₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: RegisterLoginWith GoogleTrendingRecentNew

Stats: 3,331,225 members, 8,449,233 topics. Date: Tuesday, 21 July 2026 at 01:22 PM

Toggle theme

disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland ForumNairaland GeneralChristianity Etcdisciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? (1067 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by tenry(op): 9:52am On Sep 13, 2015
Mathew and John gave different accounts of how Jesus Christ fed multitudes with 5 loaves and 2 fishes. According to Mathew 14:17, his disciples told Him that they have 5 loaves and two fishes while John 6:9 says a young lad donated it. Who actually donated 5 loaves and two fishes? The disciples as recorded in Mathew 14:17 or the lad according to John 6:9? Why did we have different account of the events? Whose account was correct? Mathew or John?
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by 1miccza: 9:57am On Sep 13, 2015
In the book of Matthew it says they brought the boy to Jesus read properly and let's see...
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by tenry(op): 10:03am On Sep 13, 2015
1miccza:
In the book of Matthew it says they brought the boy to Jesus read properly and let's see...
Oga, Whc bible are you reading? Mathew 14 from 13-19 didn't indicate that they brought a boy to him. I will advice you read both passages very well. Thank you.
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by 1miccza: 10:07am On Sep 13, 2015
tenry:
Oga, Whc bible are you reading? Mathew 14 from 13-19 didn't indicate that they brought a boy to him. I will advice you read both passages very well. Thank you.
Well it could also mean they collected it and brought it to him don't you think so?
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by tenry(op): 10:12am On Sep 13, 2015
1miccza:
Well it could also mean they collected it and brought it to him don't you think so?
Well, may be.
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by 1miccza: 10:14am On Sep 13, 2015
tenry:
Well, may be.
That was the first thought that occured to me too
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by Princewell2012(m): 12:03pm On Sep 13, 2015
These ones are irrelevant. They could be actually saying the same thing. my wife gave, i gave or we gave. What actually matters is something has been given out.


Op is trying to look for something where there is notting.



because i know you are trying to say they contradicted themselves.
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by Nobody: 12:20pm On Sep 13, 2015
tenry:
Mathew and John gave different accounts of how Jesus Christ fed multitudes with 5 loaves and 2 fishes. According to Mathew 14:17, his disciples told Him that they have 5 loaves and two fishes while John 6:9 says a young lad donated it. Who actually donated 5 loaves and two fishes? The disciples as recorded in Mathew 14:17 or the lad according to John 6:9? Why did we have different account of the events? Whose account was correct? Mathew or John?
Dont bother yourself for the answers....... U can't feed 5000 people with 5 loaves of bread n 2 fishes... it's IMPOSSIBLE.
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by tenry(op): 12:31pm On Sep 13, 2015
chuna1985:
Dont bother yourself for the answers....... U can't feed 5000 people with 5 loaves of bread n 2 fishes... it's IMPOSSIBLE.
Mumu
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by Nobody: 1:00pm On Sep 13, 2015
I will read that passage very well before commenting on it. Brb
Re: disciples Of Jesus Or A Young Boy,who Actually Donated 5loaves And 2 Fishes? by Nobody: 1:11pm On Sep 13, 2015
tenry:
Mumu
Do u have proofhuh
1 Reply

Man Orders Boss To Sign Document In The Name Of Jesus Or He DiesApostle Suleman: "Disciples Of Jesus Were Armed, Were His Bodyguards'' (Video)Man Who Donated His Hotel Building To Catholic Church, Turns Keke Napep Driver234

Dont Sweat It, Rest!! - Joseph PrincePlease Is There Any Religion Other Than Christianity?Why Atheists Believe God Doesn't Exist