LordTheus's Posts
Nairaland Forum › LordTheus's Profile › LordTheus's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 (of 43 pages)
God is a placeholder for ignorance |
Another one MaxInDHouse Tamaratonye5:What's your response to this? Like I said keep lying to yourself |
MaxInDHouse:When you're recovered from your drunken state here is just one out of many replies that not only took you off balance, but knocked you out and left you cold on the canvas, bloodied and hallucinating: FemiAjani: |
MaxInDHouse:Keep lying to yourself |
MaxInDHouse:Nice red herring, except I'm not hungry. I'm talking honest debate, not consensus. What we're talking of here is the fact that people are taking the time to read and address the nonsensical trash in your ignoramus posts and you are not even bothered to read through their posts and understand how they prove your own posts senseless. Instead you're groaning about how long there replies are. What a crying shame. |
MaxInDHouse:He didn't write rubbish. You're just too thick in the skull to see that literally everybody here is pointing out the stupidity of your so-called "answers". Go get an education. Spewing bigoted and dogmatic views doesn't count as discourse |
Nice one OP. Hahahahahahahaha I no fit laugh finish ![]() |
Threebear:I finally realized the injustice of this public voting system after the Lockdown season. No surprises here. Sometimes, I struggle to understand what the point of this show is. |
Amya:I personally still think the abundance of TV shows in the west is a MUCH bigger factor behind BBUS' relative unpopularity than the BBUS voting system (which I still totally feel is irrelevant to a show's popularity) but since you don't want to go down the rabbit hole, and since I also don't wish to derail the thread, I'll let the debate die here. I just wanted to make my points as clear as possible, hence the length. Anybody's impatience to read isn't really my problem. |
Amya:I'll make it a bit easier for you to read if it's too long. These are two relevant excerpts from my reply debunking the claims you made.... ....Now, if truly, as you claim, viewer participation is the sole causal factor behind Big Brother Housemate followership, then how come Big Brother celebrities from America and Canada happen to be more popular and/or have more followers than their British counterparts? Remember, the UK version of BB allows audience to fully decide, via voting, who stays and who goes. Therefore, there is complete viewer participation. The reason BB isn't as big in the western world as it is here is simply because of the plethora of other reality shows available with equal or higher popularity. Big Brother in the western world is just a run of the mill. Compare it to The Kardashians for example. In Nigeria, Big Brother has complete domination over the reality TV world.Long story short: most of what you claimed in your post about the Big Brother series is wrong and/or unsupported |
prewtyjulie:I like being thorough ![]() |
Amya:The math has been done. However, If you're going to hinge your arguments on the Instagram followership of housemates, then I should probably bring to your attention that Cameron Cole, the winner of the latest Big Brother UK 19 (2018) has only 26.3k followers on Instagram. The previous winner of BBUK 18 (2017), Isabelle Warburton has just 80.5k followers. If we should compare and contrast from the BBUS winners of the same years, we'll find that the 2017 winner of BBUS Josh Martinez has 231k followers on Instagram. The 2018 winner Kaycee Clark has 493k on the same app. Picture 1: 2018 BBUK winner Instagram Picture 2: 2018 BBUS winner Instagram In light of this, let's examine the next few statements in your post... The followership of the HMs of **western BB version which technically represents their fanbase is small just for one reason and one reason alone, viewer participation.The Nigerian version of the series adopted the European voting system, which was popularized by Big Brother UK. Now, if truly, as you claim, viewer participation is the sole causal factor behind Big Brother Housemate followership, then how come Big Brother celebrities from America and Canada happen to be more popular and/or have more followers than their British counterparts? Remember, the UK version of BB allows audience to fully decide, via voting, who stays and who goes. Therefore, there is complete viewer participation. ** This is only semantics but I just thought I should remind you that by Western TV series, I'm talking of both American and the UK. The BBnaija pattern of voting make the viewers invested. The game doesn't end with just the contestants, it continues with viewers. The viewers invest their time, emotion and sometimes even funds to see that who they like come out tops. The disadvantage of this system is that it isn't necessarily the best player that wins. The advantage of this system is that anyone lucky enough to grow a fanbase will do well outside of the show even if they don't win.Your argument would have been more compelling if your claim that there is a causal relationship between viewer participation and housemate followership were true, but as shown above, the connection doesn't exist. The reason BB isn't as big in the western world as it is here is simply because of the plethora of other reality shows available with equal or higher popularity. Big Brother in the western world is just a run of the mill. Compare it to The Kardashians for example. In Nigeria, Big Brother has complete domination over the reality TV world. The US system relies heavily on strategy and alliances. Interesting to watch, but it doesn't make the viewers emotionally invested enough in the housemates for the life outside the show.I don't agree with this assertion. In fact, I find it a little bit spurious. The American BB version is objectively far more entertaining and engaging in terms of the strategy and alliances and manipulation that is exhibited. The gameplay format also influenced other competitions like Survivor, The Challenge etc. If you were making the argument that BBUS is amoral and apathetic towards housemates' integrity and moral values, that's a different argument. But the truth is BBUS embodies the social, psychological nuances of the series' source material, 1984 by George Orwell. And it embodies it far better than the British or African versions ever could. The psychological manipulation, power control, the intentional distortion of previous events that happened, the use of rhetoric, betrayal etc. I can argue that all of these makes for more compelling and dramatic reality TV that keeps viewers invested. Ultimately, it comes down to preference. You can't just assume that nobody has any emotional investment to BBUS because there is no audience participation.... Oh wait there actually is because the audience still get to vote for their favorite housemate at the end of the series and the highest voted is announced on the same night of the real winner. So.... My conclusion is that Big brother naija should stop with the silly twists. If they want the eviction power to be on the HMs, then they should follow that pattern from the beginning. This will naturally give rise to alliances and voting blocs and the HMs will know that their survival in the house is strictly in their own hands.I agree with you here. The twists this year have been bland and/or careless. The organizers need to do better. The housemate voting twist was handled better in Big Brother Lockdown.
