Rich4god:


Who headed the church council then or who are the members that made up its body.

Cos the last time I checked my history books, Pope Pius I was the bishop of Rome when the movement started, he was the one that opposed marcion and later excommunicated him.

keep shooting yourself in the leg with this your article cos I bet you, by the time you will be through with this your thread, you will be surprised the credit you must have given the one single church you so much dislike.

OLAADEGBU:


The Roman Catholic history book is only useful for its faithfuls. Peter was not a Pope according to the Scriptures and that makes all the popes succeeding him untenable.

Rich4god:


Playing the usual tactics in other to dogde away from the question. Who is talking about Peter here. I still ask again... Who excommunicated marcion? Or who made up the church council that excommunicated him.

OLAADEGBU:


Is your Pius 1 not the 9th Pope in succession to Pope Peter according to your so called Roman Catholic history books? That is history according to the Vatican.

Read the real Church history outline if you want answers to your questions.

OLAADEGBU:


The Roman Catholic history book is only useful for its faithfuls. Peter was not a Pope according to the Scriptures and that makes all the popes succeeding him untenable.

btoks:

Haba, Answer the question na!

Rich4god:


KEEP RUNNING AWAY FROM THE QUESTION THAT I ASKED YOU...

OLAADEGBU:


It's either you create another thread or I will. Let us not derail this beautiful thread that outlines the history of the Church. When I say Church I do not mean the Roman Catholic church.

Rich4god:


Finally.... I thought you have abandoned the thread cos of my question...



You mission of creating this thread is to enlighten us, which then gives us the right to ask question for verification and more understanding... Else, it would have been better of in your diary locked somewhere in your room or you move the thread to the diary section....
You cant be a teacher and refuse to aswer the questions of your student...


I repeat, who excommunicated marcion...

Dont give me the impression that you are running away from this question...

OLAADEGBU:


Get your answer from the suggested link below:

http://www.gotquestions.org/origin-Catholic-church.html

PastorAIO:


When in doubt?.... Gotquestions

OLAADEGBU:


Get your answer from the suggested link below:

http://www.gotquestions.org/origin-Catholic-church.html

PastorAIO:


When in doubt?.... Gotquestions

Rich4god:


It still didnt answer my question... The link you gave me talks about the catholic church been founded by constantine at abt 325AD... Thats not the question I asked you....

My question again is....

Who excommunicated Marcion or who is/are the head/members of the church council that excommunicated Marcion....

This is like the 4th time am asking this question... Why is it taken you so long to answer.

Rich4god:


Simple question he has refused to answer.....

OLAADEGBU:


Since Roman Catholicism didn't start until after Constantine in 325 AD then know that it wasn't the Vatican that excommunicated Marcion in 140 AD. I believe I have answered your question.

OLAADEGBU:


If my answer is not good enough and you will not open another thread to address this question then you will have to wait until I conclude my posting of the Church history outline before I can engage you.

OLAADEGBU:


Since Roman Catholicism didn't start until after Constantine in 325 AD then know that it wasn't the Vatican that excommunicated Marcion in 140 AD. I believe I have answered your question.

PastorAIO:


When, according to you, Roman Catholicism started in 325 AD who were the founding members and leaders?

And what religion were they in before the formed the Roman Catholic Church?

Did these leaders include the heads of the Church in Ephesus, in Corinth, in Alexandria, in Galatia?

OLAADEGBU:


Since Roman Catholicism didn't start until after Constantine in 325 AD then know that it wasn't the Vatican that excommunicated Marcion in 140 AD. I believe I have answered your question.

Ubenedictus:
so u told us who didnt excomunicate marcion, now who did?

PastorAIO:


When, according to you, Roman Catholicism started in 325 AD who were the founding members and leaders?

And what religion were they in before the formed the Roman Catholic Church?

Did these leaders include the heads of the Church in Ephesus, in Corinth, in Alexandria, in Galatia?

Ubenedictus:


so u told us who didnt excomunicate marcion, now who did?

Rich4god:


Ever wondered why somebody will abandon his thread for almost 3days and yet, he is still active on NL.... Well, your guess is as good as mine.

OLAADEGBU:


Watch the documentary and educate yourself.

Ubenedictus:
put simply u dont know who excommunicated marcion!

OLAADEGBU:


Since you guys refuse to open a thread to address your objections I'll do that when the timing is right. In the meantime enjoy the documentary.

Rich4god:
Just wasted my MB.... The documentary didn't answer my question...
Who excommunicated marcion...

Ubenedictus:


put simply u dont know who excommunicated marcion!

OLAADEGBU:


Christians excommunicated Marcion not Roman Catholics.

PastorAIO:


This is a good start. I'm sure it's not too hard to draw a line from the christians that did so to the present day. And then we'll know who these christians are.

OLAADEGBU:

Christians excommunicated Marcion not Roman Catholics.