Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,194,687 members, 7,955,578 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 September 2024 at 09:34 AM

My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie - Literature (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Entertainment / Literature / My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie (16976 Views)

Chimamanda Adichie Poses In Her Hometown In Abba, Anambra State / Chimamanda Adichie’s ‘Americanah’ For HBO Max TV Series / Between Chimanda Adichie and Hilarry Clinton (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by dingbang(m): 6:59am On Nov 06, 2016
sassiemyk:
Sincerely speaking , OP you are dangerously on point. She writes well shaa, but I don't understand how she mixes up the slutty American lifestyles when telling a typical Nigerian story. In Half of a Yellow Sun, I am still trying to understand 1. Onyeka onwenu's smoking. 2. The random sex in the movie. 3. The woman clubbing as far back as 1960 when our women still had a sense of "womanhood". So many questions to ask her but how we go take see her now?
people did club as far back in 1960. What's so new in a random sex? Jeex. What of the girls fela kuti had sex with? U want to tell me now that they were decent? Those girls turned out to be people's mothers/grandmothers who behave so innocent now

16 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Nobody: 6:59am On Nov 06, 2016
But op, your opinion is subjective. Many won't agree, I myself don't totally agree but it's a good review

5 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Zellie: 7:00am On Nov 06, 2016
seguno2:
Great opinion.
I must confess that I have not bothered to read the book as I was discouraged by the title and the different reviews that I had read. This OP simply confirms that I missed nothing by not wasting my money and time to buy and read the book.
you should read it

1 Like

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Nobody: 7:01am On Nov 06, 2016
dingbang:
people did club as far back in 1960. What's so new in a random sex? Jeex. What of the girls fela kuti had sex with? U want to tell me now that they were decent? Those girls turned out to be people's mothers/grandmothers who behave so innocent now
which girls o ?
Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by asha9: 7:01am On Nov 06, 2016
Don't mind the illiterates. If they want to learn morals they should go to moral class. The book was not meant to teach moral but to depict the true reflection of our society. The book is for adult minds who can read with open mind and not practice at home whatever they see outside.

Chimamanda is Africa's most popular literary giant presently.


Napoleon22:
Adichie did not set to write the book to teach morals. I think that is looking at it wholly from an African perspective. The book is intended, instead, to depict reality. However I agree with the OP as to the issue of Adichie demeaning the institution of marriage, men being seen as a means to an end and the subtle glorification of sugar daddies.

14 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by dingbang(m): 7:02am On Nov 06, 2016
danyel09:
which girls o ?
dumb question...

1 Like

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Zellie: 7:03am On Nov 06, 2016
Napoleon22:
Adichie did not set to write the book to teach morals. I think that is looking at it wholly from an African perspective. The book is intended, instead, to depict reality.
Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by sassiemyk: 7:05am On Nov 06, 2016
dingbang:
people did club as far back in 1960. What's so new in a random sex? Jeex. What of the girls fela kuti had sex with? U want to tell me now that they were decent? Those girls turned out to be people's mothers/grandmothers who behave so innocent now

I don't see how Biafran war relates to Onyeka onwenu's smoking habits or the 'olosho' portrayal of the typical Nigerian woman. There was no young girl in d movie that did not have random sex. Pls this is my own opinion shaa. Once again, she is a professional writer, but shud check how people like Wole Soyinka, Chinua Achebe etc respected our cultural heritage

2 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Nobody: 7:06am On Nov 06, 2016
dingbang:
dumb question...
It was a simple question, I want to know the girls you're talking about. Very dumb person. People that thinks Fela slept with all his wives are suffering from chronic ignorance.
Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Tonason: 7:08am On Nov 06, 2016
You have done justice enough to the book. Her western up bringing has influenced her life. Over there divorce is the other of the day. Marriage is not regarded any any thing. Premarital Sex is encouraged. Gold diggers are seen as wise women. They don't have culture. In fact one of my friend then from England told boldly that she wants her father to make love to her, that even her mother is away of it. Can you imagine?

