Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,152,706 members, 7,816,904 topics. Date: Friday, 03 May 2024 at 07:48 PM

Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede - Islam for Muslims (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede (5933 Views)

Hajj Stampede: Nigerian Survivor Narrates Ordeal / How Kabir Grabbed A Man’s Testicle To Survive Hajj Stampede. Vanguard News / Emir Of Zang, Taraba Among The Dead In Hajj Stampede (Photo) (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by AlBaqir(m): 4:31pm On Sep 30, 2015
Empiree:
^^ grin VEX vs BAQIR part..............20, perhaps?
Oh! You thought its a season film! grin Am afraid its not. And absolutely on my part, no fight or ill-feelings. In fact the guy had once severally used "la'anatullah alahi" for Imam Khomeini. I don't even move an inch in retaliation. Ibn Taymiyyah has done worse for Imam Ali in his Minhaj al-Sunnah. So using vulgar language, fighting dirty, derailing etc are perfect example of the Wahhabi mentality. Mine is to dialogue with anybody in line with the Quranic injuction {Call unto the way of your Lord with wisdom and good manners; and argue with them in the best way...}.

Salam alaykum.
Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by Empiree: 4:36pm On Sep 30, 2015
Ok. ..we hear una.

Let's draw curtain over this sectarian differences.

Purpose of this thread long lost.

And of course, it would as the incident fades off.

Ulama have differences in the issue of Najd and

Both sides brought evidences from same sources.

Anyways, keep us posted as you hear latest on Hajj incident
Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by Empiree: 4:38pm On Sep 30, 2015
AlBaqir:
Salam alaykum.
Walaikum Salaam
Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by vedaxcool(m): 7:11pm On Sep 30, 2015
AlBaqir:
^What we are discussing here is Saudi not being able to lift up to their responsibilities. While you turn your back on series of eye-witness reports that clearly exposed the carelessness and mismanagement of the Saudi, you choose to wait for their "sahih" reports after their "transparent" investigations to the deadly matter. Then I need to remind you that nothing good comes out of NAJD except fitnah. One of your brother, Demmzy15, is somehow so pained with that because of his grand sheik. He choose to defend what is not defendable.

So where did I derail the flow of this thread?

You are the one going from pillar to post because of your personal problems with Iran and its leader who is so responsible and passionate about every single soul of his citizens. Now former Iraqi prime minister is your next target. Bro, you've lost it. Again if you don't have anything to post, kindly follow the prophet's advice of keeping mute.

You are indeed laughable lol grin grin grin grin, clearly a waste of anyone precious time, I ask aren't you a hypocrite with your actions so far in this thread? Demmzy watch his first post on this thread, he goes like this; @OP, Demmyz15, so many versions of the report influenced by political, sectarian, social and economic factors. watch how he exposes his intellectual dishonesty, all his previous post on this matter has continued to emphasize accounts of certain eye witness which blamed security who condoned off the road, since these eye witness account suits his selfish agenda and his uncontrollable desire to put the Saudis in bad light, but he gets here and sees the Iran, time for baqi to play the intellectual card and show he is an unbiased and just out for the truth, his eye witness tale changes to one of the several versions of the event which could be true . . . but down the line again within the same thread he forget his objectivity and his initial statement that the eye witness could be one of the several version of the event to being the truth vedaxcool has deliberately overlook, your condition is pathetic, when one lives on deciet, it is easy to forget your cover story and forget your identify. Sorry you Iran leader is irresponsible and in Obama words a politician not a spiritual leader, who uses rhetoric to fool people like you and lagoshia in achieving his political quest. Again I repeat it is better to shut up rather than avoid addressing the points raised, you had no sensible post but to derail this thread by labelling the Saudis who your irresponsible leader loathe and hate devils horn thereby derailing the thread from its initial subject matter which had nothing to do with satan or his horns. I will still elucidate this point of Iraq being the referred to in the hadith from again a PRACTICAL perspective not your lies and deciet. I hope this does not leave you sulking! I will be back!

