₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,430 members, 8,523,128 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 07:15 PM

Toggle theme

Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga (8780 Views)

1 2 3 4 Reply (Go Down)

Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by emkz(op): 7:14pm On Sep 03
STATEHOUSE STATEMENT

CLARIFICATION ON THE ONGOING FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT CASE IN WASHINGTON, D.C.


The Presidency has noted recent speculative reports concerning an ongoing Freedom of Information Act case before the United States District Court for the District of Columbia.

For clarity, the matter is a civil records-disclosure dispute under the United States Freedom of Information Act. It is not a criminal case against President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, nor has the court found him guilty of any criminal wrongdoing.

Here is the background to the case, which comes 23 years after the American Consulate in Lagos, in a letter dated February 4, 2003, informed the then Inspector General of Police, Mr Tafa Balogun, that an FBI records check found no criminal arrest records, wants, or warrants for then Governor Bola Ahmed Tinubu.
In 2022, Mr Aaron Greenspan, who is known to work with Nigerian opposition figures including David Hundeyin and Atiku Abubakar, submitted FOIA requests to several United States government agencies seeking records relating to President Tinubu. After the agencies withheld certain records or declined to confirm or deny their existence, Mr Greenspan commenced Civil Action No. 23-1816 before the United States District Court for the District of Columbia in 2023.

The court subsequently permitted President Tinubu to participate in the proceedings as an intervenor.

During the proceedings, the Defendants asserted the "Glomar defence, a standard defence that US law enforcement agencies invoke from time to time. It simply means the government agency is not "in a position to deny or admit" the existence of an investigation. It protects government personnel and the techniques and sources law enforcement agencies use to investigate and prosecute crimes.

Based on the invocation of this defence, the United States District Court granted summary judgment in favour of the CIA, EOUSA, Department of State, Department of the Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). It ruled that they be removed from the proceedings, leaving aspects of the claims involving the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Drug Enforcement Administration for further consideration.
In compliance with the court’s orders, the FBI and DEA produced 399 pages of records, with portions redacted under exemptions provided by United States law. The Plaintiff challenged the FBI and DEA's decisions to redact portions of the documents produced.
The FBI and DEA, through the United States Department of Justice (USDoJ), pushed back against the Plaintiff's requests. The FBI and DEA rejected the application to produce the documents without redactions for the following reasons:

1. Some of the documents are protected from being revealed to the public by law, for example, Grand Jury proceedings. The law exempts transcripts of Grand Jury proceedings from public disclosure. The Pen Register Act also protects from disclosure information about certain court order(s) authorising or approving the installation and use of a pen register or trap and trace device. (FOIA Exemption 3)

2. Some of the documents fall squarely within the attorney-work product and attorney-client privileges. Some documents contain instances where FBI and DEA agents sought and/or received legal advice from USDoJ attorneys. (FOIA Exemption 5)

3. Some of the documents were prepared for law enforcement purposes. (FOIA Exemption 5)

4. Some of the documents contain information which, if revealed, could lead to an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy. (FOIA Exemptions 6 and 7(C)).

5. Some of the documents, if disclosed, will reveal the identities of confidential sources or compromise the techniques that law enforcement agencies use in investigating crimes. (FOIA Exemptions 7(D) and 7(E))

President Bola Tinubu, on advice of his lawyers, has also asserted his rights as guaranteed by FOIA Exemption 7(C).


The Plaintiff has until September 11, 2026, to file any opposition and reply to the Defendants' and Intervener's processes, while the FBI, DEA and the Intervenor have until September 18, 2026, to respond to the processes that the Plaintiff might have filed.

The release or withholding of records under FOIA does not, by itself, establish criminal liability. The case concerns access to government records and the proper application of statutory exemptions.

The Nigerian media should note that this case is exclusively within the control of Judge Beryl A. Howell of the United States District Court. She will determine its outcome, based on the evidence, applicable law, and the parties' arguments, not the wishful preference of Alhaji Atiku Abubakar or his agent, Mr Von Batten.

Recent public commentary by Mr Karl von Batten has inaccurately portrayed him and his client as central to the proceedings. Neither is a party to the case.

The litigation is a civil records-disclosure dispute under FOIA. It does not constitute a criminal charge, trial, or judicial finding against President Tinubu. The FBI and DEA have produced records with redactions, and the remaining question is whether those redactions are lawful.

The United States District Court will decide that issue based on the filings and applicable US law, not political commentary.

The Presidency therefore urges the media and the public to distinguish verified court proceedings from partisan speculation.
Bayo Onanuga
Special Adviser to the President
(Information and Strategy)
September 3, 2026

Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Validated: 7:15pm On Sep 03
Una go "Explain Taya", no reprive, no evidence. Even Bayo Onanuga has become content creator like Bwala.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Ofunaofu: 7:18pm On Sep 03
Una go explain tire till.....
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by emkz(op): 7:24pm On Sep 03
Validated and Ofunaofu, how can someone be convicted in the United States and it is not on record? Atiku paid Ikemefuna $1.2 million to establish that Tinubu was convicted when no court ever convicted him. Do you see how silly that sounds?