|
Skrrrrrrr:Considering the vast assortment of successful reality television shows that are insanely popular in the west, I believe the bolded statement should be put in a more proper context. Nigeria literally has no reality show that comes close to Big Brother in terms of viewership and fanbase. The Voice and Nigerian Idol don't generate as much buzz. In America, Big Brother is far from the number 1 show when you have The Challenge, Survivor, Love Island etc. And Big Brother has been around in America much longer than the rest (nearly two decades). If we want to be technical, BBNaija isn't even 10 years old. Big Brother in the US is still going strong. There are just so many shows that match up with it in terms of viewership and fanbase. Funny enough the aforementioned American shows all have the exact same voting format. Weird. But that being said, I agree that the power to vote should remain with the audience since it's been like that for so long. At best they can implement the "Vote to evict" format for audience to vote for which housemate they want gone, and blend it with the "Vote to save" format for which housemate they want to stay. Announcements of the voting pattern will be announced to the audience every week after nomination. |
Threebear:Threebear! ![]() Ignore the haters man, I believe your government. I'm equally jaded for the series after Lockdown. Only watch for the parties now. Looking forward to seeing your predictions ![]() |
![]()
|
Bluezy13:Ok. I get your point. I suppose property but would be an apt term to use. I tend to overlook semantics in debate because usually in my experience, I've discovered that people mean different things when they use certain words due to a lack of proper understanding of the word. However, sometimes if you pay close attention to the context of discussion and usage of the word, you'll understand what they're trying to say. Thanks anyways |
Bluezy13:I think you are conflating property dualism with materialism, which is no fault of yours anyway since both arguments actually seem similar at surface level. I accept that the mind is an emergent phenomenon from the brain, but I also assert that this phenomenon is created by observable material interactions in the brain, and cannot manifest without. I reject the notion that the mind can exist independent of the brain. Contrary to your suggestion, there is no selectivity at play here |
Bluezy13:Human behavior is only considerably unpredictable due to the fact that we lack proper understanding and judgement towards the human psyche. Countless aspects that we haven’t understood as of now seem to be "random" at first, but can also point out that certain laws in the social sciences, are more flexible in nature in comparison to that of the physical/hard sciences. As Sherlock Holmes said, if you had all of the variables of human behavior, all of the various threads leading to a certain moment and could analyse them all, then you could predict any behavior. For a bigger example of this, read Isaac Asimov’s Foundation Trilogy, which predicts the futures of entire societies. On the other hand, the introduction of immateriality would make the concept of the Mind a controversial argument (just as it is already).Perhaps it would. But allow me to ask you this: If the "mind" (which you claim is immaterial) is to have any influence over the body, it will have to cause that body to do physical things in the physical world, wouldn't it? How then can it do this if it is not, itself, physical? In what sense is it a "separate" kind of thing from the physical world if it is capable of stimulating the nerve impulses and muscle movement required for me to put the plans I make in my "mind" into action? |
Bluezy13:Yes, this is otherwise known as property dualism - the position that the mind is an immaterial property of the brain. To be clear however, I'm arguing from a materialist point of view. I assert that all emergent phenomena (including mind and/or consciousness) are a product of material properties and interactions. It will also fascinate us if you could go through this :Basically your position is that the mind is an immaterial thing distinct from the brain - at least that's what I can infer from your assertion as well as the link which you pasted. Correct me if I'm wrong. Now the problem is, by claiming that the mind is distinct from the brain, you have hypothesized an entire plane of being, a radical compounding of all the complexities in the plane of being we can actually observe. And what additional data are you able to explain by adding all this complexity? Not saying that your position isn't tenable, but by virtue of Occam's Razor, I'd prefer to stick with the materialistic perspective i.e the mind as a product of material processes and interaction in the physical brain because, in my opinion, it is a simpler hypothesis to explain observable phenomena. |
Bluezy13:Well, you've already gone out of your way to counter my position that the brain produces what you call the "mind" by claiming that the mind is an independent phenomenon. It would do us both good for you to explain what you mean by the mind being "independent" |