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by LagosShia: 11:12pm On Sep 30, 2015
vedaxcool:


Sorry you Iran leader is irresponsible and in Obama words a politician not a spiritual leader, who uses rhetoric to fool people like you and lagoshia in achieving his political quest.

we have someone to "fool" us, and a number his type who also "fool" our likes. do you have "anyone" to guide you? may be Obama? tongue

should i remind you of this:
https://www.nairaland.com/981940/vedaxcool-please-answer-sunni-imam
Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by Empiree: 11:59pm On Sep 30, 2015
I'm pleading to brothers here again to please stop this unnecessary bickering.

You can not solve sectarianism - not in our lifetime.

So why screwing yourselves over it?.

Tragic incidents in Saudi were made possible by Allah's permission. That's what I believe.

And whether Najd referred to by the prophet(SAW) is Saudi or elsewhere, only time will tell.

One thing to be respected is different views. Yes, must be respected.

I do not like the idea of turning every discussion quickly into sectarianism. It's not healthy.

We become laughing stocks any freaking time we do that.

Differences can be discussed without putting on boxing gloves.

Hajj is for Muslims NOT Sunni/Shia.

We disrespect Allah and His messanger by arguing over this silly thing- yes, very silly.

Allah does not guarantee safe returns after Hajj. We see quiet number of ahadith to this effect.

There is no guarantee anyone would complete Hajj safely.

Besides, there are firm Muslims who pray so hard to die in Mecca.

Some of them might even be among the victims. May Allah Have mercy on them.

THEY ARE SHUHADAH

What is guarantee is if Hajj is properly performed, reward must be nothing PARADISE.

We need to stop blame games/politrics. This is Hajj- extraordinary event not Sunni/Shia crap.
Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by Demmzy15(m): 6:43am On Oct 01, 2015
AlBaqir:
@Demmzy15, more ahadith to wet your appetite:

I replied your so called "bone breakers" yesterday morning, but someone kept banning me. So please go to page 0 for rebuttal

The Prophet had proven "NAJD" and "IRAQ" to be separate places

Like I said earlier you ignore some hadiths and then use others which is very unfair. In my earlier posts I pointed out that Najd could be described by were you stay, so basically there are over 13 places which are identified as Najd:

1. Najd Yemen. 2. Najd Iraq. 3. Najd Hejaz. 4. Najd Khal. 5. Najd Al-Shari. 6. Najd Azaar. 7. Najd Al-Aqaab. 8. Najd Kabkab. 9. Najd Mari. 10. Najd Alwaz. 11. Najd-e-Aja. 12. Najd Barqq.

So it depends on where you're!


Sahih Muslim Book 007, Number 2666:
Abu Zubair heard Jabir b. Abdullah as saying as he was asked about (the place for entering upon the) state of Ihram: I heard (and I think he carried it directly to the Apostle of Allah) him saying: For the people of Medina, Dhu'l-Hulaifa is the place for entering upon the state of Ihram, and for (the people coming through the other way, i.e Syria) it is Juhfa; for the people of IRAQ it is Dhat al-'Irq; for the people of NAJD it is Qarn (al-Manazil) and for the people of Yemen it is Yalamlam.

Sunnan an-Nasai, Hadith No. 2657: Chapter 22 - The Miqat of the people of Iraq:

It was narrated that 'Aisha said: "The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) designated Dhul-Hulaifah as the Miqat for the people of Al-Madinah, al-Juhfa for the people of Ash-Sham and Egypt, Dhat 'Irq for the people of Al-Iraq, Qarn for the people of NAJD and Yalamlam for the people of Yemen.

