13% brings underdevelopment to the north by musiwa

13% slow down the north because it was not done very well. What 13% should have been is any income to govt, even if it is non oil. That income must goes to state.

What I mean is. You see PHCN in Kano state makes about N1billion a month. Kano state government should get 13% of that money. Kano state should also get 13% of what ever taxes Globacom or MTN pays for taxes in kano state. Kano state should also get 13% of airport revenue in Kano state that goes to the federal govt. any payment made in a state to the federal govt or its minister or organization should get 13%, that state should get 13%.

It is discrimination to give Jonathan Goodluck people only 13%. while that same govt also get income from other source. This is not acceptable. This i consider as been unfair.

what 13% does is that it takes money from the north and give to jonathan Goodluck aea. when you look at the way the derivation is done

the foreign exchange market  and bank foreign exchange are the one that use oil sale.  not state. state use naira.

@ Musiwa, the derivation program applies only to our natural resources. If the non-oil states were to exploit their own natural resources too, they would also be entitled to derivation.

Our problem is that we have depended on oil for too long.

that is not fai, look dangote take limestone from yorubaland but the goverment does not pay yoruba state 13% for the limestone. so it is done in unfair give only one resource, for every cement sold yorubas should get 13%. have you seen dangote or the federal govt pay 13%

look 13% should be for all income that come to the federal govt, either mineral or non mineral source of revenue. what the jonathan goodluck is doing is discriminating.

you can not give one govt income 13% because they come from your people. while other ethnic group, you refuse to give them. that is not fair.

Sovereign National Conference, then?

,

you are taken 13% from igbo people and give it to Jonathan Goodluck people that is not good. that is not how they do , it.


the foreign exchange market and bank foreign exchange are the one that use oil sale money. not state. state use naira

You have to remove 13% oil derivation and  also remove  value added tax and replace with 13% state taxes. This way, everybody pays 13% and all state can collect 13% directly from people. So instead of the federal govt collecting VAT, state should collect it directly from the people. This is how it is done.  That way there will be no sharing of 13% oil derivation any more.

So when you buy cement kano govt will meet dangote and collect 13% of sale of cement from him that was brought in its state.   while kano state govt will also go to PHCN and collect 13% directly from PHCN,    And kano state can collect 13% from Oando oil or Globacom or MTN.  So every company or business will pay 13% directly to their state. This is how it is done.


You have to remove 13% oil derivation and  also remove  value added tax and replace with 13% state taxes. that way state can collect it directly from companies