₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,213 members, 8,521,804 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 03:42 AM

Toggle theme

Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation - Islam (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Islam › Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation (3297 Views)

1 2 3 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 4:31pm On Jul 17, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Yes, Islam could have came from any angle, what Islam teaches is different from what Arab does. There are many Arabs practices that Islam is against, so basically Islam isn't a propagation of Arabic culture but divine revelation from the almighty
Islam is Arabic culture, the names of Muslims, the God they call on, how they pray and where they face, the dressing, the practices etc are Arab cultures.

I'm sure you're African, why do you prefer a foreign religion(Arabia religion) to your own African traditional religion?
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 5:00pm On Jul 17, 2019
tintingz:
Islam is Arabic culture, the names of Muslims, the God they call on, how they pray and where they face, the dressing, the practices etc are Arab cultures.

I'm sure you're African, why do you prefer a foreign religion(Arabia religion) to your own African traditional religion?
Lolxxxxx, PLS go find out, there's no jilbab in Arabic culture, regarding the names, Islam doesn't prohibits naming your children from ur background, but we prefer to bear Islamic names. So the choice is left for every Muslim. Well am going to repeat it for the last time, Islam isn't Arabic culture because there were many Arabian cultures that Islam destroyed.

If you want to dwell on that, pks why do you speak English, dress in English attire, and accept many of their practices.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 5:06pm On Jul 17, 2019
tintingz:
Freeing slave does not mean condemning slavery, the British colonials also freed slaves even when it's still a practice, no where in the Qur'an it condemned slavery.

So basically in Islam, it's ok to keep slaves in 21st century, yes?

So you believe killing a fellow human because of homosexuality and adultery is moral in 21st century? Don't you think that's murder?
There you go again, your yardstick is 21st century mentality, our yardstick is QUR'AN and sunnah.

An encouragement towards something is a discouragement from the opposite. Understood??
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 5:25pm On Jul 17, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
There you go again, your yardstick is 21st century mentality, our yardstick is QUR'AN and sunnah.

An encouragement towards something is a discouragement from the opposite. Understood??
I asked you questions, is it ok for you to keep slaves today?

And is killing adulterers and homosexuals moral to you?

Answer that question and let move to the next.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 5:49pm On Jul 17, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Lolxxxxx, PLS go find out, there's no jilbab in Arabic culture, regarding the names, Islam doesn't prohibits naming your children from ur background, but we prefer to bear Islamic names. So the choice is left for every Muslim. Well am going to repeat it for the last time, Islam isn't Arabic culture because there were many Arabian cultures that Islam destroyed.
It's Sunnah to name your child a Muslim name which is in arabic, I've never met a Muslim not bearing a Muslim name even converts have Muslim names. So can you give your child a name that has nothing to do with Islam or Arabic?

Islam didn't destroy Arabian cultures, e.g bowing to the Kaaba has been a practice during pre-islamic era and all other rites. Slave trade was a practice and still a practice when Islam came.

If you want to dwell on that, pks why do you speak English, dress in English attire, and accept many of their practices.
I don't have problem with people adopting other people's cultures, I'm pointing out your hypocrisy in your premise.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by Rashduct4luv(m): 6:04pm On Jul 17, 2019
tintingz:
Apostasy is abandoning a belief.

Treason is rebelling against the leader by violence and overthrowing.

Can you tell us how they are alike and deserve same death penalty?
Let's redefine apostasy.

Apostasy is rebelling against the belief of the Islamic state.

Allah's law is sacrosanct to the Islamic state just as democracy is to the secular states.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 6:18pm On Jul 17, 2019
tintingz:
It's Sunnah to name your child a Muslim name which is in arabic, I've never met a Muslim not bearing a Muslim name even converts have Muslim names. So can you give your child a name that has nothing to do with Islam or Arabic?

Islam didn't destroy Arabian cultures, e.g bowing to the Kaaba has been a practice during pre-islamic era and all other rites. Slave trade was a practice and still a practice when Islam came.



I don't have problem with people adopting other people's cultures, I'm pointing out your hypocrisy in your premise.
Lol, who is now the hypocrite here, you don't have problem following English culttur but ur problem is adhering to Islamic culture, funny.

Well, you ain't a Muslim, enough of the chit chat.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 7:02pm On Jul 17, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Lol, who is now the hypocrite here, you don't have problem following English culttur but ur problem is adhering to Islamic culture, funny.

Well, you ain't a Muslim, enough of the chit chat.
You criticized someone for eating western cultures, but you didn't see yourself eating Arabs cultures.

