Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,152,270 members, 7,815,453 topics. Date: Thursday, 02 May 2024 at 12:41 PM

Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? - Car Talk - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Car Talk / Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? (9543 Views)

Ford's Smart Jacket For Cyclists Has Indicators And Brake Lights Just Like Cars / Car Brake Pads: How Often Should They Be Replaced? / Symptoms Of Bad Or Failing Brake Pads (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by IamRespected: 5:00pm On Apr 12, 2016
Need your urgent reply to this, sienna, gazzuzz, carxus, marpol, chelseabmw, ikenna
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by leuelliot(m): 5:51pm On Apr 12, 2016
I assume you mean effective not efficient. Brake pads have a stronger overall pedal feel to brake drums. Difference in stopping distance between the two is also negligible, most auto manufacturers are dropping drums in favor of disks for their base models. Brake linings last 5 times longer than pads, i once drove a car for 80,000 miles before needing to replace the linings.

2 Likes

Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by Emekayoung(m): 11:57pm On Apr 12, 2016
[quote author=leuelliot post=44642264]I assume you mean effective not efficient. Brake pads have a stronger overall pedal feel to brake drums. Difference in stopping distance between the two is also negligible, most auto manufacturers are dropping drums in favor of disks for their base models. Brake linings last 5 times longer than pads, i once drove a car for 80,000 miles before needing to replace the linings.[/quote
]
You drove it that far cos lining doesnt do the main job,pad does...

1 Like

Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by Nobody: 12:57am On Apr 13, 2016
In terms of stopping power, pads are more effective than drums, when comparing discs and drums with similar friction surface areas (size).

The enemy of braking is heat. Which is why brakes may be more effective the first few times they are used. Several braking sessions later (from moderate to high speeds) and the stopping distances will be longer. This is caused by "brake fade", as a result of friction heat.

Discs and pads are better at dissipating heat, due to the open design. Drums and shoes are enclosed, meaning heat can not be dissipated as efficiently as in a disc set-up. Pads are clamped against the discs by calipers, meaning the piston/s and cylinder bore/s are larger, compared to the smaller pistons and bores on the wheel cylinders that force shoes against drums.

Drum brakes are also more prone to internal corrosion, the pivot points and adjusting mechanisms seize up.

15 Likes 4 Shares

Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by lonelydora: 5:01am On Apr 13, 2016
The heat due to friction generated during braking is dissipated more effectively in discs than in drums, which makes the brake not to lose effectiveness over time.
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by edlion57(m): 7:06am On Apr 13, 2016
Anything pad der try....if u doubt me... ask ur neighbor

4 Likes

Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by kirchofff(m): 7:07am On Apr 13, 2016
To me, I think its break pad
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by Harwoyeez(m): 7:16am On Apr 13, 2016
Break pad does it better than the drum because of the heat caused by friction. Although pad wears early than brake lining . Most auto makers are ditching the drum system as front wheel drive which is taking over the auto industry
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by Nobody: 7:18am On Apr 13, 2016
leuelliot:
I assume you mean effective not efficient. Brake pads have a stronger overall pedal feel to brake drums. Difference in stopping distance between the two is also negligible, most auto manufacturers are dropping drums in favor of disks for their base models. Brake linings last 5 times longer than pads, i once drove a car for 80,000 miles before needing to replace the linings.

Brake linings last longer than pads only if the linings are fitted to the rear of the car, not because linings have a longer life span. Pads fitted to the rear of a car will also last longer than the same fitted to the front. This is due to approx. 75% of braking being available at the front.

If the linings are fitted to the front of a car, they will have a considerably shorter life expectancy than pads fitted to the front of the same car.

1 Like

Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by wtfCode: 7:18am On Apr 13, 2016
break pad nah
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by dcncorneils: 7:23am On Apr 13, 2016
brake pad very more effective dan brake linninig
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by Nobody: 7:27am On Apr 13, 2016
Harwoyeez:
Break pad does it better than the drum because of the heat caused by friction. Although pad wears early than brake lining . Most auto makers are ditching the drum system as front wheel drive which is taking over the auto industry

Friction is involved in both linings and pads during braking.

Brake pads last longer than brake linings, they are at least 5 times thicker than linings.

I don't see the correlation between the switch from drums to discs and manufacturers dropping RWD in favour of FWD. I'm not also aware that FWD is taking over the automotive industry. Could you clarify this statement?

2 Likes

Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by alienvirus: 7:39am On Apr 13, 2016
When Siena enters. He takes the show.

#observation
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by banio: 7:44am On Apr 13, 2016
edlion57:
Anything pad der try

I hope You aren't referring to Mr President

Na Ajoke o
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by Edunwa302(m): 7:48am On Apr 13, 2016
Siena:
In terms of stopping power, pads are more effective than drums, when comparing discs and drums with similar friction surface areas (size).

The enemy of braking is heat. Which is why brakes may be more effective the first few times they are used. Several braking sessions later (from moderate to high speeds) and the stopping distances will be longer. This is caused by "brake fade", as a result of friction heat.

Discs and pads are better at dissipating heat, due to the open design. Drums and shoes are enclosed, meaning heat can not be dissipated as efficiently as in a disc set-up. Pads are clamped against the discs by calipers, meaning the piston/s and cylinder bore/s are larger, compared to the smaller pistons and bores on the wheel cylinders that force shoes against drums.

Drum brakes are also more prone to internal corrosion, the pivot points and adjusting mechanisms seize up.
You nailed it.......best answer
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by leuelliot(m): 7:54am On Apr 13, 2016
Siena:


Brake linings last longer than pads only if the linings are fitted to the rear of the car, not because linings have a longer life span. Pads fitted to the rear of a car will also last longer than the same fitted to the front. This is due to approx. 75% of braking being available at the front.

