Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba - Culture (3) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Culture › Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba (8560 Views)
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by TAO11(f): 7:44pm On Nov 08, 2018 |
IkpuMmadu:So? I have already addressed all these completely in this same thread. What you should have done is to quote me and debunk in clear and specific terms any of my argument you find contentious. I had thought you were really asking a question when I 1st replied you |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by TAO11(f): 7:49pm On Nov 08, 2018 |
IkpuMmadu:smiles ... I think you really don't need to be cunning and deceptive. I think you should stop it in your own interest. It damages your ego and esteem rather than help it. I think you should desist from this path |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by OlaoChi: 9:56pm On Nov 08, 2018 |
TAO11:Stop wasting your time on that jobless mumu guy. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by IkpuMmadu(op): 2:55am On Nov 09, 2018 |
TAO11:I didn't write that I just quoted it deal with the link and not me |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by TAO11(f): 4:20am On Nov 09, 2018*. Modified: 4:44am On Nov 09, 2018 |
IkpuMmadu:That's precisely my point. I have dealt with it earlier before you "quoted" some link and since it appears you still have contentions or misunderstandings, I expected you to quote me on what I wrote and debunk in clear and specific terms any of my argument you find contentious. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Badb0y4lyf(m): 5:31pm On Nov 09, 2018 |
TAO11 your knowledge is very vast on cultural and religious beliefs I will be looking forward to having a discuss with you |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by scholes0(m): 4:10pm On Nov 10, 2018 |
.. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Kerinikporo: 6:51am On Nov 17, 2018 |
Opiletool:You are right |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by TAO11(f): 8:29pm On Nov 22, 2018 |
Badb0y4lyf:Thanks so much bro for this positive remark, but I am actually no where close to being vast. I am only very passionate about these subjects and I believe I have a moral duty not to remain silent when someone asks for an information which I have, or when someone peddles misinformation which I believe I have a correction to. I generally like exchange of ideas on these subjects in the most cordial and humane manner possible. But some folks' approach to exchanges like this is through being very nasty and rude, and to which I usually respond in kind. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by lawani(m): 6:44pm On Dec 09, 2018 |
Yoruba originally meant oyo but nowadays the word is used to identify many others. In the 19th century, the ijesa did not see themselves as Yoruba but we are all children of oduduwa |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by lawani(m): 8:15pm On Dec 09, 2018 |
Yoruba and Europa mean thesame. It is used by Muslims to describe civilized and advanced people who are not muslims |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Ifiokumo: 11:37pm On Dec 09, 2018 |
IkpuMmadu:Is this why you all are afraid to go for Oduduwa Republic? |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by lawani(m): 3:37pm On Dec 10, 2018 |
In the past ifes were ifes not Yoruba. It was early in the 20th century that everybody adopted the name yoruba |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by AlphaTaikun: 7:09pm On Jul 19 |
TAO11:Bump. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by AlphaTaikun: 7:14pm On Jul 19 |
scholes0:Bump... Impressive historical takes from you right BELOW. "On the other hand, The Itsekiri relationship with Yoruba is more nodal/ vertical in nature...i.e (direct descent) and can never be changed. All the primordial villages and clans in itsekiri land came from Yorubaland, except perhaps the Royal Court." |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Nobody: 1:31pm On Jul 25*. Modified: 12:31pm On Aug 29 |
