FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 - Politics (3) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 (1896 Views)
Poll: Is FAAC increase a mirage or real
Real
21% (4 votes)
Mirage
78% (15 votes)
It's hard to say
0% (0 votes)
This poll has ended |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by mrvitalis(m): 10:13pm On Aug 23 |
Lithiumite:Because states paid high salaries that was living wage No state today not even FG can match the wage those days Workers earns 70% less minimum Professors earned $36,000 then today they barely earn 6000 dollars Corpers earned over $150 then today they earn $55 |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Kukutente23(op): 10:45pm On Aug 23 |
lawani:VAT can't form 75% of the revenue along with CIT when VAT remittance dropped |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by anonimi: 11:15pm On Aug 23 |
honesttalk21:What has 27 years of similar reforms yielded in Lagos State apart from higher revenues to government from greater tax burden on people without commensurate increase in government services and utilities to create the environment for future growth to repay the debts? |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by honesttalk21: 11:52pm On Aug 23 |
anonimi:The picture is mixed. Lagos has clearly built stronger fiscal capacity, but whether that justifies the tax burden and rising debt is a fair question. Higher IGR, transport and road investment show greater capacity, but revenue growth alone doesn't prove residents are getting better services. Lagos also isn't immune to national policy governing inflation, exchange rates, federal allocations and wider economic conditions which all shape what the state can deliver. Migration reflects those wider pressures too. Ultimately, the test is whether today's spending creates lasting infrastructure, productivity and growth capable of servicing the debt without continually pushing the cost onto residents. That requires transparent capital expenditure reporting, revenue tied visibly to service delivery, and disciplined business practice among citizens themselves, not unfair profiteering that erodes whatever gains reform delivers. |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Cromagnon: 3:15am On Aug 24 |
You need to have Surplus to be able to subsidize nigeria is unproductive and hence has no Surplus so cannot subsidize anything sustainably Gotocourt: |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by HIGHESTPOPORI(m): 3:25am On Aug 24 |
Lithiumite:Is Federal Govt not borrowing more than previous Govt combined,what happened to the subsidy savings |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by anonimi: 3:40am On Aug 24 |
honesttalk21:If Tinubu grew the state budget 100 times to N4.2 trillion in 27 years but failed to make ordinary pipe borne water available to all households then what is the basis of any renewed hope for anything different from him at the federal level? Perhaps this is why Bwala said nothing worthwhile can be achieved by Tinubu even if he is given 30 years. How much money, adjusted for inflation and population did Jakande have in four years to achieve all these progressive agenda, which didn’t stop Buhari from detaining him for corruption in 1984? Splashme:>>> >>> eluquenson:
|
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by lawani(m): 5:25am On Aug 24 |
anonimi:No there are many things in Lagos that would not have been there if not for the revenue. The state workers will be paid like any other state if not for the revenue. There would have been no rail, no good roads, no LASTMA, no well paid civil servants. A Lagos state civil servant is a big person. Even twenty years ago no Judge was paid less than one million naira. I believe today a school princi0all will be paid close to that. Don't compare Lagos to other states o. LAGBUS is a big company and the GM ranks as a big executive etc. Where did they fail? No equivalent of the Oodua group. That is the main failure but one of them Gov Aregbesola of Osun state actually listed a state owned company on the NGX, a mortgage bank and the company is doing well today. One of them Gov Ambode was the one that multiplied Lagos revenue by making it compulsory for companies to file PAYE or be shut down. Any state could have done it as Enugu just recently did it. SO DONT COMPARE LAGOS TO OTHER STATES AS LAGOS MADE A DIFFERENCE |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by lawani(m): 5:27am On Aug 24 |
HIGHESTPOPORI:IF YOU USE THE DUBIOUS FOREX RATE THAT You PEOPLE USE THEN NIGERIA HAS MUCH LESS DEBT TODAY THAN IT HAD IN 2023 IN DOLLAR TERMS |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by lawani(m): 5:36am On Aug 24 |
mrvitalis:So there was a time in this Nigeria in the past 20 years that corpers were earning in one month what 220,000 can buy today? What year was that? As in a youth coroner's monthly pay can pay like three percent of a brand new car? 150 dollars in thirty five places should buy a brand new car today. So there was a time in Nigeria that corpers allowance was that much? What year? |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by mrvitalis(m): 6:02am On Aug 24 |
