Yorimichi's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Yorimichi's Profile › Yorimichi's Posts
One view that one finds in epistemology, when one's talking about what can be justified beliefs or beliefs that aren't justified, is a view that's called evidentialism. The core idea behind evidentialism is that whenever we have a belief, it needs to be the case that that belief is justified to the extent that it's supported by evidence, and that it's responsible for us to hold that belief only to the extent that the belief conforms to the evidence that we have for it. The Intuitive Appeal of Evidence There's obviously a kind of intuitive appeal to this notion of evidentialism. If I'm looking in front of me and I'm seeing the table, and I have that perceptual evidence for the table, it certainly seems reasonable for me to believe that the table's in the room. If I look in front of me and there's no table, then it wouldn't be reasonable, we might think, for me normally to claim that there's a table in the room. And so, there's certainly an obvious, straightforward appeal to this notion that we should believe things to the extent that we have evidential support for them, and that if we're doing something like holding on to a belief even though all the evidence is against it, that there might be something epistemically suspect about that. When Belief Goes Beyond Evidence But on the other hand, it also seems like there's various cases where we might think that people have beliefs that go beyond what the evidence strictly licenses, but where nevertheless, their holding those beliefs might seem reasonable. So, here's just one kind of classic textbook case, to use this as an example. Imagine that I'm running through the woods, trying to escape an attacker. And in running through the woods, I suddenly come across a large ravine. And in order to escape the attacker, I need to jump over and clear the ravine. I'm not the world's greatest long jumper, right? Maybe I practiced some in secondary school on the interhouse sport team, but I'm not winning any Olympic medals, right? And based on the evidence available to me from my career in trying to make long jumps, I would not say that the theory; that the evidence provides sufficient support that I am going to be able to make the jump and clear the ravine. Practical Interest and Pragmatic Justification But, the only way for me to survive is to clear the ravine. If I believe that I'm able to make the jump, then that will put a little bit of an extra spring in my step, And might indeed be like what makes the difference between me clearing the ravine or not clearing the ravine, right? If I don't believe I can clear the ravine, then maybe I'm not going to make the jump at all, And that's not going to be in my practical interest; I'm going to get beaten by this attacker. If I believe that I can make the jump, then I'll go ahead and attempt it, and indeed I might put that extra spring in my step and let me jump a bit further than I strictly speaking had evidence in favor of thinking that I would be able to jump. So, in this case, we might think that my holding the belief that I'm going to be able to clear the ravine is reasonable. It's justified not because I have evidence, but it's justified because of the different practical implications of me holding that belief or not in the particular situation I find myself in, where I have certain practical interests at play. Pushing Back Against Strict Evidentialism So, some philosophers will use these kinds of cases to try to push back a bit, against a really strong kind of evidentialist view that says it's only responsible to hold a belief when that belief, is in proportion to your evidence. Immanuel Kant believed that reason is the source of morality and that the categorical imperative binds all rational agents. Kant seems to be somebody who is pushing back against a kind of strict evidentialism, somebody who wants to say that there's various grounds for belief that are not evidence in any straightforward kind of sense, but nevertheless make it reasonable and responsible, and indeed justified, for people to hold certain beliefs. Ultimately, while evidentialism offers a compelling framework for grounded reasoning, cases like the leaping runner—and the philosophical arguments of thinkers like Kant, remind us that human belief doesn't exist in a vacuum of pure data. Sometimes, the practical necessity of action or the broader grounds of moral and rational agency demand that our convictions stretch slightly ahead of our proofs, showing that what is "reasonable" to believe depends not only on the evidence behind us, but on the path we must carve forward. Shalom |