scholes0:This is why I will never be a Yoruba man. I can’t even type Itsekiri and scroll down on Nairaland without coming across Yorubas trying to claim us. To address your points: Yes, Itsekiri may sometimes wear agbada and clothes from other ethnicities as well, it does not make us Yoruba or some other ethnicity. We do not wear it as our native attire. Agbada is very widely worn across Nigeria so it’s bewildering to me that someone would even suggest this. Agbada is also a Yoruba variation on a wider style worn across Nigeria and all of West Africa. So whenever you see someone wearing something that looks like agbada, it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s agbada per se. Itsekiri are unique from both the northwestern Yoruba and the eastern ones. Your issue here, as I’ve noticed with many Yorubas who claim we are the same, is that you find it too difficult to understand what is different from you. Yes, Itsekiri has a monarchy. So do tons of other places in Nigeria, and the world. Why does it make us Yoruba? Itsekiri does not have clans, naturally we also do not have clan chiefs. We simply have lineages/genealogical lines, and every Itsekiri comes from a number of lineages spread across different towns. We have no such thing as a “lineage chief”. The lineages are basically family/extended family, considered from both matrilineal and patrilineal sides. What we do have are town councils which the senior representative is the Olare-Aba (eldest man). This goes beyond any lineage and covers the entire geographic town. On your Ginuwa point, there were definitely people living in the current Warri kingdom area before Ginuwa arrived. However, there was nothing like an Itsekiri ethnic identity prior to Ginuwa’s arrival nor was everyone there or the “primordial” villages solely Yoruba in descent. Some were Yoruba communities, some were Urhobo communities, some were IJaw communities, some were various aboriginal ethnic groups. Ginuwa consolidated all these groups and formed the Itsekiri ethnic identity out of them. Right after Ginuwa’s arrival, intermixing between the Benin party, and the Itsekiri aboriginals began. Over time, many Itsekiri royals and chiefs further went to found the towns of their own. These towns now make up the majority of the Warri traditional kingdom. So I find it very funny when some Yorubas who don’t know much about our organization say “the Itsekiri royals are Benin but the people are Yoruba”.” Whereas, it would be very difficult if not impossible, to find an Itsekiri man who cannot trace some point in his ancestry to a court chief. In turn, there is no Itsekiri court chief or royal that cannot trace parts of their ancestry to aboriginal Itsekiris. Furthermore, court chieftancy is not only patrilineal in Itsekiri culture but someone of either patrilineal or matrilineal descent is selected by the Olu for it. Which is to say that many of our chiefs that are so-called “pure Benin” by Yorubas, do not even trace their paternal ancestry to a Benin chief. You can find an Itsekiri who traces his paternal ancestry directly to a Benin chief, living as a regular man. While you will find an Itsekiri who traces his maternal ancestry to a Benin chief serving the chieftaincy role. On traditional religion, Itsekiri do not have Ebora. We have Ebura-tsitse which refers to the honoring of ancestors not a deity. While we have an “Umale” concept, the usage of it in Itsekiri is also very specific to Itsekiri culture and history. It is used to refer to our ancestors who were here prior to Ginuwa’s arrival. It is also used to refer to primordial powers or deities more generally. We share the religious vocabulary with Yoruba because we share a similar language but the specific usage of it, the names and rituals concerning it, are very different from what is found in Yoruba. Indeed, the names of many Umales do not even seem related to Yoruba etymology i.e Ibrikimo, Inama, Ejulube, Otuekine. The concept of a deified ancestor itself or a primordial force is not unique to Yorubas. Urhobos call it Edjo, Ijaws call it Amaoru/Oru, Igbos call it Alison/Agbara. The conception of Umale-Okun is also different in Itsekiri from general Yoruba conception in that Umale-Okun is also seen as a protector of the fate of the Itsekiri nation but generally this is similar just as with most sea deities across southern Nigeria. Ogun and Ayelala are also pretty much the same across both tribes. However, Ayelala is not unique or even widespread amongst eastern Yorubas much less Yorubas as a whole. We see Ayelala in Benin and various groups in Edo state, the Apoi-Ijaw you mentioned and some Urhobo communities. Now, Ayelala is not really even an Itsekiri deity though it’s associated with us for some reason but it’s not something that is widespread among Itsekiris at all. It’s mainly an Ilaje and Apoi-Ijaw thing. Ifa/divination is not something that is unique to Yorubas or something that even necesarily has its origin with the Yoruba as many Yorubas assume. It is actually a very widespread practice across southern Nigeria, the middle belt and in Benin Republic. The Itsekiri call theirs Ife, Urhobo call theirs