Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,155,978 members, 7,828,461 topics. Date: Wednesday, 15 May 2024 at 10:02 AM

Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission - Politics (6) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission (30284 Views)

Court Rules That INEC Can Determine How Election Results Are Transmitted / E-Results Transmission: Why Senate Can’t Subject INEC Power To NCC - Tambuwal / Ekiti Election: PDP Nwc Gets Hard Facts, Reconfirms That INEC Doctored Results (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by eroticecstasy: 9:20pm On Mar 10, 2023
Nigerian legal structure is on life support!

Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by smileyoo: 9:32pm On Mar 10, 2023
then why all the billions spend on bvas, when inec already know, they are to opt for manual transmission of results ?
why all these sufferings in our nation, in the name of cashless policy and naira re-design to avoid vote buying, during the election, yet the election was never transparent nor fair ?
the credibility of inec as an organisation, is clearly at stake.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by kunle4toyeyaho: 9:34pm On Mar 10, 2023
mytime24:
Jaga jaga corntree

A defeated obidient I guess?
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by jaxxy(m): 9:38pm On Mar 10, 2023
Jokay07:

Finally, I can finally sleep with smile on my face.
Are you related to Ali Baba the comedian
Lolzz.

are u sure u can sleep with 2 eyes close?

The constitution states INEC will announce the procedure to be deployed for the election inline with BVAS.


Did INEC announce a procedure to the Nigerian people as stipulated by the constitution ore election?
So what procedure did INEC announce b4 the elections?

better sleep and wake up and see ur stolen mandate has gone to the rightful owner.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Jokay07(m): 9:40pm On Mar 10, 2023
jaxxy:


are u sure u can sleep with 2 eyes close?

The constitution states INEC will announce the procedure to be deployed for the election inline with BVAS.


Did INEC announce a procedure to the Nigerian people as stipulated by the constitution ore election?
So what procedure did INEC announce b4 the elections?

better sleep and wake up and see ur stolen mandate has gone to the rightful owner.
Please quote which section of the constitution
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Jokay07(m): 9:41pm On Mar 10, 2023
jaxxy:


are u sure u can sleep with 2 eyes close?

The constitution states INEC will announce the procedure to be deployed for the election inline with BVAS.


Did INEC announce a procedure to the Nigerian people as stipulated by the constitution ore election?.
So what procedure did INEC announce b4 the elections?

better sleep and wake up and see ur stolen mandate has gone to the rightful owner.
Please quote which section of the constitution
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by ebenholer2(m): 10:06pm On Mar 10, 2023
SenatePresdo:
Fake News!

Court didn't rule anything in January, APC will want to play fast one with the Judiciary and end up shooting themselves in the leg.

Nothing is hidden under the sun.
Do not look at this with a bigoted mindset...court actually ruled concerning this in January. Kindly go and research.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Faposky95: 10:32pm On Mar 10, 2023
YorubaRonuuu:
Gbam.... This news won't be nice in the ears of the ipob and the obi followers because they will start crying that the judge has been bribed.

Yoruba Lokan

Tinubu's 8 years is certain!

Then wat....
The tribe will one day go the way of many others.....
You die before it or it does before you...
Check history
The school curricula recognises English more....wise up
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by benheaven(m): 10:44pm On Mar 10, 2023
YorubaRonuuu:
Gbam.... This news won't be nice in the ears of the ipob and the obi followers because they will start crying that the judge has been bribed.

Yoruba Lokan

Tinubu's 8 years is certain!
You are doing yourself harm

1 Like

Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by YorubaRonuuu(m): 10:51pm On Mar 10, 2023
benheaven:

You are doing yourself harm
sorry don't cry!
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by bentenny(m): 11:33pm On Mar 10, 2023
Direct e-transmission of election results is mandatory
Section 60(5) of the Electoral Act 2022 provides that “The presiding officer shall transfer the results including total number of an accredited voters and the results of the ballot in a manner prescribed by the Commission”. The use of “shall” here, it’s respectfully submitted, implies that the presiding officer must transmit the results as prescribed by the INEC Guidelines. The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) on 3 June 2022 released the Regulations and Guidelines for the Conduct of Elections, 2022. The Regulations and Guidelines were issued pursuant to Section 149 of the Electoral Act, 2022 and the Regulations and Guidelines supersede all previous regulations and/or guidelines on the conduct of elections, issued by the INEC.

The new Regulations and Guidelines cover elections and arrangements for their conduct, accreditation and voting procedure at elections, and collation of election results and making returns. They apply to the conduct of elections to offices of: “President and Vice President; Governor and Deputy Governor; National Assembly (Senate and House of Representatives); State Houses of Assembly; Chairmen and Vice-Chairmen of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) Area Councils; and Councillors of FCT Area Councils Legislature.