That's the hypocrisy I'm pointing at in your premise.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 7:20pm On Jul 17, 2019
Rashduct4luv:
Let's redefine apostasy.

Apostasy is rebelling against the belief of the Islamic state.

Allah's law is sacrosanct to the Islamic state just as democracy is to the secular states.
Does abandoning a belief in any way hurt anyone?

Like If i stop believing in Santa Claus hurt anyone?
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 8:20pm On Jul 17, 2019
tintingz:
You criticized someone for eating western cultures, but you didn't see yourself eating Arabs cultures.

That's the hypocrisy I'm pointing at in your premise.
What you don't understand is, Islam is a culture that teaches us virtually everything of our life, Islam is a total way of life. So we follow Islam not Arab.

As long as you can't differentiate between Arab cultures and Islam, that is where the problem lies. Anyway, I don't expect you to know it cos you didn't study Islam, so to you, Islam is Arab culture. Arab culture is different from Islam, take it or leave it.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 8:46pm On Jul 17, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
What you don't understand is, Islam is a culture that teaches us virtually everything of our life, Islam is a total way of life. So we follow Islam not Arab.

As long as you can't differentiate between Arab cultures and Islam, that is where the problem lies. Anyway, I don't expect you to know it cos you didn't study Islam, so to you, Islam is Arab culture. Arab culture is different from Islam, take it or leave it.
I was a Muslim, so please don't tell me I didn't study Islam.

You fail to answer some of my questions.

Ok, let's turn it around, if Islam originated from Yoruba land and whites, arabs, asians, started using Yoruba names, bowing and visiting shrine in ile Ife for pilgrimage, calling on Eledumare and Oduduwa is the prophet, wearing agbada, Kampala, adire and the scripture is written in Yoruba, Odu Ifa is Sharia, you greet in Yoruba language.

So tell me how the religion here is different from the culture of the land?
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 9:51pm On Jul 17, 2019
tintingz:
I was a Muslim, so please don't tell me I didn't study Islam.

You fail to answer some of my questions.

Ok, let's turn it around, if Islam originated from Yoruba land and whites, arabs, asians, started using Yoruba names, bowing and visiting shrine in ile Ife for pilgrimage, calling on Eledumare and Oduduwa is the prophet, wearing agbada, Kampala, adire and the scripture is written in Yoruba, Odu Ifa is Sharia, you greet in Yoruba language.

So tell me how the religion here is different from the culture of the land?
This shows that you don't get the difference between culture and Islam.


Are we eating their food?

Are we killing our female like dey used to do in d pre Islamic era?

Are we dressing like them?

Are we speaking their language?

Are we naming our child after Arabs or after pious people in Islam?

Perhaps when u answer some of these questions, perhaps u can find d difference between Arab culture and Islam
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m):
AbdulHakeem44:
This shows that you don't get the difference between culture and Islam.
Let's see.


Are we eating their food?
You don't have to eat their food.

Are we killing our female like dey used to do in d pre Islamic era?
Women are still treated as second class human in Islam.

Are we dressing like them?
Yes. Turban, jalabia, face veil etc are Arab dressing.

Are we speaking their language?
Yes, you believe learning Arabic is Sunnah when praying, greeting etc reason you must learn Arabic.

Are we naming our child after Arabs or after pious people in Islam?
Lol, are these names not Arabic or the early Muslims were not arabs Or the early Muslims were not given names by their parents during pre-islamic era?

Perhaps when u answer some of these questions, perhaps u can find d difference between Arab culture and Islam
Oga, it seems you didn't get my premise using Yoruba land as the origin of Islam as example.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 10:34pm On Jul 17, 2019
tintingz:
Let's see.


You don't have to eat their food.

Women are still treated as second class human in Islam.

Yes. Turban, jalabia, face veil etc are Arab dressing.

Yes, you believe learning Arabic is Sunnah when praying, greeting etc reason you must learn Arabic.

Lol, are these names not Arabic or the early Muslims were not arabs Or the early Muslims in Islam were not given names by their parents during pre-islamic era?

Oga, it seems you didn't get my premise using Yoruba land as the origin of Islam as example.
Lol, now I understand your type of Islam, face veil is Arab culture, now I get it. No need of argue further pls. Hijab dat ALLāh commanded was Arab culture before, Hmmmm, what a great scholar. Mudeer markaz students full everywhere o
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 12:33am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Lol, now I understand your type of Islam, face veil is Arab culture, now I get it. No need of argue further pls. Hijab dat ALLāh commanded was Arab culture before, Hmmmm, what a great scholar. Mudeer markaz students full everywhere o
Women in pre-islamic era dress the same way Muslim women dress after Islam came, just that it was not obligatory. The Jewish women also dress same, same for ancient parsian, Indian women etc.