2 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by DesChyko: 7:10am On Nov 06, 2016
I think the OP's trying to say the author made a realistic work. Kudos to her then

5 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by dingbang(m): 7:13am On Nov 06, 2016
sassiemyk:


I don't see how Biafran war relates to Onyeka onwenu's smoking habits or the 'olosho' portrayal of the typical Nigerian woman. There was no young girl in d movie that did not have random sex. Pls this is my own opinion shaa. Once again, she is a professional writer, but shud check how people like Wole Soyinka, Chinua Achebe etc respected our cultural heritage
lol she can't be like wole soyinka and chinua achebe. There is one thing we Nigerians do that annoys me, and that is comparisons.

7 Likes 1 Share

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by cococandy(f): 7:20am On Nov 06, 2016
This is an almost childish review. Did you expect her story to teach you morals? Go to your church for that. A good storyteller tells it as it is. Not as people want it to be.

16 Likes 2 Shares

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Dexema(m): 7:21am On Nov 06, 2016
Adichie is a pretty big writer and her books are filled with western influence which may go against African beliefs. However, telling such story in an African setting should have some restraint as her books are widely read by young minds who may easily decide to pick on one of her characters as a role model.

2 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by armadeo(m): 7:23am On Nov 06, 2016
Op if you call James hardly chase soft porn then I can as well disregard very other thing you have said.


My opinion.

7 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Afam4eva(m): 7:33am On Nov 06, 2016
sassiemyk:
Sincerely speaking , OP you are dangerously on point. She writes well shaa, but I don't understand how she mixes up the slutty American lifestyles when telling a typical Nigerian story. In Half of a Yellow Sun, I am still trying to understand 1. Onyeka onwenu's smoking. 2. The random sex in the movie. 3. The woman clubbing as far back as 1960 when our women still had a sense of "womanhood". So many questions to ask her but how we go take see her now?
So the clubs in the 1960 were being attended by chimpanzees?

16 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Edum13656: 7:44am On Nov 06, 2016
TwentySeven:
Obinze a.k.a Ceiling. grin
People who read the book will know what I'm talking about. grin grin grin

pre - marital sex
Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by awakeuche(m): 7:51am On Nov 06, 2016
seguno2:
Great opinion.
I must confess that I have not bothered to read the book as I was discouraged by the title and the different reviews that I had read. This OP simply confirms that I missed nothing by not wasting my money and time to buy and read the book.
bro forget what the op says, he seems to forget that writing a book does not necessarily mean everything must be black and white, the book was set in a colonial era where you either had to make great sacrifices to survive or have connections.
I feel the book honestly depicts exactly what educated women went through during that period in question... As for the societal african values the op opined she downplayed i would agree with him, the book wasn't written to sugarcoat or showcase morals in any form, it simply explains things like they are and let it be which is exactly what makes it one of the most interesting reads......
I totally enjoyed ifemelu's experiences in america, it was part funny and phenomenal. Finally i think morals were downplayed in the book and emphasis giving to the fact that life is not a bed of roses to some no matter how kind and good you may be in the case of kosi, you can still lose out.....
Sometimes bad things happen to good people too........... And yes chimamanda is also one of those writers who always want to paint Christians in overzealous light. Just read the book, you will totally enjoy it

13 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Nobody: 7:53am On Nov 06, 2016
8 o'clock mass on my mind
Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Nobody: 7:53am On Nov 06, 2016
8 o'clock mass on my mind. i will comment when i come back.
Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by 2scorehigh(m): 7:56am On Nov 06, 2016
No way.

I think you're so far from the truth, Mr. OP.

Those of us who know Adichie know that she was telling her own personal story in that book using the character Ifemelu to present her own personal views on so many issues.

Thus, Ifemelu condemned "sugar daddyism" by not joining in it even when her friends did. If you recall, she even wondered why women will just put themselves into such a situation where men will be fulfilling their materialistic needs in exchange for sex.

Two, Adichie told you the simple truth: American grass is not that green. Even European grass too. Ifemelu had to 'work' as a 'sex worker' with the man who wants sexual massage just to earn a living. Aunty Uju was always busy reading so that she can acquire a certificate to earn a better living in America.

Racism is also still an issue because Ifemelu's life became easier only when she started dating a white boy. Obinze had to fake a marriage to become a British citizen but in the meantime he was using a fake identity to work just to survive... and look at the type of job he was even doing! Before then, Obinze was only good as a babysitter for his cousin. Can you imagine! That's the same obodo oyibo everybody is raving about!

So these thing happen. Trying to deny it or expecting the author who has also lived in America not to highlight such things is not justice.

