Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? - Christianity Etc (3) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? (921 Views)
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by MaxInDHouse(m): 7:50pm On Aug 15 |
honesttalk21:Abeg who dey respect am?🥱
|
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 8:25pm On Aug 15 |
Ibn Kathir's tafsir contains different kinds of transmitted material, including Qur'an, hadith, reports from Companions, and Isra'iliyyat. They don't all carry the same weight. It appears you don't know this. His long standing authority shows how respected his work is, but it doesn't make every report he records sahih. Al Tabari also records differing views on the crucifixion resemblance. So the authority of the scholar and the reliability of a particular report are still two separate questions. Kobojunkie: |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by MaxInDHouse(m): 8:34pm On Aug 15 |
honesttalk21:You are talking about your own Muslims that you respected contradicting themselves on a subject yet you guys will start seeking the same in the Bible!😂 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 8:40pm On Aug 15 |
honesttalk21:His work is revered and regarded as the gold standard in Islam as far as tafsir is concerned. That is all that matters! For almost 800 years, Islam had no problem with the inclusion of the transmission in the tafsir. So, I think it is sensible to stick with Islamic consensus on this too.😁😁 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 9:24pm On Aug 15 |
That is all that matters isn't a response and settles nothing. It sidesteps the distinction between a scholar's authority and the authenticity of every report he transmits. An 800 year old compilation doesn't turn silence into consensus, especially when it preserves differing views. Al Tabari also records disagreement over the nature of the resemblance. If you claim there is an Islamic consensus, then what exactly is the consensus? Who was substituted, and on what authenticated basis? Judas, Simon, another disciple, or someone else? And is substitution itself the only transmitted explanation, or are there other interpretations of 4:157? Specifics not avoiding banter please. Kobojunkie: |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 9:30pm On Aug 15 |
honesttalk21:You are trying to hold me up to a standard that even Islamists don't hold themselves to. Why? 🤣🤣🤣 2. What in the world sort of dubious Taqiyya is this? Al-Tabari was from the 9th century AD, while Ibn Kathir was from the 14th century. How could the first have recorded disagreements over this issue? 🤣🤣🤣 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 10:20pm On Aug 15 |
Only because you asked for it! I'm applying the same standard consistently. Transmission doesn't equal authentication. A core claim can be affirmed while details of how it happened remain uncertain or disputed. Judaism and Christianity likewise affirm revealed events without treating every later narrative detail as equally certain. Here, the Qur'an affirms that Jesus was not killed and that Allah raised him; the specific substitution narrative comes from tafsir, not the Qur'anic text. And check the dates before calling it taqiyya. Al Tabari (839–923) predates Ibn Kathir (1300–1373) by roughly four centuries, so his tafsir shows that disagreement over the substitution existed long before Ibn Kathir. That's evidence of an earlier dispute, not a later fabrication. You still haven't answered the question: who exactly was substituted, and on what authenticated basis? Judas, Simon, another disciple, or someone else? If there's no agreed answer, there's no consensus to defend. Kobojunkie: |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 10:50pm On Aug 15 |
honesttalk21:Stop with the Taqiyyah nonsense already! 😒😒 https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2025/01/03/imam-tabari-and-the-substitution-theory/
|
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by safarifarms(m): 11:03pm On Aug 15 |
Kobojunkie:1: The "Metonymy" of John 3 (The Snake in the Wilderness) • The Analogy is about the Method, not the Scope: Jesus compares Himself to the snake in John 3:14–15 to explain how salvation happens (by looking up and believing in the one lifted up), not who gets it. The text literally switches scales in verse 15 and 16 from a historical event to a global reality. • Look at the word "Everyone": In verses 15 and 16, Jesus says "so that everyone who believes..." He did not say "every Israelite." • The Greek word Kosmos: The Gospel of John was written in Greek, using the word Kosmos for world. John uses Kosmos over 70 times. In John 1:10, it says, "He was in the world, and the world was made through him, and the world did not know him." Did Israel make up the world? No. Did only Israel not know Him? No. John uses Kosmos to mean the entire human creation alienated from God. • The Direct Refutation (1 John 2:2): You completely ignored 1 John 2:2, written by the exact same author (John). It says: "He is the atoning sacrifice for our sins, and not only for ours but also for the sins of the whole world." If "our sins" means Israel's sins, then "the whole world" mathematically must mean people who are not Israel. You cannot escape this grammar. 