For many Christians, hell is an unquestionable doctrine: a place of eternal fire where the wicked suffer forever after death. It is preached from pulpits, depicted in art, and used as the ultimate warning against sin. But what if that idea isn't actually the Bible's original teaching? The historical evidence suggests that the modern concept of hell is not a single doctrine handed down from the earliest biblical writers. Instead, it is the product of centuries of theological development, influenced by changing ideas about justice, the afterlife, and divine judgment. Sheol: Where Everyone Went In the Hebrew Bible, the word often translated as "hell" is Sheol. Sheol wasn't a place of fiery punishment. It was simply the abode of the dead. Everyone went there; the righteous, the wicked, kings, peasants, prophets, and sinners alike. The ancient Israelites didn't imagine heaven and hell as competing destinations after death. Instead, death itself was viewed as a bleak, shadowy existence. Nobody looked forward to Sheol. It was a place of silence, darkness, and separation from the living, not eternal torture. Archaeological evidence also suggests that people believed the dead still required food, water, light, and offerings, and that ancestors could continue to influence the living through blessings, curses, or hidden knowledge. The Question That Changed Everything As Israel and Judah suffered conquest after conquest; from Assyria, Babylon, Persia, and eventually the Greek empires, a troubling question emerged: color=#000099] If God is just, why do the righteous suffer while the wicked prosper?[[/color] Books like Ecclesiastes, Job, and many of the Psalms wrestle with this very problem. Eventually, some Jewish thinkers proposed a revolutionary solution: Perhaps God's justice happens after death. This idea appears most clearly in Jewish writings that were never included in the biblical canon, especially 1 Enoch. These texts introduce concepts of postmortem reward and punishment, separating the righteous from the wicked after death. Importantly, these ideas were still developing. There was no single agreed-upon view. The New Testament Doesn't Speak with One Voice By the time we reach the New Testament, there isn't one doctrine of hell, there are several. Different authors describe different outcomes for the wicked: - Some appear to teach annihilationism, where the wicked simply cease to exist. - Others describe temporary punishment, followed by either destruction or eventual salvation. - Still others speak of eternal conscious torment. These ideas exist side by side. Even the vocabulary varies. Hades continues the idea of the general realm of the dead. Tartarus, mentioned only once, refers to the imprisonment of rebellious supernatural beings. Gehenna refers to the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem, a place associated in Jewish memory with idolatry and child sacrifice. Contrary to popular sermons, there is no historical evidence that it functioned as a perpetually burning garbage dump. Over time, Gehenna became symbolic of God's final judgment. How Eternal Hell Won The New Testament contains diverse and sometimes conflicting pictures of the afterlife. It wasn't until later Christian theologians attempted to harmonize these writings into a single system that eternal conscious torment became the dominant doctrine. During the medieval period, writers expanded these ideas dramatically. Works like The Divine Comedy, particularly the Inferno; gave hell vivid imagery that continues to shape popular imagination today, even though much of that imagery comes from literature rather than Scripture. By then, hell had become more than a theological concept. It had become a powerful tool for shaping belief, enforcing moral boundaries, and influencing behavior. Why This Matters Whether one believes in hell is ultimately a matter of faith. But understanding where our ideas come from is a matter of history. The evidence suggests that the modern picture of hell did not emerge fully formed from the pages of the Bible. It evolved over centuries through Jewish reflection on suffering, diverse New Testament perspectives, and later Christian theological synthesis. Recognizing that history doesn't tell anyone what they must believe. It simply reminds us that some of the doctrines many assume have always existed were, in fact, the result of a long and complex process of development. Perhaps the most interesting question isn't whether hell exists. It's why our understanding of it changed so dramatically in the first place. |
Is this the sign of things to come in the future |
Dtruthspeaker:At this point, it feels like you're not really engaging with the argument being made. The original question was why an all-loving and perfectly just God could not simply forgive Adam and Eve rather than allowing generations of suffering. Instead of addressing that, you've repeatedly shifted the discussion, from free will, to the curse, to animals being property, to God being above moral commands, and now to whether humans also possess love, wisdom, and justice. That's why it comes across as ill-prepared and somewhat bad faith. Each time a difficulty is raised with one explanation, the conversation moves to a different explanation rather than resolving the previous one. If your position is that God can do whatever He wants because He is God, then just say that. But if you're arguing that God's actions are morally justified, then the moral questions being raised need to be answered directly rather than sidestepped. |
