I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? - Christianity Etc (3) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? (4327 Views)
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by dolphinheart(m): 8:55pm On Feb 03, 2016 |
SirWere:1. My use of the word "sand- sand" is not in reference to sand as defined by science. "Sand- sand" to me are materials found on the earth, either as an element, a mixture or a compound. 2. I did not say sand is not a mixture 3. I did not say all sands have the same component. 4. You are the expert and you just said :"The only type of soil with a trace of carbon in it is Beach sands". I did not say all sands have carbon in it, so pls understand where my layman speech is coming from before you accuse someone of uttering false statements. My use of the word "sand" is not scientific, but in reference to the components found on the earth and are in humans too. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by HardMirror(op): 8:57pm On Feb 03, 2016 |
UyiIredia:Very interesting. So what should I do? Can you share this experience |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by Joshthefirst(m): 9:03pm On Feb 03, 2016 |
HardMirror:Luke 16:19-31 gives a clear and concise representation of events occurring after death. You can ask questions after your perusal if you're interested. There are many evidences and stories, but the bible presents the readily available truth. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by Joshthefirst(m): 9:17pm On Feb 03, 2016*. Modified: 5:56am On Feb 04, 2016 |
SirWere:The dictionary's definition of faith is not my definition. I follow the Bible's definition of faith. And I have put it up. If you cannot contend with that definition, fine. I would think that you should leave it to men of faith to define faith itself. And if I were to act all smarty pants like you've been acting in your puerile effort to undermine dolphinheart, I would educate you on how people cannot just go see atoms anytime, any day, as our technology cannot see their small hypothesized structure yet. Go and utter false statements no more. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by UyiIredia(m): 9:54pm On Feb 03, 2016 |
HardMirror:For you to rationalize away. I don't think so. Best not to waste my time and yours. You are free to believe or disbelieve what you want. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by Nobody: 7:46am On Feb 04, 2016 |
Joshthefirst:Oh, I acknowledged your definition all right; I just wanted you to know that the "insultive" way of defining faith is actually the standard definiton of faith, according to the dictionary. And as for you saying Atoms can't be seen; well; check out this link. motherboard.vice.com/read/this-microscope-can-see-down-to-individual-atoms |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by onetrack(m): 9:06am On Feb 04, 2016 |
Joshthefirst:Faith is defined as the following: "strong belief in the doctrines of a religion, based on spiritual conviction rather than proof." Faith does not help me get through anything. If I believe that atoms exist, it is because researchers have shown indirect but logical and compelling proof that atoms exist. Same with the theory of evolution. Offense was not intended by me. However I stand by what I wrote. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by analice107: 4:08pm On Feb 04, 2016*. Modified: 4:25pm On Feb 04, 2016 |
dolphinheart:I have seen it, and I shall reply, given the time. The above is my responds to you. I dont know how to break the text up. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by analice107: 6:19pm On Feb 04, 2016 |
dolphinheart:My response to your other post address all these. I don't know how to break the text up, so I ended up jumbling everything up. Pls bear with me and read it like that. Thanks. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by dolphinheart(m): 6:43pm On Feb 04, 2016 |
analice107:Ill try to break it down, put your words in quotes and reply accordingly. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by dolphinheart(m): 12:51pm On Feb 05, 2016 |
@ analice107 Sir, when I responded to you, I knew exactly what I was doing.But I dnt know, hence I needed to understand if you are trying to bring a new topic in to the thread. The verses you brought up and my reply to the op are not directly related. I know you, I haveIf you had been following me, you would have known that I believe in life after death. You would have also noticed that i make comments based on my views and I ask questions so that everyone can have a better understanding of what's being discussed. When you say, 'particular set of people, do you mean those who reject Christ in this life?No, the weed and the wheat are a class of people who lived in a particular period of time. Noticed that the parable says the weed where sowed among the good seed. Therefore I dnt think they(the weed) rejected Christ, but where sown to cause confusion and change the teachings of Christ. because, what christ teaches here, applies to all who rejects Christ, Everyone. This will be their fate after judgement.You are right, it applies to those who reject Christ , but the parable was not talking about "all" who rejected Christ, and it was not talking about those who dnt know Christ. Remember I said that the verses you quoted is specific as to a time period,(in the future) and it never mentioned death directly. The issue we are having is what that fate is and when it will be applied. I posted this verses because they explain to us, that I time will come, that The Weat and the Tares shall be separated, and the