Due to the nature of the army, in which killing is widespread, will soldiers who kill make heaven?

Highbrow:
Due to the nature of the army, in which killing is widespread, will soldiers who kill make heaven?

will Abraham, David, Joshua, Moses and the military Israelites make heaven?

If u ask me, na who I go ask?

Gggg102:



will Abraham, David, Joshua, Moses and the military Israelites make heaven?

Those people were before Jesus came

CuteMadridista:

Those people were before Jesus came

will they make heaven?

Gggg102:


will they make heaven?

The conditions were different then so they CAN make heaven and if they didn't it wouldn't be because they killed as it was Yahweh that was instructing them to kill on his behalf

CuteMadridista:


The conditions were different then so they CAN make heaven and if they didn't it wouldn't be because they killed as it was Yahweh that was instructing them to kill on his behalf

what do you mean condition is different?


was killing by Moses, Joshua... a sin?

Gggg102:



what do you mean condition is different?


was killing by Moses, Joshua... a sin?

it wasn't as they were killing on direct instructions from Yahweh but Jesus has come down and preached loving your enemies and praying for them, turning the other cheek etc

so yeah, the condition is different now and anyone who kills has committed a sin

CuteMadridista:


it wasn't as they were killing on direct instructions from Yahweh but Jesus has come down and preached loving your enemies and praying for them, turning the other cheek etc

so yeah, the condition is different now and anyone who kills has committed a sin

so Moses and Joshua sinned?

If you are married with kids and some armed youth gathered to assault your wife and kill your kids, and you (successfully) killed them in the process of defending your family, will you make heaven?

The army or any state army is first a defence (defending) force.

Gggg102:


so Moses and Joshua sinned?

did you take time to read the post you quoted?

CuteMadridista:

did you take time to read the post you quoted?

it's a follow up question to your post

just a direct YES/NO answer will do.

Gggg102:


it's a follow up question to your post


just a direct YES/NO answer will do.

I see the question as one that can only come from someone who hasn't taken time to read my previous posts

I said the likes of Joshua's killings were done on Yahweh's orders so its not a sin but if someone picks up swords now and kills the entire Yoruba race it would be a sin as Jesus has changed the covenant

CuteMadridista:


I see the question as one that can only come from someone who hasn't taken time to read my previous posts

I said the likes of Joshua's killings were done on Yahweh's orders so its not a sin but if someone picks up swords now and kills the entire Yoruba race it would be a sin as Jesus has changed the covenant

so what you are saying is that there is no fixed good or evil. Yahweh can change what we consider sin.

killing wasn't a sin when Yahweh Commanded it, but now that he doesn't it is a sin.
tomorrow, He may decide that adultery, theft, homosexuality are no longer sins. then everybody is free to practice them.

anything can become a sin tomorrow and anything can stop being a sin tomorrow.

Those that kill by sword will surely die by sword!!
Judgment is for the Lord!!
The commandment clearly states Thou shall not kill!!
The wicked has no place in heaven!

Highbrow:
Due to the nature of the army, in which killing is widespread, will soldiers who kill make heaven?

All who kill for Jesus will make heaven. The Bible tells us witches and Satan people must die by the sword. We must kill them. But make sure your blade is blessed before you cut them or they bloodshed will curse the ground and you will go to hellfire.

It is well.

Highbrow:
Due to the nature of the army, in which killing is widespread, will soldiers who kill make heaven?

yes they will make heaven, war is part of life, bt u must nt take bribe to kill..

that's why in the bible u will come across a word （thou shall not kill）then another place u will see something like（do nt shed the blood of the innocent）

so as a sodier ur work is to defend ur city and her people.. and u know what that means during wars？u have to kill..

If they kill by their contracts and not in violation, they will make Heaven.

Gowon should repent his involment with Dimka, Gomwalk and Bissalla Coup to make Heaven.
OBJ & IBB have no Skeletons to hide.
Abacha & Ojukwu are in Hell.

Pending on reasons if killing to defend country no, anything else is hell

Gggg102:





so what you are saying is that there is no fixed good or evil. Yahweh can change what we consider sin.

killing wasn't a sin when Yahweh Commanded it, but now that he doesn't it is a sin.
tomorrow, He may decide that adultery, theft, homosexuality are no longer sins. then everybody is free to practice them.

anything can become a sin tomorrow and anything can stop being a sin tomorrow.

actually I'm playing the devil's Impasta's advocate here

I'm an atheist and I'm simply saying what Christians are in habit of saying to questions like this