ilynem:

Don't get me wrong. Syrio was great or Ned wouldn't pay him to teach arya. But if you were going against members of the kings guard, it is expected you go with your best men. So it is safe to say, those men where Ned's best. Syrio was great (even though he was stupid. You took down five men with a wooden sword, pick up and a real sword and fight!). But being killed by trant disqualifies him albeit with a wooden sword.

Ranchhoddas:
He meant that Robb did not lose any battle until the Red Wedding.

ilynem:

Noted Ser. So going by the show, my top ten would be:
1. Robert at his prime.
2. Authur Dayne.
3. Barristan Selmy.
4. Drogo.
5. Oberyn Martel.
6. Jamie Lannister with both hands
7. The mountain.
8. Brienne
9. Loras Tyrell
10. A tie between the hound, bronn and Dario.

deept:
Too much headache on who is a better fighter. Whoever the director/producer wants to be a better fighter is a better fighter. Sam and snow are the best, they have faced the white Walker and killed one

moski5:

the red wedding wasn't a battle twas a slaughter

datigbogirl:


Sam the best Even Sam will burst out laughing when he hears that.....

maafen:
If the Targaryens are resistant to heat and fires why does the heat of the molten gold kill Viserys Targaryen ( Daenery's brother in season 1)? Thought the trait runs in their blood.

moski5:


sm1 has said smtin about this b4 I'll just reiterate
Syrio didn't know wat was happening so if yu notice
1. he didn't kill d guards
2. he didn't pick a real sword
if not he'd ve fought trant more seriously
The best sword of bravos could ve killed trant Remember An attack on d kings guard is tantamount to an attack on d king/kingdom

datigbogirl:



What about Jorah the Andal? That one no sabi pass to dey chase Dany pvssy up and down....lols

ilynem:

And so did Robb I assume. But that doesn't mean Robb was a great fighter. I maintain my stance that in the books, Ned was average, judging from what I read in books once. And that quote doesn't necessarily mean he fought at the vanguard. It just meant his bannermen where his friends.

Ranchhoddas:
Not everyone has the gene.

maafen:
If the Targaryens are resistant to heat and fires why does the heat of the molten gold kill Viserys Targaryen ( Daenery's brother in season 1)? Thought the trait runs in their blood.

maafen:
If the Targaryens are resistant to heat and fires why does the heat of the molten gold kill Viserys Targaryen ( Daenery's brother in season 1)? Thought the trait runs in their blood.

gj22:


It is most likely him but it's not 100%. If you think it is, I will like to hear why.

Gbola5:


They have a tolerance. It is stated that some Targs loved their baths extremely hot and all. But they're not immune, they will die by fire. Which is why that scene with Dany didnt make any sense.

Ranchhoddas:
Not everyone has the gene.

Tapout:


cos of his reaction when shaggydog's head was brought in

Gbola5:


There are no loopholes. Jon is breaking his vow by leaving the Night's Watch. Who would believe him South of the Wall ? The vow says, " It shall not end until my death.", but he's alive, it's like a patient on CPR. The vow also says, " I shall live and die at my post." Live and Die. It also says, " I pledge my life and honor to the Night's Watch, for this night and all the nights to come." All the nights to come. The episode was Oathbreaker afterall.

Gbola5:


Now this is silly.

gj22:


This fire/heat magic is specific to Dany alone. Must the directors say it in an interview before you realise that? She is a chosen one. She even had a dream on how to hatch the dragon eggs.

Targaryens are not immune, Dany is. She even said it that Viserys is not a true dragon (or something like that)... fire cannot kill a dragon.

Ranchhoddas:
How so? Not every Targaryen is immune to fire hence my use of the term 'gene'.

gj22:


They weren't attack dogs. They are just blood hounds (for tracking), the ran away. What did you expect them to do, pick up a sword and start fighting Brienne of fooking tarth?

Gbola5:


She doesn't need to be immune, so why make her immune.

Gbola5:



Summerhall, Battle of Redgrass Field, The Dance of Dragons, lots of Targs have died by fire. And they were as Targ as Targs get. Its not a 'gene'. Besides they burn the bodies of dead Targs to collect their ashes, which wouldnt be possible if they were immune. The thing with Dany and the birth of dragons was a one time thing, something magical, a miracle, which would not happen again( GRRM ).

Gbola5:



Summerhall, Battle of Redgrass Field, The Dance of Dragons, lots of Targs have died by fire. And they were as Targ as Targs get. Its not a 'gene'. Besides they burn the bodies of dead Targs to collect their ashes, which wouldnt be possible if they were immune. The thing with Dany and the birth of dragons was a one time thing, something magical, a miracle, which would not happen again( GRRM ).

gj22:

Because she NEEDS to be.

ilynem:

Well, only one of them was a kingsguard and if he had killed all lannister soldiers and trant, no one would have known he did it. And he would have been in better position to protect arya. He was indeed stupid.

Gbola5:


Why.. ?!

ilynem:
Noted Ser. So going by the show, my top ten would be: 1. Robert at his prime. 2. Authur Dayne. 3. Barristan Selmy. 4. Drogo. 5. Oberyn Martel. 6. Jamie Lannister with both hands 7. The mountain. 8. Brienne 9. Loras Tyrell 10. A tie between the hound, bronn and Dario.

datigbogirl:


Jon Snow that even killed a white walker and a giant wildling... Jon is better dan Robb in my opinion.

maputohq:

i will rate them thus:
1. arthur dayne
2. drogo
3. robert
4. barristan selmy
5. jamie lannister
6. oberyn martel
7. loras tyrell
8. dario
9. hound
10. bronn
11. the mountain
12. brienne

Gbola5:


They have a tolerance. It is stated that some Targs loved their baths extremely hot and all. But they're not immune, they will die by fire. Which is why that scene with Dany didnt make any sense.