Dtruthspeaker:You're missing the distinction I'm making. I'm not claiming humans possess love, justice, wisdom, and power in the same sense or degree as God. The question is whether God is the perfect standard of those qualities. If He is, then appealing to imperfect human behavior doesn't explain or justify divine behavior. As for the girlfriend and driver examples, ending a relationship or employment is not the same as condemning billions of descendants to suffer the consequences of that person's actions. The scale and nature of the consequences are completely different. And when you say God is "above" the command to forgive, that raises another question: if forgiveness is a moral good that God commands humans to practice, why would the being who defines morality be exempt from it? Shouldn't the highest moral standard exemplify the virtues it teaches rather than be excluded from them? |
sonmvayina:I see where you are coming from but frankly there are a few very huge historical problems with your account. First of all Christianity existed for nearly three centuries before Constantine, and core ideas such as sin, salvation, Jesus' death and resurrection, and the significance of Adam are already found in the New Testament, especially in Paul's letters, which were written long before the Council of Nicaea. Secondly Nicaea did not invent Christianity or original sin. Its primary purpose was to address the Arian controversy and clarify Christ's relationship to God the Father. That said, you're right that later Christian theology developed concepts in ways that differed from earlier Jewish thought. Judaism generally emphasized personal responsibility, as seen in Ezekiel 18, whereas some Christian traditions developed stronger doctrines of inherited sin. So the more interesting question isn't whether Constantine invented these ideas historically, he didn't, but whether the Christian interpretation of Adam and inherited sin is a faithful development of earlier Jewish beliefs or a departure from them. |
Truthseeker10:According to the biblical explanation you're presenting, yes. The claim is that animal suffering is a consequence of the curse that followed human disobedience. My question is whether that is just. If animals suffer because of human actions, then creatures incapable of moral choice are bearing the consequences of decisions they never made. Why should a just system work that way? |
This is quite misleading as all parties are allowed to filled in their election observers with inec |
Dreal1247:Perhaps. But if secret forces are behind Starmer's reported resignation, were they also behind the last five UK Prime Ministers who left office? • Liz Truss: resigned after the fallout from her mini-budget triggered market turmoil and a collapse in political support. • Boris Johnson: resigned following a series of scandals and a mass resignation of ministers from his government. • Theresa May: stepped down after repeatedly failing to get her Brexit deal through Parliament. • David Cameron: resigned after losing the Brexit referendum he had called. • Gordon Brown: left office after losing the 2010 general election. The common thread isn't necessarily hidden rulers. More often, Prime Ministers fall because they lose elections, lose Parliament, lose their party, or lose public confidence. |
UK is officially ungovernable... 6 prime ministers in 8 years is pretty much a circus |
sonmvayina:I'll really love to hear more about this cos that's certainly one possible explanation, but simply calling them inventions for social control doesn't demonstrate that they are false. Many ideas can be used for social control, religious, political, and even secular ones. The real question is whether these doctrines emerged because people were trying to manipulate others, or because they were attempting to explain human nature, morality, suffering, and our sense that the world is not as it should be. If you think they're inventions, what evidence convinces you that they were deliberately created for control rather than sincere attempts to answer those questions? I'll really love to hear more from you |
MaxInDHouse:It took me while to carefully read through all of your points so that I understand your interpretation, but points seems to raise as many questions as it answers. Like If the curse is not a punishment on individuals, but merely a consequence of Adam's rebellion, then we're still left with innocent people, including infants babies, suffering and dying because of something they never chose. Whether we call it "punishment" or "consequence," the moral issue remains the same. Regarding Ezekiel 18, your explanation is possible, but the chapter's main point is broader: God repeatedly emphasizes individual responsibility. That seems difficult to reconcile with the idea that all humanity continues to suffer because of a single ancestor's act thousands of years ago. On John 9, Jesus did more than reject parental guilt. He explicitly rejected the assumption that the man's blindness was caused by someone's sin. That seems to push against the idea that every instance of suffering is traceable to personal wrongdoing. And on the curse itself: if God imposed the curse and has the power to remove it, why allow it to continue for thousands of years? If the purpose is to prove that human rule fails, wouldn't an omniscient God already know that outcome? Why must billions of humans and countless animals suffer through the demonstration? Finally, saying that everyone will eventually learn that human rulers fail doesn't fully address the original question. The issue isn't whether human governments are imperfect. The issue is why a just and loving God would choose a system in which untold suffering becomes the means of teaching that lesson. Hope this puts a lit on this. |
