₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,205 members, 8,521,777 topics. Date: Thursday, 19 November 2026 at 11:36 PM

Toggle theme

Mynd44's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Mynd44's Profile › Mynd44's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 (of 4372 pages)

Sports › Re: NFF Fires Rohr Appoints Eguavoen by Mynd44(mod): 7:43am On Dec 13, 2021
Sports › Re: NFF Sacks Rohr, Appoints Eguavoen Super Eagles Interim Coach by Mynd44(mod): 7:43am On Dec 13, 2021
Sports › Re: Austin Eguavoen Appointed Super Eagles Interim Manager by Mynd44(mod): 7:42am On Dec 13, 2021
Politics › Re: Bihari Reacts To Daily Trust Editorial: Life Has Lost Its Value Under Buhari's N by Mynd44(mod): 5:52am On Dec 13, 2021
Politics › Re: Breaking!!! 2023: I Don’t Need SE,SS To Become Nigeria President- Asiwaju Tinubu by Mynd44(mod): 6:32pm On Dec 12, 2021
8. Don't post false information on Nairaland.
Politics › Re: Chief Imam, 10 Others Kidnapped In Sokoto During Prayers by Mynd44(mod): 7:06am On Dec 12, 2021
Politics › Re: Bafarwa: Buhari Didn’t Visit Sokoto After Attacks Because Our Lives Mean Nothing by Mynd44(mod): 7:05am On Dec 12, 2021
Crime › Re: Alleged Abduction Of Commuters Along Maiduguri -damaturu, False Alarm by Mynd44(mod): 6:53am On Dec 12, 2021
Politics › Re: Snake Dish: Step By Step Preparation Of The Snake I Killed by Mynd44(mod): 8:48pm On Dec 11, 2021
Politics › Re: Sanwo-olu Unveils New Power Policy To Meet Lagos Electricity Needs by Mynd44(mod): 10:24am On Dec 11, 2021
Politics › Re: Buhari Promised To Pick Tinubu As Running Mate In 2015, Ex-party Chairman Akande by Mynd44(mod): 10:18am On Dec 11, 2021
Romance › Re: Have You Ever Begged A Partner To Stay In A Relationship? by Mynd44(mod): 6:22am On Dec 11, 2021
My policy has always been

"If you say we have problems then you see hope and a chance that we can fix those problems; if you say you want to leave, it meams you have assessed the problems and find them unsolvable"

If you tell me you are leaving, no matter how hard it is for me, its goodbye and goodnight
Politics › Re: How Tinubu Became Frustrated When Buhari Picked Osinbajo, Bisi Akande by Mynd44(mod): 6:20am On Dec 11, 2021
Politics › Re: Osinbajo’s Road To Abuja: The Untold Story by Mynd44(mod): 6:19am On Dec 11, 2021
Politics › Re: Kidnappers Murder Imo Monarch, Dump Body In Market Square by Mynd44(mod): 1:47pm On Dec 10, 2021
Politics › Re: Sanwo-olu Unveils New Power Policy To Meet Lagos Electricity Needs by Mynd44(mod): 10:07am On Dec 10, 2021
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 8:27am On Dec 10, 2021
MyExpression:
Charles Taylor, Muhammad Gaddafi, Sadam Hussain....amongst others; these are national leaders that have been convicted by the ICJ for war crimes and gross violation of human right.

Why didn't they simply delist their nation from the UN or AUhuh

That the Nigerian ministry of Defence is not been prosecuted doesn't make it right.
No army in the world is prosecuted for "green fire". If your army mistakenly bombs an hospital based on wrong Intel, it is sad but the ICC want do anything.

BTW, have you asked why the ICC has never arrested a western ruler? Dick Cheney, Bush, Donald Rumsfeld etc?
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 7:28am On Dec 10, 2021
SmartyPants:
Well, good! When the judge there makes reference to the suspension of human rights, notice he does not rely on any Nigerian provision. He merely says, "such is not new". That is because such is foreign to our constitution, though it is known to International Law. But since you wish to exclude international law from the conversation, then tell me, what is the statutory basis of the suspension of any right?

