Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,151,888 members, 7,814,006 topics. Date: Wednesday, 01 May 2024 at 12:26 AM

Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists - Business - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Business / Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists (13266 Views)

Exchange Rate: Why Prices Of Goods Will Remain High, Despite Naira Appreciation / Naira Appreciation Brings Confusion / Naira Appreciation Fastest In 15 Year History - BDC Association President (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply) (Go Down)

Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Paraman: 9:11pm On Mar 31
Economists have stated that it will take some time for Nigerians to feel the impact of the current strengthening of the naira against the dollar on the prices of commodities in the country.

The Chief Executive Officer of Economic Associates, Ayo Teriba, explained to Sunday PUNCH that the impact of the naira on prices exhibited a time lag.

He noted, “Foods that have been bought at the old exchange rate will still be tied to the old exchange rate.

“Whether a month or a quarter, it depends on the duration it takes to order and sell. The effect we should hope to see is that the prices have stopped going up. We call it acceleration.”

Echoing similar sentiments, President of Nigerian Economic Society, Adeola Adenikinju, highlighted the economic rationale behind the delay in price adjustments.

Adenikinju stated, “What people have in stock now was purchased at high prices. If they sell at lower prices, they are going to record losses.

“So until they replace the current one, that is when they will reduce their prices.

“But currently, to avoid losses, they will still sell at the rate at which they bought it. We will only start seeing the current prices of things as current stock is sold and new stock is acquired.”

According to Adenikinju, the central bank’s actions in the next few weeks will also reflect what the sellers will do.

“They will be watching the markets to see if CBN will be able to sustain the stability of the naira,” he opined.

Nigeria has been battling soaring inflation, which accelerated to 31.70 per cent in February from 29.90 per cent in the previous month, driven primarily by food inflation, which rose to 37.92 per cent.

To tame the pacing inflation, the CBN raised the benchmark interest rate to 22.75 per cent in February from 18.75 per cent and further reviewed it upward to 24.75 per cent on Tuesday.


According to Professor of Economics, Babcock University, Onakoya Adegbei, the fact that prices go up and never come down is not peculiar to Nigeria.

He said, “Reduction in production usually comes with a lag because of rigidity in production.”

He emphasised that market expectations usually drive the delay.

“There is usually a lag and that is due to the expectation theorem. For example, if you expect the price of rice to increase, you will buy more and keep it in the house, So, it will increase your demand. But if you expect that prices will fall, what you already have you cannot dispose of.

“Reduction in production usually comes with a lag because of rigidity in production. If you already produce a certain product at a certain price and the price in the market is falling, you will then wait to see if the reduction will be sustainable. If you see that it is sustainable, then you can make a move to reduce the prices of your product. It is a lag effect,” Adegbei explained.

Favour Uche, a foodstuff seller at EFAB market, told Sunday PUNCH, “The price of rice didn’t reduce even now that the dollar is down.”

Uche emphasised the challenges faced by traders, including the expenses incurred to maintain product quality amid infrastructural constraints.

“The price of rice didn’t decrease. Even now that the dollar is down, it still hasn’t reduced. For example, a carton of Titus fish cost N90,000 two weeks ago but today, the same carton of fish is sold at N95,000 as of March 29, 2024.

“Even with the fact that the dollar has reduced, but being in the system, I think I understand why. It is because they use one-third of their profit to buy diesel to cool these fish and keep them frozen. After all, there is no light. So, I understand their pain and why the prices are like that,” she added.

Another trader, Abdul Yusuf, who sells meat, asserted, “Price did not come down even with the dollar fall.

“Two weeks ago the price of one kilogramme of meat was selling at N4,800 but now, it is N5,000. So, the price did not come down even with the dollar falling.”

https://punchng.com/food-prices-wont-drop-immediately-despite-naira-appreciation-economists/?utm_source=telegram&utm_medium=social

8 Likes 3 Shares

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by libertyfather(m): 9:17pm On Mar 31
till when?

7 Likes 1 Share

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by immortalcrown(m): 9:25pm On Mar 31
Rational people know this. Sentimental and or ignorant people are the ones nagging.

If you are rational and not selfish, you don't have to be a trader to understand that it is unfair to ask traders to reduce prices now.

Only nonprofit organizations quickly adjust sale prices according to cost prices because they are not in the business to make profit. But they also adjust the prices in a way that will prevent the organizations from going bankrupt.

Even NNPC has not reduced fuel price that is directly dependent on Dollar rate. This is because fuel imported or distributed at the old rate will be sold based on the old rate. This is a simple logic.

