Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,153,159 members, 7,818,529 topics. Date: Sunday, 05 May 2024 at 06:01 PM

The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? - Sports (3) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Entertainment / Sports / The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? (30215 Views)

No African Country Voted For Osimhen For Balon D'or (Photo) / Winning A 7th Balon D'or Would Be Crazy - Lionel Messi / Cristiano Ronaldo Crowned Men’s Player Of The Year At Dubai Globe Soccer Award (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Polynek(m): 4:04pm On Jan 19, 2022
Na them Sabi, I only watch football to entertain myself
Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Antoeni(m): 4:07pm On Jan 19, 2022
Any One Leo Messi Wins , Is the Best

1 Like 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Grandmeister(m): 4:09pm On Jan 19, 2022
Angrymode:
By hierarchy, FIFA BEST but The Ballon D'or was the most popular until they turned it into a popularity contest. Even Messi should be ashamed he won The Ballon D'or ahead of Lewandoski this time around.
There was never a time it was more popular than fifa. Who remembers Shevchenko, Owen even nedved won ballon d'or?? But we remember Ronaldo, rivaldo, Ronaldinho and even cannavaro won the fifa best player.

4 Likes 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Shikena(m): 4:11pm On Jan 19, 2022
FIFA
Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by DSHADOWWALKER: 4:14pm On Jan 19, 2022
WiszyFraud:
Dem both awards are prestigious..


FIFA just trying to balance Up things after realising they gave the ballon d’or to the wrong player..



lipsrsealed


You are not as smart as you think,who told you FIFA awards the ballon d'or??
Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by pek(m): 4:15pm On Jan 19, 2022
Ballon D'or is full of controversies. 2003, it was awarded to Nedved instead of Henry. 24 goals and 20 assists from 37 league games was Henry's achievement that season. Nedved didn't come close. In 2010, Inter Milan won the treble, a certain Wesley Sneijder was unplayable that season, yet it was given to Messi. Lewandoski has stood head and shoulder above everyone in this planet. Scoring goals without a care and winning four trophies and individual awards along the way yet it was given to Messi for moving from Barcelona to PSG.

3 Likes 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Kingcalls: 4:21pm On Jan 19, 2022
Grandmeister:

I don't know when ballon d'or overtook fifa. Fifa best player was originally for the best player in the world and d'or for Europe best player. That was why guys like Shevchenko, Owen won it..

U are among the few old guards when it comes to football...alot of kids on social media ...I remember bk in 2000 when zidane was awarded fifa player of the year when pundits anticipated Figo... when balon dor later awarded Figo that same yr with the award, they called it consolation award , and Figo wasn't even pleased winning it... it was when he won it the following yr that he celebrated.... those that think balon d'or is more prestigious are kids...if so...then zidane is only on one Balon dor

7 Likes 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by seunayantokun(m): 4:25pm On Jan 19, 2022
Noisemaking media.... because Ballon d'Or is a journalists' thing...just like media awards given to people like elrufai, buratai, and the chief executive terrorist in an Abuja rock.

2 Likes

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Kingcalls: 4:27pm On Jan 19, 2022
GeneralOjukwu:


Yeah. Remember that era.

FIFA either went silent or BDO got a lot of publicity in the past decade.

All of a sudden, Ballon D'Or moved to the forefront. Before, in the days, only a very serious fan knew the BDO winners. FIFA was all the rave....

Ronaldo '96, '97.... Weah '95

Most people don't even know Sammer of Germany won balon dor in 96... once u ask who won 96, they scream Ronaldo, but Ronaldo dint win it in 96 , he won the fifa World player award

1 Like 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by GeneralOjukwu: 4:29pm On Jan 19, 2022
Kingcalls:


Most people don't even know Sammer of Germany won balon dor in 96... once u ask who won 96, they scream Ronaldo, but Ronaldo dint win it in 96 , he won the fifa World player award

Good old days. Matthias Sammer.

I loved it then because a totally different person often won the European one with emphasis on their performance on the continent.

