Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,156,211 members, 7,829,344 topics. Date: Thursday, 16 May 2024 at 03:33 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / Peaceful Islamic Nation??? (6159 Views)
The True, Peaceful Face Of Islam. / 'Its A Peaceful Religion' - Moji Olaiya Converts To Islam / Why Are Yoruba Muslims Peaceful (2) (3) (4)
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by BetaThings: 9:21am On Dec 28, 2012 |
Saluman: Did the "peace" index equate adoption of sharia with being violent? Isn't that your own (personal) definition? So how does an unproved/untested hypothesis become "evidence"? Is Japan really a secular state with their PMs often visiting the War Shrine which is supposed to hold the "divine" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yasukuni_Shrine http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/oct/18/japanese-mps-war-shrine-china-korea You would have enhanced your stand by considering alternative hypotheses. You should be wary of simple explanations for social issues. The person who posited Geography as possible explanation for instability around the world provided credible evidence. Saluman: List of your failsYou are not interested in objective debate. So Muslims who only slaves acquire during wars (unlike others who use kidnapping, debt etc to turn others into slaves) are now being projected as "slavers"? When was the last time a muslim country invaded a Christian country? Reverse the question for so-called secular countries Anyway slave trade is topical But the WWII to which the Koreans and Chinese are still sensitive is archaic! Invasions by America as recently as within the last 10 years are part of archaic history!! Did you witness the Korean war? Can you call archaic? Of course not, because it is still shaping relations today Japan and Germany are not militarised today because of their history. Objective analysts will agree with this Did secularism stop Europe from fighting 2 wars (that engulfed the whole world) within 20 years? Is that not the reason that the EU (rather than secularism) won the nobel prize for peace this year? Saluman:The truth is that you are ignoring the truth You blamed just one reason (religion) for the peacefulness of some nations. Yet it did not work in Europe. But you are sticking to that reason! I proposed 3 reasons (Geography, history, diversity) for crises, you attempted to dismiss it by considering only one - cultural homogeneity Your position is even faulty. Forget Russia's jostling with the US for military supremacy The internal crisis in Russia derives from diversity. It is fighting Muslims in Caucasus because they want independence It invaded Georgia as recently as 2008 on behalf of Russians living in South Ossetia region of Georgia (Indirectly the Georgian crisis of 2008 derived from diversity) The Corsicans (Catalonians) are fighting in France(Spain) today because of history and diversity Let me ask again: if you put all those top 5 "peaceful" countries in the Middle East, will they remain top 5 peaceful countries? How come 3 of them are Islands and 2 are virtually islands? I have made my point. Objective people can make up their mind. It is up to you what you choose to believe |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 1:31pm On Dec 28, 2012 |
@ Vedaxcool and Betathings. The arguments you people are making are very big strawmen. The fact is simple. On the peace index, your islamic countries are less peaceful than the secular ones. You guys are claiming that the peace index is biased because it is made by westerners. That is a very desperate attempt to deny reality a) The peace index is one of the best global measures accepted by the World bank and OECD. b) The peace index was done by experts with extensive research and analysis. c) There is muslim professor on the board of research- Mohammed Abu-Nimer [size=18pt]d) If you dont like studies from western schools, where the hell are your global studies and research from your muslim countries? Where are they? [/size] |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 1:55pm On Dec 28, 2012 |
BetaThings: Where did I say that the adoption of sharia equals violence? Why do you love strawmen? Your islamic countries are less peaceful than the secular ones on the peace index. End of story. BetaThings: Japan is secular. If you want to base secularism on a war shrine, then feel free to waste your time BetaThings: Enhance what? The peace index is not a hypothesis. It is a global study. When you have a study showing that islamic countries are more peaceful than secular ones then I will listen to you. I can not take your hypothesis seriously. Bring hard evidence. BetaThings: Muslims took slaves by conquering lands that had nothing to do with them also. Read about the Arab African slave trade. Or how do you think islam came to Nigeria? Wasnt it slave trade? Do you think Arabs just came and did Dawah. Muslims cant invade christians countries because they were defeated long ago. Simple. Nowadays, many muslim countries are dependent on Western technology. How can you even dare to lift a finger against them? BetaThings: Did I mention America or does America even rank well on the peace index? Why do you like strawmen? We are talking of present day peace and you are going into Asian wars and WW2 to say that a country is not currently peaceful. Mtchew BetaThings: When did I say that secularism stops wars? The point is simple; the secular countries are more peaceful than your islamic ones. Simple. You can keep denying reality BetaThings: I never gave any reason for the peace in nations. I used the peace index to state that secular countries are more peaceful. Your points do not change the fact that they are more peaceful. Islamic countries have the same factors you have mentioned and so I do not understand what yu are trying to say. BetaThings: You have made no points at all. 1) What is a virtual island? 2) The most warmongering and imperialistic nation is an island- The UK. So you point is meaningless] 3) Russia has been in many wars, coups and internal struggle far before Georgia and so you nonsense on homogenuity fails. Why not address the facts about your islamic countries rather than deflect? 3) |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by BetaThings: 12:40am On Dec 29, 2012 |
