Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It - Business (6) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Business › Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It (93599 Views)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 12 Reply (Go Down)
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by gabicon: 9:40pm On May 12, 2018 |
Solstar:Dangote may have been making mistakes of late, but the refinery he is building is not one of such mistakes. Think of it how much do we spend as a country importing PMS alone? It runs to billions of dollars yearly to be specific $28 billion. Yes that much (https://www.google.com.ng/amp/s/www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2017/06/20/kachikwu-nigeria-spends-28bn-annually-to-import-petrol/amp/) 50% of the price of PMS is tied to crude then running cost, dangote should be raking in nothing less than $15 billion profit yearly and if he runs for 10 years only you can do the maths of his wealth. if I remember correctly dangote said the refinery will cost $9 billion, dangote is financing about $3 billion, Africa development Bank is bringing 2 billion, the indians and Chinese are also involved. Secondly it will take more than 10 years for electric cars to gain footing in Africa, I mean we're are the infrastructure? We don't have electricity to power our homes is it cars we will be powering? Before we castigate dangote for poor business choice it will be nice to remember that running a business is not a walk in the park and mistakes are bound to happen some one can recover from some we can't. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by obailala(m): 9:54pm On May 12, 2018 |
Solstar:Wonderful!... You just sat down comfortably and washed off all Dangote's intelligence into a gutter. You really do think Dangote is so dumb to have sited the refinery where he did right?... You really think he didnt have all these elementary considerations thoroughly deliberated upon with experts before concluding on the location of the refiner? And by the way, the refinery itself cost less than $10 billion; the rest of the funds covers a massive urea/fertiliser plant, a petrochemical plant and a 42" subsea gas pipeline from bonny to Lagos and other locations. You really do think Dangote is so dumb not to have thoroughly consulted and understood the prospects of these ventures before proceeding?... If the subsea gas pipeline alone is built, it effectively replaces the Escravos - Lagos pipeline and that piece of equipment alone is capable of recouping the entire invested funds in a decade. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Ugosample(m): 9:56pm On May 12, 2018 |
fluentinfor:help me tell them o |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by obailala(m): 9:58pm On May 12, 2018 |
gabicon:Point of correction on the bolded bit, "it will take more than A lot of people just believe in fairy tales they read online about electric vehicles taking over. The fact is, that is still a dream; fossil fuels aren't going anywhere just yet. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Nobody: 10:07pm On May 12, 2018 |
obailala:I have stated my opinion and that is a fact that most billionaires know. That is why no one dared to gamble with expensive liquidity on such a very apparent behemoth located almost in the middle of no where near the source of the feed. Even when there are cheaper and better alternatives such as modular and customized systems. The fact that Dangote is a house-hold name does not make him immuned to mistakes. His tomatoes factory is down not so ? Now there is no structure on the farming side for backward integration. Hence he has to begin to grow the raw materials himself. Makes no sense to me. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Eagba(m): 10:08pm On May 12, 2018 |
Hardeybohwarley:ha! I'll shoot you and justify doing so due to your extreme of studity. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by ahiboilandgas: 10:17pm On May 12, 2018 |
Bishopsgate:u dont know anything bro.... |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Nobody: 10:22pm On May 12, 2018 |
Afam4eva:So business men do not fail? |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by obailala(m): 10:23pm On May 12, 2018*. Modified: 10:58pm On May 12, 2018 |
Solstar:Thanks God you said "it makes no sense to YOU", there's nothing new about how you feel cos all the greatest men in the world were once thought to be foolish when they started. Although I must confess in this case that it's even very easy to see the wisdom in Dangote's refinery investment. When its completed, he would also complete the other facilities (i.e. the petrochemicals, fertiliser and the pipeline) from the proceeds; I foresee a near future where Dangote would be richer than the entire Nigeria put together if others don't sit up, and then people who called him names would start lamenting why one individual would be allowed to get so powerful. Remember, "great men become great when others are asleep," or we could rephrase by saying "great men become great when others were busy doubting the potency of their ideas." |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Nobody: 10:32pm On May 12, 2018*. Modified: 1:15am On May 14, 2018 |