Epha, Nupe calls it Eba, Igbo groups call theirs Afa or Eha. Isoko call theirs Eva, Idoma call theirs Iba, Esan calls theirs Oguega/Iha, Benin calls theirs Iha etc. All these systems share the same core 16 × 16 divination structure but the names, incantations, rituals and sacrifices involved and their interpretations are not exactly the same. Funny enough, in Itsekiri oral tradition, Ife is actually said to have been brought to us by a Benin priest called Idiebie. Benin also shares Olokun, Ayelala, Ogun with Yoruba. I wonder if you will now say Benin culture is basically Yoruba because of this lol. Furthermore, all the deities you mentioned happened to be the ones that Itsekiri share with Yoruba. You did not mention the deities which many eastern Yorubas have and Itsekiris do not share such as, Sango, Obatala, Oro, Orisa Oko, Osanyin. You also did not mention the ones that are found in Itsekiri and are not shared with any Yoruba group, such as Hippi, Okpotu, Okposo, Ibrikimo, Otuekine, Ike, Gbasala, Abrawa, Egere, Egbudu, Isekpere, Ejelidiro, Oweisiemo, Erikpe, Ugbokua, Urunmatsoko, Ekperuma, Osonikia. I can go on and on but I think I’ve made my point. Our traditional religion are not the same. They share from a few deities but the majority of deities are different from what any region Yorubas has. Some words used to describe broad ideas are also similar by virtue of utilizing a similar language but the particular conception of that idea and the practice of it, are distinct. Our societal structures, traditional political structures, social customs are distinct. When we look outside of language, there is really very little that is unique to the Yoruba which the Itsekiri share. I find it very funny when a Yoruba then tells me that all the parts of my culture which they as Yoruba do not share are “ephemeral” or “lateral” while the minority parts they share are what is “vertical” or “nodal”. What makes you feel like you can even decide that for another ethnicity? Ironically, the things you are calling “nodal” like Umale-Okun are the things that have become less relevant today. What will never easily go is our deep connection to our Niger-Delta homeland and our Niger-Delta lifestyle which shares most similarities to the and the Urhobo. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Nobody: 2:11pm On Jul 25*. Modified: 3:34pm On Jul 25 |
TAO11:I don’t know what oral tradition you are reading but the Itsekiri oral tradition does not describe us as anything but Itsekiri. Yes, we have some Itsekiri who trace part of their ancestry to Yoruba land. Those same Itsekiri can trace their ancestry to Benin as well as other peoples. Itsekiri claims to be Itsekiri not part of any “Olukumi folk”. Please report on your own history and leave qualified Itsekiri people to report on their history. The fact that we are both writing in English and you’re using language as the only reason to claim us as Yoruba shows the absurdity. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Nobody: 2:13pm On Jul 25 |
AlphaTaikun:“Bump”. You’re not ashamed to be desperately coveting someone else’s culture. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by lawani(m): 7:20pm On Jul 25 |
Juren:Itsekiri have the right to claim to be Yoruba is the thing. They are removed from say Ibadan people for instance but they are not more removed than Ilaje, Owo or Ikale people. They are just a bit more removed from Ibadan than Ife or Ijesa. Then names of deities exist in Ijesa that are unknown in Ife or Ibadan or Ijebu. So having distinct deities does not make them different. Family compounds in Yoruba land do have distinct deities. You can also go to any Alaagba to inaugurate a new deity and you are good to go. Then the inventor of the 256 divination signs is Orunmila baba Agbonniregun and he invented it while living in Oke Igeti thousands of years ago. Two people can not invent the same thing. It is from Orunmila that it spread everywhere. There are descendants of Orunmila in Benin city who are not Yoruba people but their ancestors would be Yoruba. Sixteen signs common everywhere is not Ifa Orunmila. That one existed before Orunmila. In short the Itsekiri are as Yoruba as the Ilaje or Owo and are only different in that they are more Easterly. What qualifies the Owo as Yoruba that leaves out the Itsekiri? Nothing at all except they themselves now say they identify differently but not a faceless Monika on nairaland |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by AlphaTaikun: 8:32pm On Jul 25*. Modified: 10:22pm On Jul 25 |