Paragraph 38 of the Regulations and Guidelines, 2023 makes Electronic Transmission of Results and Upload of Results to IReV mandatory. The paragraph requires that when voting and announcement of results have been completed at a polling unit, the Presiding Officer “(1) must Electronically transmit the result of the polling unit to INEC’s collation system; (2) Must use the BVAs to upload a scanned copy of the EC8A result sheet to the INEC Result Viewing Portal (IReV); and (3) [must thereafter] Take the BVAS and the original copies of all forms in a tamper evident envelope to the RA/Ward Collation officer in the company of security agents. Polling Agents may accompany the PO to the RA/Ward Collation Centre”. [See:Simplified Electoral Act 2022, and INEC Guidelines. FEBRUARY 22, 2023 <https://placng.org/Legist/plac-publication-simplified-electoral-act-2022-and-inec-guidelines/>]. Thus, the Regulations and Guidelines require that the presiding officer must electronically transmit the results DIRECT from the polling units, after which the results would then be taken manually to the collation centres.

This means that the Regulations and Guidelines prescribe TWO levels of collationsad1). Electronic Transmission (collation) which must be done direct from the polling units; and (2). Manual collation which would then follow after electronic Transmission. Note that the manual collation is the lower level of collation. See section 64(5) of the Electoral Act 2022

Now, what’s the legal effect of failure to comply with these provisions on direct electronic transmission from the polling units, one may ask? Before answering this question, let’s look also at Section 64(5) of the Electoral Act, 2022 which requires that “the collation officer or returning officer shall use the accredited voters recorded and transmitted directly from the polling units under section 47(2) of this Act and the votes or results recorded and transmitted directly from polling units under section 60(4) of this Act, to collate and annouce the results if a collated result at his or a lower level of collation is not correct”.

https://guardian.ng/opinion/direct-e-transmission-of-election-results-is-mandatory/
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by bentenny(m): 11:40pm On Mar 10, 2023
Mylove55:
the judge said is inec decision to use any method,
And inec use the both method,
Those area with network can send electronically, and those without network can send manually
Section 60(5) of the Electoral Act 2022 provides that “The presiding officer shall transfer the results including total number of an accredited voters and the results of the ballot in a manner prescribed by the Commission”. The use of “shall” here, it’s respectfully submitted, implies that the presiding officer must transmit the results as prescribed by the INEC Guidelines. The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) on 3 June 2022 released the Regulations and Guidelines for the Conduct of Elections, 2022. The Regulations and Guidelines were issued pursuant to Section 149 of the Electoral Act, 2022 and the Regulations and Guidelines supersede all previous regulations and/or guidelines on the conduct of elections, issued by the INEC.

The new Regulations and Guidelines cover elections and arrangements for their conduct, accreditation and voting procedure at elections, and collation of election results and making returns. They apply to the conduct of elections to offices of: “President and Vice President; Governor and Deputy Governor; National Assembly (Senate and House of Representatives); State Houses of Assembly; Chairmen and Vice-Chairmen of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) Area Councils; and Councillors of FCT Area Councils Legislature.

Paragraph 38 of the Regulations and Guidelines, 2023 makes Electronic Transmission of Results and Upload of Results to IReV mandatory. The paragraph requires that when voting and announcement of results have been completed at a polling unit, the Presiding Officer “(1) must Electronically transmit the result of the polling unit to INEC’s collation system; (2) Must use the BVAs to upload a scanned copy of the EC8A result sheet to the INEC Result Viewing Portal (IReV); and (3) [must thereafter] Take the BVAS and the original copies of all forms in a tamper evident envelope to the RA/Ward Collation officer in the company of security agents. Polling Agents may accompany the PO to the RA/Ward Collation Centre”. [See:Simplified Electoral Act 2022, and INEC Guidelines. FEBRUARY 22, 2023 <https://placng.org/Legist/plac-publication-simplified-electoral-act-2022-and-inec-guidelines/>]. Thus, the Regulations and Guidelines require that the presiding officer must electronically transmit the results DIRECT from the polling units, after which the results would then be taken manually to the collation centres.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by wayodude(m): 11:51pm On Mar 10, 2023
Nigeria as we know it today is unsalvageable. Not sure why people bother.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by bentenny(m): 11:58pm On Mar 10, 2023
IGBOSON1:
Assuming this to be correct, so it then means Nigerians were hoodwinked into believing results would be transmitted electronically immediately after counting, thereby not giving room for cooking of figures that was the hallmark of elections in the past!?

