Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:59am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: That's for the Justices to decide.
So many have said the SC was wrong on Imo....so many SANs, does that make the SC decision null and void? The law supports the imo judgment but does jot support that of bayelsa,its that simple |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:58am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: The SC has no power to declare a re-run or call for fresh elections, unless it has originated from a lower court...Oga So the bayelsa case suddenly started from the supreme court |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:57am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: This chest-beating is unprecedented. So that's what is in all of this for you....chai You can contest that with your fellow partisan folks.
I have crossed that level, you hear? Its only natural to sometimes gloat na,is it easy.when i was talking about imo,you were laughing at me. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:56am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Contradicting yourself because of Diri... Was falana right or not? |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:55am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: the election is not in dispute. the dispute was whether APC should participate in the first place; see the case of zamfara. Same thing happened in those states i mentioned,even in zamfara the right thing to do is to order a rerun |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:54am On Feb 23, 2020 |
ZAWs: Channel this your high level of arrogance to Falana who has chide the supreme already; since you know more better than him. Nonsense 80% of falana's judicial comments is against the government.he took up cases even against the government severally.no lawyer in Nigeria has criticized buhari like falana.the only time he ever represented buhari was in 2015.for him to now speak in favor of apc,what does that tell you |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:50am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Just like you never believed Lyon will be removed.
And APC hasn't? I laugh at your partisanship-fiasco. It's your right.
But the law knows no party. Sorry about Lyon. You should not be arguing with me by right.i have floored you severally even in abia.its annoying man,stop it.i never argued about whether the court will remove lyon or not,i cleverly avoided that debate.we argued about who will win the election.the result ended any argument between us.if the supreme court manages to reverse itself,i hope you wont still start another argument |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:46am On Feb 23, 2020 |
ChristianNorth: The law setting them up.
There is something you guys is not getting.
The law is not what the president signs but what the court interprets it to be. If the SC decides to change a portion of our electoral act all they need to do is to set a new precedent.
The law becomes binding.
You can never fault the judgement of the SC even if it runs foul to the extant laws and you cant force them to reverse themselves.
For me, Bayelsa judgment is apt and the SCN has the jurisdiction to entertain the case I dont need to tell you that they will surely reverse themselves by march |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:44am On Feb 23, 2020 |
ChristianNorth: Go read up judicial immunity Onnoghen nko? Buhari will be waiting |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:42am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: this was in your post
right fro m 2007 amaechi case when a party candidate is disqualified,the runner up takes over. I have removed it.the supreme court fumbled,erred. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:41am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: the appeal should have dismissed the appeal allowing judgement of high court to stand because subsequent event already made it a preelection matter if we go by falana.
but the legal precedent suggest the case should be allowed No,a fresh elections should have been called with apc not partaking as a worse case scenario.in 2015,the appeal court removed two apc senators in kogi and ordered a fresh polls with apc excluded.in 2016 umeh got a judgment which excluded pdp and a fresh elections was ordered in obedience to section 140 of the electoral act.this year during the rerun polls of january,apc was excluded from a rerun in niger state for not validly nominating a candidate |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:36am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: ameachi was only reinstated as the legal candidate. Ameachi was not a runner up.
Amaechi, as a member of PDP, in his quest to be the Governorship candidate of the party, in the April 2007 elections in Rivers State, contested the Party Primaries against seven other members of the PDP. They competed for a total of 6,575 votes. Amaechi had 6,527 votes to emerge the winner. Omehia was not one of the candidates at the PDP Primaries. The PDP submitted Amaechi's name to INEC as its Governorship candidate. No court of law subsequently made an order disqualifying Amaechi from contesting the Governorship elections. PDP however substituted Omehia's name for Amaechi's without giving cogent and verifiable reason for the substitution as required by the Electoral Act, 2006. Amaechi therefore brought his suit claiming as earlier stated above. Stop stressing yourself.i cited anambra not amaechi. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:31am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: So stay of execution is now a judgement?
Na waoh What is it then |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:30am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: I have edited....am not dead-partisan like you.
Whether I hate Sylva or not....I don't sit on the SC bench.