fate that awaits the Tares.You can see now that it does not go along with the question asked by the op. The op is best answered by what happened to those that died in the past, and not what will happen to those that are alive in the future. Let's talk about what happens to the soul of a man when he dies. And I know as a JW, you don't believe in the immortal soul of a man. You don't believe that a man is primarily a spirit, having a soul(which doesn't die) and lives in a material body.Ok good, this is the topic we will stick to. I do not believe that man has an immortal soul cus the scriptures did not tell us so. In fact the scriptures says that a soul that sins will die!. Immortal soul teaching is a derived analogy from those who want to believe that something happens to man immediately after he dies. I do not believe that man is a spirit living in a material body. The scriptures was specific as to what man is when he was created, it said man was "created from the dust", not that "man came into the created dust". On several occassions God called man "flesh"!, and when passing judgement to adam, he told him what he is, God said : " from dust you are, and to dust you will return ". God also specifically said : it is from the ground you where taking.! There are several other verses I quoted in my post to you that supports this. *we will come back to this with scriptural facts later on when we look at what the spirit in man really is. I do not believe that man has a soul, but I believe that man is a soul! Will address this when we look at what "soul" is . The Spirit of a lost man is dead (second death).You can see that you did not answer the question : what goes into the furnace, the soul, spirit or body, 2 of the three or the whole 3?.(that if you believe the soul is a seperate component of man) The answer to these question is vital in our discussion as it will tell us what man really is. Remember, you have said man is primarily a spirit, and its man that gets thrown into the furnace. You have also said that the soul of a man is his consciuosness. This I find very interesting. Science , common sense and observation has been able to show us what the body does for us. For example, it has been proven that the brain determines how we think and what we think about, it processes information from other organs of the body and gives orders as to how the body reacts, what we say and what we do. Ill give a few examples. 1. A mad man is mad cus he does or behaves in a way different from the way we see as normal. Can some of this mad men be cured?, Yes. How, by giving them drugs, putting them in an environment and setting tasks for them. Does this drug work on a seperate thing in the human body called consciousness or soul? No, it works on the body(which the brain is part of). Can the environment achieve anything in the cure of these mad man if he can't see it with his eyes(part of the body), feel it with his skin(part of the body), hear it with his ears or taste it with his tongue.? No. Therefore, your consciouness is you(the man), and you are your body. One can be turned into a mad man with the right dose of drugs administered to the body. 2. Another example is what happens to man when parts of his body is damaged or removed. When a mans body parts are being removed and moved to another place, his consciousness stays wherever his brain is! Remove the eyes and take it somewhere else, that person will only be conscious, not where the eyes is, but at where the brain is. Hence the brain, which is part of our body is our consciousness . Therefore our body, being alive is the soul! damage the brain and you will lose consciousness. You know what pain caused by damage to your body can do to you, it can make you faint, but will you faint if the transmmittion of the pain to your brain is being cut off by drugs? No. 3 the third example is based on emotion and knowlege. All the things you have learnt comes from physical experience by your body. And all the knowlege you have is as a result of your brains ability to analyse them. The brains capacity is different from one individual to another, hence we have different talents and abilities. I can arguerably say that you know nothing about jesus or afterlife until you read about it. but this is not always the case for everybody , cus I believe that certain knowledge or actions can be gained or taken through a more superior force activating our body., for example, the holy spirit. In conclusion, I can say that our consciouness is not a separate entity from our body called the soul, but its our body or the results of the functions or actions of our body. So we are living souls (like the scriptures rightly tell us) cus we are animated flesh!, and not that we have souls in our body. The scritures say that soul eats, sleep, get pieced and dies! Yes, we will address theafter you have told us which of the three goes there. Am sorry if you feel judged.Still the same, you should have waited for my reply to know if I've lead anyone astray. Apology accepted. Excuse me sir. The question the OP asked is not a simple question. It may seem aOne does not carry too much emotions into answering some of these questions, yes the issue is not simple, but the question was. If you have different answer to mine, you would have just simply told him that this and this is what happens to people when they die. The scripture you quoted would have only created another argument devoid of the issue or question asked by the op. Remember, the op asked what will happen to him as an atheist when he dies!,I or the op never die yet! Moreover, some of the things you claim to