Biodun556:


The Hadith collectors have made their own research and contributions. Muslim schorlars of today should continue to make it better. However , some schorlars are bent on replacing hadith with their own opinions in order to propagate their own ideology and create divisions among muslims, one must be careful of this. Many Quran verses point to the relevance of hadith which makes it inevitable while interpreting Qur'an. I am of the opinion that not all the hadiths that were rejected are fakes, muslim recognised body and reputable schorlars who are sincere should continue to work on them.

Hassanmaye:

Yes I agree with you but just like the Qur'an have abrogating and abrogated verses the Hadith also have.
For example.
O prophet urge the believers to battle. If there are among you twenty who are steadfast they will overcome two hundred.. and if there are among you one hundred who are steadfast they will overcome a thousand who have disbelieve. Qur'an 8:65.
But this verse was later abrogated by Qur'an 8: 66
Now Allah has lighten the hardship for you and he knows that among you is weakness.
So if there are from you one hundred who are steadfast they will overcome two hundred..

nisai:
Thanks. What about beard?

GreenCovering:


How you take know say E no do am?

AlBaqir:


Beard is simply a recommended act, NEVER a compulsory act.

Hendtime:

Show me proof

Hendtime:

Then why did he not say be when he was making Adam, abi he don forget say him get power?

Alhajiemeritus:

Na Gymnastics be this my bro...
You know say Quran self came with no districts na old Scholars dey give am the marks, whether above or below, that's why we have different recitation methods.
Same with this, you can either call it (fight)قاتل or قتل.
Depending on the chain/part your Hadith was narrated from.
Peace.

nisai:
Ok sir. But I will appreciate proof to back it up.

Crayfish09:


Wa'alaikumu Salam brother.

I watched the video of the apology. It was made because many of us were accusing him of insulting the prophet, so he clarified it and apologized to those who felt offended.

Also, the debate was more of a Q and A session. They asked him to open the pages of all the false hadiths he mentioned in 10 minutes and he was unable to do so.

Baker77:


قاتل is pronounce as qo'tala while قتل pronounce as qotala..check dictionary

gentleibraheem:


Don't read to give a reply or prove a point read to Understand and Dish out your Opinion.
we are all students of Knowledge Here. Besides the single bane of most of our Ulamas is Assuming Righteousness, Pride, Sentiment and Lack of an Objective Mindset. Listen Please

Hassanmaye:

Sir he is not saying that all the Hadith are not authentic but rather Hadith which don't have backing from the Qur'an are questionable,
I start to believe him.

drealaz24:


Nothing abrogate each other here. All the verses are clear and understandable. Remember Allah knows everything.

AntiChristian:


Most of all these i stated have no backing from the Qur'an too. So they are questionable right?

Hassanmaye:

Nap, if they have Qur'an backing they Not questionable, the fact that albani Said some Hadith sahih Bukhari are daeef said it all. Only book of Allah is free from error

Itzlinda:


Quran preservation is quite differently from Hadith preservation.
Do you know anyone that has memorized sahihul Bukhari by heart?

AntiChristian:


No one is claiming the generality of the "Sahih ahadith" to be 100% as Allah has destined the Qur'an only to be such. But saying ahadith without backing from the Qur'an is questionable is false and lacks merit.

AlBaqir:


The only hadith of the Prophet that talks about beard says, "trim your moustache and leave your beard so you can be different from the Jews"

Fi'l al-Amr [commanding verb] usually indicates either: compulsion (waajib) or recommendation (isti'bab). If something is compulsory and you do it not intentionally, then there is punishment for it. Recommended act if done attracts great reward but if left undone, it attracts no punishment.

In the abovementioned hadith, the "command" in its tone and style is a recommendation, never compulsory (even if some too know group of people have made it compulsory for themselves).

You can decide to have beard, trim or shorten it. It's a choice. Sincerely, beard is manly and always look good if kept well.

Abdoolbuster:

LMAO @antii.slam, @Hend.time come o Sombody is saying that the sayings of the prophet (saw) is causing wàhálà (shame) to Islam. Ọmọ x 1 trillion I no fit laugh alone

ANTIlSLAM:


Antichristian shey you see wetin this your brother compton11 yarn?

Una no go kill person with laugh oo

compton11:
what did I say?

ANTIlSLAM:


This is what you said

"Sahih is not 100% percent reliable especially sahih Bukhari,thya book needs to be revised cos it has cause much wahala in Islamic world."


You just finish Islam

compton11:
yes cos Bukhari collected those Hadith from people after like 400 years after prophet!


And some are not reliable

MakotoShishio:
I also support Sahih Hadith

[img]https://images./5vguVpLLeqqXyvBrrs70js.jpg[/img]

ANTIlSLAM:


But ur brother antichris said Sahih bukhari is the best and 100% reliable

compton11:
yes cos Bukhari collected those Hadith from people after like 400 years after prophet!


And some are not reliable

compton11:
yes cos Bukhari collected those Hadith from people after like 400 years after prophet!


And some are not reliable

Abdoolbuster:


It is the same people who collected and transmitted the Qur'an that collected and transmitted the hadiths also. If you must reject the hadiths then you must reject the Qur'an they transmitted too. This is the Dilemma of abdools

Abdoolbuster:


Even the Qur'an was collected hundreds of years after Muhammad has long died

Alhajiemeritus:
Imam Bukhari didn't even write Sahih Buhari