It's a dead case. Having known you for quite some time..what matters to you is APC...how they do it, you don't care.
Unfortunately, it didn't work this time. I've watched pdp do unimaginable things for many years.let another do theirs and learn.you didnt believe ihedioha will be removed na..... |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:28am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: What was the only judgement before the elections? It was arrested |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:27am On Feb 23, 2020 |
donpapa: Why would she? Don’t they have the mind of their own? Common! To be a JSC no be beans o So one person cannot sway 4 others abi.. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:26am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: False........you have read the High Court judgement, and still yet I posted the Supreme Court judgement with a caveat and you still say this?
Cc: lostz ChristianNorth... Help me here on the Yola case, I posted earlier. We will go with the interpretation of wole until the court decides |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:25am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: Section 133 of the Electoral Act stipulates that upon the conclusion of an election and once candidates are declared, any challenge of the conduct of the election, of the qualification of the candidates shall be heard and determined by an Election Petition Tribunal.
by virtue of this section, only the federal high court disqualifying APC should stand because that was the only judgement before election Then falana is right at the bolded.apc appealed before the election to the appeal court.that appeal judgment stands |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:22am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: which precedent and tradition? can you at least mention one case to back up your claim?
the court agreed it is a clear case of forgery; any other option is useless.
falana is not arguing whether it is forgery or not. he is only saying the supreme Court should not take the case because it is a preelection matter; and he is wrong Falana clearly said forgery wasn't proved.right fro m 2007 amaechi case when a party candidate is disqualified,the runner up takes over.it happened in anambra central and north,joy emordi was involved and okonkwo,cant remember others.ill recall others as time goes on. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:17am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: That is what the SC corrected. It corrected nothing.it clearly reinstated the high court ruling.no addition or subtraction |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:16am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: is it her job to spoon-feed the other members?
each judge is responsible for his/her judgement. they are all being paid to interpret the law Why beg the question na? |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:16am On Feb 23, 2020 |
ChristianNorth: The SC has the power to set aside precedents. It is their duty to clean up the system.
They are not bound by precedents.
Be guided.
With this masterstroke, parties will learn how to conduct primaries Set aside precedents based on which law? Do you realize that their judgment can also amount to a nullity |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:15am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Hahahahahahaha.....it's late then.
He can tell God.
But there was only one judgement before the elections. Which was that? Before you annoy me further,what does 133 clearly states |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:12am On Feb 23, 2020 |
donpapa: She doesn’t appoint herself to preside the panel, the CJN did; And this was based on ranking and seniority! The woman was just one out of 5 judges. Can she convince the other panel members or not |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:10am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: pre election cases already are allowed to run their course in the court.
it is only when the case was instituted after election that it is overtaken by tribunal What does 133 says |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:05am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: Thank God....you are on Nairaland, not on the SC bench.
Ekwo said substitute when the substitution window was closed. So you want to waste the learned Justices time by going back to them after disqualifying Degi.
Look at the case well...give to the second. SC says NO.....it's the party's Mandate.
The judicial review papers filed by Wole will be thrown into the abyss.
Degi's lawyers remember did not contest the processes of effecting a change on certificates, as presented by Yustaz Usman.
This case is dead. Please start praying for Alaibe. That's the best bet. Hatred for sylva is leading you to contradict yourself |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 9:00am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: [b]Justice Ekwo, in his judgment, declared that Modibbo was not qualified to contest the APC primaries as well as the 2019 House of Representatives election for the federal constituency.
The court held that Usman was the lawful winner of the Oct. 7, 2018 APC primaries and candidate of the party for the constituency.
The judge further held that Usman had successfully proven beyond reasonable doubt that Modibbo falsified his age severally in order to contest election.
The court also noted that the plaintiff proved that Modibbo submitted the forged certificates for the purpose of contesting the party primaries.
The court also held that Modibbo was a serving National Youth Corps member when he contested the primary election, saying the action breached Section 4 of the NYSC Act 2004.
“A person who is a lawbreaker cannot be a lawmaker, this illegality is one that cannot be wished away,” the judge said.