Afam4eva:Bro, business no dey easy like dat o. no be money dey do am, no be research sef. dat tin dey very complex and changes practically with time and events. Success in Business na by d grace of God o. ![]() Meanwhile, ability to admit one failed despite being a Dangote, and quickly make a detour rather than sink with pride, is indeed an exceptional business virtue. But that factory would still be used sha. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Nobody: 10:44pm On May 12, 2018*. Modified: 2:45pm On May 13, 2018 |
LordKO:Well done jare. Didn't have the time to take on Solstar. Some Nigerians are just amazing. At a time, they cried over not having a functional refinery in the country. Now that the refinery is forth coming, the cry now is that it is a waste of money. I'm beginning to understand why Dangote is not willing to go into politics. ![]() |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Help4rmme2u(m): 10:44pm On May 12, 2018 |
Dangote should have given our company the task of supplying tomatoes @sylvafoodsng Sylvafoods Nig. ltd, we export and import farm produce to our customers. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Nobody: 10:52pm On May 12, 2018*. Modified: 11:51pm On May 12, 2018 |
obailala:Dangote's Tomato factory hasnt survived 10 years, now there is no raw materials and no existing structures for back-ward integration. We are talking about billions sitting there in technological investments, idle funds sitting there while he goes into farming in order to produce raw materials. That should have been thought of, during the planning phase. Dangote lost several billions for listing his businesses in foreign stock exchanges under index funds, and whether the bull is rampaging or bears comes out of hybernation, emerging markets loose. And he lost billions. I sometimes wonder if Dangote understand how Securities are traded in the real world, not the rubbish they do at Stock exchanges here. Prices are pushed by speculations and there are no good news coming from Africa, so that alone is a good ground to decimate their cap. I understand how this works and I have no time to share information on this, cos it takes months of studies and research works. Do you know there are people who knew Dangote would loose money the moment he listed his company ? Well, I am one of those who predicted it and it happened. I drank a shot of tequila to it, not because I was happy, but because my prediction was accurate. Dangote sites a Refinery worth between $14 to $18b at a location without oil wells or blocs. The same mistake he made with Tomato paste factory. Building factories without considering the nearness of the feed but only on the potential to deliver products value chain to African countries via the Atlantic. Do you have idea how much it costs to pipe the feed across kilometers ? Do you know the cost of pipeline surveillance ? Do you know the human cost associated with trucking ? Dangote will break-even, we understand that. Dangote will make RoI, we understand that. Some people on this forum say he will 'cash out' and that is the language of 419 yahoo guys who love quick money. But no, in business of that magnitude, you project a 50 to 100 years timeline and the possibility of expansion to other countries using same module. That is why I said there are better investments to put such liquidity into. There are people who try to win arguments even when they are ill-equipped by throwing around sentimental words like big man, has money, rich man, this and that. Ofcourse you may not know this, but let me remind you that most of Dangote's investments are presentment of other people's whitepapers and they are prone to miscalculations. I am probably from a more advanced background with optimized business acumen for futuristic plans, so the commentary from you really shows how the average Nigerian thinks, which understandably is why the country is economically raped and bastardized. So, you support Dangote because he is a big man without the slightest idea of how corporations are run and if Dangote is doing it right. No wonder his trucks kill people always without him facing justice. The next line of reasoning will be that he has outsourced his logistics unit, for the sake of humanity, escaping consequences via strategies of that nature echoes loudly the psychological deficit behind such reasoning, which makes me question the character behind the person at the helm of it all. Nigeria needs new kind of thinking. Please I no longer find it interesting to continue these arguments, if your businesses are successful based on such sentiments, then you are lucky. As for me, I have got mine covered using an optimized better business strategy. This is my final post on this. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Opinionated(op): 10:55pm On May 12, 2018 |
@fluentinfor, can we get other interesting thoughts on other topics from you via contact@opinions.ng Other people with nice ideas are welcome. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by adecz: 11:02pm On May 12, 2018 |
abdullkabar:You mean greenhouses... Too expensive & too low a capacity for the level of processing planned by Dangote. The other option would have been to adapt his system to process other fruits, off season of tomatoes. Like, after glut of tomatoes, the next glut is of mangoes, so, you can keep the factory plant engaged by making mango juice CFJ. The whole essence of processing is to preserve for future use. Like, you make amala flour when yam is in excess (peak harvest time october to March) not like now when a tuber can go for up to 1500. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Opinionated(op): 11:07pm On May 12, 2018 |