Hijab, scarf and face veil was not a new thing in the middle East and never started by Muhammad.

Have you heard of Purdah?

You can also read history of Hijab.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 7:02am On Jul 18, 2019
tintingz:
Women in pre-islamic era dress the same way Muslim women dress after Islam came, just that it was not obligatory. The Jewish women also dress same, same for ancient parsian, Indian women etc.

Hijab, scarf and face veil was not a new thing in the middle East and never started by Muhammad.

Have you heard of Purdah?

You can also read history of Hijab.
Who mandated hijab for Muslims, simple question
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 7:08am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Who mandated hijab for Muslims, simple question
Do you agree hijab is an arab thing before Muhammad came?

Answer that first.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 7:14am On Jul 18, 2019
tintingz:
Do you agree hijab is an arab thing before Muhammad came?

Answer that first.
What they used in the ancient Middle East then was merely head scarf and transparent veil, our jilbab or hijab conditions is much more different than that, cos the jilbab instructed by ALLāh was mean to cover the whole body and clothes.

The ancient headscarf were used by notable women to differentiate them form slave women and girls.

the headscarf and veil of a thing was not in the Arabian peninsula prior to prophethood. The Christians (catholic) who do wears something similar then we're not in Arabian and the Medina Christians do not wear it cosnthey were Coptic christians
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by proudkafir1: 7:25am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Lol, no, I only eat what is contained in the Quran and authentic hadeeth, no more no less. I am less concerned with Arabs. Arabs are no better than the black nor the blacks better than them except in piety. I don't defend any Arab governments be it Saudi Arabia or turkey or Iran, I only defend Islam. Hope you understand now
Islam is 100% synonymous with the Arabs; it is their religion, their culture which they export all over the world. The greatest raw materials and technology the Arabs have is Islam.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 7:26am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
What they used in the ancient Middle East then was merely head scarf and transparent veil, our jilbab or hijab conditions is much more different than that, cos the jilbab instructed by ALLāh was mean to cover the whole body and clothes.

The ancient headscarf were used by notable women to differentiate them form slave women and girls.

the headscarf and veil of a thing was not in the Arabian peninsula prior to prophethood. The Christians (catholic) who do wears something similar then we're not in Arabian and the Medina Christians do not wear it cosnthey were Coptic christians
Did you read about the Purdah practice I presented?

Is Hijab not an headscarf? Hijab in pre-islamic era are mostly long from head to the legs.

Whether it was worn by notable women in pre-islamic era or not is not the argument, the argument is, are they arab thing before Muhammad came?

Read history of Burqa
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by proudkafir1: 7:31am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Exactly my say, it may look barbaric, archaic, old or even fossil, but your measure for the standards is the contemporary society which keeps changing. So Islam wasn't made to keep changing with the society, Islam is one and unchangeable till end of time. If it is so, Quran texts would have to be reviewed like the Bible, but NO, no man dares it.
The quran you have today was reviewed and standardized in 1924 at Alzar university Cairo.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by proudkafir1: 7:36am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Yes, Islam could have came from any angle, what Islam teaches is different from what Arab does. There are many Arabs practices that Islam is against, so basically Islam isn't a propagation of Arabic culture but divine revelation from the almighty
Bro, Islam is 100% medieval Arabian culture. Most of Islamic practices today are pre-Islamic practices incorporated into Islam. Islam borrow from Arab culture and her school of thought was also shaped by what was happening in the Arab world.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by proudkafir1: 7:41am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
If you know well of Islam, you will know Islam encourages more of freeing slaves to enslaving. Homosexual and adulterers are to be killed as per Islamic principles, in accordance with what is contained in the Bible as well (Old Testament).

Unfortunately they will tell u it's an old ruling but tithing is from Old Testament too.
You guys will always employed the Bible to solidified Islamic argument and, at the same time, condemn it as 'corrupt' when it does not suit your argument/doctrine/sunnah. This is called 'hypocrisy'.

Islam never abolished slavery but manumitted slaves who embraced Islam. If a slave refused to convert to Islam, the likelihood that he will be freed is 0%. Mohammed freed some slaves and bought some, it is in the hadith.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by Rashduct4luv(m): 7:53am On Jul 18, 2019
tintingz:
Does abandoning a belief in any way hurt anyone?

Like If i stop believing in Santa Claus hurt anyone?
Then you will say does someone being Homosexual hurts anyone? Yet, Homosexuals are to be killed in an Islamic State.