What is the status of legal precedent as compared to Constitutional provisions?

Peruse:

Section 1: Supremacy of the Constitution
Sections 33-46: Fundamental Human Rights

http://www.nigeria-law.org/ConstitutionOfTheFederalRepublicOfNigeria.htm

Then tell me which law in Nigeria permits all the excesses you have defended.
Supremacy of the Constitution.

The fact is that for you to even have a rule of law, you need to have national security.

There are times things are not stipulated by law yet are applicable case-in-point, "doctrine of necessity"

I am afraid this part will only lead to derailing of this thread. We kinda have to stop
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 7:14am On Dec 10, 2021
SmartyPants:
Okay, let's understand principles.

1. Limitations and Derogations

In human rights, sure, there is the concept of limitation of rights, and there is the concept of derogation (suspension of certain rights in time of emergency).

In no uncertain terms, derogation is not permitted under the African Charter. State parties thereto, therefore cannot under any circumstances claim to suspend human rights pending the restoration of national security. There is a plethora of cases to this effect.

Even where derogation is allowed (in other human rights systems outside Africa), there is a particular legal procedure that must be followed before any such right can be derogated from. The requirements are stringent, and rarely ever used.

What is allowed in the African context, is the limitation of rights. And this must not be arbitrary, it must be done in line with existing laws, and not at the whim of the president or his agents.


2. Guam is the worst example you could use because it actually illustrates my point. The reason those alleged terrorists are held in Gam is not that there is not enough space on mainland USA. IT is because their law does not permit the torture and indefinite detention of individuals that goes on at Guam. Since Guam is not on mainland USA, the executive use it to bypass their own constitutional human rights protections.

If you have been following the news, every president pledges to shut it down because there is no legal justification.

The rule of law can never be suspended inany democracy, no matter what. That is a ludicrous idea.
Every time National issues pop up and people throw up International treaties and charters, I get bored and Tried.

Every country is sovereign in its laws and governance and can decide to go against a charter it signed. The only laws a country is subject to are its own laws as made by the legislature or as declared by the judiciary.

The FG held Dokubo for years and the supreme court said they can because he was considered a national threat.

That is precedence and that is the basis of the law in this case or did you see the judge mentioning the AU charter or the UN charter?
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 6:54am On Dec 10, 2021
InaNla:
Amazing defender of the universe…


Carry Go…

Biari till 2045!!!
If you are going to step to me, step with intelligent replies or keep walking
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 6:42am On Dec 10, 2021
SmartyPants:
Ah, the old, someone else is doing it, therefore it must be right argument. Really?
ubimagos:
Even with the chapters "39 & 45 of the 1999 constitution as amended" quoted by the lawyer and the judge, he is still confused
These are the words of the Superman court

"“Where national security is threatened or there is the real likelihood of it being threatened human rights or the individual right of those responsible take second place, human rights or individual rights must be suspended until the national security can be protected or well taken care of. This is not anything new.

“The corporate existence of Nigeria as a united, harmonious, indivisible and indissoluble sovereign nation is certainly greater than any citizen’s liberty or right. Once the security of this nation is in jeopardy and it survives in pieces rather than in peace, the individual’s liberty or right may not even exist.”"
Meaning even the rule of law itself is subject to National Security not the other way

Hence why Guam is done.

Hence why Boko Haram members can be held and locked up for years without trial
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 6:24am On Dec 10, 2021
SmartyPants:
I don't have any issues with the Twitter ban. My comments are general comments on the legal issues
Actually, go back to read. Those are the declarations of the judge and not just the defendant
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 6:23am On Dec 10, 2021
SmartyPants:
Sir, you are actually the one without understanding. Neither of the topic nor of the particular post you have quoted which is not connected with the subject of national security at all.

