victorakpabome:


You sure? Anyway I don't read the Bible often, so you may be right.

LaaJiblik:



Let’s Assume (while not conceding) that those were his cousins, not Mary’s children.

Question is: Did Joseph have Sex with Mary AFTER the Birth of her first child?

LaaJiblik:



Let’s Assume (while not conceding) that those were his cousins, not Mary’s children.

Question is: Did Joseph have Sex with Mary AFTER the Birth of her first child?

lankieman:
Fallacies.

yeyerolling:
Na Joseph fuk marry wey she born Jesus. Simple truth. If u lik quote me na u sabi

WOruGunu:
The issue of brothers of Jesus came from the inability of the Jews not being able to differentiate between brothers,cousin and step brothers.
But the Roman Catholic where able to go deep down the history and culture lane of the Jews were they found out that those being called the brothers of Jesus were actually is cousins, as there was no name to for cousin in Hebrew back then.
So Jesus had cousin brothers only.

victorakpabome:


Yes she did. I am Catholic by the way. See the proof from Bible.org below:

https://bible.org/question/did-mary-have-any-children-other-jesus-if-so-how-can-she-be-eternal-virgin

victorakpabome:


A FOOL sighted. Your brain needs serious formatting. Ode!

Karlovich:
Mary was a promiscuous wh*re who deceived Joseph into taking care of an illegitimate child. she deserved to be stoned to death

LaaJiblik:



Let’s Assume (while not conceding) that those were his cousins, not Mary’s children.

Question is: Did Joseph have Sex with Mary AFTER the Birth of her first child?

AkunnaTochi:


Yes, it is possible Joseph never consummated his marriage. You are trying to analyse an event that took place over 2000 years with your 21st century brain.

jdleo32:
Mary had no biological child of hers even jesus was a mystery to mankind. She remained a virgin til death. Those you heard mentioned were jesus cousins but due to translation of the Bible and time this has been misunderstood.
Most of the Bible quotations were written in Idiom as at then this have led to lots of scholars rewriting the Bible over and over again to make people understand.
And not all that happened those day was covered in the Bible. You can take ur time to research the truth through other means don't wait for ur pastor to tell u what he believes. Jesus remains the only child of MARY. And Joseph never consummated that marriage. Therefore she remained a virgin all her life.

ensign:
My brethren in christ, all of the references sighted in the answers referred to those people as the Lord's brethren just like you are my brethren even without any blood relation. The only tool of confusion here is the English Language. Please dont be deceived, The blessed Virgin Mary is not a prostitute and Joseph isnt a womanizer. If a fellow agrees that his wife would conceive through the Holy spirit, will thesame fellow not be willing to let her remain a virgin forever. Lets not forget that Joseph had been willing to send Mary away secretly just to cover her from shame but for the dream revelation.

If you get to heaven, you will know that the issue of consumating marriage or not is not as important as we have taken it in our present day world. For further knowledge on this, you may read "The Lost Books of the Bible". But until then lets us keep watching and praying until the arrival of the bridegroom. May he meet us as the 10 wise virgins.(AMEN)

cyrilamx:
then how can someone who didn't consort with a man nor had any contact with a man's semen conceive? if God can make Mary conceive without the interference of a man then why can't u reason also he can make the hymen of d woman remain intact during n after birth? truth is most of u pentecostals ain't knowledgeable in the language of the Jews of Jesus' time-- Aramaic. go and Google the Church fathers' view about Mary's perpetual virginity. the perpetual virginity of Mary predates the canonicity of the new testament...even the Protestant reformers like Martin Luther and John Calvin believe this sacred truth...

ensamy:
Yes she had other children. Mary, was about 13yrs old when she was betrothed to the widower, Joseph.

SnakeXenzia:
you are mad

Aleis:

Mary has no child apart from Jesus, that is why she still refer as Virgin.
IN the Hebrew, there is no clear distinction BTW cousins, brother and sons. Those u see mentioned, are his cousins not brothers.

AkunnaTochi:


Yes, it is possible Joseph never consummated his marriage. You are trying to analyse an event that took place over 2000 years with your 21st century brain.

omoelerin1:
Luke 2:6-7
'And so it was, that, while they were there, the days were accomplished that she should be delivered.
verse 7 'And she brought forth her FIRSTBORN SON, and wrapped him in swaddling clothes, and laid him in a manger, because there was no room for them in the inn'.

It is Catholics that claim she never had other child. Because the consider her as a saint. That is why they idolize her, praying to Jesus through her.
They believe she remained a virgin through out her life. Which is wrong.

Syncan:


Oga, no de lie na, I quoted your post o. Go and Check Mk.6:3 you quoted to see Joses there, abi you don't read your copy and paste?

kolafolabi:
Mary had four other sons, Joseph, James, Jude, and Simon. Because of the virgin birth, Joseph was not the father of Jesus so these were the half brothers of Jesus. The last three mentioned are not to be confused with those who were disciples of Jesus by the same name. Here are some passages where the other sons of Mary by Joseph are mentioned (Matt. 12:46; 13:55; Mark 6:3; John 2:12; 7:3, 5, 10; Acts 1:14; 1 Cor. 9:5; Gal. 1:19).

https://bible.org/question/did-mary-have-any-children-other-jesus-if-so-how-can-she-be-eternal-virgin

HeyCorleone:
Even if she did I don't see of how much importance it is. Our focus in the Bible, and thru out History have always been on the people who made impact, not their relatives.

toye440:

I notice NL to b a very bias platform. on Fridays wen this uncircumcised Philistines upload their trash Christians r blocked from commenting, in fact u hv to take oath. but wen it comes to Christian matters every Philistine is given access easily. Since wen has NL start taking sides?

victorakpabome:


You are a weasel. Catholics don't call Mary a saint. Where did you hear that?

victorakpabome:


You are a weasel. Catholics don't call Mary a saint. Where did you hear that?

Tosinex:
Mary never had any other child apart from the LORD that he bore through the power of the Holy Spirit. Neither did Joseph sex her till he departed, so Mary came a virgin, gave birth a virgin and departed a virgin. Joseph was vast in age when Mary was given to him and he had other children from his previous wives who departed before Mary came in, thanks.

amakadihot87:
.......of course they do.........d name of my church is even st mary