₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,906 members, 8,520,079 topics. Date: Tuesday, 17 November 2026 at 10:43 AM

Toggle theme

JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) (13577 Views)

1 2 3 4 Reply (Go Down)

JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by FreeStuffsNG(op): 10:46pm On Nov 07
This man refused life-saving treatment because of his religion - days later the rules changed


Aleem Maqbool, Religion editor and Catherine Wyatt


In August this year, 26-year-old Isaac Valdez had an epileptic seizure while browsing in his local library, causing him to convulse and strike his head against the ground.

He lost consciousness. Later, in hospital, it transpired Isaac had hit his head with such force it had led to a brain haemorrhage.

Treatment was seriously complicated by the fact that, as a Jehovah's Witness, Isaac carried a "No Blood" card, an indication that he would not accept treatment involving any form of blood transfusion because of his religious beliefs.

As a result, a procedure to drain fluid from Isaac's brain did not take place.

But his family, from Waxahachie, Texas, were encouraged by the fact that he regained consciousness and even started to talk again. He was able to confirm that he stood by his "no blood" beliefs.

The family's relief at his apparent improvement was short-lived. Isaac slipped into a coma and his condition worsened rapidly.

A neurosurgeon told Isaac's family the only way to save his life was an emergency operation, but that it was one that required blood transfusion.

His family took the decision to abide by Issac's wishes as a lifelong Witness not to accept such a procedure.

Isaac - who his twin brother Jacob Valdez describes as an intelligent man who loved volunteering and helping the elderly - died on 26 August 2026 when doctors turned off his life support.

Medical statement inside and outside of wallet
Jacob's "no blood" card which is like the one carried in Isaac's wallet
Just 23 days later, the Jehovah's Witnesses' Governing Body announced a seismic change in teaching that would, in effect, have given Isaac the religious green light to have the life-saving treatment he had refused.

The change suddenly means the vast majority of medical procedures using donated blood are no longer prohibited to followers. Now, decisions on whether to accept such treatments are to be left to individuals.

Jacob, already dealing with the death of his twin, was angered at the Jehovah's Witnesses' leadership for not coming to their conclusion sooner. He told BBC News he believes Isaac could well still be alive if they had.

The original rule on blood transfusions dates back to 1945, towards the very end of a war during which the use of blood transfusions had been increasingly widespread. The leaders of Jehovah's Witnesses announced that their believers were not permitted to accept transfusions.

This was based on their interpretation of Bible verses from both the Old and New Testaments prohibiting the consumption of blood, including one from the Book of Acts that instructs believers to abstain from blood, from food offered to idols, and from things that had been strangled.

So, why has the Jehovah's Witnesses' Governing Body, based in New York state, now decided to change the rules, 81 years after introducing them?

It comes after years of pressure from both within and outside the faith, but that is not how leaders of the faith describe the decision.

"The change is basically the application of Bible principles to modern medicine and its methods," says the Jehovah's Witnesses international spokesperson, Paul Gillies, who described it as both a fresh look at scripture and at medical advances.

Jehovah's Witnesses international spokesperson, Paul Gillies, wearing a dark suit, white shirt and yellow dotted tie
Jehovah's Witnesses international spokesperson Paul Gillies says the ban on transfusion of whole blood remains but blood components can now be used.

We meet Gillies at the Jehovah's Witnesses UK headquarters set in 85 acres of Essex countryside. It is a vast modern complex where hundreds of volunteer followers of the faith live and work without pay.

He insists the basic teaching has not changed and that the transfusion of whole blood is still prohibited. However, for decades, most transfusions have not used whole blood, instead using the specific components of blood that are needed by the patient.


The change is being justified by permitting the use of blood components, like plasma and red blood cells and platelets, in the huge numbers of medical procedures that were previously banned.

Gillies says the Bible references "abstaining from blood" but not "various components that could be extracted from blood".

He says the Governing Body felt it their duty to avoid scriptural "overreach" and only apply what was specifically described in the Bible.

But that explanation has stunned many and led them to ask if it was not a huge overreach 81 years ago to ban blood transfusions in the first place, when transfusions are not specifically mentioned in the bible.

Others are then also asking why it has taken so long to come to this landmark decision, given that transfusions that do not use whole blood have been the norm for decades.

These are questions Jacob asked as soon as the ban was lifted, just days after a memorial service for Isaac.