Retailers that have old stock sell with the rate that will enable them buy more from wholesalers who imported at high rate.

Also, retailers and importers who bought items after the fall of Dollar rate need to sell with the existing high prices because there is no guarantee that the current Dollar rate will either be stable or go lower.

The Dollar rate has to either remain stable or continually fall for many months before it becomes wise for traders to reduce prices. Traders may reduce prices now and Naira will fall to 3k per dollar next two months, making it difficult for the traders to raise capital by then.

Illustrations:
1.
Old and cheaper stock. You bought 10 bags at the cost of ₦3,000 (₦300 per bag). You plan to sell each bag ₦400 to make the gross profit of ₦100 per bag. The cost price later increased to ₦500 per bag and you have sold only 5 bags. 400x5=2,000 (₦2,000). With the new cost price of ₦500 per bag, one bag is now sold for ₦600. But you continued to sell the remaining 5 bags at the rate of ₦400 per bag because they are old stock. After selling the 10 bags, you got ₦4,000.

Someone that does not understand business will say you have ₦1,000 as your profit (4,000-3,000=1,000) because you bought the bags ₦3,000. The ₦1,000 is even a gross profit here, not net profit. But they don't understand that one.

But did you actually make any profit? grin Let's check it. Since the new cost price is ₦500 per bag, you need ₦5,000 (500x10) to restock your shop. But you realised only ₦4,000 from your previous sales. This means you didn't make any profit and the money is not even enough to replace the sold bags. I am not even talking about the rent and utility bills you paid while selling the 10 bags grin Na to go village be that.

2.
When you buy at high rate and the rate falls while you have not sold out the stock: You got 10 bags at the cost of ₦5,000 (₦500 per bag) and plan to sell each bag ₦600. You sold 5 bags and got ₦3,000 (600x5) before the cost price fell from ₦500 to ₦300 per bag. You reduced your sale price from ₦600 to ₦400 to please your customers. You got ₦2,000 (400x5) from selling the remaining 5 bags. This means you made the total of ₦5,000 from selling the 10 bags.

Did you make any profit? No, because you paid ₦5,000 for the bags. Did you incur any loss? Yes because you paid rent, security and other utility bills when selling the 10 bags.

32 Likes 4 Shares

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by helinues: 9:26pm On Mar 31
Gravity no dey work when it comes to price of Goods and services in Nigeria.

What goes up don't come down

grin

49 Likes 2 Shares

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by oloriooko(m): 9:32pm On Mar 31
But food prices rose immediately naira depreciated

103 Likes 8 Shares

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by detopea1: 9:35pm On Mar 31
NNPC has not reduced price of imported petrol bought with dollars.

Business people that know what they are doing will be looking at the body language of NNPC.

We are in a volatilty stage. 3-5 months of stability will determine if there will be any significant price reduction of food.

But we don't import yam, garri, etc. This shows that we are battling with cost push inflation which started when price of petrol went from 165 naira to 650 naira. Diesel price is high too.

27 Likes 1 Share

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by MaziObinnaokija: 9:35pm On Mar 31
sad we are our own enemies, enemies of progress in this country. Even those that have old stock will still shortchanged their customers.

29 Likes 5 Shares

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Richtaiwo: 9:38pm On Mar 31
dreji:
He should've tell us when
Like seriously? He should have told you when the wares will be out of stock before ordering for fresh ones at the new rate? Honestly, I have been reading foolish comments but this particular one takes the crown. Are you aware this government owes you no explanation? Your president, gringory obi is your president and only he owes you any explanation.

5 Likes 1 Share

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by jkpbestseries: 9:39pm On Mar 31
when i become the president i will arrest anyone that read economics in school and set Price Regulatory Agency across the federation, becos all the economist have no solution to Nigeria economy. People are quick to add price but not quick to reduce price.

16 Likes 1 Share

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Ahmed0336(m): 9:45pm On Mar 31
oloriooko:
But food prices rose immediately naira depreciated
Epp me tell em oooo



Dis corn tree is just something else.

16 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Paraman: 9:53pm On Mar 31
libertyfather:
till when?
next month or may
Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by BlocksNG(m): 6:55am On Apr 01
batstards.

8 Likes 1 Share

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Vinnie2000(m): 6:56am On Apr 01
Prices will never come down again. sad

By the expected time, Manufacturers, Wholesalers and Retailers will be too Unwilling to bring down the prices of their items. undecided

Tinibu should be BLAMED for putting Nigerians through Pains
With his Useless policy of Fuel Subsidy Removal.😏😕

That Terrible Action set the Motion for most Traders to become Greedy or too Money Concious. 🙁

12 Likes 1 Share

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Stevenson20: 6:56am On Apr 01
There's no sign that the prices of foodstuffs will go down soon. Some of all these goods were already stored in warehouses before this dollar hike; yet we choose to sell them at an exorbitant amount immediately we hear that dollar has gone up.

