BetterHeadline:
Our dear muslim friends claim that muhammad's messages and teachings came from allah and are, therefore, divinely inspired. We will use science to look at some of his messages and teachings, and then issue a conclusion on their divinities.
If any of the messages and teachings are scientifically wrong, then we are left with no choices but to challenge the divinity of allah and Muhammad by asking: Is allah a liar? Is Muhammad a liar?
Kindly keep in mind that during Muhammad's time science as we knew it today was already in existence especially in Christian nations. It is obivious from many of his scientific claims (many of which aren't in this post) that he simply copied his "divine" sciences from actual scientists of his time so as to give his made-up religion legitimacy with scientific backing. Unfortunately for Muhammad, science of his time was still at its infancy and many scientific discoveries were simply hypotheses and scientific heresies. He goofed by incorporating these scientific hypotheses into his teachings as a proven scientific theory that he received from heaven. By doing that, he exposed himself as a . . .
Okay, firstly, let's check if we Christians are permitted to use and talk about science.
Ecclesiastes 1:13
Of course, science (to seek and explore wisdom...) is no easy tasks, but as believers we must be up for it.
Roman 2:19-20
In fact, here we learned that as believers, we are tasked to become scientist ("Who have the form of knowledge and of the truth" ) so we can have confidence to guide the blind, be light of those in darkness...etc.
So we learned so far that Christianity is pro-science, and Christians who are against it are mis-guided (most likely by their pastors.) In fact, as Believers we have been given science as tools with which we explore the beauty of God's creations and seek solutions to our problems such as exploring space and seeking solution to cancer..etc.
Jesus: The prince of Peace said: Seek and you will find [Mathew 7:7, Luke 11:9]
1Timothy 6:20 KJV
Believers must avoid anti-science people- those include even your anti-science pastors.
Judith 11:4
Another proof that Christianity is pro-science.
This doesn't mean Christians should blindly follow any scientist, no far from it, but we can follow trusted scientists or better still we should just build our own science lab so we can have uncontaminated science.
Okay, so far we have learned that Christianity is pro-science, and we are permitted to use it to seek answers to questions: through true science God reveals Himself, but false science is a lack of divinity.
Here we seek answers regarding the divinity of allah and his messenger:
Sahih al-Bukhari 3329
So someone asked Muhammad some questions, and angel jibril acting on behalf of Allah immediately sent down the answers.
In the answers we learned why some children look like their father while others look like their mother. According to Allah via Jibril via Muhammad, the child looks after whichever parent ejaculate first during intercourse.
Is this science True or False? Answer: False.
Another False Science
Sahih Muslim, Book 003, Number 0614
Here we learned that Women discharge also determines the gender of the child: The child will be born female if her discharge is more powerful than his, otherwise the child will be born male.
Is this science true or false? Answer: do I really have to answer?
Another False Science.
Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 8, Book 73, Num 113
muhammad maintains again that female discharge determines the resemblance of the child. It doesn't.
Another False Science.
Sunan Abu Dawud 67
Here we learned that water cannot be contaminated even water in which menstrual cloth and human shit are thrown. Muhammad knew that because allah told him so.
But can water be contaminated (that is, defiled)? The answer is YES, which means Muhammad's reply was scientifically false and, therefore, wasn't divinely inspired.
Another False Science
Sunan Ibn Majah 520
Carcass means "The dead body of animal."
Muhammad and his bandit came across a pond in which a donkey had died and rot. Their common senses told them the water wasn't good, but muhammad made them drink from the pond because allah told him that "water cannot be contaminated."
Another False Science.
Sahih al-Bukhari 5782
Another brilliant allah science. Here we learned that if an housefly come near you especially when you are drinking, you should catch the housefly and dip it inside your drink. Why? Because one wing of the housefly carries disease and the other wing carries the treatment for said disease. So dipping the housefly into your drink will turn your drink into medicine. Then you can drink your drink to cure yourself of diseases. Muhammad knew this because allah told him so, remember.
Is there a treatment for a fly's disease in one-half of its wing?
Answer: NO
Another False Science.
al-Bukhari, Book 71, Number 591
A black cumin (also called Nigella seed, or Kalonji) is a type of herbal plant which can be made into an herbal coffee or mixed with cooking oil.
The black cumin is rich in vitamin, iron, zinc, and potassium.
Okay, I won't go into detail about this seed because doing that isn't the point of this post.
But let's study Muhammad claim. He claimed that "black cumin is healing for all diseases... except death."
This begs a question: Is death a disease? Well, I'll leave this for our philosophers.
Is black cumin a healing for all diseases? Of course not. This scientific claim by Muhammad is false.
There are other verses of course, but they'll make this post too long.
Conclusion
We have decided to use the basis of science to test the divinity of allah and his messenger. Safe to say they didn't pass.
So to answer the question: Are Allah/Muhammad's teachings divinely Inspired? Is allah/muhammad a liar?
The answers are: Well you now know the answers. HERE we also provide biblical answer to the question. Antichristian can provide a good defence for this scientific errors. |
