Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,148,859 members, 7,802,751 topics. Date: Friday, 19 April 2024 at 08:48 PM

Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' - Religion - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' (729 Views)

Isaac Amata: "Hillary Clinton Will Win US Presidential Election" / The Parable Of The Two Sons - Paul Ellis / Bishop David Oyedepo And His Two Sons (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by ElderLoLo: 3:02pm On Mar 25, 2016
A sound knowledge and God's people to contribute on the topic
Who is really a sacrificial between the two sons " Ismael OR Isaac
Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by zenith4biz(m): 3:19pm On Mar 25, 2016
Waiting for the children of Ismael and Isaac
Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by LordIsaac(m): 3:36pm On Mar 25, 2016
The one they told you in the religion of the family you're born into. We know the truth sha.

1 Like

Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by stonemasonn: 5:20pm On Mar 25, 2016
Isiaka
Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by Lease(m): 6:23pm On Mar 25, 2016
If we consider the fact that Prophet Muhammed was born around 570 AD which means Quran was written over 5 centuries after Jesus Christ's Crucifixion and the fact that the Biblical records indicating that Isaac was the one to be sacrificed by his father was written about 2,000 years before the birth of Christ makes the answer pretty simple and straight forward. There is no way the Quran's version that came after about 2,570 years would be correct. Let's remember that Prophet Mohammed was a trader working for the woman he eventually married and in the course of his job must have had the opportunity of interacting with the Jews and Christians of the era especially those living in Medina and its subburbs after fleeing Jerusalem to escape the assault of the Roman Empire. Thus he must have mixed up the story heard from the Jews regarding Isaac and Ishmael. Alternatively given that Ishmael's mother was an Arab it could also be that the story was twisted in the Quran because of the hatred they had towards the Jews then. This later view appears to be more accurate for me and can be also be supported by the fact that other biblical issues or events were also changed e.g claim that the sacrifice was done on the Black stone of Kaaba instead of on mount Moriah, Holiest day of the week was changed from Sunday to Friday, Facing the direction of Jerusalem during prayer by Jews was changed to Facing the direction of Mecca, Forty day's fasting period by Jews changed to 29/30 day's fasting period and many more changes.

1 Like

Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by urahara(m): 11:42am On Mar 26, 2016
Lease:
If we consider the fact that Prophet Muhammed was born around 570 AD which means Quran was written over 5 centuries after Jesus Christ's Crucifixion and the fact that the Biblical records indicating that Isaac was the one to be sacrificed by his father was written about 2,000 years before the birth of Christ makes the answer pretty simple and straight forward. There is no way the Quran's version that came after about 2,570 years would be correct. Let's remember that Prophet Mohammed was a trader working for the woman he eventually married and in the course of his job must have had the opportunity of interacting with the Jews and Christians of the era especially those living in Medina and its subburbs after fleeing Jerusalem to escape the assault of the Roman Empire. Thus he must have mixed up the story heard from the Jews regarding Isaac and Ishmael. Alternatively given that Ishmael's mother was an Arab it could also be that the story was twisted in the Quran because of the hatred they had towards the Jews then. This later view appears to be more accurate for me and can be also be supported by the fact that other biblical issues or events were also changed e.g claim that the sacrifice was done on the Black stone of Kaaba instead of on mount Moriah, Holiest day of the week was changed from Sunday to Friday, Facing the direction of Jerusalem during prayer by Jews was changed to Facing the direction of Mecca, Forty day's fasting period by Jews changed to 29/30 day's fasting period and many more changes.

Epic of gilgamesh was writeen hundreds of years before the story of noah was written. So by your fantastic logic the epic is correct because its earlier
Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by Skako(m): 4:54pm On Mar 26, 2016
Lease:
If we consider the fact that Prophet Muhammed was born around 570 AD which means Quran was written over 5 centuries after Jesus Christ's Crucifixion and the fact that the Biblical records indicating that Isaac was the one to be sacrificed by his father was written about 2,000 years before the birth of Christ makes the answer pretty simple and straight forward. There is no way the Quran's version that came after about 2,570 years would be correct. Let's remember that Prophet Mohammed was a trader working for the woman he eventually married and in the course of his job must have had the opportunity of interacting with the Jews and Christians of the era especially those living in Medina and its subburbs after fleeing Jerusalem to escape the assault of the Roman Empire. Thus he must have mixed up the story heard from the Jews regarding Isaac and Ishmael. Alternatively given that Ishmael's mother was an Arab it could also be that the story was twisted in the Quran because of the hatred they had towards the Jews then. This later view appears to be more accurate for me and can be also be supported by the fact that other biblical issues or events were also changed e.g claim that the sacrifice was done on the Black stone of Kaaba instead of on mount Moriah, Holiest day of the week was changed from Sunday to Friday, Facing the direction of Jerusalem during prayer by Jews was changed to Facing the direction of Mecca, Forty day's fasting period by Jews changed to 29/30 day's fasting period and many more changes.
haha u dey lie ho
Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by Skako(m): 4:55pm On Mar 26, 2016
the bible also stated that it was ismael
Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by orisa37: 7:57pm On Mar 26, 2016
Christ is The Charter. Isaac is The Article. The 3, Abraham, Ishmael and Isaac are Subscribers to the Charter.

1 Like

Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by INJESUSNAME: 9:51pm On Mar 26, 2016
Skako:
the bible also stated that it was ismael
Where is it in the Bible?
And where is it in the quran?

1 Like

Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by stonemasonn: 10:34pm On Mar 26, 2016
This is just a rivalry between the Arabs and their big brothers the Jews. Its non of my business who was to be cannibalized.
Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by Nobody: 4:56am On Mar 27, 2016
Skako:
the bible also stated that it was ismael
That's not true at all

1 Like

Re: Who Is Really A Sacrifial Between The Two Sons 'ISMAEL Or ISAAC' by INJESUSNAME: 5:59am On Mar 27, 2016
Skako:
the bible also stated that it was ismael
prove it with Bible chapters and verses, or consider your claim a lie, as usual.

(1) (Reply)

Photos (the Pastor Who Is Too Anointed To Walk On Bare Floor) / Why Do We Dream???? / About This Church That Gave Muslims Their Compound To Pray (what Do You Think)

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 26
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.