Politicians aside, na we the masses dey do ourselves

8 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by GrammarNazi1(m): 6:56am On Apr 01
Prices should drop as soon as possible.
Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by magoo10(m): 6:57am On Apr 01
In other words the present naira gain needs to be sustainable for a reasonable period of time to enable prices of commodities to go back to normal.

6 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Tjra: 6:57am On Apr 01
MaziObinnaokija:
sad we are our own enemies, enemies of progress in this country. Even those that have old stock will still shortchanged their customers.

oloriooko:
But food prices rose immediately naira depreciated

💯

5 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by JoeEeL(m): 6:57am On Apr 01
Where is catrioina laing that was deceiving u guys to go into elections and love nigeria?

She don disappear leave una now abi?

Una eye don clear? E never clear. APC, turn the heat on.

3 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by ivolt: 6:57am On Apr 01
jkpbestseries:
when i become the president i will arrest anyone that read economics in school and set Price Regulatory Agency across the federation, becos all the economist have no solution to Nigeria economy. People are quick to add price but not quick to reduce price.
Then be ready to see people queue to buy few beads produce daily.
Layman "sense" doesn't work with economics.
Many countries have learnt the lesson in a bitter and tragic way.

5 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Flame333: 6:58am On Apr 01
Most of them didn't buy at old dollar rate they only increase base on s speculation and are ready to take advantage of the increase.....Perishable and Semi Perishable goods price will drop but non Perishable will prove stubborn....

9 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by wittywriter: 6:59am On Apr 01
helinues:
Gravity no dey work when it comes to price of Goods and services in Nigeria.

What goes up don't come down

grin

BlocksNG:
batstards.





Wittyness
Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by owiko(m): 6:59am On Apr 01
T
Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by ScamDemicEra: 6:59am On Apr 01
....... mind control, propaganda, otumopo, occult, satanism can help you win election but cannot help in actual governance e.g bring commodity prices down.

10 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by CodeTemplar: 7:02am On Apr 01
See nonsense excuse.

8 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by TANID(m): 7:03am On Apr 01
That Was Absolutly true

1 Like

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Benjamin4388(m): 7:04am On Apr 01
Richtaiwo:

Like seriously? He should have told you when the wares will be out of stock before ordering for fresh ones at the new rate? Honestly, I have been reading foolish comments but this particular one takes the crown. Are you aware this government owes you no explanation? Your president, gringory obi is your president and only he owes you any explanation.

You are typing trash

7 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by benjamin007: 7:06am On Apr 01
Bulk sales available lamme be your plug

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by vibbb: 7:07am On Apr 01
Jokers - Naira depreciation affects food price immediately - but when Naira appreciate, price of commodities will not be affected (reduce) immediately.

6 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by sofeo(m): 7:08am On Apr 01
Alright.
We are waiting.
Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Ffolksy: 7:10am On Apr 01
The loss will only be in the book. Not in reality

When prices went up, why did sellers adjust their prices upwards immediately regardless of old stocks bought at lower prices? This only gave them massive profits on record, but not in actual reality.

Cost of restocking is the actual determinant of the value goods in store. Sellers are making crazy profits this period cos they are overvaluing their goods.

Just a matter of time, sellers who operate on the principle of rate of returns will force prices down. What's the point tying your money down, when you can sell out quickly and still have enough money to restock?

4 Likes

Re: Food Prices Won’t Drop Immediately Despite Naira Appreciation – Economists by Vinnie2000(m): 7:10am On Apr 01
MaziObinnaokija:
sad we are our own enemies, enemies of progress in this country. Even those that have old stock will still shortchanged their customers.

BLAME Tinubu.
He is the Cause.😏😒

Retailers or Traders were NOT Greedy under Jonathan or Yaradua or even Buhari.

As soon tinibu Removed Subsidy which led to Exhorbitant Fuel Price, the Economy Sommersaulted and Crashlanded.😌

If you as a Clothes Trader travel from Warri to Onitsha Markets on High transportation costs,
Can you sell ur Clothes cheap?😕

As a Bookshop owner, If you Travel a Long Distance with high Tfare to get products, can you send the books cheap? sad

5 Likes

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply)

Orange Drugs Set To Produce ‘Soap-Noodles’ At Onitsha plant / Affiliate Marketing In Nigeria / The New Naira Coins And Polymer Notes

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 47
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.