be lies above where never said or implied by me. You may not have quoted any scripture, but your statement speaks volumes.Yes it does, but condemnations comes after judgement and not before, and you have not giving me a fair hearing. You have dasukied me. You maybe wrong on that.I hope so. But you implied them.No, you are thinking I implied them. When you hinder the growth of the wheat, you fall into that class. It doesnt matter who you are.Good, you are right, the question is, have I hindered the growth of the wheath(this question is dependent on who the wheat is! Notwithstanding, you do not have the ability to determine who will be in the weed class eventually. No, as a matter of fact, God wants us to worship him in a place of strength andSo do not be concerned with those that serve God cus of fear of hell. i will not lead them astray if I tell them there is no hellfire cus they are still astray for worshiping God for fear of hellfire? So you are wrong if you condemn me based on the result of my teaching rather than on the truth of my teachings. Christ didn't die for us to be good. He died to give us a new life in our spirit. TheYou can see that I did not mention What Christ did or the importance of what Christ did, To accept or gain from what Christ did, you have to do what Christ commands, which entails doing good.! Now the issue is if you do good out of fear or love. What christ means here is that, you may think you areNow tell us, what is the outcome of those who worship God, but their heart is not their. Though you are right, but its much more than that. As you can see, I mentioned three cases of those who think they serve God and not just the one you responded to. Your heart condition plays a vital role in your salvation, as emphasized by what happened to saul, the issue of the pharisses and jesus statement. Do you know how many years I have been without a man touching my skin? Do youI do not have the answers to these questions o. Yes, it is hard when one is persecuted, it is hard when one is undergoing the temptations of the flesh, but one should focus on ones goal and not on if God will purnish those who persecuted or kill us. I have a goal of enjoying life evalasting and wunt mind if a person who has been persecuting me before(to the point of killing me)shares such enjoyment with me. Sweetheart, I can decide to live as I like, if I don't have any price in sight. What will be the case of someone who can do, anything, I mean anything to anybody, because he feels not accountable to God?Yes, you can, but compare that short live to evalasting life. Someone who feels he can do anything or does anything wrong to anybody will not gain Evalasting life, that's good enough punishment for me. Yes, He is the God of Justice, that's why he won't let the wicked go on punished. Adolf Hitler, Prophet Muhammed, Charles Tass Russell, Joseph Smith, Osamabinladin, Isis, boko haram. The wickedLeave the judging to God! Let God do the judging and do not condemn someone based to what you have heard. The wicked will not go unpurnished , but like you said, they will be purnished according to their deeds. The issue should have been how they will be purnished, though we wunt discourse that untill we know what happens to man at death.! Will continue in my next post, but when you reply this part, pls tell us what burns in hellfire, the spirit, soul or body.? Add scritures to show us what goes there. |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by Zenlife: 1:34pm On Feb 05, 2016 |
If truly you an atheist, why care? And really who cares! |
| Re: I Am An Atheist, What Will Happen To Me In Death And How Do You Know? by dolphinheart(m): 7:59pm On Feb 05, 2016 |
@ analice107 Continuation There's just one hellfire.I'm not asking about hell, I'm talking about hellfire!. Is hell and hellfire the same thing?, absolutely not, therefore, use scriptures to tell us what hellfire is and include the original greek and hebrew word for hellfire! There are basically three types or terms used toYou are wrong, those terms do not describe hell, but hell is sometimes taken as the english translation of those terms. 1. Hell= original term=Sheol="Sheol" is a hebrew word that is sometimes translated as hell, grave or pit. So pls note, whichever way a translation translate the word "sheol", it is still talking about the original hebrew word "sheol". I will put a "** "sign when quoting the scriptures in which the original word is "sheol". Pls also take note of the underlined. Now let's see what happens in sheol, who goes there and what goes there using the scriptures as guide. Eccl 9:4-6,10 Anyone who is among the living has hope —even a live dog is better off than a dead lion! For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing; they have no further reward,[u] and even their name is forgotten. Their love, their hate and their jealousy have long since vanished; never again will they have a part in anything that happens under the sun. 10 Whatever your hand finds to do, do it with all your might, for in the **realm of the dead, [u]where you are going, there is neither working nor planning nor knowledge nor wisdom Ps 6:5 For in death there is no remembrance of you; in Sheol who will give you praise? Ill advise you read job chapter 14, but ill just pick some verses from it. 10 But a man dies and fades away; he breathes his last — where is he? 11 As water disappears from the sea and a river becomes parched and dry, 12 so man lies down never to rise again. They will not wake up until the heavens are no more; they will not stir from their sleep. 