I remember Osei Kuffour of Ghana/Bayern winning too. The BDO would just pick a very technical player (at times a defensive midfielder)not necessarily a flashy attacker like FIFA almost always picked.

I loved it back then!

1 Like 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Erimmy2(m): 4:29pm On Jan 19, 2022
Chijeep:
Balloon D'or anyday anytime twice on my birthday.
I rep January 19th...
Happy birthday to me
Happy birthday brother. Wishing you all the best.

1 Like 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by BlackZeus17: 4:33pm On Jan 19, 2022
If FIFA can design an award that'll be as beautiful as d balon dor then I sure believe the balon dor will loose it's relevance..

But for now people thinks that balon dor is the ultimate award and most players cry when they miss out is cos the award looks beautiful unlike FIFA award..

FIFA's mistake was to merge with balon dor, now it's hard for me to convince someone that balon dor is not the award for the world best

4 Likes 2 Shares

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Funkymode(m): 4:45pm On Jan 19, 2022
Fifa is the most prestigious award in football,
Balon di'or is a third party award and no award could be greater than the main football governing body award (Fifa), if Balon di'or like or any other body like, they should raise the price money to 1 trillion dollars, it's still doesn't make it anyway more prestigious, it'll always and forever be ranked below Fifa award

1 Like

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by TheVictorious(m): 4:53pm On Jan 19, 2022
chiefolododo:
I think it's FIFA Best Player. Balon'dor is an award organised be a magazine company, we have many magazine companies even if France, what if a media house in France or Spain or Italy decides to organize their own best player award...

They didn't ask which one should (deservedly) be the most prestigious. WHICH ONE IS??

1 Like

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by chiefolododo(m): 5:06pm On Jan 19, 2022
TheVictorious:


They didn't ask which one should (deservedly) be the most prestigious. WHICH ONE IS??
it's FIFA Best Player
Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Hndrrxxx(m): 5:07pm On Jan 19, 2022
AsampeteNwaanyi:
fifa best
balon dor is just a French magazine award and has no right to determine the best player.
any country can also organize their awards.

But in all fifa best remains the most prestigious award in the world of football.
because it's the award organised by the world body of football.
They hardly get controversial and they almost get it right every time unlike balon d'Or.
told someone that there's no right thinking football body that'll pick Messi over lewy football achievement and fifa proved me right.
balon d'Or just wanted to cash out on Messi brand hence the award and the phantom new best striker award to lewy as compensation.
they're Afterall a magazine company so profit should be the priority.

the thing is that balon dor has more publicity than fifa best.

comparing balon dor to fifa best is like comparing Pes football game to fifa football game.
cheesy
shut your damn mouth 'fore you dropped, nigga

1 Like 2 Shares

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Keegan: 5:12pm On Jan 19, 2022
ThierryJay:
It's now the Ballon dor undoubtedly.

Before Ballon dor used to be synonymous with European footballer of the year. But since the merger of Ballondor and Fifa the best in 2010 and the split in 2016, the Ballon dor holder is now considered as the world best player.

Ever wondered why CR a few years ago said his life ambition was to win Seven Ballon Dors and not seven Fifa WPOTY.

Ever wondered why Evra and co were raising awareness about Balon dor weeks to the ceremony but many players did not even make any preamble reference prior to the Best?

Ever wondered why Lewandoski and pundits were crying he had never won Ballon dor in his career even though he won Fifa the best in 2020. Why do you think other players were consoling him for not winning Ballon dor in 2020 even though he won the Best award same year? It's because they knew he missed out on the biggest prize during the pandemic.

Ever wondered why awareness for Ballon dor on Nairaland started months to the event with several threads prior to the d-day but for the best, the thread even came to FP after the event had ended. You think it's a coincidence?


I love it when someone is so reasonable, precise and factual. You are a genius.

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Zenithpeak(m): 5:13pm On Jan 19, 2022
AsampeteNwaanyi:
fifa best
balon dor is just a French magazine award and has no right to determine the best player.
any country can also organize their awards.