Juren:Desist from being IRRESPONSIBLE while displaying knee-jerk conclusions here! If you have no job, go get one! I ONLY "bumped up" two posts on this thread and quoted what the gentleman here wrote. I have NO need for "coveting" anybody's culture. Besides being Yoruboid languages, there are differences and similarities between mainstream Yoruba folks and Itsekiris. It's a historical FACT that besides the presence of Yoruba subgroups in the Delta State area from centuries back pre-and post Ginuwa (such as the Ijebus, Ilajes and Ifes who established communities such as Ode-Itsekiri, Omadino, Ugborodo, Ogidigben, etc), the Benin migration of Prince Ginuwa in 1480 (his mother was originally from Ile Ife but got married to Oba Olua of Benin Kingdom) into Ode-Itsekiri where he met the male and female aboriginals who were of Ijebu origin. There is also a migration of a small clan of Igala settlers centuries later. I suspect you are one of those pro-Bini people because your post above is massively riddled with the talk of Benin influence on Itsekiri BUT you MUST realize from here on out that even the Ogiamien family representative in Benin (who claim direct descent from the Ogiso era lineage before the Oranmiyan Dynasty was started over 800 years ago from circa 1200) have strongly affirmed in a 2018 Guardian newspaper with the link BELOW (and several newspaper interviews) that the paternal ancestry of the current Obas of Benin is Yoruba from Ile Ife which Benins and Usen people call "Uhe." "Ogiso and Ogiamien are Aborigine Binis while Oba Of Benin is Yoruba" https://guardian.ng/features/ogiso-and-ogiamien-are-aborigine-binis-while-oba-of-benin-is-of-yoruba-descent-high-chief-esotericist-monday-wehere/ WATCH the Historically Insightful 5 Videos right BELOW and read the 2 EXCLUSIVE newspaper articles about the Ogiamien family of Benin. [1] Ogiso and Ogiamien are Aborigine Binis while Oba Of Benin is of Yoruba origin =>https://guardian.ng/features/ogiso-and-ogiamien-are-aborigine-binis-while-oba-of-benin-is-of-yoruba-descent-high-chief-esotericist-monday-wehere/ [2] Ogiamien Vs Oba of Benin: Royal rumble ends =>https://tribuneonlineng.com/ogiamien-vs-oba-of-benin-royal-rumble-ends/ [3] All Benin Obas Are From Ile Ife https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z2Gf9LUr1-o Igodomigodo Family - Mar 25 2024 [4] 99% of Benin Traditions Are From Ile Ife https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZznZ8Cdb5aM Igodomigodo Family - [5] History Of Usen, Oba Of Benin & Itsekiris Call +491749661566 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EUfCwAlFH-8 Igodomigodo Family - Watch the over 2 hours video right ABOVE (from the timestamp 3:19 minutes) when the conversion starts. Then the MAJOR interview [affirming the Yoruba paternal lineage and Ile Ife origins of ALL the Obas of Benin and the royal titles and deities] with the gentleman from USEN in Ovia South West LGA of Edo State, a town of TRUE descendants from Ile Ife in Yorubaland starts from the timestamp of 27 minutes to 1 hour 27 minutes. USEN currently has an Oba called the Olu Awure of USEN and his direct ancestor, Afelogiyan was the FIRST EVER ruler of Usen (formerly Ife Kekere) centuries back over 800 years ago. Afelogiyan is ALSO the OLDER biological brother of Oranmiyan whose real name is "Oluwaiye" both of who were Oduduwa's grandsons NOT his sons which is another error and fabricated story from the palace of this current Oba of Benin and his late father Oba Erediauwa. It was from USEN that Oranmiyan left to become the FIRST EVER Oba of Benin with the advent of the Oranmiyan Dynasty over 800 years ago! [6] The people of USEN in Ovia South West LGA of Edo State who are direct descendants of Afelogiyan who is Oranmiyan's OLDER brother have long DEBUNKED the highly misleading, pure FALSEHOODS by the palace in Benin that "a missing prince" called "Ekaladehan existed in the Ogiso era who came to Ile Ife and became Oduduwa. There are other communities near USEN such as Utese in Edo State that came from Ife as well. The family salutation in USEN or Benin for instance of families with Ife ancestry is DELAUHE (How is UFE or Ife). The video timestamp from 09:57 to 10:30 right BELOW, CLEARLY shows the "Esogban of Benin" [The title "Esogban" is ORIGINALLY called "Asogbon" in the Ile Ife royal palace many centuries ago before the chieftaincy title was brought to Usen and Benin] explaining CLEARLY where hIs direct male ancestor came along along with Oranmiyan (from Ile Ife in Osun State) and the unique family salutations or ways of greeting one another in Benin based on their different family ancestral origins. SALUTATION IN BENIN https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZQZl-yyNqE EDO Lineage