2: The Definition of "Gentile" and "All Nations" Your claim: Gentile only means Israelites living in the diaspora, and Genesis 10 proves "Gentiles" just means the family of Japheth/Arabs. • The Definition of Gentile (Goyim / Ethne): In Hebrew, the word is Goyim. In Greek, it is Ethne. Both words literally mean "the nations"—specifically, every nation that is NOT Israel. • Genesis 10 Disproves your Point: You quoted Genesis 10:2–5, which lists the descendants of Japheth. The descendants of Japheth are not Israelites. Jacob (Israel) wasn’t even born yet! Jacob comes through Shem, not Japheth. Therefore, Genesis 10 explicitly proves that "Gentiles" refers to non-Israelite nations. (Also, historically, Arabs are traditionally traced through Shem/Ishmael, not Japheth, showing your genealogy is completely incorrect). • The "All Nations" Promise: You claim we are "plugging ourselves" into a covenant meant only for Abraham's descendants. But Genesis 22:18 says: "through your offspring all nations (goyim) on earth will be blessed." If it only blessed Abraham's biological family, it wouldn't say all nations on earth, because Abraham's family is only one nation. • The New Testament "Plug In" is Literal Scriptural Doctrine: You claim we are visually inventing a "religious interpretation" to plug ourselves in. But the Apostle Paul explicitly states that non-Israelites are plugged into Abraham's covenant through faith: o Galatians 3:7: "Understand, then, that those who have faith are children of Abraham." o Galatians 3:29: "If you belong to Christ, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise." o Romans 11: Paul uses the literal analogy of an olive tree where natural branches (unbelieving Israel) were broken off, and wild olive branches (Gentiles) were grafted in to share in the nourishment of the root. Summary: "If salvation is only for the biological bloodline of Israel, then why did Jesus explicitly command His disciples in Matthew 28:19 to go and make disciples of panta ta ethne[b] (all the Gentiles/nations)?[/b] If they were only supposed to look for hidden Israelites, the Greek text would say diaspora or oikos Israel (house of Israel), which Jesus knew how to say. Instead, He commanded a global mission to non-Jewish nations, fulfilling God's promise to Abraham to bless the entire earth." |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 11:14pm On Aug 15 |
safarifarms:To all the Gentiles implies all the Israelites who were scattered to all of the other nations. I answered this when I made clear that, according to Genesis 10, the use of the same term by the Prophet of the YHWH of Israel is used to refer to people who are of the same bloodline. Again, he was sent by His Father only to the lost sheep of Israel aka the scattered sheep of Israel - Ezekiel 34. 😒
|
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 11:15pm On Aug 15 |
Marvelous you're not seeing you actually strengthened my point. If al Tabari preserves competing reports about the substitution, citing al Tabari doesn't establish any one of them as the settled Islamic account. Transmission of competing reports isn't authentication of one. The question remains unanswered: who was supposedly substituted, and what makes that particular report sound? If one strand names one disciple while another gives a different account, you can't turn both into the Islamic explanation simply because al Tabari recorded them. And saying al Tabari compiled reports doesn't settle their authenticity either. The issue isn't whether these reports appear in tafsir; it's whether any particular report was actually authenticated. Until that's shown, we're dealing with transmitted exegetical material, not Qur'anic fact or established consensus. If you still push back, bring something actually new and valuable to your position, not repeated rephrasing. Kobojunkie: |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 11:27pm On Aug 15 |
honesttalk21:Competing? Al-Tabari's reports literally read like the drivel of a madman! 🤣🤣🤣🤣 2. Authenticated? We have both Al-Tabari and Ibn Kathir pushing for substitution, and Islam allowing both to ride through the centuries. Why demand authentication almost 1000 years later? Is this some sort of joke? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 11:51pm On Aug 15 |
You claimed there was Islamic consensus. [/b]But al Tabari's own tafsir preserves multiple reports about who was substituted. That's documented disagreement, not consensus, straight from the source you cited. [b]The gap in your response is treating both transmit it as both authenticated it. Al Tabari and Ibn Kathir preserving substitution reports doesn't mean either one established which specific report is sound. And calling al Tabari's report madman's drivel while still citing it as proof doesn't help your case. If the report is nonsense, that hardly makes its transmission evidence of settled fact. Authentication was never a 1,000 years later demand. It's the standard a report needs if it's going to be presented as fact. Centuries of inclusion don't remove the need to ask what the actual chains establish. I'm not imposing a modern standard; I'm asking the same question you keep avoiding; which specific report is authenticated, and on what basis? Kobojunkie: |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 11:56pm On Aug 15 |
honesttalk21:Stop lying! The substitution narrative was upheld from the time of Al-Tabari over 1000 years ago. Ibn Kathir only offered up a tamer story 400 years later and linked his narrative back to a supposed transmission. 🤣🤣 2. The gap here is your invention! 🤣🤣🤣 3. A standard that was overlooked for over 1000 years, and you suddenly wish to invoke me at this point in time? Nonsense! 🤣🤣🤣 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by safarifarms(m): 12:40am On Aug 16 |
Kobojunkie:No. Gentile means anyone who is not a Jew or not an Israeli.