But in all fifa best remains the most prestigious award in the world of football.
because it's the award organised by the world body of football.
They hardly get controversial and they almost get it right every time unlike balon d'Or.
told someone that there's no right thinking football body that'll pick Messi over lewy football achievement and fifa proved me right.
balon d'Or just wanted to cash out on Messi brand hence the award and the phantom new best striker award to lewy as compensation.
they're Afterall a magazine company so profit should be the priority.

the thing is that balon dor has more publicity than fifa best.

comparing balon dor to fifa best is like comparing Pes football game to fifa football game.
cheesy

I share your sentiment...

1 Like 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by macof(m): 5:14pm On Jan 19, 2022
Kingcalls:
The FIFA Best player of the year award was just concluded with the Polish and Bayern Munich record breaker claiming the award as the FIFA mens Best player for the year 2021 . The Polish striker defeated Lionel Messi and Mohammed Salah to record his 2nd FIFA Best award

The Balon D'or was also awarded a couple of months ago in November and the winner of that award went to the legendary Lionel Messi, with the second position going to the pole and 3rd went to double winner ( champions league and European cup) chelsea's Jorginho ... claiming his 7th Balon d'or

They have been arguments and counter arguments on who deserves it more and also about the award that is more prestigious...

HISTORY AND CONTROVERSY

The first ever Balon D'or was awarded to the late Sir Stanley Matthews in 1956 by A French football magazine based in France, over the years it was only won by Europeans , it was basically known as the European awards . In 1991 FIFA created its own award for outstanding players and it was called The FIFA world player of the year award with Lothar Matthäus winning the inaugural award .. So they were 2 awards that were given yearly ...Balon d'or started awarding non Europeans in 1995 and George Weah was the first non European to get the Balon d'or award, that was because they were already loosing credibility and interest from football lovers and that was because FIFA awarded 94 to Brazilian Romario, while Balon dor awarded Hristo Stiochkov of Bulgaria in the same year of 94. FiFa had taken total control of the award as Balon d'or was viewed as an European award or consolation award. Zinedine Zidane only won one Balon D'or Ronaldinho also won only one and Ronaldo de Lima only won 2 , the three balon dor we usually credit both players( Zidane and Ronaldo de Lima) with , were actually awards they won under FIFA Player of the year award, thats why players like Michael Owen, Andriy Shevchenko and Pavel Nedved that also won balon dor are not really recognised, thats because those were the same years Luis Figo, Zidane and Ronaldinho won the FIFA player of the year Award ... Lionel Messi was the last to win the FIFA player of the year award in 2009 before they merged in 2010 ... when they merged , that was when prestige and Glamour was attached to Balon D'or, and again being that FIFA adopted Balon D'ors golden ball plaque .... FIFA detached from Balon D'or in 2016 after Blatter was expelled cos they believed that decision of merging both was wrong ...

The FIFA Best Awards are voted by coaches and team captains of football nations under FIFA, while the Balon d'or is voted by journalists that are selected in nations under the governing body