Jacob, who had already left the Jehovah's Witness faith he was brought up in, texted prominent figures from Isaac's congregation in Texas after Isaac's death. The messages are full of angst, and painful to read.

He asked them to consider "the part you played in encouraging so many people to sacrifice their life for something that was never God's will".


Most did not reply, but one "elder" responded saying he could not understand why Jacob was so angry and fixated on the policy shift.


This all further infuriated Jacob, who particularly wants the faith's decision-makers to be accountable for all the lives lost.

"I want to ask them if they could apologise directly, I would like not to have a deflected answer, just straightforward apology," he says.

It is extremely difficult to say how many Jehovah's Witnesses, among the estimated nine million followers of the faith worldwide, died each year having refused treatment involving blood transfusions. But research in one medical journal in 2016, The Obstetrical & Gynecological Survey, put the figure at around 1,100.

"We're sympathetic to their feelings, and if individuals have lost family members and are concerned about some of these questions, they deserve to be heard compassionately," says Gillies.

But there was little clarity about why the change did not come earlier.

"Why has it taken this time? Well, I guess because it takes time, it doesn't necessarily mean that there is some magic change that's taken place," says Gillies.

And when asked, Gillies deflects calls for the leadership to apologise, saying that many lives had, in fact, been saved because faithful Jehovah's Witnesses had not been exposed to blood contamination scandals.

He also insists that even after the new edict, some Jehovah's Witnesses could still decide they did not want to accept a transfusion, and that may have been the case even if the edict had come years ago.

Indeed, the BBC spoke with Alex Ball, 58, a Jehovah's Witness from West Sussex, who says in 2012 a doctor told him he would not survive the chemotherapy he needed to treat his blood cancer unless he also had a transfusion.

"I wanted to adhere as closely to the scriptures as possible when I was sick, and I think I did that well."

With help from what is called "a Jehovah's Witness Hospital Liaison Committee", Alex found an American consultant who could perform a treatment to boost Alex's blood cells without the need for any products from someone else. His UK consultant agreed to treat him using the new method and it worked.

More than a decade later, Alex says he would make the same decision again, despite the change in blood policy that would have permitted the transfusions he had been told he needed.

It is not just receiving blood which has been an issue.

Elisha Cummings, 50, a Jehovah's Witness from Trinidad and Tobago, was unable to donate blood to her aunt, who died, because of the rules.


Elisha Cummings was advised by an elder not to donate blood to her aunt Eva who died
They also cost her her marriage too, with her husband of 10 years leaving the faith and divorcing her after it came to light that he had had a blood transfusion as a child, something that was looked down upon in her Witness community.

"Since the blood policy change, I have not been myself," she says. "It left me in a sort of depressed mode."

"How many houses did I go to trying to convince people about the blood doctrine? And you're coming now and it's something totally different," Elisha says.

Elisha says her beliefs as a whole have been shaken, yet she feels reluctant to leave the faith, partly because it is what provides her with her community and she fears isolation.

In the past, those who disagreed with "blood doctrine" were ostracised or felt like they needed to leave the faith. Will they now be able to come back?

"Any individual that wants to come back to the faith is warmly welcomed," says Gillies, speaking of those who had left the faith because they had accepted a transfusion for themselves or a relative.

"If they would like to become one of Jehovah's Witnesses again and would like to speak to the elders, then they're very welcome to do so."
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cx5ynly549njo

Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by FreeStuffsNG(op):
"Why has it taken this time? Well, I guess because it takes time, it doesn't necessarily mean that there is some magic change that's taken place," says Gillies.
Strangely, this decision was taken by elders who should be Holy-Spirit filled. Most of them are probably dead by now.

Most did not reply, but one "elder" responded saying he could not understand why Jacob was so angry and fixated on the policy shift.

This all further infuriated Jacob, who particularly wants the faith's decision-makers to be accountable for all the lives lost.

"I want to ask them if they could apologise directly, I would like not to have a deflected answer, just straightforward apology," he says.


There is no way the JW will not eventually apologise. The Word of God does not change. It is settled, only the word inspired by the flesh change. Almost all the churches are guilty of this pride of life led by the carnal mind and now imposed on the church through wrong doctrines and teachings.