Greetings Part 5 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BOBY3QxokR0 Respected Usen people of Ovia South West of Edo State (Usen is where High Chief Gabriel Igbinedion's mother hails from and Usen is 36 kilometers away from Benin City) too have strongly affirmed in videos online that they are from Ile Ife ancestry and part of the larger Yorubaland with direct relationship with the Ikales of Ondo State (but Usen is located on the other side of the border in Edo State) with an Oba known as Oba Oluogbe 11, the Olu Awure of Usen. The FIRST EVER traditional ruler of Usen if you don't know was Prince Afelogiyan who was Oranmiyan's biological older brother and both were Princes and grandchildren of Oduduwa who originally came to Ife from the hilly town of Oke Ora in Osun State just 8 miles away from the current Ile Ife. One of the respected Usen indigenes who spoke in a detailed 2-hours video interview right ABOVE gave an example of the Benin High Chief titles such as "Esogban" which in Usen and Ile Ife Palaces is known originally "as Asogbon" a CLEARLY pure Yoruba word and Chieftaincy title of Ife origin. It was from Usenland now in Edo State that Oranmiyan came to what is now Benin (Usen is just 36 kilometers away from Benin City) to establish the Oranmiyan Dynasty with Prince Eweka (later known as Oba Eweka 1) being the royal son he fathered from the daughter of a noble man. The Usen folks and the Ogiamien family also affirmed in different interviews I've seen over the years that most of the Benin palace chieftaincy titles and ALL the deities venerated in the palace in Benin Kingdom (Ogun, Osun, Olokun and more, etc) were brought directly from Ile Ife (via Usen Kingdom) and the Ogiamien family too bluntly affirmed that the deities (Ogun, Olokun, Osun, etc) now venerated in Benin NEVER existed during the Ogiso era before the Oranmiyan Dynasty started. It is therefore very CLEAR that even Prince Ginuwa who migrated on EXILE to Ode-Itsekiri in 1480 and became a king or Olu is of that same direct Oranmiyan Dynasty paternal ancestry from Ile Ife in Yorubaland via Usen (being the FIRST son of Oba Olua and a mother of Ile Ife origin). However Benin is Benin, Yoruba is Yoruba, and Itsekiri is Itsekiri and each other's identities should be respectful while affirming centuries of shared historical and cultural values. Since 1981, I've had access to advanced archival materials and advanced knowledge of the histories of different ethnicities of Nigeria and more from around the world, so you need to come correct. I have NO time for loose talk from you and I will have to BLOCK you on this discussion forum if you display that sort of initial verbal attack again. Period. "Ogiso and Ogiamien are Aborigine Binis while Oba Of Benin is Yoruba" https://guardian.ng/features/ogiso-and-ogiamien-are-aborigine-binis-while-oba-of-benin-is-of-yoruba-descent-high-chief-esotericist-monday-wehere/ Cc: lawani |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Nobody: 10:42pm On Jul 25 |
AlphaTaikun:A lot of what you have said here is so wrong, and some are so irrelevant that I do not even know how to begin communicating with a mind that thinks otherwise. I have already addressed anything worth responding to in my other posts on this thread. Anyone interested can take a look at that. Thanks. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Nobody: 1:56am On Jul 26*. Modified: 12:44pm On Aug 29 |
lawani:The majority Itsekiri position, is that Itsekiri are a distinct ethnic group. Only a minority says otherwise, and that is mainly due to politics. The official Warri Kingdom website which many Yorubas like to cite, also identifies Itsekiri as a distinct ethnic group. I say this as someone who doesn’t even agree with everything on that website. So it is either you have not done enough research on the matter, you are selecting and choosing what to believe, or you know better and choose to misrepresent the Itsekiri people position on their identity. My point was that there are only a few Yoruba deities Itsekiri share, such as Umale-Okun and Ogun. These are big deities that have made their way out of Yoruba land to Esan, Bini, Urhobo, Fon, Gbe, and various groups in Edo states. Therefore, it does not make sense to use these deities as the main qualifiers for why Itsekiri should be Yoruba. When groups which we all agree are not Yoruba have these particular deities as well. The fact that deities such as Sango, Obatala, Oro, Orisa Oko, Osanyin can be found basically everywhere across eastern Yorubas but cannot be found in Itsekiri should tell you something. The fact that many deities which are found widely