The judge declared that in view of the disqualification of Modibbo, Usman, who polled the second highest votes in the Oct. 7, 2018 primary election of the APC for Yola South/Yola North/Girei Federal Constituency of Adamawa, was the lawful winner.
Justice Ekwo gave an order directing the APC and INEC to immediately replace Modibbo’s name with that of Usman as the lawful candidate of APC for the federal constituency.[/b]
https://www.google.com/amp/s/dailypost.ng/2019/05/03/court-nullifies-adamawa-apc-rep-elects-election-gives-reasons/amp/
This is the high court judgement. It was a pre-election matter. The FHC replaced Modibbo with another APC candidate.
The Modibbo went to the CoA and took a stay of execution, and later won. But the substitution window was over.
The SC now ruled and said...NO....the party should suffer for their profligacy.
They upheld the FHC judgement ,then added a but and gave it to the 2nd party.....just like in Bayelsa.
Cc: mushystuff lostz dansuqi ChristianNorth This showcases wole's brilliance.same ekwo ruled against apc.in adamawa,his judgment was clear and without ambiguity,he gave declaratory and consequential orders to the fullest.compare it to the bayelsa judgment which he stopped short.he knew what he was doing and wole has latched unto it. Secondly,there was a clear proof of forgery here beyond doubt.you cant compare it to that of the apex court. Now the supreme court in disqualifying an entire party and declaring the next party in line is doing so illegal.what law supports it? The precedent and tradition has always been to give it still to that same party since the electorate supports them.it is a perverted decision. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 8:46am On Feb 23, 2020 |
bkool7: Our politicians should stop this trend of losing and election and running to court to win the election. Power belong to the people. And when the people have given their mandate, on who's mandate do you want to rule even if you get a verdict too. It's a recipe for disaster This practice is inimical to democracy. And the Supreme Court and Political Parties are to blame What if the winner subverts the will of the people and the actual winner loses like in edo in 2007 |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 8:43am On Feb 23, 2020 |
fergie001: So the several APC members, the SC removed last year after the elections on certificate forgery......what should happen?
He didn't speak up then?
2 or 3 HoRs-Elect were removed by the SC last year in Yola, so the SC had no jurisdiction because?
Oga, na waoh! He just realized now.afterall i started knowing much about the electoral act from 2014 |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 8:16am On Feb 23, 2020 |
Lostz: you should remember APC only got an injunction from the 'appeal court" to participate in the election few days to election. appeal court delivered their judgement after election .
the judgement did not remove the governor but you cannot go into an election without a deputy. since inec window for substitution of candidates is over; it means Lyon went into the election without a deputy which is also against the Constitution on joint tickets.
falana is no longer thinking properly.
1. the only judgement before election was that of the high court disqualifying APC. 2. APC only got an injunction to participate in the election. 3. appeal court delivered it judgement after election.
4. legal precedent said pre election cases are allowed to run their course in Nigeria court even after election. Is precedent now above the electoral act |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 8:15am On Feb 23, 2020 |
donpapa: Forgery in its entirety is a criminal offense. PDP only used that as a bait to sought the disqualification of the APC candidates. What pressure? Was there no pressure on Imo judgement too? We can’t be too sentimental about this my brother, the law of the land prevails! Forgery can still be a ground at the tribunal.they may also rescind that of imo but bayelsa has a better chance. |
Politics › Re: Bayelsa Election: Falana Says Supreme Court Is Wrong, Lacks Jurisdiction by Dansuqi: 8:11am On Feb 23, 2020 |
mushystuff: The Court of Appeal is not the final arbiter on pre-election issues, the supreme court is. The right of appeal had not been exhausted and PDP rightly made use of the available right. Was Zamfara not a pre-election issue? Did Court of Appeal not give judgement enabling APC in Zamfara to contest? Did the Supreme court not overturn that decision hence the PDP leadership in Zamfara today? Did Falana raise this issue?
The fact that an election had been conducted did not negate an ongoing suit which the parties had a right to appeal up to the Supreme court! There are several portions of our laws still untouched.its clear that he went offer the electoeal act and discovered this new section |