Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 11:00am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: copy it here and point out how it back your claim like I always do Section 140of the PrincipalAct is amended- Deletion of section 134 of the Prindpal Act. (a) in the marginal note, by substituting for the word "Notification" "Nullification"; Amendment of section 140 of the the word Principal Act. (b) by substituting for subsection (2) a new subsection"(2)"- "(2) Where an election tribunal or court nullifies an election on the ground that the person who obtained the highest votes at the election was not qualified to contest the election, or that the election was marred by substantial irregularities or non-compliance with the provisions of this Act, the election tribunal or court shall not declare the person with the second highest votes or any other person as elected, but shall order for a fresh election"; and (c) by deleting subsection(4) Section 144of the PrincipalAct is amended- (a) by substituting for subsection (t), a new subs |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:57am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Johans1991: the useless woman should be removed from supreme court and send back to state high court. the same thing she did to rivers state in 2015. I wont advice that.let her serve out her tenure |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:56am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: Section 187 “(1) In any election to which the foregoing provisions of this part of this Chapter relate, a candidate for the office of Governor of a State shall not be deemed to have been validly nominated for such office unless he nominates another candidate as his associate for his running for the office of Governor, who is to occupy the office of Deputy Governor; and that candidate shall be deemed to have been duly elected to the office of Deputy Governor if the candidate who nominated him is duly elected as Governor in accordance with the said provisions. (2) The provisions of this Part of this Chapter relating to qualification for election, tenure of office, disqualifications, declaration of assets and liabilities and Oath of Governor shall apply in relation to the office of Deputy Governor as if references to Governor were references to Deputy Governor. Guy,where does it state that the 1st runner up benefits? You are funny oh.the punishmenr for this is clearly stated in the electoral act which boils down to what falana was saying |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:55am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: But he disqualified the candidate of the APC ?
Hahahahahahaha.....absolving the CJN and heaping abuses on Odili for same interpretation?
Na wah.....na real wah Let us limit ourselves to bayelsa please |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:54am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: which part of the law? copy it here Section 140 of the electoral act.search for it |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:51am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: the law did not say you should cancel an election that is not in dispute. the election was not in trial, there was no court judgement stopping inec from going ahead with the election. APC did not say the election was faulty The closest law to such a situation provides for fresh polls |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:50am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: And where there is NONE? Only the constitution supercedes the electoral act.you create precedents out of laws |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:49am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: That means the CJN was wrong on Zamfara then.... Ill not dabble into that.let us follow the law rigidly |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:47am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Following SC precedents, you swear in the runner up who participated in all stages of the election. Tanko Muhammed CJN....decided in a similar case in the Zamfara issue. Is a precedent superior to an existing law? |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:46am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: they did not declare a winner. they only removed a candidate that was not qualified and ask inec to declare a winner (the candidate that meet necessary legal requirements? Based on which law? What does section 140 states |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:45am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: In the lower court, was the nullification or re-run of the election a subject matter? Does any law states that a 1st runner up takes over? No such law exists. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:43am On Feb 23, 2020 |
[quote author=Lostz post=86885396]in those cases the election was in dispute; what the court did was 1. cancel an election that is faulty 2. [b]disqualified candidate that were not properly nominated or qualified.
but in the case of bayelsa, only APC candidacy was in dispute; what Court did was disqualified a candidate that is not qualified[/[/b]quote] Just like atiku's lawyers,you are making my case for me.the bolded is the same thing.disqualify and order a fresh elections and exclude apc.no law states that the 1st runner up is sworn in.why are you scared of a rerun |
Politics › Re: Falana Faults Supreme Course Judgment On Bayelsa Polls by Dansuqi(op): 10:39am On Feb 23, 2020 |
ejimatic: . Forgery is a criminal act and its conviction affects a person participation and qualification in an election. The case in question started before election and concluded after it .So it is still in order. The federal high court to the supreme court can hear it before or after election. It is not restricted to the tribunal. Section 133 places restrictions |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:36am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: I have told him severally, The SC has no power to nullify an election or rule for a re-run unless it has originated from a lower court. But all cases must originate from lower court.if they dont have powers to call for a fresh elections,then they do not also have power to declare a winner.its legally safer and better to order a rerun and allow the electorate choose |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:34am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: File another case then.... Pdp didn't.
That's why Adah of the CoA ruled against them for. That the case should have come as a civil or criminal case.
The PDP didn't ask for that. If you are not satisfied, you can also file a criminal case against him. You are missing the point.after disqualifying apc,does the law says you conduct fresh elections or swear in the runner up? |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:33am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: which section of the law? you should quote it here to argue your case.
there is no electoral law or legal precedent that said supreme Court should order for a rerun in an election that was never in dispute because one candidate is not qualified. The kogi,anambra and niger cases i mentioned nko |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:32am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: I know where his pendulum always swing. This Bayelsa case made him a bit transigent though.