Thirdly, like someone has already told you Mr. OP, the book is not really about morality. If you want to read a moral book, it's simple, read any publication from our Nigerian pastors or even better still, just write it!

Finally, I don't see how marriage was ridiculed. If anything, I think Adichie was simply promoting the idea that people should always marry the person they love. Simple.

Obinze married his wife who was just available. Wrong move. He was never satisfied in his marriage. Who told you Kosi is the type of woman every man will like to settle down with? C'mon, that Kosi is nothing but a bimbo! To be frank with you, I wouldn't marry Kosi myself because she can never give me what I want in a woman.

She's just a beautiful girl but she seriously lacked the ability to give her husband the type of challenge he wanted - the type his former girlfriend Ifemelu is always presenting to him. Kosi was just like our typical African women who may even be okay with the idea that their husband is having extramarital affairs... as long as he is rich and/or he is still bringing in the money!

Aunty Uju 'prostituted' her life. She chose money over love. Wrong move. Look what she got in the end. She lost her so called security in a jiffy the moment the Army general died. In fact, she had to 'escape' to avoid the wrath coming from the army general family. She also became a single mother for life. Even years later, when she tried to get a 'father' for her son, you will notice that the connection was not there with the man she was in relationship with.

17 Likes 1 Share

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by ceejayxy(m): 7:58am On Nov 06, 2016
Bro she told a story,andbshe told it the way it is

3 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Ishilove: 8:00am On Nov 06, 2016
jejemanito:

She didn't glorify no sugar daddies undecided The novel was set in a period where CONNECTION with powers that be was the only realistic way to make it.

Honesty wasn't paying off as we cn see in Obinze's life. Nigga was forming americana with posh personality, until hunger and reality made him loyal and went to Chief with his cap between his hands. Adichie was basically being honest undecided

If a man had to bow to the whims of Godfathers before he could make it, how do you expect the females to cope


Summary: The author told an honest and realistic story.


I concur. The op just dey misyarn.

4 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by kingthreat(m): 8:02am On Nov 06, 2016
Ever since reading purple hibiscus where the psychopath father figure in the family was killed because of his excesses, I have always had a problem with Adichie.
She is not that a terrific story-teller if you ask me. She is simply a good writer. With her views on feminism liberalism and pro-homosexuality, I won't waste a cent on her novels. Never

4 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by awakeuche(m): 8:05am On Nov 06, 2016
2scorehigh:
No way.

I think you're so far from the truth, Mr. OP.

Those of us who know Adichie know that she was telling her own personal story in that book using the character Ifemelu to present her own personal views on so many issues.

Thus, Ifemelu condemned "sugar daddyism" by not joining in it even when her friends did. If you recall, she even wondered why women will just put themselves into such a situation where men will be fulfilling their materialistic needs in exchange for sex.

Two, Adichie told you the simple truth: American grass is not that green. Even European grass too. Ifemelu had to 'work' as a 'sex worker' with the man who wants sexual massage just to earn a living. Aunty Uju was always busy reading so that she can acquire a certificate to earn a better living in America.

Racism is also still an issue because Ifemelu's life became easier only when she started dating a white boy. Obinze had to fake a marriage to become a British citizen but in the meantime he was using a fake identity to work just to survive... and look at the type of job he was even doing! Before then, Obinze was only good as a babysitter for his cousin. Can you imagine! That's the same obodo oyibo everybody is raving about!

So these thing happen. Trying to deny it or expecting the author who has also lived in America not to highlight such things is not justice.

Thirdly, like someone has already told you Mr. OP, the book is not really about morality. If you want to read a moral book, it's simple, read any publication from our Nigerian pastors or even better still, just write it!

Finally, I don't see how marriage was ridiculed. If anything, I think Adichie was simply promoting the idea that people should always marry the person they love. Simple.

Obinze married his wife who was just available. Wrong move. He was never satisfied in his marriage. Who told you Kosi is the type of woman every man will like to settle down with? C'mon, that Kosi is nothing but a bimbo! To be frank with you, I wouldn't marry Kosi myself because she can never give me what I want in a woman.

She's just a beautiful girl but she seriously lacked the ability to give her husband the type of challenge he wanted - the type his former girlfriend Ifemelu is always presenting to him. Kosi was just like our typical African women who may even be okay with the idea that their husband is having extramarital affairs... as long as he is rich and/or he is still bringing in the money!

