₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: RegisterLoginWith GoogleTrendingRecentNew

Stats: 3,331,110 members, 8,448,735 topics. Date: Monday, 20 July 2026 at 06:19 PM

Toggle theme

disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland ForumNairaland GeneralChristianity Etcdisciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? (1064 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by tenry(op): 9:52am On Sep 13, 2015
Mathew and John gave different accounts of how Jesus Christ fed multitudes with 5 loaves and 2 fishes. According to Mathew 14:17, his disciples told Him that they have 5 loaves and two fishes while John 6:9 says a young lad donated it. Who actually donated 5 loaves and two fishes? The disciples as recorded in Mathew 14:17 or the lad according to John 6:9? Why did we have different account of the events? Whose account was correct? Mathew or John?
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by 1miccza: 9:57am On Sep 13, 2015
In the book of Matthew it says they brought the boy to Jesus read properly and let's see...
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by tenry(op): 10:03am On Sep 13, 2015
1miccza:
In the book of Matthew it says they brought the boy to Jesus read properly and let's see...
Oga, Whc bible are you reading? Mathew 14 from 13-19 didn't indicate that they brought a boy to him. I will advice you read both passages very well. Thank you.
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by 1miccza: 10:07am On Sep 13, 2015
tenry:
Oga, Whc bible are you reading? Mathew 14 from 13-19 didn't indicate that they brought a boy to him. I will advice you read both passages very well. Thank you.
Well it could also mean they collected it and brought it to him don't you think so?
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by tenry(op): 10:12am On Sep 13, 2015
1miccza:
Well it could also mean they collected it and brought it to him don't you think so?
Well, may be.
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by 1miccza: 10:14am On Sep 13, 2015
tenry:
Well, may be.
That was the first thought that occured to me too
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by Princewell2012(m): 12:03pm On Sep 13, 2015
These ones are irrelevant. They could be actually saying the same thing. my wife gave, i gave or we gave. What actually matters is something has been given out.


Op is trying to look for something where there is notting.



because i know you are trying to say they contradicted themselves.
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by Nobody: 12:20pm On Sep 13, 2015
tenry:
Mathew and John gave different accounts of how Jesus Christ fed multitudes with 5 loaves and 2 fishes. According to Mathew 14:17, his disciples told Him that they have 5 loaves and two fishes while John 6:9 says a young lad donated it. Who actually donated 5 loaves and two fishes? The disciples as recorded in Mathew 14:17 or the lad according to John 6:9? Why did we have different account of the events? Whose account was correct? Mathew or John?
Dont bother yourself for the answers....... U can't feed 5000 people with 5 loaves of bread n 2 fishes... it's IMPOSSIBLE.
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by tenry(op): 12:31pm On Sep 13, 2015
chuna1985:
Dont bother yourself for the answers....... U can't feed 5000 people with 5 loaves of bread n 2 fishes... it's IMPOSSIBLE.
Mumu
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by Nobody: 1:00pm On Sep 13, 2015
I will read that passage very well before commenting on it. Brb
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by Nobody: 1:11pm On Sep 13, 2015
tenry:
Mumu
Do u have proofhuh
1 Reply

Man Orders Boss To Sign Document In The Name Of Jesus Or He DiesApostle Suleman: "Disciples Of Jesus Were Armed, Were His Bodyguards'' (Video)Man Who Donated His Hotel Building To Catholic Church, Turns Keke Napep Driver234

Photos From The Burial Of Muslims Killed In The Mecca Crane CrashTyrese Gibson Says He 'literally Witnessed A Miracle' When God Healed His MotherOriginal Sin - Are We Condemned By The Sin Of Adam And Eve?