Ukutsgp:
i just came here to debunk the claim that u people compiled the bible and i have done just that. Cos i hate hearing that. The bible had been compiled before your so called roman catholic came into existence. They are all in the post. U can read it up.

I dnt hv to reply u on the other matters. That is for another day. I have other business to attend to.

I dnt have ur time.

nora544:


since when we have photos!
I know nigerians have a photo from her pastor at home when he is realy important.
do you know that to remember a person you need a photot did we have this 1000 years ago.
Please use your brain or perhaps you left it in the church.

craziebone:


the catholics in here suffer severe bashing on daily basis. Thats why they appear to be hostile. It is the same thing you find with any group of people who are exposed to attacks on daily basis. If you open a thread that tends to attack Jehovah's withnesses, christ embassy, Oyedepo, etc, you will see some of their members become hostile to you.

The bottom line is: that the catholics are being hostile to you does not confirm that they do not follow the way of christ including patience, perseverance etc.

craziebone:


the catholics in here suffer severe bashing on daily basis. Thats why they appear to be hostile. It is the same thing you find with any group of people who are exposed to attacks on daily basis. If you open a thread that tends to attack Jehovah's withnesses, christ embassy, Oyedepo, etc, you will see some of their members become hostile to you.

The bottom line is: that the catholics are being hostile to you does not confirm that they do not follow the way of christ including patience, perseverance etc.

HARMONIEE:
lol. Please sir, use your brain too.. Who saw Mary and all those dead people when they were alive and is still alive today? The person drawing or molding is doing It out of imagination.. Don't let the spirit brainwash you too sir. I love your idea, but Hey did your Pope see Mary when she was on earth? So how come he knows what she looks like? (Exodus 20:4-5)

Ukutsgp:
i just came here to debunk the claim that u people compiled the bible and i have done just that. Cos i hate hearing that. The bible had been compiled before your so called roman catholic came into existence. They are all in the post. U can read it up.

I dnt hv to reply u on the other matters. That is for another day. I have other business to attend to.

I dnt have ur time.

craziebone:


i think what a christian and an intellectual would have replied to my post you quoted is that; he would have asked me to show that the bible doesn't teach those things you said it teaches! He wouldn't have resorted to angry and hate words.

Op, if you want to have an intellectually and spiritually inspired discussion, you can ask me for my opinion. I must say again that i am not catholic. I attended their school and have read a lot about them so i know a whole lot about them that some people mistake me for one. There are certain things i do not agree with them on. But i am someone who likes a discussion where everyone can be free to face the possibility of know that what we use to believe is absolutely untrue.

chukwudi44:
resol;ution 24 of the council of carthage in 419CE

Canon 24. (Greek xxvii.)

That nothing be read in church besides the Canonical Scripture

Item, that besides the Canonical Scriptures nothing be read in church under the name of divine Scripture.

But the Canonical Scriptures are as follows:
•Genesis.
•Exodus.
•Leviticus.
•Numbers.
•Deuteronomy.
•Joshua the Son of Nun.
•The Judges.
•Ruth.
•The Kings, iv. books.
•The Chronicles, ij. books.
•Job.
•The Psalter.
•The Five books of Solomon.
•The Twelve Books of the Prophets.
•Isaiah.
•Jeremiah.
•Ezechiel.
•Daniel.
•Tobit.
•Judith.
•Esther.
•Ezra, ij. books.
•Macchabees, ij. books. ◦The New Testament. ■The Gospels, iv. books.
■The Acts of the Apostles, j. book.
■The Epistles of Paul, xiv.
■The Epistles of Peter, the Apostle, ij.
■The Epistles of John the Apostle, iij.
■The Epistles of James the Apostle, j.
■The Epistle of Jude the Apostle, j.
■The Revelation of John, j. book.



Let this be sent to our brother and fellow bishop, Boniface, and to the other bishops of those parts, that they may confirm this canon, for these are the things which we have received from our fathers to be read in church.

http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3816.htm

MrsAwesome:
Meaning Jesus never existed because he has no photo right...

HARMONIEE:
if the Roman Catholic wrote the Bible then they are confused cos what they wrote isn't what they practice, no single scripture to backup MOTHER OF GOD.

vest:
Who Is A Mother?

HARMONIEE:

You have not answer me yet.
About purgatory,
what the Bible said is far different from what Catholics paint it. Matthew 12:32 simply means the person won't be forgiven here on earth or before God in judgment (unlike joshua the high priest that was) i was once a Roman Catholic faithful sha. So I know what the demonic leaders are using to brainwash and enslave people to sin.

About mother of God,
Mary was the vessel God used in bringing Jesus (God in human form) to the earth so she was right in saying it. Remember i asked you, is Mary God's mother? Search your conscience and answer me openly YES! (GOD our creator, has a mother) or No (he doesn't) don't hide inside the Bible as Satan did when tempting Jesus.

About the eucharistic ;
Did Jesus say, you should be eating his physical body or he meant the memorial body (luke 22:19), do you mean the wafer for the eucharistic is Jesus physical body or you mean it's for remembering Christ?


Please answer me directly don't bend scriptures. Thanks alot.
Everyone contributing God bless you but let's Remember the topic:
ARE ROMAN CATHOLICS CHRISTIANS?
Cos my aim is to know what part of Roman Catholic doctrine was derived from the gospel the apostles preached.


