Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,153,783 members, 7,820,742 topics. Date: Tuesday, 07 May 2024 at 08:35 PM

Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? (5555 Views)

Army Report: Senior Military Officers Denied US, UK Visas Over Rights Abuses / Betty Akeredolu: 'I Met My Hubby During NYSC, He's Broke, Couldn't Take Me Out' / BREAKING!!! Again, U.S Sanctions Buhari Over Human Rights Abuses (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (Reply) (Go Down)

Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Seun(m): 12:49pm On Mar 07, 2015
The US and other western countries refused to sell arms to Nigeria because of human right violations they observed going on in our war against Boko Haram. Why couldn't we just stop the human rights abuses in order to get their superior weapons and crush Boko Haram? This is the same US that sold weapons to Osama Bin Ladin before he became a terrorist and several rebel groups in Syria fighting against Assad. If Osama Bin Ladin and Syrian rebels could fight without egregious human rights violations that would cause the U.S. not to sell them weapons, then why couldn't our Army do the same? Did they think it was more necessary to violate human rights than to get superior weapons?
Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by 53cur3m0d3(m): 12:55pm On Mar 07, 2015
There are a lot of false allegations and counter accusations these days that the vast majority don't know what is actually going on. I fear for what the country has become.

3 Likes

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Iaz93: 12:55pm On Mar 07, 2015
hmmm
Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Seun(m): 12:56pm On Mar 07, 2015
The U.S. says, don't execute people on mere suspicion without proper trial. Don't punish the innocent along with the guilty. If you do this we will provide you with assistance and advanced weapons that will make it easy for you to defeat the Bokos. Sounds like a good deal to me.

9 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by steppin: 12:58pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun:
The US and other western countries refused to sell arms to Nigeria because of human right violations they observed going on in our war against Boko Haram. Why couldn't we just stop the human rights abuses in order to get their superior weapons and crush Boko Haram? This is the same US that sold weapons to Osama Bin Ladin before he became a terrorist and several rebel groups in Syria fighting against Assad. If Osama Bin Ladin and Syrian rebels could fight without egregious human rights violations that would cause the U.S. not to sell them weapons, then why couldn't our Army do the same? Did they think it was more necessary to violate human rights than to get superior weapons?
Nothing is easy as it seems. Us soldiers sometimes violate human rights in countries they fight in, but the difference is that, they always try the offenders in the court of law.
Our country is still has a long to go in other to attain to that level.

1 Like

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Iaz93: 1:02pm On Mar 07, 2015
They want us to be their puppets before they sell us weapons. Most of their demands are outrageous, methinks.

9 Likes

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Firefire(m): 1:03pm On Mar 07, 2015
Nigeria is at war, war with terrorist and terrorism.

Accusation of Human Rights Abuse is common during war including American war in Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.

casualty of war can never be ruled out during war.

Nigeria could not be an exemption.

Bottom line: Our own war is self-inflicted, politically motivated and painfully a war within her own territory.

11 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by ConfessionsNgr: 1:03pm On Mar 07, 2015
Not everything is as we hear it on the media. Just saying

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by alberto2k(m): 1:05pm On Mar 07, 2015
Yeah its a good deal but incase of emergency If U.S refuses to sell, other countries will... Legally or illegally! angry

1 Like

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by anonimi: 1:06pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun:
The US and other western countries refused to sell arms to Nigeria because of human right violations they observed going on in our war against Boko Haram. Why couldn't we just stop the human rights abuses in order to get their superior weapons and crush Boko Haram? This is the same US that sold weapons to Osama Bin Ladin before he became a terrorist and several rebel groups in Syria fighting against Assad. If Osama Bin Ladin and Syrian rebels could fight without egregious human rights violations that would cause the U.S. not to sell them weapons, then why couldn't our Army do the same? Did they think it was more necessary to violate human rights than to get superior weapons?

I think you need to read more on US arm sales to countries that seriously violate human rights, such as Saudi Arabia, Egypt under Mubarak etc.

International relations and sale of weapons is more complex than the simplistic excuse of human rights abuse smokescreen given by the US.

Cheers.

13 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by vedd: 1:07pm On Mar 07, 2015
Respect for human right and the rule of law are not in Nigeria military's dictionary when it comes to relating with (bloody) civilians.

The most effective counter-insurgency strategy is to win the heart and minds of the affected communities. But such human rights violations makes it quite easy to believe that they're not too eager to win the war too quickly.

