Mahrez or Mane
Cos one won the premier league and the nation cup, the other won the ucl and runner up

onedayatime:


True.
To be fair enogh, you are a dumbass. What has Messi got to do with African Player of the Year award?

Title say: Salah, Mane & Mahrez Make Top 3 Finalists For African Player Of The year . Messi is an Argentine. An Argentine is someone from Argentina and Argentina is in South America. They have their own football association call CONMEBOL. If you want him to win CONMEBOL, then follow CONMEBOL.

No come here dey spit thrash again. Biko

Calm down.

You didn't take time to read the guy I quoted.

He said How do you win UCL and not win player of the year... He then said " Thunder fire Messi and CR7".

I.e. referring to Mane and Salah missing out on Global awards.

Sure enough they currently are the best in Africa that's not really disputable this year.
The guy I quoted lamented their loss at global/uefa awards, not this one(African). Cheers.

onedayatime:


True.
To be fair enogh, you are a dumbass. What has Messi got to do with African Player of the Year award?

Title say: Salah, Mane & Mahrez Make Top 3 Finalists For African Player Of The year . Messi is an Argentine. An Argentine is someone from Argentina and Argentina is in South America. They have their own football association call CONMEBOL. If you want him to win CONMEBOL, then follow CONMEBOL.

No come here dey spit thrash again. Biko

You Sir, are an idiot.
Did you read what he mentioned?

He was replying to someone who dragged Messi and Ronaldo to a competition that doesn't concern them and he's trying to correct him.
But you came with the dumbass line.

Mane!
Outstanding!
Best African Player
Ask Messi

[quote author=Asour post=85134882]


True.

To be fair though. They(the two) weren't as effective as is thought in Liverpool's UCL win.

Calm down...

They lost half of their group fixture games in the UCL. (Including Against red star Belgrade).
They Lost the first leg against Barca in the semi-final. (A game in which both of them prominently featured).

Salah (while a good player) didn't even feature in the 2nd leg. Mane (who played) was Certainly not key in Liverpool's great comeback. (Himself missing clear-cut opportunities).
They were salvaged by their team mates (Origi & Vinny's) heroics.
Salah came to score a penalty in the final but this would not have happened without Origi's heroics previously.

Barca only lost one game in The whole UCL 2018/19.
I.e. the game against Liverpool.

No Liverpool player had 70% MOTM awards Messi had in the campaign. It's easy to say they won the Champions league.


If your analysis are considered then RONALDO should have win d award last year

[quote author=9iceprince post=85136417][/quote]
That'll further implicate Ronaldo.
Messi had the highest MOTM award last year.
Highest goal scorer everywhere except the World Cup.
Highest assist also.

Asour:



Calm down.

You didn't take time to read the guy I quoted.

He said How do you win UCL and not win player of the year... He then said " Thunder fire Messi and CR7".

I.e. referring to Mane and Salah missing out on Global awards.

Sure enough they currently are the best in Africa that's not really disputable this year.
The guy I quoted lamented their loss at global/uefa awards, not this one(African). Cheers.

I have to admit, I didn't follow the trend. am so sorry for that.

Seun still have some work to do in that aspect. All related comments should be group together.

Once again am sorry

We can all agree that Mane deserves it.

OyiboPep:


You Sir, are an idiot.
Did you read what he mentioned?

He was replying to someone who dragged Messi and Ronaldo to a competition that doesn't concern them and he's trying to correct him.
But you came with the dumbass line.

son, you are a fool. just take it like that and don't mention daddy again. always remember to be a good boy

下一个 Mane

Mane all the way... please don't rub him of that.

Liverpool fans and their dumbass opinion, how does winning the UCL makes you the best African player..Mahrez singlehandedly led Algeria to win the nations cup, which should be a criteria..

Mane all the way. The guy is hardworking and humble.

MANE for where after wining domestic treble last year.+wining the league back to back also winimg AFCON + his free kick stop us from winimg AFCON@NIGERIA so abeg weting u stil want MAHREZ ALL THE WAY

Why is everyone saying Mane.. This is an African award.. African achievement supersedes all.. Mahrez beat Mane 2 times (group stage n final) to win d Nations cup..Mahrez should win it..They both had a good season in Europe winning multiple trophies..