I know a church brought to Nigeria from US in the late 1960s that indoctrinated its members to meet under tree and in the members residences. When other churches were building and meeting in their own buildings, that church kept starting congregrations that meet under trees and members residences. Decades down the line, they changed the doctrine but it was too late. Now they have no visibility and presence in most of the prime locations and now have buildings in obscure parts of the suburbans. If I mention the name of the church, you will be wondering if it is a new church yet it has been around in Nigeria for decades and even older than most of our pentecostal churches like Winners etc.

Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Amotolongbo(f):
Anyone who dies because of a religious principle, rejecting traditional or scientific remedies is a fool and idïot combined
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by FineUsername(m): 10:53am On Nov 08
Make wuna dey play.



I hope say other church doctrines no go give wuna or your relatives this kind permanent regrets.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by geoworldedu: 10:54am On Nov 08
Christian rules will change more more. Kumuyi's rule too have changed, but Sewa has been damaged already, just as Waldis predicted it. Kumuyi spoilt Sewa's life. Such a very wicked man.


Otem Erectus 233
Chapter Two Hundred and Thirty Three

Now Willem, one of the pastors of those days, the same which Waldis spoke about millions of years ago began to get old in Negre.
Then he began to change all the things which he once taught the people about, according to the vision which Jasheb got from Waldis.
For the same man was he who caused a great conflict between a couple named Sewa and Tosin in those days.
For Sewa the wife was a member of his church while Tosin the husband was not.
Now in the past, Willem condemned the use of the big box in watching events ongoing in the world, saying, it is a box of the devil.
So his followers refused to watch events in the box. And some of them broke the boxes, saying we cannot watch this box invented by the devil.

Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by AllBlack: 10:56am On Nov 08
Hahahahaaaaa

He was living his life on the religious rules set by his fellow humans

Fellow human IMPOSED his ideas as LAW and you couldn't have sense to chew the meat and throw the bones? you carry everything put for mouth
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Seunpapa65: 10:57am On Nov 08
His family should have just ignore his nonsense belief maybe he would have been alive and appreciate them
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by ceejay80s(m): 10:59am On Nov 08
their loss, I have no pity for them,
what's the difference between not taking blood transfusion and committing suicide?
do whatever it takes to save ur life,
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Willie2015: 11:00am On Nov 08
Once it is not forbidden or written explicitly in the Bible.

That means u got to use your common sense and wisdom.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by YoungLionken(m): 11:01am On Nov 08
I thought the OP was a Muslim? If so, what's his concern or interest regarding JW and Christianity in general..?
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by fredoooooo: 11:01am On Nov 08
If its not foolishness in the first place whi refuse such?
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Obakoolex(m): 11:01am On Nov 08
Ignorance in place of knowledge is total destruction
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Fiscus105(m): 11:03am On Nov 08
Not too late for your brother, your brother just died from his foolishness!

Religion shouldn't take common sense from person, whose brain is functioning.

Many of doctrines religions faithful (,, xtians, Islam, Judaism) are following today, were written by human beings like them, and many of such doctrines were written then, by their myopic knowledge, selfishness, culture or what applicable at that time, some even written by their wickedness)

The oneous is on faithful to know different between proclamation of God and human instructions.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Obakoolex(m): 11:05am On Nov 08
But wait o freestuffsNG..... Have you found jesushuh
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Eba50: 11:06am On Nov 08
am proudly j.w no matter the changes
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Ishilove: 11:06am On Nov 08
geoworldedu:
Christian rules will change more more. Kumuyi's rule too have changed, but Sewa has been damaged already, just as Waldis predicted it. Kumuyi spoilt Sewa's life. Such a very wicked man.


Otem Erectus 233
Chapter Two Hundred and Thirty Three

Now Willem, one of the pastors of those days, the same which Waldis spoke about millions of years ago began to get old in Negre.
Then he began to change all the things which he once taught the people about, according to the vision which Jasheb got from Waldis.
For the same man was he who caused a great conflict between a couple named Sewa and Tosin in those days.
For Sewa the wife was a member of his church while Tosin the husband was not.
Now in the past, Willem condemned the use of the big box in watching events ongoing in the world, saying, it is a box of the devil.
So his followers refused to watch events in the box. And some of them broke the boxes, saying we cannot watch this box invented by the devil.
What are you going on about??
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Auditt: 11:07am On Nov 08
When you think that the blacks are the only people in this brain washing thing, you go shock.