If your life is a threat to national security, there is a legally prescribed route by which the State can take your life.

It is not for me, being the president, to get up one day, declare you a threat and then take your life just like that.

Capiche?
Actually, no.

Really? Tell those in Guam that
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 6:21am On Dec 10, 2021
SmartyPants:
Sure, from a lay person's perspective, National Security may sound like a logical reason for the violation of individual rights. Except, in reality, it is impossible, in modern society, for fundamental human rights and national security concerns to clash.

That is because human rights and national security are but two sides of the same coin, smoldered together by the concept of the rule of law. What is national security but the aggregation of fundamental human rights concerns? But who defines a national security threat? Who measures its gravity? This is where the rule of law enters into the arena as an arbiter.

In practical terms, where there is a national security concern, there must also be a legal route of expressing and managing that concern. It is not for the executive to arrogate to itself this power. That is why the legislative exists -- to make laws that would allow the executive to lawfully check whatever it is that threatens national security.

For example, to deprive a man of his liberty on the grounds of national security, there must be a law that enables the executive to do so. Any action taken outside of this, regardless of its legitimacy, itself becomes a threat to national security, by undermining democratic structures and allowing the executive to usurp the other branches of government.
And in this case, how does twitter ban or suspension violate your human right? Under the laws on Nigeria, twitter does not exist since it neither pays taxes or is registered under Nigerian law.

Plus the right of media houses to access a non existing platform does not exist
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 6:07am On Dec 10, 2021
SmartyPants:
You're talking utter nonsense.

What do you know about the justiciability of fundamental human rights? What do you understand by fundamental human rights? Are you saying the right to life is not justiciable?

And where have you ever heard of socio economic rights being justiciable??

Mr. Man don't dabble into things of which you are completely ignorant.
You are the one without understanding. If your life is a threat to National Security, National Security takes precedence
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 6:05am On Dec 10, 2021
Richy4:
I am interested in the tax expect of the matter.. if twitter was supposed to pay taxes and they were not, why is that?...

No wonder there are zero infrastructure... Pictures of bad roads keep surfacing on social media about the state of roads in Nigeria.. if a giant like Twitter isn't paying...
What big tech companies do is to not register ib your country and collect money for adverts via agencies or through transfer then claim since they don't operate physically in your country, they don't owe you taxes. It is a case of "no face no case"
Politics › Re: Twitter Ban: Court Dismisses Suit Against FG, Fines SERAP N100,000 by Mynd44(mod): 6:04am On Dec 10, 2021
SmartyPants:
Egwuatu held that when national security is threatened, the issues of fundamental human rights take a second stage

Such statements should make all shudder. Does this lawyer even understand what fundamental human rights are - as opposed to the broader concept of human rights?

We have a long way to go.
What are your fundamental human rights as against National Security?

You are the one who doesn't understand this
Politics › Re: Air Peace Takes Delivery Of Fifth Brand New Embraer 195-E2 Aircraft (photos) by Mynd44(mod): 5:12am On Dec 10, 2021
Crime › Re: Bandits Kills Commissioner In Katsina, 16 Others In Niger Mosque by Mynd44(mod): 5:10am On Dec 10, 2021
Politics › Re: Who And What Is Responsible For This Hardship In Nigeria? by Mynd44(mod): 4:56am On Dec 10, 2021
The Nigerian citizen is the nunber 1 culprit.

Buhari, GEJ, Obasanjo and every other leaders are part of the citizens so those of you who want to separate the country from its leaders should reconsider
Politics › Re: Katsina Commissioner Assassinated by Mynd44(mod): 10:03pm On Dec 09, 2021
Politics › Re: Agitations:Nigeria Must Embrace Restructuring Before It Is Too Late, Says Fayemi by Mynd44(mod): 9:58pm On Dec 09, 2021

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 (of 4372 pages)