Every day, new appalling stories emerge from Nigeria that justify my calling the place a zoo, jungle and a shithole to boot! A people get the kind of gov’t they deserve and work for! The same conscienceless scum that foisted Buhari on us for 8 good years are now trying to foist an even worse character on Nigeria, out of pure greed, bigotry, lust for power and hate!
The information is correct as the transmission of result either through manual or electronic means rest squarely on the decision of INEC which the commission had made in the guidelines and regulations of INEC and was released last year!
In summary,INEC through their own guidelines and regulations, mandated the transmission of results through electronic means from the polling units which is in tandem with the amended electoral laws!
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Bigfish121(m): 1:21am On Mar 11, 2023
Match don start,them change goal post.
Useless people

Eben24:
Of which the commission chose their preferred method of transmitting the results and announced it publicly but later didn't adhere to it.. Na fraud be that...
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Bigfish121(m): 1:37am On Mar 11, 2023
Some Nigerians are just too dull in this trend.
Inec issued guidelines for the election and did not follow itand people here are praising them.
We really have a long way to go.

1 Like

Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by BluntCrazeMan: 5:52am On Mar 11, 2023
Jokay07:
bluntcrazeman, your attention is needed here



Instead of you to answer my simple question inside the other uncrowded harmless thread,, you're here mentioning my moniker on another thread.

Nevertheless,, I will still respond to you..

Now..
Let me still drag you back to that same Electoral-Act-2022: Section-64; Sub-Section-(4);.(a-&-b)..

The words there are very clear.

We can all agree that the “Directly-Transmitted Results From The Various Polling-units”, as described inside the Electoral Act, could be done using any method on this earth, (be it “Optical-Fibre Transmission”, “Solar-Waves Transmission”, “Radio Transmission”, “Sonar Transmission”, and even “Seismic Transmission” too),, but definitely NOT “Manual Transmission”, because it wouldn't satisfy the expected requirements of the Electoral Act.


Section-64(4) of the Electoral Act simply maintains that, no matter the Method or Mode which INEC employed for the Transmission of the results (“Directly from the Polling-units”),, it MUST be completely done-and-dusted with before the Collations that are supposed to use the results from those polling-units would start.
This is because,, those directly transmitted results are the results which the Collation Officers at the various “WARDS COLLATION CENTERS” must use to satisfy the requirements of the Section-64(4) of the Electoral-Act-2022.




Therefore,, this particular Court-Ruling still didn't deflate my arguments..


Please read the Section-64; Sub-Section-(4):.(a-&-b) of the Electoral-Act-2022 again,, and explain it well to me,, just in case I am not understanding it very well..
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by BluntCrazeMan: 6:29am On Mar 11, 2023
mokafor:

https://www.thecable.ng/rewind-in-january-court-ruled-that-inec-can-use-any-method-for-results-transmission/amp


The Labour Party,, (that is, if they are truly wise), should just appeal this Judgement..

They should be defending their stand with Section-64; Sub-Section-(4)..



(And not Section-60; Sub-section-(2)..)
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Deepthoughts: 6:49am On Mar 11, 2023
tinsel:

Go to school
Your own school of thought or which one?,if you can disprove my comment with facts n not by baseless retorts please.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Babastrong(m): 6:55am On Mar 11, 2023
[quote author=azadus18 post=121635634]We no go gree[ freedom of killing yourself. Lol]

1 Like

Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Karnice600: 7:23am On Mar 11, 2023
mokafor:

https://www.thecable.ng/rewind-in-january-court-ruled-that-inec-can-use-any-method-for-results-transmission/amp

Sensitive positions in a country being run by idiots, from presidency downwards.

Africans seem to have this omen that forbids them to have the capacity of building a working system.

*****

Nigeria appears to be the only country on earth where laws are made for collective regression, with each law maker trying to prove or defend positions detrimental to the country's growth, so long as their pockets and stomachs are secured.

You see INEC boldly defending her incompetence with the electoral act. Then you begin to think if these laws were designed to take us back to stone age.

The Nigerian flag has lost most of its color, in so much that what some of us now see is a high flying rag, shredded by ethnic bias and bigotry.

The only institutions that seem to have the trust of meaningful Nigerians to some good degree now are the banking institutions and Telcos. This is where the average Nigerian draws solace from. Your bank transactions and internet connection at this moment, despite their hiccups, can be far trusted than all the arms of the government put together.
This could be the last hanging thread, keeping Nigeria from off a civil conflict. Who knows..

Look up the definition of a failed state and ask yourself how many steps away from that are we.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Chetas81(m): 8:10am On Mar 11, 2023
BAD CITIZENS REMAIN WITH with badness
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Karnice600: 8:25am On Mar 11, 2023
emerged01:

I think two purposes of BVAS are to accredit voters and upload votes to IREV.
Accreditation was done but uploading/transmission of votes depends on INEC's discretion for security purpose.