It is like someone pays an investigator to say you are a woman, whereas you are a man by every sense of it. It is a serious crisis to manufacture what does not exist.

Now, if the settlement was sealed, why should they be exposed? If Atiku claimed they were related to a drug issue, then Atiku needs to explain his interest in the case. Atiku needs to inform the judge if he is a drug dealer.

If Ikemefuna is as connected as he claims, he can contact a highranking FBI officer to give him information. He has no connections beyond twitter.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Validated: 7:27pm On Sep 03
emkz:
Validated and Ofunaofu, how can someone be convicted in the United States and it is not on record? Atiku paid Ikemefuna $1.2 million to establish that Tinubu was convicted when no court ever convicted him. Do you see how silly that sounds?

It is like someone pays an investigator to say you are a woman, whereas you are a man by every sense of it. It is a serious crisis to manufacture what does not exist.

Now, if the settlement was sealed, why should they be exposed? If Atiku claimed they were related to a drug issue, then Atiku needs to explain his interest in the case. Atiku needs to inform the judge if he is a drug dealer.
What is Tinubu hiding by hiring lawyers and sending emissaries to bribe with $3m?
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by LagosOrigin: 7:31pm On Sep 03
When will tinubu visit the United States?

If the US government no arrest am, No be my mama born me.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by BATified2023: 7:34pm On Sep 03
LagosOrigin:
When will tinubu visit the United States?

If the US government no arrest am, No be my mama born me.
princeoflagos


U don come again this election season


grin grin grin
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by emkz(op):
If I put a machete, gunpowder, salt, pepper, water, and blood on the floor and ask you to swear that Tinubu sent emissaries to bribe someone with $3 million, will you be willing to do it? The idea is that after you swear on those things, you cannot eat food prepared with salt, pepper, water and anything that had blood else you'd face something terrible

See Karl Marx lied. He recycled a picture of Eric Trump as a recent one to appear important and pulled it down after he was told he circulated the same picture in 2024. He also claimed to have been appointed into a White House presidential commission. There is still no record of such an appointment. Then someone wanted to bribe him with $3 million and he is struggling to name the person?

How old are you, sir?
Validated:
What is Tinubu hiding by hiring lawyers and sending emissaries to bribe with $3m?
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by emkz(op): 7:39pm On Sep 03
When will Atiku visit?
LagosOrigin:
When will tinubu visit the United States?

If the US government no arrest am, No be my mama born me.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by rossipki: 7:41pm On Sep 03
Validated:
Una go "Explain Taya", no reprive, no evidence. Even Bayo Onanuga has become content creator like Bwala.
UNA GO CRY TAYA AFTER YOU LOSE ELECTION.

Criminals seeking Nigerian Presidency through the back door.

Meanwhile Peter Obi has no Manifesto till now.
So-called presidential candidate.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by seunmsg(m): 7:44pm On Sep 03
Validated:
What is Tinubu hiding by hiring lawyers and sending emissaries to bribe with $3m?
Nobody offered Ikemefuna Okeke any single kobo. He’s a liar and a fraudster. He should produced the evidence of the bribe and the name of the person that offered it to him.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by seunmsg(m): 7:45pm On Sep 03
I’m glad the president’s team has decided to clarify things instead of letting the liars keep rehashing same take with different spins daily.

The 399 pages document Okeke is lying about have berm released to David Hundeyin and Greenspan since 2023. They only went back to court to ask for the removal of the redacted parts. The one they gave them, they couldn’t find anything there because there is nothing.


This is what the fraudster called Ikemefuna who is not even a party to the case has been spinning and twisting to entertain deluded obidients. He’s scamming Atiku and messing with the heads of Obidients at the same time. Very crooked guy 🤣🤣🤣
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Ofunaofu: 7:52pm On Sep 03
seunmsg:
I’m glad the president’s team has decided to clarify things instead of letting the liars keep rehashing same take with different spins daily.
What exactly is there to clarify?

Was Bayo Onanuga with Tinubu when he was running the streets of Chicago in the ’90s, culminating in the forfeiture of $460,000 to the U.S. government over funds the court found represented proceeds of narcotics trafficking?

Or has Onanuga now also been appointed Tinubu’s official historian of Chicago?
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by seunmsg(m): 7:55pm On Sep 03
Ofunaofu:
What exactly is there to clarify?

Was Bayo Onanuga with Tinubu when he was running the streets of Chicago in the ’90s, culminating in the forfeiture of $460,000 to the U.S. government over funds the court found represented proceeds of narcotics trafficking?

Or has Onanuga now also been appointed Tinubu’s official historian of Chicago?
lol. A civil forfeiture in which the FBI returned money to the accused and then asked the court to dismiss the case with prejudice is absolutely nothing.