Bluezy13: The Mind is an independent phenomenon of its own, functioning distinctly depending on the body it embodies.You are boldly asserting here that the mind is a self-sufficient phenomenon, which tacitly admits that it doesnt necessarily need a brain or body to exist. However you go ahead to claim that it can manifest itself accross multiple individuals differently. So I ask again, can you present any evidence to support your claim that the mind is an independent phenomenon that can exist without a brain? |
Bluezy13:Done in my previous post And if in your opinion, the mind requires the brain to function, that means the Mind is not a part of the brain but rather it is attached to the brain.Your issue here is you are taking a dualistic approach, divorcing the mind and body as two separate things. The mind can NOT exist without a body - specifically without a brain. And like I said, if you have evidence to the contrary, I'd be glad if you presented it If on the other hand, you maintain that the Mind is in the brain, then "where" exactly in the brain is the Mind ?I literally stated the mind is not a spatial phenomenon, so this question is built on a misrepresentation of my position. You're treating the mind as if it were some sort of object, or maybe you're imagining it as something from an ethereal realm. It is literally a result of processes in the human brain. |
Bluezy13: The Mind is an independent phenomenon of its own, functioning distinctly depending on the body it embodies.Now unless I'm mistaken, please explain what you mean when you say the mind is an "independent phenomenon". Independent of what? |
Bluezy13:As far as I know, there exists no evidence for this assertion. It is a bare claim without any support. Prove me wrong. Note that I have already demonstrated that the mind is indeed an emerging property of the human brain using traditional neuroscience. If you insist that the mind doesn't require a brain to manifest, you'll have to illustrate this for me using objective evidence |
Bluezy13:When I say the element of an object, what I'm trying to refer to is the attributes of an object, be it tangible or not. |
Bluezy13:The bolded is a non-sequitur and assumes that the mind must be a material element. Also, I never said that the mind is located in the brain. I said the mind is a property of the brain (1) Where exactly in the brain is the Mind located ?This is a rather funny question. Where exactly in a moving vehicle is speed located? (2) How do you explain an intangible thing as the Mind being a part of a tangible thing as a human being ?I already used neuroscience to answer this question a few posts ago. The mind cannot be located spatially. However, it is a result of active process in the HUMAN BRAIN. Maybe I'm confusing you by using the words "part" or "element". I think a better way to put it is: the mind is "function" or "product" of the brain. Think of your PC and the operating software. The mind is the product of the interaction and integrated activity of various brain structures. Brain injury affects cognitive processes, injuries to other parts of the body do not, unless they lead to brain damage. So it's reasonable to assume that the mind is a product of the brain. |
Bluezy13:Off the top of my head, I'd say it's a basic/fundamental part of a whole |
Bluezy13:Here is a quick definition from Oxford mind |
Bluezy13:It may not be as controversial as you suppose it is. You see, the workings of the human mind actually have very plausible explanations in contemporary neuroscience which proves that the human mind might not be as incomprehensible as we make it out to be. The human brain is an extremely complex physical organ and is possibly the most complicated stuff in the universe. It's composed of billions of neurons all of which are massively interconnected with the associated structures, the axons and dendrites and such. However, the brain is divided into discrete structures that all have specific purposes and these are cross-wired with each other as well. We can observe quite easily now how specific areas of the brain are responsible for specific actions and thoughts, and we can also observe the deficits that occur when those structures and areas are damaged by stroke or accident. Given all of this, it's clear that there is sufficient evidence to support the idea that the mind is an emergent property of brain activity. Refer to the attached picture The cerebrum is divided into four lobes: frontal, parietal, occipital and temporal.https://mayfieldclinic.com/pe-anatbrain.htm The brain evolved over millions of years with four basic steps built bottom to top, and back to front, starting with the brain stem and spinal chord. Next, the Cerebellum, the Limbic System, and the Cerebrum were added. It then evolved the further lobes which developed specialist functions. These functions work on brain circuitry, and the biochemistry of neurotransmitters. There is no evidence whatever of any outside influence on the mind (consciousness). No "soul" or "universal consciousness" or any other such fanciful notion. You can check out the link above if you want to read more. Neuroscience does actually give decent explanations for the basic workings of conscious, subconscious, or unconscious brains.
|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 (of 43 pages)




