₦airaland Forum

TheCabal:
I cited a scholarly paper and you cited a blog. Are you in secondary school? I don't think we should talk anymore.

Clearly this conversation is above your paygrade.

TheCabal:
^{According to rabbinic law, from the second century to the present, the offspring of a gentile mother and a Jewish father is a gentile, while the offspring of a Jewish mother and a gentile father is a Jew .
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0364009400001185
The Origins of the Matrilineal Principle in Rabbinic Law}

Only a man born of a Jewish woman is a jew. Jews are matrilineal not patrilineal.

You should'nt have started this thread. The die is cast.

TheCabal:
^{According to rabbinic law, from the second century to the present, the offspring of a gentile mother and a Jewish father is a gentile, while the offspring of a Jewish mother and a gentile father is a Jew .
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0364009400001185
The Origins of the Matrilineal Principle in Rabbinic Law}

Only a man born of a Jewish woman is a jew. Jews are matrilineal not patrilineal.

You should'nt have started this thread. The die is cast.

totit:
Funny how you choose find solace in the video but chose to deny the result of the test Are those E1A not collected among some ibo group/people before it was examined

Funny dude

totit:
Hahahahaha.
See how you contradict ya self

Who's every, and what does " some" means?


Looolx

RussianICBM:
Why is this even a debated topic in the first place?

It shows that this Joke has been taken too far for us to be debating the plausibility of someone in central Imo state being jew, smh.

All Igbos who have taken a DNA test have so far ALL Come back 100% African.

Fulanis for example have a partly Arab/North African/Berber DNA component, and it CLEARLY shows in their results.

totit:
Did you even read the OP at all?

Loolx

OK, let me help you :





Now,after the so called result came out, here are the result :

http://forward.com/fast-forward/379533/igbo-men-have-no-semitic-dna-according-to-controversial-test/


http://www.timesofisrael.com/messianic-jews-to-nigerians-youre-not-real-jews/

ezeagu:
Which ancient skeletons?

totit:
I quote you :




The bolded has explained and proved my point here.

totit:
I guess Jews are plenty for obodo nigeria, I am a southerner, remember

In that case, ibo being a race/tribe should quit claiming Jews as it seems it spreads across various tribes and individual.
Ibo author again,that same dude that's been going around trying to claim ibo jewish loolx he's been all over the net fighting for a week now

Thank you

totit:
Thank you,@ the emboldened
By the way, wiki isn't a reliable source, anybody can edit it,and besides wiki doesn't run DNA test nor verify jewish identity.

Nice chatting with yah

ezeagu:
The entire idea of that haplogroup being from Jacob, who is not even confirmed as a historical figure, is not based on solid evidence. If the argument is that the other Jews are not true Jews then there will never be a way to confirm whether Jacob existed or not and what origin he had.

totit:
If not all ibo are Jews then it would be wrong to tag a whole tribe Jews, mixed or not it's all about the test, isn't it?

totit:
I was aware of that but I wanted to corner the dude.

Now, let do the math :
• is ibo tribe jewish
• If so, why was the result came out negative, and does that means that those tested are not ibos
If they are,let me ask again,is ibo jews(as a whole)

IgboSubmarine:
They should get more samples from other parts of Igboland especially those parts that have a large presence of fair skin people Example



Kanu and his wife should be tested.

totit:
Should we now conclude that all those tested are not ibos,and besides, why did they fail the test if ibos are Jews as we were made to believe before this revelation? And remember this quote :




So, what's the problem here

totit:
Stop shouting. Provide prove to that.
Show me the link that states the samples were collected from Nnewi

totit:
Then that says it all.
Let me ask, why were they rejected, E1A?

IgboSubmarine:
Are you sure

I will check again if truly intermarriage affects only the autosomal

totit:
you've said it all,and you know what? The majority carry it. Because as it stands, the majority tested has so far proved(as it stands)ibo race isn't Jews. And yes,you are right again,the bolded approve my point and the statement you just made ;ibo not being Jewish but base on individuality. I am mee,jew too

IgboSubmarine:
Intermarriage will definitely affect the genetic make-up of the later descendants.


Don't you think so

totit:
And I quote you :

ezeagu:
There's nothing like "Jewish 100%", even if we go with this funny theory, Igbo "Jews" would not be 100%, they'd be watered down with whoever you guys think the Igbo people are made up of who would be black Africans.

Furthermore, this is a ridiculous reason to claim or even been campaigning for Igbo Jewish identity.

totit:
Now you are contradicting ya self bro.

The result read : [b]E1b[/b]were none jewish.

IgboSubmarine:
You are just been a nuisance on this thread


So many Igbo communities have intermarried with other tribes especially those communities at the fringes of Igboland which will definitely affect their genetic make-up


The Jewish people should have taken samples from Igbo communities that are at the center of Igboland and have less intermarriage with other tribes


For example, Anambra has an indigenous Igala community.

So imagine what will become of their genetic make-up after years of intermarriage with other ethnic groups



GoldAlpha12 which part of Igbo land are you from since you have E1B1 genetic make-up.

ezeagu:
That would also mean that millions out of more than 500 million black Africans "may be Jewish".

ezeagu:
Actually, it has been revealed from further research that they are not.

ezeagu:
Then that rubbishes the idea of that haplogroup indicating 'Jewish' ancestry.

totit:
you've said it all,and you know what? The majority carry it. Because as it stands, the majority tested has so far proved(as it stands)ibo race isn't Jews. And yes,you are right again,the bolded approve my point and the statement you just made ;ibo not being Jewish but base on individuality. I am mee,jew too

totit:
The dude as subconsciously confessed. He fell for it. That is,ibo being Jews is a big lie strictly base on individuality not ibo tribe hence the contractions in the result.

totit:
Thank you
You've proved me right. Obviously,being Jews isn't a tribe thing but individual, I guess mee I am jaw to.

For,In that case it's wrong to call you a jew and not ibo people . Don't you agree

0b100100111:


I join you for the laughter


"Some"