3 Likes

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Firefire(m): 1:08pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun:
The U.S. says, don't execute people on mere suspicion without proper trial. Don't punish the innocent along with the guilty. If you do this we will provide you with assistance and advanced weapons that will make it easy for you to defeat the Bokos. Sounds like a good deal to me.

collateral damage is inevitable in a war in our terrain, U.S demand of withdrawing the weapons engaged in the battle filed for Military training would be a sabotage to the on-going war.


Americans should tell us their game plan.

7 Likes 1 Share

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Nobody: 1:08pm On Mar 07, 2015
following......
Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by osamaBUSH(m): 1:12pm On Mar 07, 2015
they should say it in plain language dem dey fear us"
Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by WisdomFlakes: 1:15pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun, the easy answer is that the Federal government politicized its response to the Boko Haram menace from the very get-go, thereby crippling any prospect of a sincere effort at curtailing or defeating the insurgency.

All what we are currently seeing in terms of our army's gains vs. the insurgents was merely initiated in order to win re-election for the incumbent.

4 Likes 1 Share

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Seun(m): 1:20pm On Mar 07, 2015
Firefire:
collateral damage is inevitable in a war in our terrain
Is it also necessary to regularly execute unarmed suspects without trial? Funny enough, it was this very act that radicalised Boko Haram.

3 Likes 1 Share

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Cutehector(m): 1:29pm On Mar 07, 2015
Human rights violation was more common in buhari's regime

4 Likes 1 Share

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Trailblazer1(m): 1:31pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun:
The US and other western countries refused to sell arms to Nigeria because of human right violations they observed going on in our war against Boko Haram. Why couldn't we just stop the human rights abuses in order to get their superior weapons and crush Boko Haram? This is the same US that sold weapons to Osama Bin Ladin before he became a terrorist and several rebel groups in Syria fighting against Assad. If Osama Bin Ladin and Syrian rebels could fight without egregious human rights violations that would cause the U.S. not to sell them weapons, then why couldn't our Army do the same? Did they think it was more necessary to violate human rights than to get superior weapons?
let's consider the collateral damage of US refusal to self arms with an analysis of it cost/benefit to both Nigeria and the Us.
1. The primary victim of bokoharam is the Nigerian masses.
2. Humanitarian laws seeks to protect only the masses and not terrorists
3. The US refusal to sell arms to Nigeria will only encourage bokoharam continuous onslaught of the poor masses that the same humanitarian law seeks to protect.
4.even if humanitarian abuses are inevitable by the Nigerian Army, the recent military Victories has provided succour to the poor masses without which would have been a continuous onslaught of the masses.
I succinct to say that the US are being hypocritical and economic with the truth.
Refusal to sell arms to Nigeria only increases the death of the poor masses whom they supposedly seek to protect.

11 Likes 5 Shares

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Seun(m): 1:36pm On Mar 07, 2015
Firefire:
U.S demand of withdrawing the weapons engaged in the battle filed for Military training would be a sabotage to the on-going war.
Can you give us the full details about this demand? Thanks.

anonimi:
I think you read more on US arm sales to countries that seriously violate human rights, such as Saudi Arabia, Egypt under Mubarak etc. International relations and sale of weapons is more complex than the simplistic excuse of human rights abuse smokescreen given by the US. Cheers.
This might be true. However, if we had stopped the human rights abuses and they still refused to sell us weapons, that would have proved it.

vedd:
Respect for human right and the rule of law are not in Nigeria military's dictionary when it comes to relating with (bloody) civilians.
The most effective counter-insurgency strategy is to win the heart and minds of the affected communities. But such human rights violations makes it quite easy to believe that they're not too eager to win the war too quickly.
I think we have community support because Boko Haram has done anti-muslim things like bombing mosques, but we could've got it earlier.

Trailblazer1:
undecided
If you have something on your mind, please share it. We are all here to learn the things we don't know.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Gbawe2: 1:41pm On Mar 07, 2015
@OP.

It is not simply about Human rights abuse and I think you know this. There is a copious amount of information out there which reveals why the USA remain worried about helping our government in any shape or form. One of the most important reason the USA will not assist Nigeria is that a lot of information and actual occurrences show them that the Nigerian Government, under Jonathan, is not sincere about tackling Boko Haram.