13 If only You would hide me in •Sheol and conceal me until Your anger passes. If only You would appoint a time for me and then remember me. Ps 16:10 [b]because you will not abandon me to the **realm of the dead, nor will you let your faithful one see decay. Note: some translations use "soul" instead of "me" in that verse. "Regarding the word “Sheol,” Brynmor F. Price and Eugene A. Nida noted: “The word occurs often in the Psalms and in the book of Job to refer to the place to which all dead people go. It is represented as a dark place, in which there is no activity worthy of the name. There are no moral distinctions there ............In a sense, ‘the grave’ in a generic sense is a near equivalent, except that Sheol is more a mass grave in which all the dead dwell together. . . . A Translators Handbook on the Book of Jonah, 1978, p. 37. So what have we learnt from the scriptures quoted so far? 1. That all humans, both good and bad, go to sheol 2. That all humans decay in sheol. 3. That humans are souls which decay when they die. 4. That the experience of one in sheol as recorded by the scriptures does not correspond with man made theories about hellfire. 5. That the spirit which you claim is the man , does not go to sheol. 6 you, me, the op, die, when we die, we decay. 7. The soul does not think, experience anything!, know anything in sheol! 8. That what goes to sheol is the soul, which in the previous post i have explained it to be the man himself! 9 man is not conscious when he is in sheol. All the above supports my view that when "you" die "you"(the same way the scriptures use the word ) turn to dust(sand-sand) cus that's what we are! 2. Hell=Hades. (i)It's a spirit realm. (II)This is a location where the Souls of the dead are kept till judgement . A kind of society, an abode of the dead.Ill take your points(numbered I-V) when I've used the scriptures to explain hades to you. Hades is the common transliteration into English of the corresponding Greek word haiʹdes. It perhaps means “the unseen place.” In all, the word “Hades” occurs ten times in the earliest manuscripts of the Christian Greek Scriptures. The Greek Septuagint translation of the Hebrew Scriptures (from Genesis to Malachi) uses the word “Hades” 73 times, employing it 60 times to translate the Hebrew word sheʼohlʹ, commonly rendered “Sheol.” Luke, the divinely inspired writer of Acts, definitely showed Hades to be the Greek equivalent of Sheol when he translated Peter’s quotation from .(read act 2:27 and compare it with ps 16:10 ) Inversely, nine modern Hebrew translations of the Christian Greek Scriptures use the word “Sheol” to translate Hades in revelation ; and the Syriac translation uses the related word Shiul. This automatically shows us that sheol and hades mean the same thing despite being in different languages. Another supporting evidence are found in your own words which is found in (II) and and (IV) above that souls go to hades. If the scriptures shows that souls go to hades and sheol, it means sheol and hades are the same thing! This I want you to consider when claiming that man/soul is conscious in hell. Your post is now contradicting itself when you claim man is a spirit, but soul burns in hell, does the spirit goes to hell? No! The scriptures never said so.! Now let's go the points you raised. (I)there is no scripture that indicates that hell is a spirit realm, an abode of spirits or that spirits go to hell. If there is pls show us. (II) the soul goes to hades(greek), the soul goes to sheol(hebrew). This Indicates that both mean the same thing. The scriptures is abundantly explicit and self explanatory when it tells us what happens to the "soul" in sheol. Your explanation of what happens to the soul in hades contradicts the scriptures view of what happens to the soul in sheol! This I will like you to examine and comment on. (III)using Luke 16:19-31 as a parameter, the verses never said lazarus went to hades or that hades has two levels. (IV) everbody goes to hades, everybody goes to sheol. The scriptures indicate that there is no praising jehovah in sheol. Your explanation indicates otherwise. Its either the hebrew scripture writers are lying or you have a wrong understanding of the parable of the rich man and lazarus. (v) some of the saints resurrected with jesus when he was resurrected ? Where did you get this from. Cus from the scriptures I read, the saints that where resurrected where resurrected when jesus died and not when he was resurrected. Peter also indicated that David was not among those resurrected as he was still in hades. Abraham also was not resurrected among the saints as this would have created a commotion that even the pharises or the romans would not have been able to hide or control. Another point to consider is that this people where resurrected back to earth with flesh and blood and entered Jerusalem. in the account of “the rich man” and “Lazarus.” The language throughout the account is plainly parabolic and cannot be construed literally(like you are doing) in view of all the preceding texts and explanations I have given Note, however, that “the rich man” of the parable is spoken of as being “buried” in Hades, giving further evidence that Hades means the common grave of mankind, same as sheol. To be continued in next post |
Atheist, What Would You Consider Evidence Of God's Existence? • God Is An Atheist: What Theists Cant argue.Discover God's God • Does Your Family Know That You Are An Atheist? What Are Their Thoughts On It? • 2 • 3 • 4
Power Must Change Hands Prayer Points May 2018 Download (PDF) • For Atheist Doubting God , How Do You Explain This • Beat Your Servant With Many Stripes - Said The Lord Jesus.