Truthseeker10:Whenever animals first became capable of experiencing pain, fear, hunger, disease, injury, and distress. But the timing isn't really the issue. The question is whether their suffering is justified. If animals are not moral agents and cannot sin, why should they suffer as a consequence of human actions at all? |
Dtruthspeaker:The difference is that I'm not claiming to be perfectly loving, perfectly just, all-wise, and all-powerful. He even command us to forgive seventy times seven times 😜 Humans often struggle to forgive because we're limited, emotional, and imperfect. God, on the other hand, is supposed to be the moral ideal. And even when people end relationships or fire employees, they don't usually condemn billions of descendants who had nothing to do with the original offense. That's the part your analogy doesn't address. |
There is no rebellious or fallen angel named Satan anywhere in the Hebrew Bible. And the notion of such a divine being, as well as such a background, are creations of the literature of Greco-Roman period Judaism and early Christianity. In Bible scholarship you can't find any reference to any such entity or any such background anywhere in the Hebrew Bible. Any attempts to identify such references in the Hebrew Bible are attempts to renegotiate passages that refer to other things. Isaiah 14:12: So, Lucifer in Isaiah 14:12, that's a reference to the human king of Babylon. Ezekiel 28: Ezekiel 28 is about the human king of Tyre as a representative of humanity in the Garden of Eden. Job 1–2 & Zechariah 3: In Job 1 and 2 and Zechariah 3, the reference is not to an entity named Satan. The reference in Hebrew is to hasatan "the Satan." And there, "satan" is being used as the title of an office or a role within the divine council. This is someone who works for God and does God's bidding as kind of a prosecuting attorney, because "satan" is a generic noun that just means "adversary" or "accuser." You even have the angel of the Lord identified as a satan when they come out against Balaam in Numbers 22. So, anybody can step into the role of an adversary or accuser, and that's why you have just such an office, role, or position within the divine council. And then you have this bizarre reference in 1 Chronicles 21:1 to a satan: an adversary, an accuser, inciting David to number Israel. When we look at the parallel passage in 2 Samuel 24:1, there it's God who incites David. While there are some scholars who suggest that the lack of a definite article in the reference to "satan" in 1 Chronicles 21 might indicate this is being used as a personal name, I don't think that is accurate. I think, instead, it is just obscuring God's role in that incitement and just using the indefinite "an adversary, an accuser" in place of the reference to God themselves. So, it's in the Enochic literature that we see this use of Satan not only as a title for the head malevolent angel, the fallen angel who is responsible for all the calamity that ensues, we also see the plural "satans" being used to refer to a class of deity in the Enochic literature. By the time we get to the New Testament, "Satan" has become the name of this head malevolent angel, the one who rules over all the other malevolent angels and demons. By the way: "Demon" is itself a product of Greco-Roman period Jewish literature. It is borrowed from a Greek concept, and there's no term that can legitimately be translated as "demon" anywhere in the Hebrew Bible.If you want a good analogy for the way the word "satan" is used in the Hebrew Bible, the Greek concept of "devil" works just fine. You have the notion of the devil, which sounds like an office or a position rather than somebody's name; you have the notion of a devil, which can refer to a class of deity; and you have the notion of plural devils. That's exactly how the word "satan" is used in Hebrew. And again, that wouldn't become the name of the head malevolent divine being or angel until around the first century CE, around the time of the composition of the New Testament. I'll love to hear your opinions and contributions about this topic. Shalom |
MaxInDHouse:That view raises a few questions. If God sees all humans merely as extensions of Adam's punishment until some future point, why does the Bible repeatedly speak of individuals being judged according to their own actions even now? For example, Ezekiel 18 explicitly says, "The son will not bear the guilt of the father." Also, if people today "deserve whatever happens to them" simply because they descend from Adam, then suffering, disease, abuse, and the death of infants would be punishments inflicted on individuals who never personally chose Adam's rebellion. That seems difficult to reconcile with the idea of a just judge who does not punish children for their parents' sins. Romans 5 does teach that Adam's sin affected humanity, but it does not necessarily follow that every tragedy that befalls a person is something they deserve. In fact, Jesus rejected that assumption when discussing victims of disasters and people born blind (Luke 13:1–5; John 9:1–3). So the issue is whether inherited consequences are the same thing as deserved punishment. Those are not necessarily identical concepts. Again how can you claim to understand the standpoint of god |
