Kukutente23:

No wonder the SC threw the judgement in the trash
How can a Court bar a party from fielding candidates? A state high court for that matter

It is settled law that a court judgment is binding and effective no matter how ridiculous it looks until set aside.the apex court erred

garfield1:


What stupidity.are you not the one that has been tagging and quoting me childishly since morning? Are you ok at all

stop displaying your ignorance here. Stop been biased here. Argue well with what’s laid down in the amended electoral act ok. Follow the rules of law and not been sentimental in your arguments here

garfield1:


The civil courts clearly barred pdp as a whole from sponsoring candidates in plateau sir.that judgment subsists and the apex court is bound by it

mum*u number 1. The way you carry Plateau State matter as if na your papa get am. God don shame you now. Mutfwang until 2031. Those illegal seats obtained by Lalong and Co. Will all be retrieved. Keep watching

garfield1:


It is settled law that a court judgment is binding and effective no matter how ridiculous it looks until set aside.the apex court erred

The apex court set it aside by declaring that a state high court has no jurisdiction

TruthsFM:
the Appeal court of justice president is lalong cousin. That was why lalong pro lawmakers are heavily favoured in the Appeal court of justice

apc is dead in plateau state, we suffered during lalong s 8years, with just 6months come and see what mutfwang is doing, gagdi is doing very well in his constituency, but he should have known he is not bigger than plateau people, he is a good politicians , plateau pple re very emotional people and will not 4get his name in a hurry.

Jlow2:
apc is dead in plateau state, we suffered during lalong s 8years, with just 6months come and see what mutfwang is doing, gagdi is doing very well in his constituency, but he should have known he is not bigger than plateau people, he is a good politicians , plateau pple re very emotional people and will not 4get his name in a hurry.

yes , in the next 8 years, APC will never smell that seat in plateau State

Kukutente23:

The apex court set it aside by declaring that a state high court has no jurisdiction

They had no jurisdiction to as this wasn't a normal civil case and the case wasn't before on appeal.this apex court was a post election court with limited jurisdiction

DUNKA:
mum*u number 1. The way you carry Plateau State matter as if na your papa get am. God don shame you now. Mutfwang until 2031. Those illegal seats obtained by Lalong and Co. Will all be retrieved. Keep watching

See stupidity

TruthsFM:
stop displaying your ignorance here. Stop been biased here. Argue well with what’s laid down in the amended electoral act ok. Follow the rules of law and not been sentimental in your arguments here

What foolishness...go and sit down kid

garfield1:


They had no jurisdiction to as this wasn't a normal civil case and the case wasn't before on appeal.this apex court was a post election court with limited jurisdiction

Ok. So what is the business of a post election court with a judgement it has no jurisdiction over?
What you're advertently asking for is for the post election court to give effect to a judgement you just said it has no jurisdiction over

garfield1:


What foolishness...go and sit down kid

just be calming down ok. You predictions are always in errors. A lot of people warned you on that including barrister fergie001 your friend. You are thinking in a childish way.

Kukutente23:

Ok. So what is the business of a post election court with a judgement it has no jurisdiction over?
What you're advertently asking for is for the post election court to give effect to a judgement you just said it has no jurisdiction over

A judgment of a pre election or civil court is binding on all courts including post election courts and vice versa..they are bound by it via the principle of stare decisis.moreover it is a judgment in rem.the nomination case of shettima settled by the civil courts was followed by the electoral court same as the appeal judgment giving inec powers to transmit however it wishes..
The post election supreme court does not have jurisdiction to sit on that case but it must give effect to it.jurisdiction in law is about sitting to try the case not following it.this is elementary law.the apex court decision is akin to the apex court now overturning all the sacked lawmakers in plateau.cc fergie001

TruthsFM:
just be calming down ok. You predictions are always in errors. A lot of people warned you on that including barrister fergie001 your friend. You are thinking in a childish way.

My predictions are always in error? Did tinubu not win,did apc not win kogi and imo? Did dino not take third? Which of your predictions happened.what a foolish fellow

Jlow2:
apc is dead in plateau state, we suffered during lalong s 8years, with just 6months come and see what mutfwang is doing, gagdi is doing very well in his constituency, but he should have known he is not bigger than plateau people, he is a good politicians , plateau pple re very emotional people and will not 4get his name in a hurry.

APC is very much alive controlling almost all legislative seats there.the house of assembly is in APC hands and muftwang will be impeached

garfield1:


My predictions are always in error? Did tinubu not win,did apc not win kogi and imo? Did dino not take third? Which of your predictions happened.what a foolish fellow

I don hear 👂 you here

garfield1:


A judgment of a pre election or civil court is binding on all courts including post election courts and vice versa..they are bound by it via the principle of stare decisis.moreover it is a judgment in rem.the nomination case of shettima settled by the civil courts was followed by the electoral court same as the appeal judgment giving inec powers to transmit however it wishes..
The post election supreme court does not have jurisdiction to sit on that case but it must give effect to it.jurisdiction in law is about sitting to try the case not following it.this is elementary law.the apex court decision is akin to the apex court now overturning all the sacked lawmakers in plateau.cc fergie001

What you're simply doing is muddling up the waters. It is the executive that gives teeth to judgements of the court not the court itself. The courts whether lower or upper are to interprete laws in accordance with what is before them.
What you want the SC to do is to give effect to a judgement without considering how meritorious the judgement is. That is summarily converting SC to the executive.
The SC has the right to overturn or uphold judgements of lower courts and that's exactly what it just did. This claim of SC giving effect to lower courts judgement devoid of merit is totally off point.

garfield1:


APC is very much alive controlling almost all legislative seats there.the house of assembly is in APC hands and muftwang will be impeached

Mumu man, go and impeached the incumbent governor that’s doing the needful in the state not only that, Caleb is the people’s Governor. You will rant tired in the next 4 years as you are wailing on governor Fubara victories.

garfield1:


What of bayelsa

I cannot make any comment about Bayelsa because I have never been there. I have neither lived nor even briefly been on ground in Bayelsa to witness firsthand where the allegiance of majority of the masses tilt(ed) to.