Going against professional advice is detrimental. They should have consulted widely before proposing such rule.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Reference(m): 11:07am On Nov 08
Just say, 'that is life' and that is the way the world works. Man will continue to remain fallible. He is not God. He learns by mistakes and in his sacrifices all others are led and saved. Is that not the 'likeness' of one who gives his life for his friends.... Now, does this bit sound scriptural.

So it may sound counter intuitive but this is what the Christian faith is all about. Going through things in order to save others and the joy that accomplishes that.

Remember from the birth of Baby Jesus through his life and times on earth it has been a battle against the law, one contradiction after the other.

The early church was not spared with some burnt alive for their beliefs considered heretic but are mainstream today.

It is just the nature of man, a constantly moving conveyor belt of reforms fueled by the blood of believers and skeptics.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Treasure17(m): 11:10am On Nov 08
Even the Bible says you should be wise as serpent. Refusing blood transfusion in the name of doctrine is stupidity.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by ubest1(m): 11:10am On Nov 08
Madness human set rule for the foolish without brain to obey all, nobody kill ur brother una foolishness did
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Reference(m): 11:11am On Nov 08
Eba50:
am proudly j.w no matter the changes
That is what I am saying.
It should not. It should make your faith even stronger.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by zenburster:
If the earlier instruction about transfusion was from God, where is this latest one from?

Did God change his mind or did the church leaders change a man made doctrine.

When it comes to religion, use your brain. Even the Bible was written by men and episcopal doctrine and which books made the cut to be included in the Bible were decided by men at the council of Nicea in 325AD.

Like I said, use your brain and dont die because of religious doctrine.

If you ask me, science >>>> religion.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by orikoku: 11:16am On Nov 08
When blood of jesus can not safe me, why will I reject blood transfusion? Una go get sence by force.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by enemyofprogress: 11:18am On Nov 08
You all must learn in a hard way.



After Delilah killed Samson, she went back to her hometown,Ohafia
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Blakjewelry(m): 11:19am On Nov 08
I still amazes me how modern man still believes what horse riding and sun bake brick living brought about.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Judolisco(m): 11:21am On Nov 08
There's a reason God created us with a brain.. How you make use of it is left to you
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by tragergeorge(m): 11:22am On Nov 08
soon they'll justify same sex,,, marrying multiple women,marry kids,and y'all will be screemin why it took Soo long....
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Igbophobia: 11:23am On Nov 08
Hmmmm
.

Even Islamic terrorists are writing about JW.

For JW, this is why belonging to a cult doesn't lead nowhere near heaven.

Repentance from sin and turning to Jesus is the answer.
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Codes151(m): 11:24am On Nov 08
You brother na xxodo,

Sorry to say. But try to ensure no other person is that naive in your family
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by hslbroker2(m): 11:26am On Nov 08
This is a very painful situation, and it raises a serious question about religious authority and human life. If a doctrine can be changed today after people have lost their lives obeying it for decades, then the leadership owes its members a sincere explanation.

Faith should bring people closer to God, not make them afraid to accept life-saving medical treatment. Religious leaders are human beings, and they can make mistakes. But when those mistakes have consequences as serious as someone's death, accountability should not be avoided.

The saddest part is that no policy change can bring Isaac back. I believe every religious organisation should put human life, compassion and individual conscience first. Nobody should have to lose a loved one before a religious doctrine is reconsidered.

My personal opinion
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by Heffalump(m): 11:27am On Nov 08
I don't know why I refused to be cowed by religion. If you're not capable of advancing your mental capacity to judge as a natural being created by God, to follow rules that encourage safety, peace, security, and dignity of the human race, then you're a subhuman unworthy of existence. kiss
Re: JW Rules On Blood Transfusion Have Changed,But It's Too Late For My Brother(Pix) by netmillionaires(m): 11:35am On Nov 08
Even the ban that is still in place will be thrown out in the future, and the people who adhere to it and perish will regret it. You'd better use your brain now.
1 2 3 4 Reply

JW Adjustment On Blood Transfusion: Doctrinal Changes & Effects • Aunty Esther Dies After Cancer Battle & Refusing Blood Transfusion • Are Jehovah Witnesses Right About Their Belief Against Blood Transfusion? • 2 • 3 • 4

''born Again'' -what Did Jesus Mean? • Why Do Nigerian Motorists Keep Religious Books On Their Dashboards? • Jesus Was Born Years Earlier Than Thought. - Pope