|
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 12:42am On Aug 16 |
Too sad. I thought you will do better. What exactly do you mean by upheld? Is it transmitted, believed, or isnad verified? If you mean scholars continued transmitting the narrative, that's not authentication. Longevity alone doesn't establish which report is sound, nor turn competing accounts into consensus. Have a truly valuable informative good day. Kobojunkie: |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 12:44am On Aug 16*. Modified: 2:41am On Aug 16 |
honesttalk21:By "Do better," you mean you thought your Taqiyya obfuscation of the facts would work on me? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Even the AI tool's comparison shows that Ibn Ishaq's version of the story does more justice to the whole substitution narrative than a few others put forth before it. 😒
|
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Ken4Christ: 2:30am On Aug 16 |
LadyExcellency:This is an important point, because the fundamental difference between the biblical Jesus and the Jesus presented in Islam is not a minor theological disagreement. It concerns the very nature of Jesus and the meaning of salvation. The biblical Jesus did not seek to escape suffering or preserve His own life at the expense of someone else. He willingly gave Himself for humanity. He said, “The good shepherd gives his life for the sheep” (John 10:11). His death was not an unfortunate accident or an act of self-preservation. It was the purpose for which He came. This is why the Christian Gospel is so radically different from the idea of salvation being earned through religious transactions or promises of paradise. Jesus did not say, “Someone else should die for Me.” He said, in essence, “I will give My life for you.” For Muslims reading this discussion, I would encourage you not to simply accept either side's description of Jesus. Go back to the sources and examine the claims for yourself. Read the New Testament and ask: Who did Jesus claim to be? Why did He come? What did He teach about sin, forgiveness, sacrifice, and eternal life? At the heart of Christianity is a God who comes to humanity and gives Himself for sinners. The cross is not a story of Jesus escaping suffering. It is the story of Jesus willingly embracing suffering for our redemption. That is why the question ultimately goes beyond Christianity versus Islam. The real question is: Who is Jesus Christ? If Jesus is merely a prophet, then Christianity's central claim is false. But if He truly is the Son of God who died and rose again for the salvation of humanity, then His identity and message demand a response from every one of us. Eternity is too important for us to settle this question based on tradition, emotion, or what we have been told. We should sincerely seek the truth and be willing to follow it wherever it leads. |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by honesttalk21: 4:07am On Aug 16 |
Ironic. You said it yourself Kobojunkie:And Kobojunkie:That's not broad agreement something happened that's you calling one specific narrative the Islamic view, upheld and settled. But the chart you just posted shows al-Tabari's own tafsir preserving multiple competing versions of who was substituted and how not one upheld account. Even if you retreat to consensus that some substitution happened, that's not what you claimed across both posts; you called a specific version settled. The chart you posted disproves that specific claim, not just the general idea. Kobojunkie: |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by Kobojunkie: 4:31am On Aug 16 |
honesttalk21:At this point, you just want to argue for the sake of arguing, right? 😒😒 |
| Re: Who Is The Islamic Jesus Described In The Quran? by sonmvayina(m): 10:25am On Aug 16 |
This happens when you invent a super hero . Anybody can make up any story about that character. Jesus was invented by the Romans for their new religion called Christianity, Islam on the other hand came on board when some Christians who were dissatisfied with the trinity nonsense and decided to create their own identity....... So funny to follow....two blind mice. |
What Is The Real Name Of The Islamic God? • China Will Rewrite The Bible And The Quran To 'reflect Socialist Values' • T.B. Joshua’s Isreal Visit Described As Huge Success • 2 • 3 • 4
Rapture, What About It ?! • Everyday Word From God To Build Your Faith. • Fair Or Not
