Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? - Christianity Etc - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? (921 Views)
| Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by LadyExcellency(op): 12:32pm On Aug 14 |
In Islam, when the Romans came to arrest Jesus, he hid among his disciples and offered them a deal: “Who will take my place, and Allah will reward him with a castle in paradise?” The Islamic Jesus bargains for his own survival. He offers paradise as currency for someone else’s suffering. He escapes and someone else dies. This fits perfectly with Muhammad’s method, castles, virgins, rivers of wine, palm trees in paradise, divine bribery, used to extract whatever Muhamed desired from his followers. The Islamic version of Jesus is repackaged in Muhammad’s image: transactional, self-preserving, power-driven. The real Jesus, the biblical Jesus, didn't ask anyone to die for him, he died for us. They are projecting the image of Muhammad onto Jesus. At the Battle of Uhud, Muhammad asked his companions to sacrifice themselves to protect him, promising Paradise to those who did. Seven of them were killed while shielding him. |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 1:11pm On Aug 14*. Modified: 10:42pm On Aug 14 |
LadyExcellency:Below was my original comment to you! Ignorance is not bliss! When you propagate lies, you become no different from those you think you attack. If you do not get the story straight, don't you see your religion is made even more meaningless by your lies?😒😒But now, I am having a serious rethink. While you did not get the actual details of what was said correct, I found out where the possible narrative came from, and I am thinking maybe if you copy the text as-is from there, you could just be on to something. 🥱🥱 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 1:12pm On Aug 14 |
LadyExcellency:This one is a distorted version of the original story. The Jews who get Jesus didn't narrate their story like that. |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 1:17pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:What have the jews to do with this now?😒😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by WatchYourSix: 1:40pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:The Quran is not the only source Muslims follow in their religious life….there are other Tasfir, hadith that serves as further guide apart from the Quran to them and these sources did mention what the op said U like being condescending all the time
|
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 1:58pm On Aug 14*. Modified: 2:23pm On Aug 14 |
WatchYourSix:... I found the Tafsir! 😒 (All-Wise.) in all that He decides and ordains for His creatures. Indeed, Allah's is the clearest wisdom, unequivocal proof and the most glorious authority.My mistake for not getting it from the Tafsirs on this one, given that I typically leave the adding/changing/removing up to the Hadiths and not the Tafsirs. I have now completely lost my previous faith in Ibn kathir. 😒😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 2:07pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:The Jews own Jesus na! Abi na Arabs get am ni. Shuu! |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 2:10pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:Yes, Jesus of Israel was an Israelite who said His Father sent him to the Lost sheep of Israel, meaning that no non-Israelite could have him. 😒😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 2:14pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:He is not just an Israelite, he is a Jew! Are you now afraid to call him a jew because it make what you believed in a lie?☹️ |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 2:16pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:Jesus was born a Jewish Israelite. A jew is simply an Israelite who descends from either the bloodline of Judah or of Benjamin. So what is there to be afraid of? He himself said His father sent him to the Lost Sheep of Israel meaning He was not sent only to the Jewish section of Israel but to all Israelites.😒😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by WatchYourSix: 2:25pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:Hahahahahaha!! What point are u trying to make seff…?? Sounds like u want to pick a fight with the guy |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 3:43pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:Jesus is a jew! Simple |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 3:44pm On Aug 14 |
WatchYourSix:Fight? What's the fight about. Fact is fact no need cutting corners. JESUS IS A JEW! Ce fini |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 3:45pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:I didn't say you are wrong. I instead pointed out that He, as an Israelite, was sent to the bloodline of Israel, meaning that non-Israelites cannot claim to be of Jesus Christ of Israel. Basically, the Isa of Islam CANNOT be the same as the Jesus Christ of Israel. 😒😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 3:50pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:Ok thanks. Jesus is for all who accept and confess him though. |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 3:53pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:And by that He meant those to whom He was sent, which is the Lost sheep of Israel. Not a single non-Israelite can obtain that which is Jesus Christ of Israel's salvation from sin. 😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by WatchYourSix: 4:03pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:The guy ddnt argue with you weda hes a Jew or not… suddenly u started accusing him of being afraid to admit and it will make his belief a lie.. the guy is even an atheist seff |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 7:16pm On Aug 14 |