There is the real and entirely justified fear that supplying the Nigerian army with serious fire-power may simply amount to arming Boko Haram and promoting the course of terror. Let us stop pretending and patronising ourselves with these simplistic and self-deceiving discussions. The entire world know that it is politicians in the current government, as GEJ confessed, sponsoring Boko Haram while Commanders in our Army secretly abet the terror group. The USA has the right to refuse to be a part of such madness where it is difficult to identify friend or foe because of the insincere and duplicitous conduct of our Government and Army.

http://www.nigerianwatch.com/news/6488-us-report-reveals-nigerian-military-tipped-off-boko-haram-about-chibok-girls-rescue-plan


US report reveals Nigerian military tipped off Boko Haram about Chibok girls rescue plan


Sunday, 01 March 2015 05:41

RECENT reports from US intelligence sources have revealed that Nigerian military commanders leaked plans to rescue the abducted Chibok girls to Boko Haram terrorists which ended up botching the operation.



On April 14, over 200 pupils were abducted from Government Girls Secondary School Chibok in Borno State, sparking an international outrage. In response to the global outcry, the US sent spy planes to Nigeria to help locate the girls and a plan was agreed with the military to mount a daring rescue operation.

[size=14pt]However, according to two US Army generals, details of the rescue mission was leaked to Boko Haram before it could be put into operation, enabling the terrorists to take preventative action. Accusing the Nigerian Army of treason, the generals revealed that that the war against Boko Haram was purposefully sabotaged by the Nigerian government, as if it would not, defeating the terrorists would not have taken longer than a month.[/size]

US sources pulled out from helping Nigeria rescue the missing Chibok girls after Washington discovered that Boko Haram had been fed the details of a covert rescue mission that would involve using gas. Source said that as soon as the Americans arrived and flew surveillance flights over Nigeria, they located the girls and proposed gassing the areas in the Sambisa Forest and then sending in a raid mission to rescue the girls while their terrorist captors were paralysed asleep.

However, shortly after Nigeria’s security chiefs were given this plan in high confidence, its details were leaked to Boko Haram who promptly acted to foil the plot. On its next surveillance flight over the area, the US team saw the Boko Haram terrorists all wearing gas masks.

US agents were very disappointed with this and immediately afterwards, Washington announced that it will no longer share information with Nigeria. This was one of the major reasons why the US gave up on a mission of working with the Jonathan government and eventually pulled out of the fight against Boko Haram.


According to military sources, it was this betrayal that led to Washington sanctioning Nigeria and preventing her from purchasing security equipment because the US is not convinced of the sincerity of the Jonathan government. Since the episode, the US has refused to sell Nigeria military hardware amid fears that it may end up in the hands of Boko Haram, although the official reason given was the human rights record of the Nigerian Army.

Since it began its operations in 2009, Boko Haram has always managed to infiltrate the Nigerian security forces where it has as lot of supporters and sympathisers. Terrorist cells are regularly tipped off about military missions and have subsequently been able to lie in ambush for Nigerian soldiers.

Of late, however, Boko Haram has been on the back foot since the establishment of the regional Multi National Joint Task Force. Because the task force is made up of regional neighbours Cameroon, Chad and Niger Republic, Boko Haram has been unable to infiltrate it, ass their troops have not been compromised.

8 Likes

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Nobody: 1:45pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun the problem is bigger than u think
The syrian rebels are guilty of carrying out human ryt abuse

The US hav problems of Human right abuses ,the use EIT. Enhanced interrogation techniques or soldiers engaging in Human actions in combat areas.
But the d/f is that the follow up cases and ensure possible justice
Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Redoil: 1:47pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun:
The U.S. says, don't execute people on mere suspicion without proper trial. Don't punish the innocent along with the guilty. If you do this we will provide you with assistance and advanced weapons that will make it easy for you to defeat the Bokos. Sounds like a good deal to me.
if i their is a lot at stake for helping you i will give a very good and geniue excuse not to do so to the detriment of people arround you.

3 Likes

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Nobody: 1:47pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun:
The US and other western countries refused to sell arms to Nigeria because of human right violations they observed going on in our war against Boko Haram. Why couldn't we just stop the human rights abuses in order to get their superior weapons and crush Boko Haram? This is the same US that sold weapons to Osama Bin Ladin before he became a terrorist and several rebel groups in Syria fighting against Assad. If Osama Bin Ladin and Syrian rebels could fight without egregious human rights violations that would cause the U.S. not to sell them weapons, then why couldn't our Army do the same? Did they think it was more necessary to violate human rights than to get superior weapons?


So Syrian rebels weren't guilty of Human Rights violations??