This hadith was narrated in Makkah, so the Najd would be different. When the Prophet talked about fitna, horns of satan, etc he was in Medina.

mam Khattabi (319h-388h) said
ومن كان بالمدينة كان نجده بادية العراق ونواحيها ، وهي مشرق أهلها واصل النجد ما ارتفع من الارض
'and for the one who is in Madeenah then his Najd would be the desert of Iraaq and it's regions for this is to the east of the People of Madeenah. The basic meaning of Najd is that which is raised/elevated from the earth
[Ailaam al hadith of Imam Khattabi 2/1274 alMagharabiya]

Talking about the hadith you mentioned, let's look at how another hadith explained it and please don't play that fabrication card with me!

“The Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu alayhi wasallam) addressed us and said: ‘The Talbiyah of the people of Al-Madinah begins at Dhul-Hulaifah. The Talbiyah of the people of Sham begins at Juhfah. The Talbiyah of the people of Yemen begins at Yalamlam. The Talbiyah of the people of Najd begins at Qarn. ""The Talbiyah of the [size=15pt]people of the east[/size] begins at Dhat ‘Irq.’ Then he turned to face the (eastern) horizon and said: ‘O Allah, make their hearts steadfast.’[Sunan Ibn Maja Vol. 1, Book 25, Hadith 2915]

This has totally destroyed your arguments, I'll be expecting more bone breakers!
Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by Demmzy15(m): 7:03am On Oct 01, 2015
LagosShia:


so Iraq is the only "elevated" land relative to Medinah? tongue


Which other one?! undecided

and who says it must be to the east? and if it is to the east, is Iraq to the east of Medinah or to the north? and "najduna" is possessive; meaning "our najd". how does iraq becomes the possession of arabs in the times of the Prophet (s)?

How can the Prophet also explain the hajj of people of Iraaq when it's not possession of the Muslims then?

Sahih Muslim Book 007, Number 2666:
Abu Zubair heard Jabir b. Abdullah as saying as he was asked about (the place for entering upon the) state of Ihram: I heard (and I think he carried it directly to the Apostle of Allah) him saying: For the people of Medina, Dhu'l-Hulaifa is the place for entering upon the state of Ihram, and for (the people coming through the other way, i.e Syria) it is Juhfa; for the people of IRAQ it is Dhat al-'Irq; for the people of NAJD it is Qarn (al-Manazil) and for the people of Yemen it is Yalamlam.
Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by vedaxcool(m): 10:03am On Oct 02, 2015
LagosShia:


we have someone to "fool" us, and a number his type who also "fool" our likes. do you have "anyone" to guide you? may be Obama? tongue

should i remind you of this:
https://www.nairaland.com/981940/vedaxcool-please-answer-sunni-imam

grin grin grin So you mean you have found your IMAM? That Erratic old man? You are confused, Shiasm is an invitation to confusion I have not started with you and you are reliving past moments with uncle veda repeatedly schooling you on the ethics of Logical Thinking to the extent you yelled Ya Husayn madad and got no help from him. Thanks for underscoring my point, despite your knowledge and being educated -I guess- of being fooled by a man whose value for human life is extremely limited only good for being used, but due to blind fanaticism, sectarianism and opaque thinking insist on being fooled by an individual may I ask of what use is your brain?

Obama, I remember your shameless Iran general complaining the great satan failure to bomb ISIS hampered its operations in Iraq - in essence Ya Obama Madad?, as usual, they chant great satan in tehran to fool people like yourselves while dealing behind close doors to further their Agenda!