across Itsekiri are not found amongst any eastern Yoruba group or any Yoruba group for that matter, but are instead found across Ijaws and Urhobo should also tell you something. There is practically no Yoruba group that doesn’t share even some of its “family compound” deities with some other Yoruba group. They do not share it with Itsekiri however, because Itsekiri are not Yorubas. Ibrikimo, Gbasala, Inama, Okpotu anre also not a “family compound” deity. These are widely known across Itsekiri people and were major deities that shaped our history and culture. I’m sure an Itsekiri reading this would be amused that you refer to Ibrikimo as a mere “family compound” deity. Ayelala that we’ve mentioned is not even an Itsekiri deity. Some Itsekiris may have honored it but it’s not widespread at all. Why should whether you are willing to “inaugurate” our deities matter? If Esan, Igbo and other Nigerian groups are willing to inaugurate our deities, does it now make us them too? You as a Yoruba person, would you accept to be Esan, Igbo, or another ethnic group if they were willing to accept your deities? If not, then why do you want to put my own people at a lower standard than yourselves? On Itsekiri and the south east Yorubas, practically every social custom between us is as different as any two southern Nigerian ethnic groups. We do not greet the same as Owos, we do not have Orikis, our traditional rules on how property are inherited are distinct, our wedding ceremonies and funeral proceedings are also distinct. I can go on and on but I do not see the point. On who invented 256 divination system. I said it is a widespread practice across southern Nigeria and the middle belt, and no one knows who invented it. Yoruba invented their own specific set of 256 signs known as Odu Ifa. But that is a different set of signs from Itsekiri’s Ife, Benin’s Iha, Urhobo’s Efa, Igbo’s Aha, and so on. lawani:The Itsekiri have never claimed to be Yoruba as a group, so there is no need for us to now claim that identifying differently. And a faceless moniker on Nairaland is not enough to make the Itsekiri Yoruba. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by lawani(m): 6:36am On Jul 26 |
Juren:What I mean is that deities are so frivolously created that individuals not to talk of family compounds can have one. So different deities don't matter. There is no Sango in Ile Ife. They have Oranfe. No Sango in Ijesa as well. I don't think there is Ayelala in Ijesa. No Oyo man offers libation to Atakunmosa that is in Ijesa. No non native of Ere Ijesa knows about Onikoje. There is 256 signs in Itsekiri but it does not exist in Igala or any other group that I have ever heard of. They all, including the non Orunmila priesthood in Yoruba land use sixteen signs. The one in Itsekiri is of Yoruba origin. The Osun or Obatala priests use sixteen signs and I believe Ayelala priests use sixteen signs too. So don't debate issues you don't even understand. 256 signs are Orunmila signs and there exists Yoruba diviners that don't use it even today not to talk of other people in West Africa. Then Itsekiri are whatever they themselves say they are which does not remove from the fact they are no different from Ilaje or Ikale who are south eastern Yoruba. That is my point or how are they different? It isn't as if they have any tie to a non Yoruba group. The Benin city that they had a tie to was no different from them or from Owo or Usen in the past and it is only the current Benin that does not speak the Yoruba language. The old Benin palace was a city of 50k people and their language was the same Yoruba dialect spoken in Usen or Itsekiri land today before new people from the suburbs entered the city recently. What makes the Itsekiri Yoruba is traditional leadership being of the same family as other Yoruba, language and ancestral ties as well as accounts of migration. Warri itself is Iwere. There is Iwere among the Oyo and they were obviously originally the same people as the founders of Warri. The mother of the first Aare ona Kakanfo was from Iwere Ile. Are you going to say New York has no link with York in England? |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Nobody: 7:03pm On Jul 26*. Modified: 12:36pm On Aug 29 |