So how does this solve the issue of transparency? Does this meet the need of all parties involved in the electoral process, as agreed from the onset, for the purpose of credibility?
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by Mylove55(f): 8:35am On Mar 11, 2023
bentenny:

Section 60(5) of the Electoral Act 2022 provides that “The presiding officer shall transfer the results including total number of an accredited voters and the results of the ballot in a manner prescribed by the Commission”. The use of “shall” here, it’s respectfully submitted, implies that the presiding officer must transmit the results as prescribed by the INEC Guidelines. The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) on 3 June 2022 released the Regulations and Guidelines for the Conduct of Elections, 2022. The Regulations and Guidelines were issued pursuant to Section 149 of the Electoral Act, 2022 and the Regulations and Guidelines supersede all previous regulations and/or guidelines on the conduct of elections, issued by the INEC.

The new Regulations and Guidelines cover elections and arrangements for their conduct, accreditation and voting procedure at elections, and collation of election results and making returns. They apply to the conduct of elections to offices of: “President and Vice President; Governor and Deputy Governor; National Assembly (Senate and House of Representatives); State Houses of Assembly; Chairmen and Vice-Chairmen of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) Area Councils; and Councillors of FCT Area Councils Legislature.

Paragraph 38 of the Regulations and Guidelines, 2023 makes Electronic Transmission of Results and Upload of Results to IReV mandatory. The paragraph requires that when voting and announcement of results have been completed at a polling unit, the Presiding Officer “(1) must Electronically transmit the result of the polling unit to INEC’s collation system; (2) Must use the BVAs to upload a scanned copy of the EC8A result sheet to the INEC Result Viewing Portal (IReV); and (3) [must thereafter] Take the BVAS and the original copies of all forms in a tamper evident envelope to the RA/Ward Collation officer in the company of security agents. Polling Agents may accompany the PO to the RA/Ward Collation Centre”. [See:Simplified Electoral Act 2022, and INEC Guidelines. FEBRUARY 22, 2023 <https://placng.org/Legist/plac-publication-simplified-electoral-act-2022-and-inec-guidelines/>]. Thus, the Regulations and Guidelines require that the presiding officer must electronically transmit the results DIRECT from the polling units, after which the results would then be taken manually to the collation centres.
nonsense,
Did you attend the training to know what inec instructed presiding officers to do?
This is always the problem of idiotic pigs
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by bentenny(m): 8:39am On Mar 11, 2023
emerged01:

I think two purposes of BVAS are to accredit voters and upload votes to IREV.
Accreditation was done but uploading/transmission of votes depends on INEC's discretion for security purpose.
INEC made that discretion through their 'guideline and regulations' where it stated explicitly that the mode of transmission of results was through electronic means from the polling unit!
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by bentenny(m): 8:45am On Mar 11, 2023
Mylove55:
nonsense,
Did you attend the training to know what inec instructed presiding officers to do?
This is always the problem of idiotic pigs
This is not a matter of insults or emotions!
Read the guidelines and regulations which is an extension of the amended electoral acts!
If inec gave a contrary training to their presiding officers,then the commission has defaulted in their own laws of which there are grave consequences for such actions which may include an outright cancellations of the presidential election assuming you are right in your assertions!
Peruse before commenting!
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by emerged01(m): 8:59am On Mar 11, 2023
bentenny:

INEC made that discretion through their 'guideline and regulations' where it stated explicitly that the mode of transmission of results was through electronic means from the polling unit!
"Discretion". Find out what it means.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by emerged01(m): 9:04am On Mar 11, 2023
Karnice600:


So how does this solve the issue of transparency? Does this meet the need of all parties involved in the electoral process, as agreed from the onset, for the purpose of credibility?

Transparency will always be an issue in an election that's why an election can only be fair.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by bentenny(m): 9:05am On Mar 11, 2023
emerged01:

"Discretion". Find out what it means.



Discretion implies choice!
This is why inec came up with a guideline and regulations for the 2023 elections last year where they specified their mode of transmission which is through electronic means directly from the polling unit!
Any last minute alteration from their guideline and regulations will be seen as an act of disobedience against their own laws and there are grave consequences!
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by orisa37: 9:16am On Mar 11, 2023
PROF. MAHMOOD IS WISE AND ASTUTE.
Re: Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission by emerged01(m): 9:34am On Mar 11, 2023
bentenny:

Discretion implies choice!
This is why inec came up with a guideline and regulations for the 2023 elections last year where they specified their mode of transmission which is through electronic means directly from the polling unit!
Any last minute alteration from their guideline and regulations will be seen as an act of disobedience against their own laws and there are grave consequences!

Yes,INEC has its own guidelines and regulations but they have the power to act against them when the situation calls for it. But not carrying the parties along on the need to take such step is where the mistake came in.

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply)

RCCG Not Repairing Lagos-ibadan Expressway – Ogun / Boko Haram Suspect Arrested In Lagos (Photo) / Osinbajo And IGP Idris In Closed-Door Meeting

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 60
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.