WatchYourSix:My statement remains that Jesus Christ is a Jew. I don't care if the guy is an atheist. Thanks for your observations |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 7:20pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:Jesus when he was living commanded his disciples to go into the world and make salvation of the world. So salvation is for everyone who as long as they believe in Jesus no matter the number, few or many. Just believe us all it requires |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 7:34pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:They were to go into the world to the Lost sheep of Israel wherever they may be found, to gather them back. That is what His mandate from YHWH of Israel was, and the same mandate He gave to his followers. 😒😒 Salvation cannot be for everyone because the only ones who needed saving from anything were the Lost Sheep of Israel. 😒 The Covenant was made only to the Israelites by the YHWH of Israel in His Law of Moses ---the Constitution of the ancient nation of Israel --, and it explicitly offered them a chance for Salvation, redemption from the curse of sin(not sin alone). The Israelites, as He proclaimed through Moses, were eventually condemned/cursed by him, the YHWH of Israel. And the redemption that came right as that happened was the salvation from the same curse, which He offered to those of them who were spared the purging that followed the curse.😒😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 7:45pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:By the mandate of Jesus Christ every human is a lost sheep of Israel. It's not literal |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 7:47pm On Aug 14 |
Kdon2:There is no evidence of this in any of the Gospels!😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 8:18pm On Aug 14 |
Interestingly the Qur’an itself says nothing about a bargain, a castle, or Jesus asking anyone to die for him. Qur’an 4:157 says only that it was made to appear that they killed him, while 4:158 says Allah raised him. There is no dialogue, offer, or reward-for-substitute scene in the Qur’an. The who will take my place? account comes from later tafsir, attributed to Ibn ʿAbbas, not from the Qur’an. So the Uhud comparison projects a later exegetical account onto a Qur’anic passage that never contains it. Critique the tafsir if you wish, but attribute it correctly as not what Allah by the Quran 4:157–158 actually says. |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 8:24pm On Aug 14 |
honesttalk21:Are you saying Ibn Kathir lied against Isa of Islam and Allah of Islam? 😒 (All-Wise.) in all that He decides and ordains for His creatures. Indeed, Allah's is the clearest wisdom, unequivocal proof and the most glorious authority.I mean, Ibn Kathir is widely respected among Islamic scholars, and this, to me, is a big deal. So, if you are suggesting that his tafsirs are not authentic enough to be held up to the Quran, then doesn't that literally mean all scholars of today who read from him are equally worthless?😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by WatchYourSix: 8:25pm On Aug 14 |
honesttalk21:Ur voice is loud now when u want to use not directly written in the Quran as a defence But there are other shameful things u pple follow thats not in the Quran but u boldly defend that they are in the Hadith |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 8:37pm On Aug 14 |
WatchYourSix:Interesting response albeit discarding your upload attachment. In any case I'm not rejecting hadith as a category, only rejecting one report being presented as Qur'anic fact. Judge that report on its own isnad and matn, like any other hadith. |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 8:42pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:Not lying exactly means and presents as accurately reporting what scholars held. Tafsir is scholarly interpretation, not the Qur’an itself. Ibn Kathir records different views about who was substituted, then gives his own preference. That is a reasoned scholarly judgment, not unanimous transmission. Classical scholars differed over tafsir precisely because it was open to interpretation. |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 8:56pm On Aug 14 |
honesttalk21:So, do we take his tafsir account that literally includes an isnad of sorts as standing alongside that which is recorded in the Quranic text? Yes or no! If this isnad had been in a Hadith somewhere, I would have had to worry about whether it is sahih or not. But this is literally in the Quran's own Tafsir, and by Ibn Kathir, the same. It is literally like it has been elevated to Quranic-levels.😒 2. HIs reasoned scholarly judgment in this case adds quite a new and different context to the story not found in the Quran. Do we take his reasoned scholarly judgment to heart, then, as a correct addition to the narrative? 😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kdon2: 9:15pm On Aug 14 |
Kobojunkie:Ok |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 9:39pm On Aug 14 |
An isnad appearing in Ibn Kathir's tafsir does not make the report Qur'an. It remains a transmitted report, assessed on its chain and content, as any hadith would be. Ibn Kathir's judgment is respected, but it remains scholarly interpretation, not revelation. His tafsir on 4:157–158 presents differing reports on the substitution, mainly through Wahb ibn Munabbih and Ibn Ishaq, with disagreement over details such as who volunteered. That alone shows the account is not a single settled Qur'anic narrative, but transmitted tradition open to scrutiny. The distinction is simply that the Qur'an is revelation; tafsir records and evaluates human interpretations of it. Kobojunkie: |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 9:47pm On Aug 14 |
honesttalk21:I would have considered this explanation for why not to consider this isnad as part of Qur'anic content if it were maybe located elsewhere in one of the Sahih Hadiths, but I have yet to find it anywhere else but in this tafsir. That is both strange and interesting!😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 9:54pm On Aug 14 |
It's actually not really strange. Ibn Kathir's tafsir is a compilation of transmitted material, not a Sahih collection. Reports found there include material outside the rigorously authenticated hadith corpus, including differing or weaker traditions. So its absence from Bukhari or Muslim doesn't make the report mysterious or Qur'anic; if anything, it is another reason to assess the report on its own chain and content rather than elevate it to Qur'anic fact. Kobojunkie: |
What Is The Real Name Of The Islamic God? • China Will Rewrite The Bible And The Quran To 'reflect Socialist Values' • T.B. Joshua’s Isreal Visit Described As Huge Success • 2 • 3 • 4
Rapture, What About It ?! • Everyday Word From God To Build Your Faith. • Fair Or Not