It would be nice to read from Dangote's team too. Aroms that wrote the OP is not a dullard but let's read what Dangote's camp think for our education in Business Management and Economics. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by wman(m): 11:21pm On May 12, 2018 |
I really enjoyed the contributions of everyone on this thread. Nice one guys. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by obailala(m): 11:57pm On May 12, 2018 |
Solstar:Oga, there's no businessman or business in this world that doesn't experience one or two setbacks. But success is all about perseverance and ensuring the successes outnumber the failures. It's laughable the way you continue to rubbish Dangote's intelligence / acumen whilst you brandish your own superior knowledge and understanding of business; you even go ahead to paint a picture that Dangote is only just a lucky person who thrives because he's functioning in a broken society like ours. Talking about trying to win an argument, you're obviously the one so keen on winning a non-argument. Going back to your first post, you started by slamming Dangote for a poor business decision of investing $14 - $18 billion on a refinery when electric cars and solar panels were supposed to be the future. Whilst I agreed with every other thing you said in that post, I and several others on this thread totally disagreed with your assertion that fossil fuels/refinery was bad business. Ever since then, you've been moving from one point to the other trying to justify your original point about Dangote not being a smart businessman lately; that to me seems like a person desperate to win an argument. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by lereinter(m): 12:16am On May 13, 2018 |
not everything someone read on Nl or internet is to quickly believed |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 12:19am On May 13, 2018 |
CoolFreeday:no social life |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 1:07am On May 13, 2018 |
hisgrace090:supply demand price IF international market demand more than you with higher price, Who do you think farmer will sell to. Who local sufficiency epp |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 1:30am On May 13, 2018 |
SternProphet:was it a mistake or tuta absoluta that caused the hiccup? |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by Nobody: 2:40am On May 13, 2018 |
he failed in the tomato business |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 2:54am On May 13, 2018 |
fluentinfor:Can the farmers be sued for breach of contract and arrested? Was the writer in pluto when ebola bombarded tomato farms some years ago? Oh! The writer thinks it was accidental and happened the same period Aliko Dangote's factory was just starting? The writer is naive seriously that he does not know there are cabals in Agricultural businesses. So, if most farmers in Kano or Kaduna sell to dangote tomato factory, how will those cabals that import tomatoes to Lagos, Ogun, Uyo, Ibadan etc make cash. Do you know the kind of commission these cabals take from every truck that enters major markets? Seriously, some writers are suppose to be spanked. And this one is a candidate for 100 lashes. |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 3:16am On May 13, 2018 |
Afam4eva:If you have a business bringing 20 billion And another (cement) worth 200 billio Will you hold unto the tiny one that takes up too much of your time? He sold it to tiger brands he did not fail and the Telecoms company?Has he started it Why compete when you can monopolise What were LAfarGE and elephant cement looking at while he was building cement plants Now the tomato company? Someone like Dangote, should, in the least do proper feasibility study before delving into any business. That's the baseline.which feasibility will predict tuta absoluta |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 3:18am On May 13, 2018 |
abdullkabar:yet Mtn Dstv Shoprite Are making a difference Keep playing the victim |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 3:20am On May 13, 2018 |
Bishopsgate:did not know he can speak Yoruba o |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 3:30am On May 13, 2018 |
wordcat:name the business or forever hold your peace? When did govt issue license for rice or wheat farming abi it's your laziness? Did govt you from building cement plant? 28 ppl collected refinery license, .....since obj time, where are the refineries? You better stop hating and find your own niche |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 3:40am On May 13, 2018 |
Rainmania:we need stupid ppl tocontrast the wise ones |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 3:45am On May 13, 2018 |
uuzba:500,000 and 1.1 million mangoes |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 3:48am On May 13, 2018 |
gentlegenius:what is wrong with buying a profitable football club?what is he supposed to focus on? |
| Re: Why Dangote Closed His Tomato Factory And Lessons You Can Learn From It by MIKOLOWISKA: 3:54am On May 13, 2018 |
PrecisionFx:did anybody hold LAfarGE or elephant from building more plants. They were happy with their local champion status, now you're lamenting. Who stopped you from plantingsugar cane? Govt ba? |
Why Dangote Refinery Petrol Is White • Tomato Factory: Dangote, Kubau Communities To Resolve Land Dispute • Why Dangote’s Failed Paste Factory Should Give Buhari More Headache Than Dangote • 2 • 3 • 4
What Is A Domiciliary Account? • Difference Between NEFT And Instant Electronic Transfer • Aliko Dangote And His Ex Wife Meet, Years After Divorce (Photos)