No controversy

Nobleking2000:
mahrez all the way how can you win the epl and afcon and not win the african footballer of the year.

if mane was that good why did epl not give him the pfl player of the season and uefa player of the year yet they found their fellow european who won the champions league and second place finish in uefa nations league to give their award to. It is high time we start valueing our african competitions to give it its worth and pedigree.

Even in europe if you want to win the uefa player of the year you are expected to win the champions league or euro before being considered for that if not for that what would have made van dirk win the award ahead of messi and ronaldo despite messi winning the world best and ballon d’or.

Who won the premier league player of the year? Olodo if not mani

The world is backing Mane
He will win it with a wide margin

Jarus:
No contest here. They should just give it to Mane.

I think there's a contest though.

Salah and Mane practically had identical performances in the year, at least, in terms of goals and assists for club (League and Ucl)...and they practically won the same trophy. When we bring Afcon into it, Mahrez had a good one, going one step of winning the competition over Mane's side, beating Mane's team twice in the process and single handedly progressing his side to the finals against Nigeria. I think those performances go a long way.

Even though Salah went out in the knockout stages, he still managed 2goals in the competition, compared to the other two's 3goals in the competition despite getting to the finals. None of them won the Afcon best player by the way...and this award is supposed to be an individual award. I think they all stand a chance, though I believe Mane has done enough to take this one over the other two, just because he was more consistent. However, I won't be surprised if Salah or Mahrez takes the award.

4601CE:
If this was some local NFF stuff, some assholes would start screaming islamisation because the three of them are Muslims

How old are you?

IAmTobore:
How old are you?

Go and ask your father

Asour:



True.

To be fair though. They(the two) weren't as effective as is thought in Liverpool's UCL win.

Calm down...

They lost half of their group fixture games in the UCL. (Including Against red star Belgrade).
They Lost the first leg against Barca in the semi-final. (A game in which both of them prominently featured).

Salah (while a good player) didn't even feature in the 2nd leg. Mane (who played) was Certainly not key in Liverpool's great comeback. (Himself missing clear-cut opportunities).
They were salvaged by their team mates (Origi & Vinny's) heroics.
Salah came to score a penalty in the final but this would not have happened without Origi's heroics previously.

Barca only lost one game in The whole UCL 2018/19.
I.e. the game against Liverpool.

No Liverpool player had 70% MOTM awards Messi had in the campaign. It's easy to say they won the Champions league so they had a better campaign but you would have to add Salah + Mane + Firminho's goals to reach Messi's 12.

So there you have it, you decide.

Correct guy.

mane all the way♡

StrikeBack:
Mane biko



How can you win UCL and you are not winning player of the year

Thunder fire Messi and Ronaldo

exclude RONALDO oga

[quote author=OyiboPep post=85136844]
That'll further implicate Ronaldo.
Messi had the highest MOTM award last year.
Highest goal scorer everywhere except the World Cup.
Highest assist also.

So Messi that has less than 10 goals in 2017/2018 UEFA champions league is your own highest goal scorer in Champions league last year..

Cityfirstborn:
Liverpool fans and their dumbass opinion, how does winning the UCL makes you the best African player..Mahrez singlehandedly led Algeria to win the nations cup, which should be a criteria..

Mr know all If it's based on Country's performance only then how come the 2018 FIFA best player is not from FRANCE

Mane is up to the task

He is the winner already

I rep mane

Cityfirstborn:
Liverpool fans and their dumbass opinion, how does winning the UCL makes you the best African player..Mahrez singlehandedly led Algeria to win the nations cup, which should be a criteria..

Mahrez singlehandedly did what, he played well yes but he didn't do anything singlehandedly abeg. Salah will win it if its truly decided by voting

SaintHilary:
Simple Question.
Would you rather have a 2015 BMW or 2019Hyundai
Whatever your answer is should be the winner

Well since you are asking, I will definitely love to keep both

Even with the here on Nairaland Mane don collect
so who the Bleep are the host not to hand it over to Mane