lawani:In 2011 corper earned 18.000 that was over $100 dollars surely around $120 to $130 that I’m sure |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by lawani(m): 6:05am On Aug 24*. Modified: 8:55am On Aug 24 |
mrvitalis:Can that money pay 3 percent of the cost of a brand new car back then? How many kg of garri, beans, rice could it buy compared to what the 55 dollars of today can buy? I served in 2006. The allowance was 8k and before going for service, the people working as my employees were being paid around that and the money was not even up to one percent of the cost of a brand new car then maybe not up to 0.5 percent even The 150 dollars you talk about maybe up to 7 percent if the cost of some good cars now. Don't use only cars too, use any other thing |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by honesttalk21: 6:38am On Aug 24 |
anonimi:Since 1979, Lagos has had elected civilian governments only in stretches: Jakande's four years (1979–83), Otedola's brief period during the Third Republic (1992–93), and the continuous civilian era since 1999. Treating 1983–99 as part of one uninterrupted civilian record is therefore misleading; most of those years were under military rule, without elected state accountability. The water problem is also more than simple neglect. Capacity remains below 210 MGD against demand of roughly 780 MGD, while ageing infrastructure, chronic underfunding and rapid population growth have widened the gap. Tariffs are kept low for affordability, but widespread non-payment and poor cost recovery leave the LWC unable to finance maintenance and expansion adequately. Residents have therefore turned to boreholes and vendors out of necessity, despite the contamination risks. Budget growth has favoured roads, transit and revenue infrastructure, while water investment has simply not kept pace with Lagos's growth. |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Lithiumite: 6:43am On Aug 24 |
mrvitalis:By defending the naira and depleting your foreign reserves so you can be feeling rich in dollars without any viable means to sustain it.......GEJ in 2010 met the reserves at $42.08b as @ january but closed the year at $32.34b also by 2014 GEJ opened the year at $42.67b and closed @ $34.47b......always needing to deep into ur fx reserves to augment the value of the naira while running double digit inflation @ 13%. Buhari started 2022 with $40.52b but closed at $37.09 b with inflation already at 18.8% from 8% in 2014. Your fx reserves as at today is about $52b and you do not see tinubu govt Deeping their hands in there at least not yet......you are now getting the usd at its true value without having to keep borrowing to defend the naira. You now have lesser demand for the dollar because it isn't subsidised anymore. |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by mrvitalis(m): 7:07am On Aug 24 |
Lithiumite:If defending the naira with $10 billion dollars reserve per year gave us $575 billion dollars And not defending leaves us at $200 billion which do you think made more sense ? Any smart person idea would have been to earn more dollars There is no country that doesn’t manipulate their currency none |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by mrvitalis(m): 7:12am On Aug 24 |
lawani:3 percentage of a brand new car ? Can 77k do that today ? 18 could get you over 2 bags of rice 50kg each that I’m sure It could get 3 50kg bags of Garri Benue Could get over 25 creates if eggs Could book a flight from Lagos to port harcourt Could buy you 7 stock jeans Could buy you 50 plus chicken republic refill meal U want more ? |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Lithiumite: 7:23am On Aug 24 |
mrvitalis:What figures are you quoting pls, you need to be more explicit like an intelligent person,no one understands zilch in what you posted up there. |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by honesttalk21: 7:44am On Aug 24 |
I am a little curious about when around $5,250.00 could buy a brand new car. Is there some mix up against fairly used vehicles? |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by lawani(m): 8:42am On Aug 24 |
mrvitalis:You don't get it. 77k can't do it today and there was no time corper allowance could do it in Nigeria and you don't need up to that for a corper in Nigeria. A lecturer one even does not earn up to that. A Prof does not earn much more than double that and the governor of Delta recently said his salary is just over double that. So stop saying a corper was paid 150 dollars a month by the FG. It never happened except when forex rate was being manipulated |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by lawani(m): 8:47am On Aug 24 |