Saluman: @ Vedaxcool and Betathings. BetaThings: It will be hypocritical to sit in judgment on people when you have different social systems, beliefs and needs. Some states in the US have the death penalty on their books. Should a state that does not execute criminals adjudge states that do as violent So Muslims don't need to become arrogant and start judging based on their own values Christians often jump at opportunities to rewrite history to favour themselves. The first translation of Quran into English was done by Christians. The first translations of Quran into Nigeria languages were done by Christians. Were these done to enable embrace Islam? Muslims don't do that. We are not so judgemental and manipulative. Let people apply policies that suit their conditions. It does not make sense for Iceland to be spending so much money on arms. But who would blame military spending of Vietnam, Philippines etc and all the neighbours of China with which China has gone into dispute over the sea near them. OECD and World banks mean nothing. Where is Washington Consensus on quantitative easing, on liberalisation etc Having on board, a muslim does not change anything. Turkey is a muslim country but they have restriction on wearing of hijab 1 Like |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 2:08am On Dec 29, 2012 |
BetaThings: A capitalist would never judge communism as a viable economic system A muslim would never judge christianity as a viable religious system Where are your muslim studies since you accept no western studies? Are you not sounding like Boko Haram? "No to western education". You disagree with research and hardwork done by professors and experts because most of them are from the west. Please give me a better work from your muslim scholars from your muslim countries. |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by BetaThings: 9:20am On Dec 29, 2012 |
Fact is that a "peace index" report was released No reason was given for the way countries were placed Now you, Saluman, hypothesised that secularism can explain the position of countries In the process, you presented your opinion as a fact. Your opinion failed to distinguish between correlation (even spurious correlation) and causality Violence is a social, not a physical science, issue. Hence a simple explanation like yours will not work; normally a multiplicity of factors will be required Eg poverty can have effect on crime rates. But it cannot fully explain proclivities to crime Even when you assemble several factors, they will not explain every single case. Explaining about 80% will normally do Let me mention some points briefly I never mentioned virtual Islands. I said they are virtually islands. Canada has only one neighbour Britain is an island that has been very "violent". But history (influenced by geography) explain "Great" Britain's actions Its problem with IRA (in Northern Ireland) is partly due to religious diversity Japan's shrine is not an ordinary cementry like the one at Arlington. It is a shrine. Please study Shintoism a little If you want evidence about influence of geography, read the book I mentioned. It provides compelling evidence The hypothesis you (Saluman) are pushing (secularism) is not backed by evidence. It is just a weak correlation Like I have said, if secularism were that important Europe would not have fought WWI and WWII And WWIII has been averted so far because of EU not because of secularism I admire your admiration for Turkey, but it is not deep enough But you ignored 2 points - Turkey is a member of NATO and has always wanted to join EU So why would it not embrace those "virtues" so much loved by Europe As regards the quest for peace, I am not interested in factors that play to the taste of foreigners Respect for fa..ots "rights" is considered a virtue Do you think any sensible country should accept that devilish I don't care that my country sits at the bottom of the pile behind everybody, that is something we should not even contemplate So my questions When will secularism win Nobel prize for peace? When will a secular country surrounded by hostile neighbours come tops in that assessment? Why are secular countries scattered all over the list? Does that not indicate that other factors are at play? Now remember a Christian opened this thread. This is of course part of the usual tactic to attack Islam in order to deflect attention from the sordid deeds of Christians. You want me to "face fact" about Islam. Should we not do the same for Christians in order to strike a balance. Since you are interested in "peace" Can you tell me any Christian nation, now or in the past, that has implemented the doctrine of turning the other cheek? Has there even been a Christian nation that did not have an army? If they have always had armies, what are the purposes they were used for? Has any Christian nation failed to respond to an attack in compliance with the doctrine of turning the other cheek? Has Christian nations attacked other nations in the past? If yes, were those attacks justified by the need to protect themselves? Or has any Christian nation attacked another nation for economic advantage? Or for political advantage? 1 Like |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by vedaxcool(m): 9:52am On Dec 29, 2012 |