MaxInDHouse:That may explain the biblical perspective, but it doesn't solve the moral question. If animals are merely property with little value, then why does the Bible repeatedly portray God as caring for them, feeding them, and taking notice of them? And if value is determined solely by ownership, does owning something make it morally acceptable to inflict suffering on it? 🤷🏽 More importantly, your argument seems to be shifting from "animals suffer because of Adam's sin" to "animals suffer because they don't matter as much." Those are two different explanations. The question remains: if God is perfectly just and compassionate, why create sentient creatures capable of pain and then subject them to suffering for a punishment they neither chose nor understood?😏 |
MaxInDHouse:Having the power to do something and being justified in doing it are two different questions. I don't dispute that, according to the Bible, God can give life and take it away. The question is whether His actions are morally good. Saying "He created everything, therefore He can do whatever He wants" explains His authority, but it doesn't explain why innocent suffering is just. If God thinks deeply before acting, then there must be a good reason for animals suffering, children dying, and entire populations enduring misery. Simply saying God has the power to do it doesn't answer why it is morally right for those who never chose the actions being punished. |
MaxInDHouse:Brotherly doesn't that seem cruel, inhumane and unjust I mean that still means innocent creatures are being punished for someone else's actions. If a human ruler cursed an entire planet and caused billions of animals to suffer because of one person's mistake, we would call that unjust. Why should the same standard not apply to God? And if God chose to curse the ground, then the suffering of animals is ultimately a result of God's decision, not the animals' actions. They had no free will in the matter, no understanding of the command, and no opportunity to choose differently. |
MaxInDHouse:But isn't that the point I was making in the first place. If Man truly have free will and God is not omniscient, then how can He be certain that every one who opposes his will, will eventually be defeated and His plan will succeed? 🤷🏽 Either He already knows the future outcome, which implies foreknowledge, or He doesn't, in which case the future remains open and His victory is not guaranteed. Also, if he truly isn't omniscient then how does he prophecy about the future and how is it so certain each and every one of his prophecies will surely come to pass 🤷🏽😏 |
MaxInDHouse:But that still doesn't explain why innocent beings suffer. You don't see it that way ? 😏 If suffering and death entered the world because humans misused their free will, why do animals suffer from disease, predation, starvation, parasites, natural disasters, and extinction? Animals didn't choose to disobey God, don't understand moral laws, and aren't moral agents.🫠 Why should creatures incapable of sin bear the consequences of a problem they didn't create? |
MaxInDHouse:If God isn't omniscient, then that creates an even bigger problem for your argument. How can He be certain that His plan will succeed, that evil will ultimately be defeated, or that His future promises will come true? You can't appeal to prophecy and God's ultimate victory while also claiming He doesn't know the future. At that point, God's success becomes a hope rather than a certainty. |
oranget:The broader context of 1 Corinthians 11 strongly suggests Paul is discussing conduct in the gathered church. He begins the section by talking about worship practices and later, in the same discussion, repeatedly refers to the assembly "coming together" (1 Corinthians 11:17-18, 20, 33). If Paul considered women praying and prophesying in the assembly unacceptable, it would be strange for him to spend several verses explaining how they should do it properly rather than simply forbidding it. Also, your argument proves too much. Yes, people can pray and prophesy outside church. But Paul wasn't writing a general manual on every place prayer can occur; he was addressing issues in the Corinthian congregation. The question is not whether prayer and prophecy can happen elsewhere, but why Paul gives instructions for women who pray and prophesy if he intended them never to do so in the gathered assembly. That is precisely why many scholars see 1 Corinthians 11 and 1 Corinthians 14 as addressing different issues, rather than Paul first permitting women to prophesy and then later issuing a blanket prohibition. |
