Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,148,904 members, 7,802,933 topics. Date: Saturday, 20 April 2024 at 04:03 AM

3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. - Religion - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. (801 Views)

Comparison Of Proof Of God, Jesus, Mohammed And Great Mortal Men / Christianity And The Burden Of Proof... / How Religious People Think The Burden Of Proof Works (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (Reply) (Go Down)

3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 8:13am On May 18, 2022
People can say one of the following things:

1. God exists
2. God does not exist
3. I do not believe the claim that God exists

Options 1, the statement that a God exists, is a positive assertion that has the burden of proof. However, it is an extraordinary claim, since it is contrary to ordinary experience. Carl Sagan stated “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”, which means that the statement that God exists should be supported by extraordinary evidence.

Option 2, It is not an extraordinary claim to say that God does not exist although, as a positive assertion, it still has a burden of proof. Since it is not an extraordinary claim, the total absence of real evidence could be considered sufficient proof.

Option 3 does not have the burden of proof, as long as I honestly do not believe that claim.

I am more of option 3.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by LordReed(m): 8:25am On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
People can say one of the following things:

1. God exists
2. God does not exist
3. I do not believe the claim that God exists

Options 1, the statement that a God exists, is a positive assertion that has the burden of proof. However, it is an extraordinary claim, since it is contrary to ordinary experience. Carl Sagan stated “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”, which means that the statement that God exists should be supported by extraordinary evidence.

Option 2, It is not an extraordinary claim to say that God does not exist although, as a positive assertion, it still has a burden of proof. Since it is not an extraordinary claim, the total absence of real evidence could be considered sufficient proof.

Option 3 does not have the burden of proof, as long as I honestly do not believe that claim.

I am more of option 3.

I agree with your post but I would add a caveat. The caveat is that while most conceptions of a god cannot rise to fulfil their burden of proof and thus can be totally discounted, there may be concepts of god(s) that we either cannot properly explore or cannot even yet conceive so thus cannot be discounted entirely.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by temielects(m): 8:25am On May 18, 2022
You better wake up from ur slumber God almighty exists and rule over the affairs of men
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 8:29am On May 18, 2022
LordReed:


I agree with your post but I would add a caveat. The caveat is that while most conceptions of a god cannot rise to fulfil their burden of proof and thus can be totally discounted, there may be concepts of god(s) that we either cannot properly explore or cannot even yet conceive so thus cannot be discounted entirely.
Yes absolutely. Example is the flying spaghetti monster.
We cannot say he doesn't exist because we cannot yet conceive him
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 8:30am On May 18, 2022
temielects:
You better wake up from ur slumber God almighty exists and rule over the affairs of men
do you have proof?
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 8:38am On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
do you have proof?

Simple: it is seen that No thing in this world created itself. Everything in this world has a Creator.

And The Creator of this world is Who we call God.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 8:42am On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
People can say one of the following things:

1. God exists
2. God does not exist
3. I do not believe the claim that God exists

Options 1, the statement that a God exists, is a positive assertion that has the burden of proof. However, it is an extraordinary claim, since it is contrary to ordinary experience. Carl Sagan stated “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”, which means that the statement that God exists should be supported by extraordinary evidence.

Option 2, It is not an extraordinary claim to say that God does not exist although, as a positive assertion, it still has a burden of proof. Since it is not an extraordinary claim, the total absence of real evidence could be considered sufficient proof.

Option 3 does not have the burden of proof, as long as I honestly do not believe that claim.

I am more of option 3.

Raw-bish! IT IS ONLY WHEN A CLAIM IS MADE that there MIGHT BE a burden of proof, IN ANY CASE.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by temielects(m): 8:52am On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
do you have proof?
no debate with you until He himself reveal to you
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 10:44am On May 18, 2022
temielects:
no debate with you until He himself reveal to you
temielects, personal testimonials are not evidence
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 10:45am On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


Simple: it is seen that No thing in this world created itself. Everything in this world has a Creator.

And The Creator of this world is Who we call God.
the God is flying spaghetti monster
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 10:46am On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


Raw-bish! IT IS ONLY WHEN A CLAIM IS MADE that there MIGHT BE a burden of proof, IN ANY CASE.

What's your evidence for your God?
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 11:21am On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
the God is flying spaghetti monster

Obviously this is in your language.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 11:24am On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
temielects, personal testimonials are not evidence

Then why do you call witnesses? Are they witnesses because they are just coming to warm up the chairs in Court?

You people truly need to re-go to school.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 11:28am On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


Then why do you call witnesses? Are they witnesses because they are just coming to warm up the chairs in Court?

You people truly need to re-go to school.