But for Plateau, I live and breathe Plateau

Babsolala:


I cannot make any comment about Bayelsa because I have never been there. I have neither lived nor even briefly been on ground in Bayelsa to witness firsthand where the allegiance of majority of the masses tilt(ed) to.

But for Plateau, I live and breathe Plateau

Muftwang won narrowly via mangu lga

Kukutente23:

What you're simply doing is muddling up the waters. It is the executive that gives teeth to judgements of the court not the court itself. The courts whether lower or upper are to interprete laws in accordance with what is before them.
What you want the SC to do is to give effect to a judgement without considering how meritorious the judgement is. That is summarily converting SC to the executive.
The SC has the right to overturn or uphold judgements of lower courts and that's exactly what it just did. This claim of SC giving effect to lower courts judgement devoid of merit is totally off point.

You still do not understand the matter.an electoral court cannot overturn the decision of a civil court and vice versa.there is a big difference between a supreme court sitting as an electoral court and a civil court.it must abide by it.besides the case was not before it on appeal.that matter got to the apex court sitting as a regular court and they failed to rule on it meaning they lost jurisdiction to overturn that case.this supreme court is not the regular supreme court but an election one with limited powers and jurisdiction.it cannot try pre election matters but must abide by it.kekere ekun explained this uzodinma vs emeka 2019 supra.perhaps Fergie can explain better since you have lost your comprehension abilities

garfield1:


You still do not understand the matter.an electoral court cannot overturn the decision of a civil court and vice versa.there is a big difference between a supreme court sitting as an electoral court and a civil court.it must abide by it.besides the case was not before it on appeal.that matter got to the apex court sitting as a regular court and they failed to rule on it meaning they lost jurisdiction to overturn that case.this supreme court is not the regular supreme court but an election one with limited powers and jurisdiction.it cannot try pre election matters but must abide by it.kekere ekun explained this uzodinma vs emeka 2019 supra.perhaps Fergie can explain better since you have lost your comprehension abilities

Truckload of claptrap
Can you then explain how Supreme Court overturned all the winners of election in zamfara in 2019? Was the SC sitting as an election court or as a regular court? Was the election result contested in the pre-election matter that was brought before it for it to overturn the results

garfield1:


Muftwang won narrowly via mangu lga

WON

A win is a win no matter how narrowly.

Moreover, despite the THEN incumbent party which had Lalong (a sitting governor) as the DG for APC Presidential Campaign and with all of the tools and machineries at their disposal, Muftwang's party still won.

Time to focus on other tasks. Have a lovely weekend, bro.

Kukutente23:

Truckload of claptrap
Can you then explain how Supreme Court overturned all the winners of election in zamfara in 2019? Was the SC sitting as an election court or as a regular court? Was the election result contested in the pre-election matter that was brought before it for it to overturn the results

Your analogy are the claptrap actually.the matter in zamfara was a pre election matter which never got to the tribunal and all courts had jurisdiction.if you don't have what to say,either you rest or apply commonsense and investigate.i thought you were intelligent or had an iota of it

garfield1:


Your analogy are the claptrap actually.the matter in zamfara was a pre election matter which never got to the tribunal and all courts had jurisdiction.if you don't have what to say,either you rest or apply commonsense and investigate.i thought you were intelligent or had an iota of it

You've been irritable and insufferable since the judgement yesterday. Receive sense.
You're contradicting yourself.
If you say zamfara is a pre-election matter and all courts have jurisdiction, what is the Plateau issue? Is issue of Congress a post election matter?
You claimed SC can't adjudicate on jurisdiction for Plateau matter since the issue came from tribunal. Is a tribunal meant to be an appeal court for pre-election matter?
Explain how SC then adjudicated on zamfara post- election matter when it came through a pre- election case. You see your life now?
Stop foaming at the mouth.

Babsolala:


WON

A win is a win no matter how narrowly.

Moreover, despite the THEN incumbent party which had Lalong (a sitting governor) as the DG for APC Presidential Campaign and with all of the tools and machineries at their disposal, Muftwang's party still won.

Time to focus on other tasks. Have a lovely weekend, bro.

Like i use to tell Him, he need to be calming down, if He say He won narrowly, what about other lga where The Governor win by wide margins, Isn't winning a state a cumulative margin by each candidates again, The guy does not know what to say again, he was disappointed by his wild imagination on his self glorification about the cases based on his political inclination

TruthsFM:
Mumu man, go and impeached the incumbent governor that’s doing the needful in the state not only that, Caleb is the people’s Governor. You will rant tired in the next 4 years as you are wailing on governor Fubara victories.

The guy is pained anyway, he miscalculated based on his political leaning, which always affects his judgement, he always contradict himself not knowing that those things will come back look at him closely in the face

engineerboat:



The guy is pained anyway, he miscalculated based on his political leaning, which always affects his judgement, he always contradict himself not knowing that those things will come back look at him closely in the face

yes soo. He’s heavily wailing in pains ooo. Nairalanders don’t take him serious again.

garfield1:


APC is very much alive controlling almost all legislative seats there.the house of assembly is in APC hands and muftwang will be impeached

Kid,go and impeach him na