sonmvayina:Your take is quite an interesting one but if the story isn't meant to be taken literally, then what is the basis for doctrines like sin, the Fall, and the need for salvation? And while understanding what it means to be human is important, that doesn't answer whether God exists, what morality is based on, or why suffering exists. Those questions remain either way. |
MaxInDHouse:That doesn't really answer the question. If God is omniscient, He already knew from the beginning that no human government would bring lasting peace. So what is being proven, and to whom? Allowing thousands of years of war, disease, famine, oppression, and death to demonstrate a conclusion He already knew seems less like a lesson and more like unnecessary suffering. An all-powerful God could establish His right to set standards without billions of people paying the price for a point that He knew would be proven from the start. And if the majority remain unconvinced after thousands of years, doesn't that raise questions about the effectiveness of the demonstration itself? |
gohf:You're basically saying, "Stop questioning the design and just accept it." But that doesn't answer the criticism. If God knowingly created a system where billions would suffer, sin, and perish, despite having the power to create a world without those outcomes, then the fact that He can eventually fix it doesn't absolve Him of responsibility for creating it that way in the first place. Imagine an engineer deliberately builds a bridge knowing it will collapse and kill thousands, while having the ability to build a perfectly safe one. Promising to build a better bridge later wouldn't remove responsibility for the first disaster. You say God shouldn't be judged for what He has done but for what we do with what He has given us. But what He gave us includes our nature, our environment, the possibility of evil, suffering, disease, natural disasters, and the conditions under which every human decision is made. Those weren't our choices. And saying "get with the program or get left out" doesn't solve the moral question either. The question isn't whether God is powerful enough to enforce His plan. The question is whether the plan itself is morally justifiable when an omniscient being could have achieved the same end without the immense suffering along the way. A future utopia doesn't explain why centuries of pain, death, and misery were necessary when an all-powerful God had other options available from the beginning. |
gohf:What are you talking about in genesis chapter 1 Throughout the chapter God repeatedly “saw that it was good” (Genesis 1:4, 10, 12, 18, 21, 25) |
MaxInDHouse:If the issue is simply who has the right to set standards, then why does forgiveness require generations of suffering, death, and punishment? A parent can establish rules, uphold authority, and still forgive a child without condemning their descendants. The question isn't whether God has the right to set standards; it's why an all-powerful God couldn't uphold those standards while also extending immediate mercy. |
The Cosmic Plot Hole: Why the Story of Faith Feels So Complicated If you dig into the traditional story of creation and salvation, you eventually run into a wall of frustration. The narrative seems simple: humans break a rule in a garden, and launches a rescue mission. [/color] But the moment you ask logical questions, the story requires a massiv. e tower of theological "lore" to explain away its plot holes. Why did an all-powerful, all-loving God make it this complicated? The Broken Window and the 4,000-Year Wait If human history was fractured over a single act of disobedience, why didn’t God just say, "I forgive you" and move on?[color=#990000] Theology argues that true forgiveness isn't free, someone has to absorb the cost of the damage. To maintain perfect justice, God couldn't just wave a wand; He had to pay the debt Himself on the cross. But then comes the timing problem: Why wait 4,000 years to do it? Leaving generations of people in a spiritual holding cell (Hades) while waiting for the "perfect historical window" of Roman roads and Greek language feels agonizingly slow. To a skeptic, it looks like a human-made rationalization to fix a timeline glitch. The Heaven Paradox: Curing Free Will To justify human suffering, religion relies heavily on free will; the idea that genuine love requires a real choice to choose evil. But if Heaven is a place with no sin, does that mean free will is stripped away at the pearly gates? To fix this leak, philosophers argue that earthly freedom is broken, while heavenly freedom is perfected. In Heaven, you aren't a robot; you simply have such flawless clarity and fulfillment in the presence of God that choosing evil becomes completely unappealing. Earthly Freedom: The power to choose between good and evil. Heavenly Freedom: The achievement of desiring only the good. The Ultimate Battle: Divine Foreknowledge Even if you accept the free will defense, you face the absolute boss battle of philosophy: If God knows everything, He saw the entire movie before hitting play. He knew the snake would talk, the fruit would be eaten, and millennia of atrocities would follow.