^ Nice, couldn't have done better. you always live up to your name betathings, but let me add, that certain secular nations in history had the most violent history e.g the soviet union massacre millions all in a bid to be secular, during the French revolution committed violent atrocities why? All in a bid to be absolutely secular and cleanse the state of religious influence. So we see one thing secularity does not guarantee peace. In fact the M.E is always facing one war or another because it is located in a region that is rich in resources, this simple fact have continued to guarantee interference by world powers etc in ensuing unrestricted access to such resource, so we should forgive our simple minded atheist who blames everything including climate change on religion, in fact he calls UK the most violent country on earth yet it is ranked 29 on the peace index, so we should leave his apparent flip flop with the knowledge that while an atheist blames religion for everything wrong in the world and praise man for everything good religion simply says man has to hold himself to account for his misdeeds and shall one day if not in this world be held responsible for his actions of cruelty. |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by BetaThings: 3:22pm On Dec 29, 2012 |
Thanks Incidentally, I forgot natural resources. The reason why Congo DR is not likely to have peace. Sadly. Yet Republic of Congo, since it is not rich in resources, does not get so much attention Incidentally, we see that some of the reports are sponsored or influenced See how the IMF auditor says in his report that the IMF was put under pressure to slant a report against China http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/auditor-finds-imf-was-pressured-by-us-to-fault-china/2012/12/19/64979dae-4a11-11e2-ad54-580638ede391_story.html 1 Like |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 10:05pm On Dec 29, 2012 |
DELUSION!!! I think I will highlight the false parts of Betathings comment; BetaThings: Fact is that a "peace index" report was released Lies. Many factors were considered in the peace index. You are just not willing to admit that your islamic countres are less peaceful -external and internal wars -respect for human rights (a consistent failure in islamic countries) -Political instability -Number of Jailed persons etc BetaThings How foolish. Shintoism and Buddhism are different religions. Furthermore, unlike you I have Japanese girlfriend who is from a shinto background, so please STFU,muslim! Now 64% of Japanese do not believe in God and most are not religious. They only identify with their family's religion on census papers. You wouldnt know this if you have never read extensively about religion in Japan or met a Japanese person who explained this to you. As for Canada, it's neigbour, the USA is violent and the next neighbour, Mexico is even more violent. Get some facts As for the UK, was it religious diversity that founded its imperialism? Just sharrap! Your island theory fails. The most imperialistic country was an island. Gbam BetaThings lolz.... BetaThings Japan is next to china if I remember clearly. Your ignorance is quite astounding. How many muslims compared to atheists win nobel prizes? Why even go there? BetaThings I am not a christian |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by vedaxcool(m): 10:09pm On Dec 29, 2012 |
I bet just like "logic"boy professors that wrote the peace index report, these IMF academics put in a lot of work to slant a report against China, lol global politics ever so interesting indeed BetaThings: Thanks |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 10:13pm On Dec 29, 2012 |
BetaThings: Thanks See the lies that some people have to tell to keep their delusions of peace alive? a) The Peace Index is not done by the IMF b) The peace index is not a report but it is a study based on hard research across many countries. Furthermore, Your Congo with little natural resources still does rank high in the peace index. Try again |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 10:17pm On Dec 29, 2012 |
vedaxcool: ^ The bold highlights how silly you are. The peace index is for year 2012 and not 1945 or the 15th century. As for your strawman argument; when did I claim that secularism guarantees peace? By the way, Stalin was not in this century. |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 2:10am On Dec 30, 2012 |
The muslims were presented with the peace index. A rigorous study that shows that secular countries are more peaceful than islamic ones. What did they do about the evidence? |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by BetaThings: 7:33am On Dec 30, 2012 |
vedaxcool: I bet just like "logic"boy professors that wrote the peace index report, these IMF academics put in a lot of work to slant a report against China, lol global politics ever so interesting indeedWe have been asked to shut up because we are foolish We should take that advice because as you can see a particular point of view must be pursued at the expense of objectivity |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by faluasafe: 10:22am On Dec 30, 2012 |
I will advise that u should d ignore further rantings of dis pagan (christian?)Called saluman.Even if he is sponsored to engage in dis fruitless arguement, I believe u guys ve punctured most,if not all of his belated points. Let it be clear to u-saluman- dat Islam is such a complete, perfect WAY OF LIFE that even the greatest critic, not a warped mind like u acknowledge. I rest my case. |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 12:19pm On Dec 30, 2012 |