Human Rights in a war like is a joke. We've gotten weapons from China and Russia. Move on

USA has been violating human rights since the days of W. BUSH till present day

9 Likes 1 Share

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Nobody: 1:48pm On Mar 07, 2015
It starts from our Training techniques use on our security personnels.
Methodology of investigation.
Military training
Seun
Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Redoil: 1:48pm On Mar 07, 2015
IbnSultaan:
Seun the problem is bigger than u think
if so then why blaming gej?

1 Like

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by atlwireles: 1:52pm On Mar 07, 2015
The western Nations need to define what they mean by boko haram human right.

3 Likes

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by pamcode(m): 1:52pm On Mar 07, 2015
problem is all about to much power neing given to the authorites and also sturborness of civillians.
Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Nobody: 1:53pm On Mar 07, 2015
Seun:
The US and other western countries refused to sell arms to Nigeria because of human right violations they observed going on in our war against Boko Haram. Why couldn't we just stop the human rights abuses in order to get their superior weapons and crush Boko Haram? This is the same US that sold weapons to Osama Bin Ladin before he became a terrorist and several rebel groups in Syria fighting against Assad. If Osama Bin Ladin and Syrian rebels could fight without egregious human rights violations that would cause the U.S. not to sell them weapons, then why couldn't our Army do the same? Did they think it was more necessary to violate human rights than to get superior weapons?


Seun, please you people should stop minding those morally bankrupt nations like the USA.

I have a chat with a military man who fought against the boko haram.

He said that a time came when the boko haram men started giving their women their gun loaded magazines. These women hid them in the hajiab and were not searched because in islam, military men are forbidden to search women. So this continued until it was discovered.

So a Kogi commander was brought who ordered the searching of these women and anyone caught was amputated and left to die.

This made the USA and their house-boy britain to start ranting.

9 Likes 3 Shares

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Gbawe2: 1:53pm On Mar 07, 2015
IbnSultaan:
Seun the problem is bigger than u think

Indeed. Imagine how Boko Haram were quickly able to procure and use gas mask shortly after the USA decided to gas and knock them out so that ground offensive can then move in to rescue the girls? Those are the sort of things that should worry all decent Nigerians. We may love deceiving ourselves in Nigeria but the USA, and any serious nation for that manner, will justifiably not work with such a dangerous level of internal sabotage. This is the main reason the USA has washed its hands off helping Nigeria while GEJ is President.

The greatest fear, which is legitimate and justified, is that any weapon supplied to Nigeria may end up in the hands of Boko Haram. What will this then do to Nigeria considering that very powerful weapons could make Boko Haram considerably more dangerous and more deadly than the terror group is already? Any right-thinking Nigerian will appreciate that the USA acted responsibly and correctly given all that has happened.

6 Likes

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Nobody: 1:54pm On Mar 07, 2015
The US has D/F defination 4 Human right abuse which is applied on D/F nations atlwireles
Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Nobody: 1:54pm On Mar 07, 2015
atlwireles:
The western Nations need to define what they mean by boko haram human right.


That is it! They should define the rights of a terrorist.

2 Likes

Re: Why Couldn't We Stop Human Rights Abuses To Get Better Weapons? by Nobody: 1:57pm On Mar 07, 2015
Gbawe2:


Indeed. Imagine how Boko Haram were quickly able to procure and use gas mask shortly after the USA decided to gas and knock them out so that ground offensive can then move in to rescue the girls? Those are the sort of things that should worry all decent Nigerians. We may love deceiving ourselves in Nigeria but the USA will not work with such a dangerous level of internal sabotage. This is the main reason the USA has washed its hands off helping Nigeria while GEJ is President. The greatest fear, which is legitimate and justified, is that any weapon supplied to Nigeria will end up in the hands of Boko Haram. What will this then do to Nigeria considering that very powerful weapons could make Boko Haram considerably more dangerous and more deadly than the terror group is already? Any right-thinking Nigerian will appreciate that the USA acted responsibly and correctly given all that has happened.
. That's intel confidentiality problem
Lots of Guys will give intel 4 few Dollars to d other sides
Bad state of d economy
Seun Nigeria Military has always worked with d us in terms of training
But weapon transfer is a big problem b/c the are nt sure if we will nt transfer d tech 2 a 3rd party

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (Reply)

Are These Accepted In Society Today?(photo) / 546 Bills Pending At NASS As 8th Assembly Winds Down / Bayelsa Election And Arms Proliferation, Hate Speech, Illegal Immigrants

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 62
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.