Two more questions please:
1)Is Mary the Queen of heaven?
2)why do Roman Catholics use statutes and images.





I am enjoying the discussion thanks all. Let's make our aims and beliefs plain

HARMONIEE:

You have not answer me yet.
About purgatory,
what the Bible said is far different from what Catholics paint it. Matthew 12:32 simply means the person won't be forgiven here on earth or before God in judgment (unlike joshua the high priest that was) i was once a Roman Catholic faithful sha. So I know what the demonic leaders are using to brainwash and enslave people to sin.

About mother of God,
Mary was the vessel God used in bringing Jesus (God in human form) to the earth so she was right in saying it. Remember i asked you, is Mary God's mother? Search your conscience and answer me openly YES! (GOD our creator, has a mother) or No (he doesn't) don't hide inside the Bible as Satan did when tempting Jesus.

About the eucharistic ;
Did Jesus say, you should be eating his physical body or he meant the memorial body (luke 22:19), do you mean the wafer for the eucharistic is Jesus physical body or you mean it's for remembering Christ?


Please answer me directly don't bend scriptures. Thanks alot.
Everyone contributing God bless you but let's Remember the topic:
ARE ROMAN CATHOLICS CHRISTIANS?
Cos my aim is to know what part of Roman Catholic doctrine was derived from the gospel the apostles preached.


Two more questions please:
1)Is Mary the Queen of heaven?
2)why do Roman Catholics use statutes and images.





I am enjoying the discussion thanks all. Let's make our aims and beliefs plain

Emyben:

You aint here to learn like u wana make us believe.You are primarily here to criticize, condemn and judge and that makes you and this thread a flesh and piece of trash. I dont know why some Catholics here are replying you and your garbage. italo....stop ya responses. This dude is not here to learn.

HARMONIEE:
you people amuse me..
My question is simple.
ARE ROMAN CATHOLICS CHRISTIANS?
Simply say yes with prove of their doctrines similarities with that of the apostles
example ;
Yes, because in Harmony chapter 1 vs 2
and Jesus prayed! Holy Mary, mother of God Almighty, pray for all sinners, Now and the hour of their death, AMEN

And in verse 4 apostle Paul yelled, Saint Elijah pray for us!


Or No, because, your reasons

jamesjohn2010:
you cannot come to God except He draws you. Reasoning and human logics are not it. no matter how educated you are in the world, you cannot know the bible unless by revelation from God. flesh and blood cannot tell u. it is only the lamb that is worthy to open the seal. the bible is the Revelation of Jesus. the old Catholic that came on were the good one until the first seal was opened and a man sitting on White horse given crown but has no bow came on. the old Catholic were Pentecostals ( peter, James, John, Paul ... were). about 300hundred years later(Nicene era) another set came on to blend Christianity and existing roman idolatry. even many denominations that sprang thereafter are not much different either. but rest assured God has children in every denomination. the doctrines of denominations won't get us any where but the engrafted word with revelation will. but God has men: Paul, Ireneus, Luther, Columbus, Martin, Wesley and Branham to counter the moves.
I will shock u. most of our churches doesn't know God be it Pentecostal, Catholic, Presbyterian, Baptist , Methodist.... I will say more if moved

HARMONIEE:
I need to understand something

And save my relatives!
ARE ROMAN CATHOLICS CHRISTIANS?
REMEMBER THE MEANING OF CHRISTIAN (LIKE
CHRIST)
DOES GOD HAVE A MOTHER?
WAS MARY WITHOUT SIN?
please Friends teach me something I don't know. I need your opinions please

An2elect2:


No, they are not.
God has no mother.
Mary was with sin.
Its not my opinion, it is scriptural.

Hope u are saved!?

MrsAwesome:
Imagine...
What point was God trying to make ...prove by letting his begotten saviour born...come from someone with sin..? I mean it doesn't make sense anymore then. Clean supposed to come from clean......
Atheists will be rejoicing with these confusionism in Christendom....

An2elect2:


No, they are not.
God has no mother.
Mary was with sin.
Its not my opinion, it is scriptural.

Hope u are saved!?

Pavore9:
Na today?...I wonder how people go about as if their salvation is dependent on Catholics renouncing their faith, abeg make una dey go una "heaven" make we see road. PRAISE BE TO JESUS, HONOUR TO MARY!

HARMONIEE:
I need to understand something

And save my relatives!
ARE ROMAN CATHOLICS CHRISTIANS?
REMEMBER THE MEANING OF CHRISTIAN (LIKE
CHRIST)
DOES GOD HAVE A MOTHER?
WAS MARY WITHOUT SIN?
please Friends teach me something I don't know. I need your opinions please

brainoid:
Harmony is no available seems he got a ban or something , but basically he says he got what he is wants.. He isn't creating confusion, he is separating the sheep from the qoats, roman Catholics are not Christian, read these two books, rescued from hell and testimony of an ex satanist by pastor jonas, he will mail them to you just mail him about it.. And am not sure when Harmony is coming back,, also Mary was born with sin don't confuse yourself read Luke 2:22-24 don't defend the Vatican and her evil doctrine, roman Catholicism is pure evil, that's the little i could say, if you need to contact harmony mail him = iamharmonie@gmailcom


Thanks.