lawani: lawani:I have already covered this in my earlier posts, but I will respond briefly. The Itsekiri share only a limited number of major deities with the Yoruba, and these are largely deities that also spread beyond Yorubaland to other distinct peoples, including the Bini, Esan and Urhobo. Therefore, their presence among the Itsekiri does not make the Itsekiri people Yoruba any more Yoruba than it makes those other peoples Yoruba. lawani:I actually know a bit about this matter. That is why I am aware that the Esan, Benin, and many other groups have their own sets of 16 signs that can be combined to form 256 signs. While you, on the other hand, do not appear to be aware of this. It is well established in the academic literature that the 16-to-256 combinatorial structure is widespread across West Africa. What the Yoruba developed is their own specific corpus of 256 signs, known as Odù Ifá. The Itsekiri do not have Odù Ifá; we have our own set of signs and our own divinatory process. lawani:This is not right. The Itsekiri are distinct from the Ilaje, Ikale and other southeastern Yoruba groups, which is why we identify as a separate ethnic group. Please show some respect. We do not claim a distinct identity on a whim. Yes, the Itsekiri language is very similar to those spoken by the Ilaje, Ikale and other southeastern Yoruba peoples. However, virtually everything else is distinct, our customs, social structure, marriage practices, funeral rites, traditional systems of inheritance, etc. Imagine, that the Yoruba suddenly began speaking a language very similar to Tiv. The linguistic similarity would be obvious, but there would still be major cultural and social differences that would make it unreasonable to classify both peoples as the same ethnic group on the basis of language alone. In the same way, the Itsekiri speak a closely related language to Yoruba, but differ in many other respects that distinguish us as a separate people. Regarding your claim that we have no ties to any “non-Yoruba” people, first of all, we do not need ties to any non-Yoruba people in order to be distinct from the Yoruba. We are distinct because of our objective cultural differences. Now, that being said, we do have ties to non-Yoruba peoples, and it is very strange for someone to claim otherwise. Language aside, our cultural norms are much closer to those of the Warri Ijaw, Urhobo, the wider Niger Delta and Benin than to those of any Yoruba subgroup. We also had early, close interactions with the Portuguese. As for the claim that Benin was historically Yoruba-speaking and that the city was later overtaken by people from the suburbs. I have heard this before. It is mainly promoted by ethnic propagandists and is not supported by serious historians, anthropologists or linguists. For the purpose of this discussion, let us stick to claims that are actually supported by credible evidence. Otherwise, the discussion is pointless. lawani:I really do not see your logic here. The traditional Itsekiri political system came from Benin, not Yorubaland. Yes, the original name for the Warri Kingdom is Iwere. Itsekiri oral tradition usually explains the name as being derived from the Ewere leaf, not from Iwere-Ile in Oyo. In the case of New York, there is actual historical record tying its name to the English York. Furthermore, there are Itsekiri communities whose names are also found among other peoples. There is an Itsekiri community called Orere, and there is also an Urhobo community called Orere. Does it mean that one came from the other? There is also an Itsekiri community called Koko and a Koko in Kebbi State. Does that mean the Itsekiri of Koko in Warri migrated from Kebbi State, or that they left the Koko in Warri to found the one in Kebbi State? This is something that happens everywhere and everyone knows. Even Edo was the former name of Tokyo in Japan. Does this then mean the founders of Tokyo were the Edo people of Nigeria? I’ll address the part on It’sekiri ancestral ties and migration accounts, briefly. The Warri Kingdom was built on the basis of various communities of differing origins. The Itsekiri people today emerged through the political consolidation, interaction and intermarriage of these various communities. We do not claim to belong to where their ancestors migrated from, we claim to be Itsekiri. On a related note, I do not understand the idea of claiming a group simply because they migrated from your land. Migration may explain where a group once came from, but it does not give the people of that former homeland ownership over the migrants or their descendants. Nor does it automatically determine their present ethnic identity. There is no population in the world whose ancestors did not migrate from somewhere at some point. |
| Re: Why Do They Hate Been Called Yoruba by Nobody: 7:04pm On Jul 26 |
. |
A Tribe Called Yoruba! • A Tribe Called Yoruba People • A Tribe Called Yoruba • 2 • 3 • 4
Family Of Late Oba Of Benin Are Tenants In The Kingdom-ogiamen Family • Seadog Confraternity • Nigeria's Golden Moments