I'm a witness for the existence of flying spaghetti monster.
You got to believe me when I tell you that I saw him creating your God
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 11:28am On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


Obviously this is in your language.
Prove me wrong.
Flying Spaghetti Monster is real.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by kaaya149: 12:04pm On May 18, 2022
Very true. Thanks for sharing thoughtful information.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by MaxInDHouse(m): 12:17pm On May 18, 2022
I think everyone has a choice since some so called believers view unbelievers as insanes and unbelievers also thought the same towards believers! cheesy

1 Like

Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 1:07pm On May 18, 2022
MaxInDHouse:
I think everyone has a choice since some so called believers view unbelievers as insanes and unbelievers also thought the same towards believers! cheesy
There's no argument that someone has a choice but when you want to make your choice the undiluted truth then we will ask you for proof. No one would care what you believe if you can just keep them to yourself but if you want to make it open then be ready to face whatever others believe as well
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by MaxInDHouse(m): 1:27pm On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
There's no argument that someone has a choice but when you want to make your choice the undiluted truth then we will ask you for proof. No one would care what you believe if you can just keep them to yourself but if you want to make it open then be ready to face whatever others believe as well
Excellent!
Meaning you have to start going to meet people in their homes like preachers do because staying on social media doesn't reach the hearts of people who will like to see you face to face! cheesy
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 1:45pm On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
Prove me wrong.
Flying Spaghetti Monster is real.

I do not need to. We both have no need for it.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 1:52pm On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
I'm a witness for the existence of flying spaghetti monster.
You got to believe me when I tell you that I saw him creating your God

Workch tried this, it did not work! grin why?
Because, no man makes Truth!

And we know Truth.

Therefore, we automatically know YOU LIE and that you are only saying this because you are a hater of God.

So this is very bad and unaceptable evidence because it was given with a very very bad interest
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 2:02pm On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


Workch tried this, it did not work! grin why?
Because, no man makes Truth!

And we know Truth.

Therefore, we automatically know YOU LIE.



How do you know that I am lying?
Can you prove that I am lying?

Who's workch?
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 2:03pm On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


I do not need to. We both have no need for it.
I do because I'm a living testimony of his existence and going by your logic. Testimonies are valid.

Can you prove that I am not telling the truth?
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 2:04pm On May 18, 2022
MaxInDHouse:

Excellent!
Meaning you have to start going to meet people in their homes like preachers do because staying on social media doesn't reach the hearts of people who will like to see you face to face! cheesy
nope, I don't have to.
I have to respect other people's belief by not knocking on their doors to tell them my own beliefs.

May I bless you. I, Jehovah, the God of Jehovah witness cheesy
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 2:05pm On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
How do you know that I am lying?
Can you prove that I am lying?

Who's workch?

grin That is also one of the wonders God has done in men, WE KNOW TRUTH AS SOON AS WE MEET IT OR HEAR IT OR SEE IT, like baby turtles finding their way to the sea ! grin
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 2:17pm On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
I do because I'm a living testimony of his existence and going by your logic. Testimonies are valid.

I Did not request for your testimony or your thoughts or opinion. So, doing this is exactly like those men whom we see on the street talking even no one is around them.

FatherOfJesus:

Can you prove that I am not telling the truth?

I have answered this!
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 2:18pm On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


I Did not request for your testimony or your thoughts or opinion. So, doing this is exactly like those men whom we see on the street talking even no one is around them.



I have answered this!

The lord flying spaghetti monster said he wants you to serve him all the days of your life. cheesy

I'm a living testimony of his grace and might cheesy

You cannot disprove that
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 2:20pm On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


grin That is also one of the wonders God has done in men, WE KNOW TRUTH AS SOON AS WE MEET IT OR HEAR IT OR SEE IT, like baby turtles finding their way to the sea ! grin
The truth is that the Flying Spaghetti Monster is the only true God and any other God is a man-made God.

We know the truth and by my testimonies I have confident that it's the truth. I'm sure you can not disprove that cheesy

Disprove it if you disagree
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by Dtruthspeaker: 2:23pm On May 18, 2022
FatherOfJesus:
Prove me wrong.
Flying Spaghetti Monster is real.

As I said earlier, I do not need it for anything.
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 2:23pm On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


grin That is also one of the wonders God has done in men, WE KNOW TRUTH AS SOON AS WE MEET IT OR HEAR IT OR SEE IT, like baby turtles finding their way to the sea ! grin
The lord God flying spaghetti monster just ministered to me.
He said you will rot in hell if you don't serve him in spirit and in truth.

My brother dtruthspeaker, the lord loves you. He's willing to welcome you into his meatball bossom and with his noodly appendages. Desist from your evil ways and drink sweet wine in eternity with our noodly lord.

Permesan be upon him cheesy
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 2:24pm On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


As I said earlier, I do not need it for anything.
Flying spaghetti monster loves you. Testimonies are valid, that's your word against you.

My testimony is valid even in court according to you cheesy
Re: 3 Types Of God Claims And Which Has The Burden Of Proof. by FatherOfJesus: 2:26pm On May 18, 2022
Dtruthspeaker:


As I said earlier, I do not need it for anything.
it doesn't matter whether you need him or not.
He created you in his own image and he will find you. You will go to hell if you don't acknowledge this cheesy

(1) (2) (Reply)

Frightening Friday! / Pastor Odumeje Arrives In London, UK For His Highly Anticipated Crusade / Question About Jesus Christ

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 45
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.