If the linings are fitted to the front of a car, they will have a considerably shorter life expectancy than pads fitted to the front of the same car.

Yes Rear drums on a Honda Accord, forgot to mention that
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by jayriginal: 8:15am On Apr 13, 2016
Everyone saying Siena has the best answer, whether they understand what he said or not.
grin

6 Likes 1 Share

Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by alaskido(m): 8:31am On Apr 13, 2016
Brake pads are more effective.
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by ikachi1: 8:48am On Apr 13, 2016
The effectiveness of the pads type over the lining is obvious. It has been proven to have more breaking horse power due to direct application of the hydraulic force on the pistons to the discs making it more efficient. Less energy loss during transmission. On heavy machines that need breaking, the disc is taking over as opposed to the drums.
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by airsaylongcon: 8:49am On Apr 13, 2016
jayriginal:
Everyone saying Siena has the best answer, whether they understand what he said or not.
grin

When u have got a reputation of been on top of your game in your field, whatever you says goes
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by andymofia(m): 8:54am On Apr 13, 2016
I think sanitary pad is the best grin tongue
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by jayriginal: 8:56am On Apr 13, 2016
airsaylongcon:


When u have got a reputation of been on top of your game in your field, whatever you says goes

Oh I don't doubt his experience, I'm just pointing out the follow follow mentality of people endorsing things they don't understand simply because it sounds complicated.
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by Specialist900(m): 8:59am On Apr 13, 2016
I will go with brake pads. These days auto-manufacturers use brake disc and brake pad in both front and rear wheels
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by airsaylongcon: 10:29am On Apr 13, 2016
jayriginal:


Oh I don't doubt his experience, I'm just pointing out the follow follow mentality of people endorsing things they don't understand simply because it sounds complicated.

Siena talk forced me to do a lot of reading about cars ọ. I used to drive and Audi 80 B3 (still drive it when I just want to mock about). I never knew anything ABOUT audi platforms until I saw Siena tell someone that he (Siena) has no clue what an Audi Tiger Face was. My jaw dropped. I'm like "what other name can someone call Tiger Face again?" ended up reading so much stuff and found a Tiger Face is an Audi 80 B4 and the jallopy I had was a B3. Now I'm knowledgeable all the way to B6 (cos that's the latest I've handled). I've got wiring diagrams, maintenance manuals and all what not from B3 to B6. Some in Russian sef that I translated to English.
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by phibetakappa: 10:42am On Apr 13, 2016
Siena:
In terms of stopping power, pads are more effective than drums, when comparing discs and drums with similar friction surface areas (size).

The enemy of braking is heat. Which is why brakes may be more effective the first few times they are used. Several braking sessions later (from moderate to high speeds) and the stopping distances will be longer. This is caused by "brake fade", as a result of friction heat.

Discs and pads are better at dissipating heat, due to the open design. Drums and shoes are enclosed, meaning heat can not be dissipated as efficiently as in a disc set-up. Pads are clamped against the discs by calipers, meaning the piston/s and cylinder bore/s are larger, compared to the smaller pistons and bores on the wheel cylinders that force shoes against drums.

Drum brakes are also more prone to internal corrosion, the pivot points and adjusting mechanisms seize up.
That's the more reason why the disc brake is used at the front when the manufacturer uses the disc and drum combination.
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by jayriginal: 11:00am On Apr 13, 2016
airsaylongcon:


Siena talk forced me to do a lot of reading about cars ọ. I used to drive and Audi 80 B3 (still drive it when I just want to mock about). I never knew anything ABOUT audi platforms until I saw Siena tell someone that he (Siena) has no clue what an Audi Tiger Face was. My jaw dropped. I'm like "what other name can someone call Tiger Face again?" ended up reading so much stuff and found a Tiger Face is an Audi 80 B4 and the jallopy I had was a B3. Now I'm knowledgeable all the way to B6 (cos that's the latest I've handled). I've got wiring diagrams, maintenance manuals and all what not from B3 to B6. Some in Russian sef that I translated to English.

Nice!
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by erico2k2(m): 12:49pm On Apr 13, 2016
jayriginal:


Oh I don't doubt his experience, I'm just pointing out the follow follow mentality of people endorsing things they don't understand simply because it sounds complicated.
Bro some times,you are so good in what you do that U can xplain it to a lay man he would understand what you mean.
That's if U are a good teacher
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by erico2k2(m): 12:50pm On Apr 13, 2016
airsaylongcon:


Siena talk forced me to do a lot of reading about cars ọ. I used to drive and Audi 80 B3 (still drive it when I just want to mock about). I never knew anything ABOUT audi platforms until I saw Siena tell someone that he (Siena) has no clue what an Audi Tiger Face was. My jaw dropped. I'm like "what other name can someone call Tiger Face again?" ended up reading so much stuff and found a Tiger Face is an Audi 80 B4 and the jallopy I had was a B3. Now I'm knowledgeable all the way to B6 (cos that's the latest I've handled). I've got wiring diagrams, maintenance manuals and all what not from B3 to B6. Some in Russian sef that I translated to English.
Lol this guy gt me cracked up
Re: Brake Pads And Brake Lining Which Is More Effective? by williesmith: 8:07am On Apr 21, 2016
Vote for the pads, too smiley I got mine at https://www.crossdrilledrotors.ca/ , never let me down. So, brake pads are way more effective than brake lining, at least on my opinion. See, the majority on this thread thinks the same.

(1) (Reply)

New Chevrolet Optra Vs Tokunbo Car / FRSC To Impound Motorcycles, Tricycles Without Number Plates From August / Number Plates: How Well Do You Know Your Car?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 45
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.