2 Likes

Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by vedaxcool(m): 10:07am On Oct 02, 2015
LagosShia:

[s]
your life is very sad and your ideology really fits your character.

you keep deceiving yourself. did the former PM of Iraq say Karbala should become "the Qibla", in the sense of replacing the Ka'ba? No!

if you know a bit of arabic you will understand what he said. what is the meaning of "qibla"? "qibla" means "direction, a destination you move towards". "qibla" is an arabic word that has a meaning, a literal meaning. when used literally, it doesnt mean Makkah or the holy Ka'bah. he said "Karbala should be a qibla for the Islamic world" and not "the qibla". he did not use the arabic article of "al", which is the equivalent of "the". he meant Karbala should be a destination for the Islamic world when things are improved. he then went on to mention "the Qibla" which we face in the five daily prayers (i.e. the Ka'bah/Makkah).

such deception is very filthy.[/s]

You live a sad life. The video is there for all to see
Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by vedaxcool(m): 10:34am On Oct 02, 2015
AlBaqir:

Oh! You thought its a season film! grin Am afraid its not. And absolutely on my part, no fight or ill-feelings. In fact the guy had once severally used "la'anatullah alahi" for Imam Khomeini. I don't even move an inch in retaliation. Ibn Taymiyyah has done worse for Imam Ali in his Minhaj al-Sunnah. So using vulgar language, fighting dirty, derailing etc are perfect example of the Wahhabi mentality. Mine is to dialogue with anybody in line with the Quranic injuction {Call unto the way of your Lord with wisdom and good manners; and argue with them in the best way...}.

Salam alaykum.

www.nairaland.com/attachments/2918032_wetinconcernme_jpegddb979c6c814546ffb19421a6c57080d
grin grin grin

you shamelessly derailed a threat you felt made you heroes look bad, rather than rebut you decided how best do I get back at this evil op for daring to question your perspective u have spent all your time on nairaland promoting or did he not know Iran is your hero and nothing must be pinned on them? You decided in your crude thinking and reasoning as a shia to throw you best spanner work, the Saudis are the devils horn, this reflects your cynical mentality of a shia, which lacks the manners and decency expected from a muslim and deviates from the path of wisdom and honour Islam encourages.

“…and be not amongst those who join gods with Allah, those who split up their Religion, and become shias (sects) - each party rejoicing in that which is with itself.” (Quran, 30:31-32)

1 Like

Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by vedaxcool(m): 10:42am On Oct 02, 2015
Practical Reasons why Iraq is the place Referred to in the hadith under discussion

1. Murder of Ali r.a

In the 19th of Ramadan 40 AH, which would correspond to January 25/26, 661 CE, while praying in the Great Mosque of Kufa, Ali was attacked by the Kharijite Abd-al-Rahman ibn Muljam. He was wounded by ibn Muljam's poison-coated sword while prostrating in the Fajr prayer.[118] Ali ordered his sons not to attack the Kharijites, instead stipulating that if he survived, ibn Muljam would be pardoned whereas if he died, ibn Muljam should be given only one equal hit (regardless of whether or not he died from the hit).[119]

Ali died a few days later on January 31, 661 CE (21 Ramadan 40 A.H).[118] Hasan fulfilled Qisas and gave equal punishment to ibn Muljam upon Ali's death.[113

Ali's death will prove to be the tipping point where fitnah and misguidiance entered the Ummah.

Note the place of his death, Kufa, mordern day Iraq.

Ali's r.a murder at the hands of accursed khariwajites would be the dividing line where matters of politics took a religious clothing and placed the seeds of division in the ummah!

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: Crush Cause: 300 Iranians Violated Rule-Hajj Stampede by Empiree: 10:44pm On Oct 25, 2015
Empiree:
@Demmzy15, i disagree with you, sir. There is currently an attempt to divert attention of muslims from Najd referred to by the prophet(SAW). Now, my contribution on this is not in any way meant to blame Saudi authority for recent incident. I do not hold them deliberately responsible unless and until firm evidence suggests otherwise. I already drafted my opinion on this stampede incident here https://www.nairaland.com/2624196/see-whos-responsible-hajj-stampede#down

Where Is Najd?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QbHymIJWMfA
Part 2. Just out
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aqBEm6oWTys

(1) (2) (Reply)

Animal Rights In Islam / Multipurpose Liquid Soap / Sheik Ismail Mufti Menk In Kano

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 74
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.