mrvitalis:There is no country on Earth except Nigeria where the government is confiscating dollars and selling it at 450 to the elite when the market rate is 1000. Mention the country. Don't just say things that never happened |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by lawani(m): 8:53am On Aug 24 |
honesttalk21:He inferred that 225k is what corpers should collect if the government does right by them and that amount is ten percent of 2.3 million and five percent of 4.6 million making it 2.5 percent of 9.2 million naira and roughly 1.5 percent of 20 million. How much is the average or the cheapest brand new car today? |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by honesttalk21: 8:58am On Aug 24 |
lawani:Oh, I missed the 225k point. |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Kukutente23(op): 11:00am On Aug 24 |
lawani:I don't know which universe you're typing this from but Lagos state workers are not the highest paid civil servants in Nigeria and no they are not big people. Most of them don't even have a decent roof over their heads!! And in which universe is a school principal being paid 1m in Lagos state or any state for that matter? Get off whatever you're inhaling. It's harmful |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Kukutente23(op): 11:06am On Aug 24 |
Lithiumite:Reduce your lies bro Inflation was never 13% under GEJ. GEJ ran single digit Inflation throughout his tenure And foreign reserve depletion does not mean subsidising dollars in all cases. If you were still importing 100% of your petroleum products where exactly do you think the dollars to meet that humongous daily demand will come from You need to educate yourself on simple things so you don't keep spilling trash Your head is filled with propaganda from APC WhatsApp group. GEJ never subsidised dollars at least not at the rate at which Buhari did. Buhari did to give you Dangote refinery. Dangote refinery is today saving you fx. Hope you get it now? |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Kukutente23(op): 11:39am On Aug 24 |
[quote author=Lithiumite post=140430508][/quote]Noted. It reduced year on year until single digits for the last 3 years of his tenure But reduce your ignorance about the foreign reserves See how APC never achieved single digits even with their evil manipulation of data
|
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Image123(m): 11:51am On Aug 24 |
Kukutente23:i remember this same thread, i have mentioned this same thing a couple of times. Note the coloured. Kukutente23:Lolz, talk about shooting one's self in the foot. You've demonstrated evidence of consistent increase in naira, our currency. Asides oil and gas, most of other FAAC generation are in naira. Major sources of FAAC are oil and gas revenue, company income tax, VAT and customs revenue. FAAC is also spent in naira, not dollars. Bring in dollar when you want to whine about GDP, not FAAC. Federal government mostly spends its part on F[b]ederal roads and infrastructure, Defence and security, federal universities and hospitals, federal civil-service salaries, national agencies, debt servicing, social programmes and federal capital projects. Almost all these are in naira. Similar thing goes for states and local governments. [/b] You may also note the percentage shift in annual oil and gas revenue and non-oil and gas revenue. We've made outstanding progress from 1999 to now. From over 70-80% to currently 40-45% reliance on o&g. Give kundus where due. We all know what we are doing sha. When it's time to talk about debts, which are mostly in dollars. Your hypocritical brain will forbid dollars and remember naira. Dey play. |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Lithiumite: 9:16am On Aug 25 |
Kukutente23:I thought you said gej never did double digits Thank you for being Honourable enough to recant your earlier assertion,I will give you that. Also be Honourable enough to post current inflation figures and also highlight the curve tinubu is turning on this issue......I for one acknowledged gej for atleast bringing it down to 8% before he left. Thanks |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by pharmagba: 9:23am On Aug 25 |
Opposition politicians and fraud/ liars are siemese twins. When they compare debts they dont compare exchange rate but when they compare earning they want to |
| Re: FAAC Allocation With Dollar Equivalent 2010-2025 by Kukutente23(op): 10:44am On Aug 25 |
Lithiumite:GEJ inherited double figures and brought it down to single digits Tinubu inherited 22% inflation and took it to over 35% the highest in our history and had to hide it by rebasing. So Tinubu performed worse than all former presidents combined swhen it comes to inflation
|
14 States That Will Struggle If FAAC Allocation Stops • 2023 FAAC Allocation For Nigerian States - Before & After Fuel Subsidy Removal • INEC Official Caught With Dollar Notes In Oworo, Lagos State. • 2 • 3 • 4
The Stuff White Ppl Will Tell You About Nigeria Is Mindblowing • Free And Fair Elections, Gej Is Keeping His Promise • Canada Finally Deports The Infamous Kemi Omololu-olunloyo