These are the winners of FIFA player award since 91

1991 Lothar Matthäus Inter Milan

1992 Marco van Basten AC Milan

1993 Roberto Baggio Juventus

1994 Romário Barcelona

1995 George Weah AC Milan

1996 Ronaldo Barcelona

1997 Ronaldo Inter Milan

1998 Zinedine Zidane Juventus

1999  Rivaldo Barcelona

2000 Zinedine Zidane Juventus

2001 Luís Figo Real Madrid

2002 Ronaldo Real Madrid

2003 Zinedine Zidane Real Madrid

2004 Ronaldinho Barcelona

2005 Ronaldinho Barcelona

2006 Fabio Cannavaro Real Madrid

2007 Kaká ACMilan

2008 Cristiano Ronaldo Manchester United

2009 Lionel Messi Barcelona

2016 Cristiano Ronaldo Real Madrid

2017 Cristiano Ronaldo Real Madrid

2018 Luka modric Real Madrid

2019 Lionel Messi Barcelona

2020 Robert Lewandowski Bayern Munich

2021 Robert Lewandowski Bayern Munich

These are the winners of Balon D'or award since 91

1991: Jean-Pierre Papin (Marseille)
1992: Marco van Basten (AC Milan)
1993: Roberto Baggio (Juventus)
1994: Hristo Stoichkov (Barcelona)
1995: George Weah (AC Milan)
1996: Matthias Sammer (Borussia Dortmund)
1997: Ronaldo (Internazionale)
1998: Zinedine Zidane (Juventus)
1999: Rivaldo (Barcelona)
2000: Luis Figo (Real Madrid)
2001: Michael Owen (Liverpool)
2002: Ronaldo (Real Madrid)
2003: Pavel Nedved (Juventus)
2004: Andriy Shevchenko (AC Milan)
2005: Ronaldinho (Barcelona)
2006: Fabio Cannavaro (Real Madrid)
2007: Kaka (Milan)
2008: Cristiano Ronaldo (Manchester United)
2009: Lionel Messi (Barcelona)
2010: Lionel Messi (Barcelona)
2011: Lionel Messi (Barcelona)
2012: Lionel Messi (Barcelona)
2013: Cristiano Ronaldo (Real Madrid)
2014: Cristiano Ronaldo (Real Madrid)
2015: Lionel Messi (Barcelona)
2016: Cristiano Ronaldo (Real Madrid)
2017: Cristiano Ronaldo (Real Madrid)
2018: Luka Modric (Real Madrid)
2019: Lionel Messi (Barcelona)
2020: Cancelled because of Covid-19
2021: Lionel Messi (Paris Saint-Germain)

Now let's gather and give our verdict on the award thats more prestigious, The Balon D'or or FIFA Best player
Below images are the 97 player of the year held by Ronaldo
1998 held by winner Zidane standing with Ronaldo and Davor Suker
2001 held by winner Luis Figo with David Beckham and Raul Gonzalez
2004 Ronaldinho, 2016 Cristiano Ronaldo and the present new trophy held by modric in 2018


There's no controversy here.. Fifa best men is the more prestigious one
It's in the name.. It is Fifa and it's "best men"
If one said Ballon D'or is just cruise and a reason to gather for small chops, they wouldn't be wrong

1 Like

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Keegan: 5:19pm On Jan 19, 2022
Chatflick:
The OP is just obsessed with Messi and Ronaldo argument else he wouldn't have asked this question.

I see a pained somebody because Messi has 7 Ballon D'or

They just hate the great magician for no reason. Oh, they hate him because he made them cry several times and lastly he achieved what they were fervently cursing him not to achieve. Messi shut the haters up the very day he won the Copa America.

6 Likes 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by macof(m): 5:23pm On Jan 19, 2022
pek:
Ballon D'or is full of controversies. 2003, it was awarded to Nedved instead of Henry. 24 goals and 20 assists from 37 league games was Henry's achievement that season. Nedved didn't come close. In 2010, Inter Milan won the treble, a certain Wesley Sneijder was unplayable that season, yet it was given to Messi. Lewandoski has stood head and shoulder above everyone in this planet. Scoring goals without a care and winning four trophies and individual awards along the way yet it was given to Messi for moving from Barcelona to PSG.
You will know someone who is significantly aged from comments like this. Reference to history and age-long criteria
Only children who started watching football from 2010 think Ballon D'or is the best individual award but it's not their fault because that's all they've known

4 Likes 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Kmf0: 5:34pm On Jan 19, 2022
Afcon
Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by genii96(m): 5:59pm On Jan 19, 2022
One osba global award
One is a trophy of a Private french magazine


Ballon d'or is more popular, that's it
Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Kojochyke(m): 6:05pm On Jan 19, 2022
slawormiir:
Damnnn niggarrrr

I know Penaldo fans will say fifa is the most prestigious
Ah swear
Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Kirkman: 6:11pm On Jan 19, 2022
At least Lawandoski finally won an award that he truly deserved that was robbed off him at the Ballondor. So nothing else concern me.. grin
Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Kojochyke(m): 6:13pm On Jan 19, 2022
LesbianBoy:
When Ronaldo 2018 ballon d'or award was given to Modric, that's when these awards lost their credibility angry

Also, these award organizers have lowkey shown they are Messi fans. Scam awards
Abeg wetin Ronaldo achieve dat year wen Modric nor surpass?
Ronaldo fit even play world cup semi final?
Abeg nor be by scoring 10 goals in one game.. Football is bigger than that.
Ronaldo is just a great goal scorer.. That's all.
That year, Messi even had a far bigger stat n contribution to football than Mormor n
Ronaldo. Google it.
But Modric went further by even being d glaring best player in d World Cup.