Hurting someone is not the criteria of judgement in Islam as you know. The law is the final.

Each country has its laws and Apostasy is for an Islamic state.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 8:40am On Jul 18, 2019
Rashduct4luv:
Then you will say does someone being Homosexual hurts anyone? Yet, Homosexuals are to be killed in an Islamic State.
Then it's barbaric to kill a fellow human in this case.

Hurting someone is not the criteria of judgement in Islam as you know. The law is the final.

Each country has its laws and Apostasy is for an Islamic state.
If you're in a state where Santa Claus is worship as God and you stop believing in Santa, do you think it's moral for you to be killed?

Let's see the victim side here.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 9:06am On Jul 18, 2019
proudkafir1:
The quran you have today was reviewed and standardized in 1924 at Alzar university Cairo.
And has its wordings changed?
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by AbdulHakeem44(m): 9:20am On Jul 18, 2019
proudkafir1:
You guys will always employed the Bible to solidified Islamic argument and, at the same time, condemn it as 'corrupt' when it does not suit your argument/doctrine/sunnah. This is called 'hypocrisy'.

Islam never abolished slavery but manumitted slaves who embraced Islam. If a slave refused to convert to Islam, the likelihood that he will be freed is 0%. Mohammed freed some slaves and bought some, it is in the hadith.
Lolxxxxx, follow the argument well bro, I was only trying to point out that the same Islamic rulings people are condemning today is in the Bible of the Christians.That doesn't negate the fact that the bible is corrupt nor does it says there are no elements of truth remnants in the Bible. So understand perfectly, don't twist my words.

What happened to the slaves captured in the battle of badr, did they accept Islam before they were released? Lol
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 9:24am On Jul 18, 2019
proudkafir1:
Bro, Islam is 100% medieval Arabian culture. Most of Islamic practices today are pre-Islamic practices incorporated into Islam. Islam borrow from Arab culture and her school of thought was also shaped by what was happening in the Arab world.
It's funny how some people think Islam has nothing to do with Arab cultures when the early adherents were arabs.

I even made it obvious for him using Yorubaland as Islam origin.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by najib632(m): 10:14am On Jul 18, 2019
tintingz:
It's funny how some people think Islam has nothing to do with Arab cultures when the early adherents were arabs.

I even made it obvious for him using Yorubaland as Islam origin.
you have come with your rubbish again. You're just a racist,
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by tintingz(m): 10:47am On Jul 18, 2019
najib632:
you have come with your rubbish again. You're just a racist,
I'm sure you didn't go through the premises.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by proudkafir1: 11:27am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
And has its wordings changed?
Yes, the wordings changed and all the texts were modified to reflect a uniformity in reading. However even at that, we still have various readings (Hafs, doori, warsh,etc) with slight variations in text, readings and meanings.
Re: Even Perfection Erodes With Time. Islam Needs Reformation by proudkafir1: 11:41am On Jul 18, 2019
AbdulHakeem44:
Lolxxxxx, follow the argument well bro, I was only trying to point out that the same Islamic rulings people are condemning today is in the Bible of the Christians.That doesn't negate the fact that the bible is corrupt nor does it says there are no elements of truth remnants in the Bible. So understand perfectly, don't twist my words.

What happened to the slaves captured in the battle of badr, did they accept Islam before they were released? Lol
If a material is corrupt I never expected you to quote it to validate an argument that suits you, because you will reject the same book when it contradicts your argument. This is what we call hypocrisy. The quran had been corrupted since Uthman decided to burn the manuscripts of the quran hence destoyed all evidence that could have been used to validate the authenticity of the current quran. If Christians burn Bible manuscripts what will Muslims say? What happened to the verse of stoning of adulktery that was eaten by a goat (sunnah ibn majjah 1944)? Some of the quranic revelations were also advice from umar hence nullified the myth of any divine origin (quran 66:5, sahih bukhari 8:53).

The battle of badr does not in any way contradict the fact that Mohammed bought and sold slaves, and his sahabas did the same.
1 2 3 Reply

A Month Of Reformation & Redefinition, Ramadan Is Here. Are You Ready? • I Think Islam Was A Reformation Of The Pre-islamic Religion • Ramadan Is Here - A Month Of Reformation & Redefinition. Are You Ready? • 2 • 3 • 4

A Muslim Nairalander Responds To Farouk's Problems: What Do You Think? • Building A Relationship With The Quran This Ramadan • Why Does Quran Refer To Allah As 'god' And Not 'God'?