Aunty Uju 'prostituted' her life. She chose money over love. Wrong move. Look what she got in the end. She lost her so called security in a jiffy the moment the Army general died. In fact, she had to 'escape' to avoid the wrath coming from the army general family. She also became a single mother for life. Even years later, when she tried to get a 'father' for her son, you will notice that the connection was not there with the man she was in relationship with.

you summed it up even better than i did, i simply reread the book from this your succint summary....
I approve this comment.

8 Likes 1 Share

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by Sanchez01: 8:07am On Nov 06, 2016
danyel09:
Chimamanda is good, very good bit she's overrated. I've read all her works, I still can't compare with Chinua's "There was a country" or the great "Things fall Apart" I don't even want to delve into Soyinka, Ekwensi and the rest. She's good, very good and living the dream but overrated.
Chimamanda is an upcoming writer compared to those you paired her with. Truth is, she's a crazy feminist who doesn't hide it. Ironically, she's married, yet, champions a cause that subtly negates marriage.

I stopped reading her materials when I read 'Half of a Yellow Sun'. Other than the fact that writers sometimes use their works to poke at the socio-cultural anomalies plaguing their socities, that of Adichie was birthed on cheap sentiments and her understanding or judgement was obviously inclined. On the issue of sex, there seems to be an aggressive campaign for premarital sex and that it does not bother her bothers me.

I honestly don't expect her to take on the bandwagon route as seen in most writers but one would really get to wonder how the likes of Ngozi Chimamanda Adichie's works negates Buchi Emecheta's.

For those who have read most of Buchi's works, majorly 'The Joy of Motherhood' and 'Second Class Citizen' as opposed to Chimamanda materials, you'd see a great deviation, particularly on how women should be seen or viewed. Truth is, times have changed and one can hardly pick the concept of didactism and sermony from Chimamanda's works. She comes off to me as the Andrew Marvel, John Donne and a host of metaphysical writers we never had.

4 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by asha9: 8:08am On Nov 06, 2016
Does he know that Hardly Chase novels are all detective novels. For him to call it porn novel means he is yet to read Chase, and everything he has written about Chimamanda should be disregarded.


armadeo:
Op if you call James hardly chase soft porn then I can as well disregard very other thing you have said.


My opinion.

6 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by kaziblake(f): 8:16am On Nov 06, 2016
I have read the book over again and I don't seem to get your point undecided

Chiamanda is still my best author

4 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by kaziblake(f): 8:17am On Nov 06, 2016
seguno2:
Great opinion.
I must confess that I have not bothered to read the book as I was discouraged by the title and the different reviews that I had read. This OP simply confirms that I missed nothing by not wasting my money and time to buy and read the book.
You missed a lot...don't mind this op that castigated the book.
It's just 1500,go and get yours

5 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by TamedWolf90: 8:22am On Nov 06, 2016
Believe me eh,I would have loved to put in one or two of my observations but Dude honestly there are bigger pressing issues in the country right now than a Novel....#Word

3 Likes 1 Share

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by ayosmiles(m): 8:26am On Nov 06, 2016
Actuallly, there is something deeply wrong with that book even though its my most interesting chinamanda book.

I find the personality of Ifemelu deeply disturbing; no morals, no conscience even snatching another womans husband. She is also very arrogant and childish. Remember that creative writing is a form of media, u are always passing across a message. Anti adichie is telling our young ladies that look up to her that its ok to use men and dump them, its ok to be selfish and date married men and that there is no end to racism.

Ifemelu is also obsessed with pleasure, whatever gives her pleasure, doesnt matter if it hurts anybody, stupid brat. Chai! I hate that girl, but i love the book.

7 Likes

Re: My Honest Observation And Critique Of Americanah By Chimanda Adichie by 0gbeni(m): 8:42am On Nov 06, 2016
why not write your own novel ? i thought you were going to critique the book on literary grounds but what do we have here, a load of poo

Right/wrong is relative by the way, don't try to force your opinion(s) on the readers or the writer

4 Likes

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (Reply)

Top Quotes From Novels You've Read / Chimamanda Adichie Covers Stylist Magazine With "We Should All Be Feminist”Shirt / Chimamanda Adichie Stuns In New Photo

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 66
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.