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by ENIGMATIC2023(m): 6:16pm On Jan 19, 2022
"The FIFA Best Awards are voted by coaches and team captains of football nations under FIFA, while the Balon d'or is voted by journalists that are selected in nations under the governing body".


Journalists are always biased.

1 Like

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Nobody: 6:21pm On Jan 19, 2022
Fifa best has always been the award to beat. Balon d'or for me is more of politics than the game. Imagine awards voted by journalists to award voted by the real sportsmen. They are not equal jàre. The way a coach will analyse football is quite different from how laymen would.

1 Like

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by Guardiola84: 6:24pm On Jan 19, 2022
Christane:
the Ballon dor was a better award until it became corrupt and only handed to those the governing body love ...bt the FIFA award z now d real deal who check out stat and give d award to who truly deserve it(lawandowski) truth be told the FIFA award z actually bigger than Ballon dor ..cus Ballon dor z just a France football award
Pls what did lewy n his polish team win for him to deserve FIFA best award ?stop hating messi blc next d WC is coming to Argentina get ready to faint

1 Like 1 Share

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by brightalo1010: 6:24pm On Jan 19, 2022
AsampeteNwaanyi:
fifa best
balon dor is just a French magazine award and has no right to determine the best player.
any country can also organize their awards.

But in all fifa best remains the most prestigious award in the world of football.
because it's the award organised by the world body of football.
They hardly get controversial and they almost get it right every time unlike balon d'Or.
told someone that there's no right thinking football body that'll pick Messi over lewy football achievement and fifa proved me right.
balon d'Or just wanted to cash out on Messi brand hence the award and the phantom new best striker award to lewy as compensation.
they're Afterall a magazine company so profit should be the priority.

the thing is that balon dor has more publicity than fifa best.

comparing balon dor to fifa best is like comparing Pes football game to fifa football game.
cheesy

Even Cristiano ronaldo and Lewa needed Balon D'Or award more than your Fifa award because they know as footballers the most valuable one, that's why Ronaldo entire family were busy fuming , ranting crying throwing tantrum each time Messi wins it over Ronaldo .

You're just an ordinary NL commenter that's why you never asked why footballers values BD more.

4 Likes 2 Shares

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by udeh3(m): 6:33pm On Jan 19, 2022
FIFA is the world regulatory body. So, they organizes and gives the best award as far football is concern on this planet Earth. So, whichever way they choose to organize it, it's still the most incredible.

The world cup is the most prestigious football tournament in the world. Maybe, it's organized by the French media and not FIFA.

Saying the French media organized award is the most prestigious award to FIFA award is like also saying that a governor is bigger than the president of a Nation

1 Like

Re: The Balon D'or Vs FIFA Best: Which Is A More Prestigious Soccer Award? by udeh3(m): 6:36pm On Jan 19, 2022
brightalo1010:


Even Cristiano ronaldo and Lewa needed Balon D'Or award more than your Fifa award because they know as footballers the most valuable one, that's why Ronaldo entire family were busy fuming , ranting crying throwing tantrum each time Messi wins it over Ronaldo .

You're just an ordinary NL commenter that's
why you never asked why footballers values
BD more.

So, if they want to talk about world best player and award, you will quote the French media award other than FIFA.

Why not say Okocha was African (CAF) best player multiple times since he was the BBC player of the year many times

2 Likes 1 Share

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (Reply)

Djokovic Arrested Hours After Winning Australian Visa Fight / All Real Madrid Players And Staff Go Into Coronavirus Quarantine / Ajax Beats VVV-Venlo 13 - 0, Lassina Traore Scores Five

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 107
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.