I remember him opening a thread why Diri won't be sworn in a day before, but that is his opinion...we must not agree on everything.
Will tag him next time, but kahal hasn't said a word on Bayelsa surprisingly. Seems kahal is from imo and has vested interest there.i think sarrki opened that thread.but nobody has a better record than ejimstic |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:27am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: The case didn't come as a civil case.
The one against Lawrence came as a civil case. We are getting somewhere but you are contradicting yourself.after punishing and disqualifying a candidate for any offend civil or election,what does the law specify next |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:25am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Kahal has never made any statement on the Bayelsa issue.....I have followed him very well..he only comments on Imo. Ejimatic the other day said it the way it was and you were not alright....hahaha. Hope you haven't forgotten? I prefer ejimatic,he's objective and consistent right from ekiti.we agree to disagree |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:23am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Section 187 “(1) In any election to which the foregoing provisions of this part of this Chapter relate, a candidate for the office of Governor of a State shall not be deemed to have been validly nominated for such office unless he nominates another candidate as his associate for his running for the office of Governor, who is to occupy the office of Deputy Governor; and that candidate shall be deemed to have been duly elected to the office of Deputy Governor if the candidate who nominated him is duly elected as Governor in accordance with the said provisions.
(2) The provisions of this Part of this Chapter relating to qualification for election, tenure of office, disqualifications, declaration of assets and liabilities and Oath of Governor shall apply in relation to the office of Deputy Governor as if references to Governor were references to Deputy Governor Thank you.i know this already.now when he's not duly nominated,what does it say that the civil court should do |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:22am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: I thought you are a Justice Sir....it speaks of a joint ticket. After disqualification,what next |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:19am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: I thought Kekere-Ekun read the lead judgement for Imo
Kai I was talking about bayelsa mr.stop tagging christiannorth,better you tag ejimatic or maybe kahal |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:18am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: you can't order a rerun for election that is not in dispute. the court is not there to do what is best but to follow the law and precedent What does the law states in a pre election matter where someone is disqualified? Please quote the statue directly |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:17am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: I don't think you have ever heard me comment about Imo.
It's above my little judicial level just like that of Kogi.
I have told you that, there are certain levels I have crossed, you should know that David.
If the tribunal attacks the election and it goes up and it's proven, the SC will definitely concur to their request.
I am happy, you are seeing the futility of your arguing the Bayelsa case and trying to drag us to Imo. You should already know the kind of person I am by now. I dont understand you honestly. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:16am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Hahahahahahaha.....please where and how did I apologise to Ejembi? Did Ejembi read the lead judgement? And you said....you were for anything against Ihedioha....
Please, I hope you don't lie.. Let me not be judgemental.
You want to let us move the train to trading words and you know I don't do that....David. I can't trade words with you.....stay on topic. You forget too quickly |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:11am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: You know them, don't you...? Post what the state sir |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:11am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Does the SC have the lower to call for a re-run or nullify an election, if it didn't originate from a lower court? The best thing was a rerun.why are you afraid of a rerun? Even in imo,you are still afraid |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:10am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: I need r can understand a partisan fellow at Who only understands issues from a biased perspective. Nah....am not cut out for that...
What does Section 187(1) and (2) state?
Was this case brought as a civil case under 364 of the Penal code? Help interpret what those sections specify |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:08am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Don't doublespeak... I am still laughing until now.....don't forget, you were for Uche Nwosu (neck-in-deep, hope you won't deny that).
I don't gloat over partisan issues....did I call you out when your Uche Nwosu was adjudged to be the candidate of two parties and subsequently disqualified? No
Am I calling you out now?NO..
Because am acquiring knowledge, and I am loving it.
Yours might be for gloating rights, not for me. I am for anything but ihedioha.you failed to agree that ihedioha didnt make the two third but when he was disqualified,you chameleonically(apologies to ejembi psc) claimed ihedioha now meets it with nwosu out. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:05am On Feb 23, 2020 |
hush15: Without sentiments, even if the case was treated as a pre election matter, since they are convinced that the records of the deputy governor elect was questionable, they disqualify the duo and since the election is dusted and concluded, it's still amount to the same thing, loosing. The outcome was inevitable cos at the end of the day, PDP will still have their day They must call for a rerun |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 10:05am On Feb 23, 2020 |
|
Politics › Re: Falana Faults Supreme Course Judgment On Bayelsa Polls by Dansuqi(op): 10:01am On Feb 23, 2020 |
ejimatic: . When did The forgery case start? Answer :Before election. what iare the duties of the Election Tribunal? answer : consideration of grievances arising from the Conduct of the election..Forgery may be concluded ..........However since it is a case of forgery arising from irregularities of name it is a preelection matter. and can be entertained by a federal high court. So forgery is not restricted to the tribunal alone. He is saying that at the conclusion of elections,it must be litigated at the tribunal not a civil court |