Even in plea bargaining agreement, the accused is charged to court, convicted and then given a light penalty. He’s never discharged and acquitted and then given back the proceed of the crime. The FBI will also never issue a letter through the US Embassy declaring that the person has no criminal record.


So, you guys should stop chasing shadows and start campaigning based on issues. This same propaganda failed in 2023, it will fail again in 2027.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Ofunaofu: 8:09pm On Sep 03
seunmsg:
lol. A civil forfeiture in which the FBI returned money to the accused and then asked the court to dismiss the case with prejudice is absolutely nothing.

Even in plea bargaining agreement, the accused is charged to court, convicted and then given a light penalty. He’s never discharged and acquitted and then given back the proceed of the crime. The FBI will also never issue a letter through the US Embassy declaring that the person has no criminal record.


So, you guys should stop chasing shadows and start campaigning based on issues. This same propaganda failed in 2023, it will fail again in 2027.
seunmsg, let me get this straight: are you saying the FBI and DEA returned the $460,000 to Tinubu?
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by seunmsg(m): 8:11pm On Sep 03
Ofunaofu:
seunmsg, let me get this straight: are you saying the FBI and DEA returned the $460,000 to Tinubu?
Go and read about the case and stop asking silly question.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Cj4charles(m): 8:14pm On Sep 03
Then allow them to release details of it
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Ballmer: 8:14pm On Sep 03

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7vyBSkJ6dU

Obidients are hoping everyone will be like the criminal they want to impose on Nigerians. Same criminal that looted N250 million monthly for good 8 years.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Atlantis585: 8:15pm On Sep 03
When did drug dealing and money laundering cease being a criminal offense?
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by blackgold2018(m): 8:15pm On Sep 03
emkz:
If I put a machete, gunpowder, salt, pepper, water, and blood on the floor and ask you to swear tharlt Tinubu sent emissaries to bribe someone with $3 million, will you be willing to do it? The idea is that after you swear on those things, you cannot eat food prepared with salt, pepper, water and anything that had blood else you'd face something terrible

See Karl Marx lied. He recycled a picture of Eric Trump as a recent one to appear important and pulled it down after he was told he circulated the same picture in 2024. He also claimed to have been appointed into a White House presidential commission. There is still no record of such an appointment. Then someone wanted to bribe him with $3 million and he is struggling to name the person?

How old are you, sir?
the hustle is real. Episode upon episode
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Racoon(m): 8:15pm On Sep 03
Hehehe! A President who trusts his people does not spend the eve of an election paying American lawyers to keep his people in the dark. The reputation is already wounded. Fire burning them everywhere. Let the US judge answer please.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Eba50: 8:16pm On Sep 03
timuboo should just travel to u.s and pay visit to trump

Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Dreambeat: 8:17pm On Sep 03
Ok we gree say na civil forfeiture. Just ask them to release the files We wan check something
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by davidtemi(m): 8:17pm On Sep 03
He just wishes to dash US money right.

Awon ti olorun ma dojuti ke yin aye won
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Oakenshield: 8:17pm On Sep 03
Make the full case file the public and watch them spin the narrative again and judiciary will give kangaroo judgement
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by ARISHEM: 8:18pm On Sep 03
All parties should keep kwayet and allow the FBI release it
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by SixSeven: 8:18pm On Sep 03
Integrity cannot be bought at the market.


You go explain taya

Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by adecares(f): 8:19pm On Sep 03
What people don't know is that if there's actually any criminal record against President Tinubu, it would have been out in the open a long time ago, I still remembered how the then President Obasanjo pressed President Tinubu's neck as a sitting governor of Lagos state. He even withheld his state's allocation.
I even love the fact that the opposition left elections matter to focus on issues that shouldn't even be on their list, instead of you to tender facts that would boost your points into being elected, you are rather telling people why your opponent shouldn't be elected.
What a shame!
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by PigTormentor: 8:20pm On Sep 03
It's time to ignore these noises about forfiture.
Tinubu is winning anyway, allow them to keep wasting time on frivolous topics.
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by Sleekfingers: 8:23pm On Sep 03
Atlantis585:
When did drug dealing and money laundering cease being a criminal offense?
Was he convicted?
Show proof of his drug dealing
Re: Tinubu's $460000 forfeiture, a civil-dispute matter, not criminal - Bayo Onanuga by DLifeless1: 8:23pm On Sep 03
Then you guys should stop running helter skelter and allow the US release the files lets see if it is civil or Criminal na?
1 2 3 4 Reply

Bola, I laid foundation for the Univ, same year you forfeited $460000 - Atiku • Only The Law Will Matter - Not Media Tactics Or Street Yelling — Afe Babalola • Keyamo: Tinubu’s Forfeiture Of $460,000 Was Civil, Not Criminal • 2 • 3 • 4

2019: Atiku Chooses Senator Bruce As Running Mate • Buhari Vs Osinbajo: How Nigerian VP Violated The Greatest Law Of Power • Tanker Drivers Suspend Strike In Lagos