heavenly places, So is satan still ruling in the heavenly realms? NO, he is still pretending to be god of the earth, Yes, is he fighting against God's people, Yes Revelation 13 shows what he does at the last trumpet sounded... In the old testament he had been sneaking, like 2Cor.11.14 And no wonder! For Satan himself transforms himself into an angel of light. (NKJV) disguises himself but God can see through his deception and thank God he was rebuked in the case of Joshua the priest. Do you think he gave us his ambition because he was cast out of heaven Isaiah's words are a prophecy Isa.14.12 "How you are fallen from heaven, O Lucifer, son of the morning! How you are cut down to the ground, You who weakened the nations! (NKJV) This happened when Jesus won the battle That's why verse 15 Isa.14.15 Yet you shall be brought down to Sheol, To the lowest depths of the Pit. (NKJV) This is yet to happen, and like Revelation says it happens just before the millennium reign Ezekiel prophecies it as well Ezek.28.8 - They shall throw you down into the Pit, And you shall die the death of the slain In the midst of the seas. Ezek.28.9 - "Will you still say before him who slays you, "I am a god'? But you shall be a man, and not a god, In the hand of him who slays you. It has not yet happened. Yes he was cast out from God's presence as Moses wrote in Genesis and roamed the earth but he sneaked into the assembly of God's children when they present themselves before the LORD. I hope you all understand. God bless |
| Re: From Heaven They Descended Into Hell — Then Lucifer Reacted by OkCornel(m): 3:29pm On Dec 15, 2024 |
Gabrielshow24:Ehya... so according to your position, Satan was cast out of heaven before earth and man were created. Then several centuries after in Luke 10 v 18, Jesus said he saw Satan fall like lightening from heaven (you never even considered if this was metaphorical by the way). Then Paul wrote in Ephesians 6 v 12 that there are still spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms. But oh no... according to you, the war in heaven has already happened and Satan and his Angels are cast out of heaven to earth. A round of applause for you. |
Great Sign From Heaven At Pastor's Burial • Did Jesus Knew He'll Be Resurrected Right From Heaven Before He Came To Earth? • Joshua Bamiloye Mike: The Movie “Lucifer” Used By Devil To Win Souls • 2 • 3 • 4
The Mistakes Of Constantine That Birthed The Trinity Doctrine, Paganism With Chr • Benny Hinn Is A Heretic? • Have You Prayed For Nigeria Today?