[color=#990000][/color] Why go through with it? Theology claims a universe with free creatures who can love is fundamentally better than a universe of programmed robots, or that the Fall allowed God to display His ultimate attribute of mercy. But it still leaves a devastating question: Is the prize truly worth the price tag of human history? Where the System Shatters: Animal Suffering The free will shield works for human tragedy, until you look at a creature with no moral choice. Animals didn't eat any forbidden fruit. They cannot sin, and they don't participate in a cosmic drama of salvation. Yet, for hundreds of millions of years, innocent animals have endured disease, starvation, and the brutal reality of predation. If a human engineer designed a machine that required the agonizing friction of innocent parts just to function, we would call it a horror show. While theology scrambles to blame a corrupted natural order or the "package deal" of physics, But for the skeptic, animal suffering is often the definitive proof that the universe isn't a broken masterpiece undergoing a patient, divine restoration. Instead, it looks exactly like what evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins described: a universe of "pitiless indifference." The Verdict When you connect the dots, you are left at a crossroads. On one side is an intricate, mind-bending theological framework that views history as a patient, loving rescue mission. On the other side is pure, cold logic, the view that religion is an elaborate, evolving coping mechanism built to rationalize the chaotic suffering of a universe ruled by blind physics. I'll love to get your views and contributions to this dilemma. Shalom |
Did you know the phrase "faith in Jesus Christ" is actually a mistranslation? Hello everybody, If you know anything about Christianity, you know that you have to have faith in Jesus. It's kind of the most obvious thing, right? Yet the phrase "faith in Jesus Christ," as it appears in Paul, is likely a mistranslation. So let me break that down. Now, in letters like Galatians or Romans and especially Galatians; Paul talks about the predicates for how you can understand God's action in human history and his intentions. He goes through some of the figures in Judaism, some of the biblical figures that are crucial to this idea of an unfolding plan that God has for his people. So, one of those figures, obviously, is Abraham, who establishes the covenant. He circumcises and establishes that covenant with God. And Paul says that it's because of Abraham's faithfulness in this plan that the covenant is possible. Then he moves on to Moses. He explains that for a little bit, and then he says that it's because of Moses's faithfulness that his people come out of exile, establish the commandments, and so forth, that the covenant is continued. Then he moves on to Jesus. So when you get to that phrase and I won't go into all the technical details, but in Greek, it's called the difference between a subjective and an objective genitive. The genitive is a case of possession, and you're either the subject or the object of that possession. Now, he's already talked about Abraham's faithfulness and used the genitive. He talks about Moses's faithfulness to the covenant using the genitive, and then he talks about Jesus using the exact same construction in context. And so that should be translated as "Jesus's faithfulness in God's plan" , that is, to be crucified and to have faithfulness in the idea that he would then be resurrected and establish a new covenant, or renew the covenant, or establish that covenant between God and the Gentiles. He talks about participation in Christ and about the Spirit, I'll do another post on that. But he talks about how Jesus's faithfulness carries this forward. So he's explaining the place everyone is in now, relative to that idea of God's intention for human history, for his people, and now for the Gentiles. So, over the last 30 years or so, scholars have debated this. As I say, most people will say "the phrase faith in Jesus" and think almost nothing of it, in the sense that it just seems so natural. When you read most English translations, that's what it'll say: "faith of Abraham": Abraham's faithfulness; Moses's faithfulness, but then it'll get to Jesus in the same letter and start talking about "faith in Jesus." I am of the opinion that it should be the other way around, and in fact it probably makes more sense. It doesn't mean that you wouldn't have faith in what Jesus has done, or that you couldn't have faith in Jesus in general but I do think that's a later understanding. I think what Paul's talking about is a trajectory of different figures who demonstrated their faithfulness, and that has allowed the moment to come that they are in at that present time when he's writing the letters. So, if you go back to something like Galatians 3:26 or Romans 3:26, you're going to see that it'll say, in the genitive, "it is the faith of Christ Jesus", or "it is the faith of Jesus" that has allowed all of this to happen. But again, your English translations will swap the Greek and turn it into "faith in Jesus Christ." I think it should be the other way around. Shalom |
this is nothing short of a pump and dump right there |
femi4:so god is a security camera right?? Got it ![]() |