faluasafe: I will advise that u should d ignore further rantings of dis [b]pagan (christian?)[/b]Called saluman.Even if he is sponsored to engage in dis fruitless arguement, I believe u guys ve punctured most,if not all of his belated points. I am not a pagan or christian. Islam is a complete and perfect way of life but tell any muslim to show you a muslim country with a higher standard of living to a country like Denmark and they start insulting you. |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 12:20pm On Dec 30, 2012 |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by maclatunji: 12:15am On Dec 31, 2012 |
Saluman: That is easy now. Saudi Arabia is way above Denmark. Do people in Denmark leave their stalls to offer prayer every day? Does Denmark host about a million people simultaneously every year for any activity? You have been told that Islamic metrics for these things are different. Yet, you insist on arguing like an obstinate individual. No need to create threads, just live in your bubble. 1 Like |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by Saluman(m): 2:11am On Dec 31, 2012 |
maclatunji: Wait!! What are you talking about? Do you muslims have a different definition of peace? Are war and politcal instability good things? Sorry, but you are talking bull. maclatunji: 1) On what basis is Saudi Arabia better than Denmark? Denmark is one of the most peaceful countries in the world and higher ranked than Saudi on the peace index (note that the thread is about peace). 2) For your point about prayers, you are engaging in shirk- idolizing Saudi Arabians that they dont steal based on some dubious claims. I have heard that story and I personally know that it is a lie. Many shopkeepers lock their stores before going for prayers and my friend (a muslim) has been robbed in a downtown market. There has been an increase in the number of reported cases of pick-pocketing and other forms of theft in Makkah, particularly in the region of the Grand Mosque, and in Madinah. Pilgrims should take additional care with valuables while visiting these two areas and may consider using a money belt or under-garment pouch as a means to carry valuables.http://travel.state.gov/travel/cis_pa_tw/hajj/hajj_5584.html 3) As for your point about tourism, Denmark gets about 8.7 million arrivals a year. maclatunji: Yeah right. What islamic metrics are there to peace? Mtchew Keep calling me an obstinate individual after you will ban someone for insults |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by maclatunji: 6:54am On Dec 31, 2012 |
Saluman: ^Your comprehension is low. Denmark gets 8.7 million visitors in total in a year, divide that by 12. What do you have? Moreover, these people are spread all over Denmark not congregated in a single place and definitely not from all races at the same time. I never said people don't steal in Saudi Arabia. On that one, you are arguing with yourself. As it has been proven that crime happens everywhere, it is good to ask you to define peace by yourself. If millions of people can leave whatever they are doing to perform the same activity 5 times a day in a particular country without anarchy prevailing I wonder what that means if not a highly secure, peaceful and cohesive state. That you mentioned shirk in the context of my last post simply shows how ignorant you are. Interacting with you is more of a waste of time. 1 Like |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by vedaxcool(m): 12:32pm On Dec 31, 2012 |
maclatunji: that much is true, a waste of time in every sense of the word! |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by maclatunji: 12:33pm On Dec 31, 2012 |
^ Absolument. |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by pembawapete: 7:22am On Apr 08, 2013 |
Just see this http://www.visionofhumanity.org/gpi-data/ The list of the most peaceful countries: AMERICA 1. Canada 2. Chile 3. Uruguay EUROPE 4. Iceland 5. Norway 6. Sweden 7. Finland 8. Spain 9. Portugal 10. Switzerland 11. UK 12. Netherlands 13. Belgium 14. Germany 15. Austria 16. Czech Republic (80% atheist) 17. Slovakia (62.0% of Slovaks identified themselves as Roman Catholics, 5.9% as Protestants, 3.8% as Greek Catholics, 0.9% as Orthodox, 13.4% identified themselves as atheists) 18. Romania ( Christian. 85,9% ) 19. Hungary (Christian 80%+ ) 20. Poland AFRIKA 21. Botswana (99% non-islam) http://www.bedia.co.bw/news/news.php?NewsID=42 ASIA 22. Bhutan (Buddha) 23. Vietnam (82% atheist) 24. Malaysia (60% Islam) 25. Japan ( Non-religious (49%), Buddhism (34%), Shintoism (3%), Christianity (1%) ) AUSTRALIA 26. Australia 27. New Zealand Yes there is a peaceful islamic country such as malaysia, because it is strongly affected by british. |
Re: Peaceful Islamic Nation??? by BetaThings: 5:45am On Apr 11, 2013 |
^^^^ Anybody who believes that Britain is peaceful is trying to twist history No Indian will believe that anyway A lot of Nigerians still blame Britain for some of the political problems in Nigeria If Malaysia is peaceful because of the British, how come countries colonised by Britain in Africa are not on your list What was the stand of Britain on apartheid and the way it was enforced? How come I woman is safer on a night bus in Dubai than on an equivalent bus in London Google the list of the most warlike states and tell us where Britain stand |
Can A Muslim Break A Voluntary Fast If Invited To Eat? / Can I Combine Missed Ramadaan Fasts With 6 Days Of Shawwaal With One Intention? / Can One Be A Muslim And Still Engage In Fortune Telling Or Witchcraft?
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 114 |