A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall - Christianity Etc - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall (3892 Views)
| A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 6:57pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
As stated above, this is simply a response to a topic I came across on the home page of this forum: https://www.nairaland.com/5443357/allegory-garden-eden-account-fall I normally do not concern myself with religious debates online or in real life conversations because it usually gets to the point where people leave the topic and try to silence me by making references to my personal choices. ![]() However, on this, I choose to correct the pervasive thinking on that thread put forward by a user by the name Offpoint. Below is an edited version of my response to him on the topic: First of all, there is no sexual allegory to be seen in the story of the fall. None whatsoever. Adam was present right there when the serpent was talking to Eve. The fruit is a very real fruit: There was a tree of life (for spiritual nourishment which could be eaten), there was also a tree of the knowledge of good and evil (not to be eaten). There were many other trees. The emphasis on trees and fruits generally was because the first creation were all herbivores, no one ate meat not even the lions and tigers. If indeed sex is the fruit, how do we explain the fruit from the Tree of life which was also mentioned in the bible and which they were not forbidden to eat from? Secondly, evil did not enter the world through Cain. At least not in the world as we know it now, because all of his descendants were killed by the flood. The only surviving people after the flood were Noah and his family. Noah himself is a direct descendant of Seth, the son born to Adam after Abel was killed. Evil came into the world again after the flood through the descendants of Ham, Ham is Noah's second son between Shem and Japheth. Apparently, Noah had gotten drunk with wine and was unclothed. Ham saw his unclothedness and announced it to his siblings. His brothers went into the tent and covered him up by carrying a cloth but walking backwards to avoid seeing their father's unclothedness. Noah then cursed Ham and his descendants for that error. The next time the bible mentions people who did evil in the sight of God was in the story of the tower of Babel. These people tried to build a monument towards the sky in an attempt to defy God, these people are descendants of Ham. Lastly and about the missing books of the bible we know today. The people who removed the books from the bible were translators because the Jewish council of Rabbis who first convened to put the complete scrolls together in what you now call the Bible refer to those missing books as UNINSPIRED works. Uninspired means they were not written through revelations, visions, or dreams from God but through the writers own will. If you have read any of these books, you would notice a subjective theme from the writer's point of view missing in most of the other books left in the bible today. This does not mean the books are demonic or seek to distort the Christian's attitude towards God. As at the time the Bible was being translated, the translators themselves began removing these books based off their own personal decision. There are still Bibles with the complete books, no single book missing from them, but you have to go back to translations that were released before 1560 which is when the Geneva bible was produced. This is the first time it was divided into chapters and verses and arguably the first time The Apocrypha (Uninspired writings) were removed. That will be all for now. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by UceeGod: 9:40pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
I strongly believe the account of creation in Genesis, just like that of Revelation was a mixture of allegory and real characters. The garden, trees, fruits, eating of fruits, are all symbolic while satan, the man and woman are real. But let's not over allegorise these characters; we know satan didn't impregnate Eve, Adam did and they gave birth to Cain Genesis 4:1 |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 9:57pm On Sep 29, 2019*. Modified: 10:19pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
Offpoint:Offpoint please let us continue from here. I can see it's already getting too heated on the other thread. 1. Regarding the fact that every animal including humans were herbivores, these are the verses: Genesis 1:29 King James Version (KJV) And God said, Behold, I have given you every herb bearing seed, which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree, in the which is the fruit of a tree yielding seed; to you it shall be for meat. Genesis 1:30 And to every beast of the earth, and to every fowl of the air, and to every thing that creeps on the earth, wherein there is life, I have given every green herb for meat: and it was so. In some versions,meat is replaced with food. Verse 30 covers Lions and Tigers, etc. Their sustenance (man in verse 29 & animals in verse 30) as prescribed here is on plants, fruits, and trees. Nothing more, unless you want to add something to those verses. ![]() 2. Regarding the fact that there were other trees made mention of especially the tree of life which they were allowed to eat from: Genesis 2:9 King James Version (KJV) And out of the ground made the Lord God to grow every tree that is pleasant to the sight, and good for food; the tree of life also in the midst of the garden, and the tree of knowledge of good and evil Genesis 2:16-17 King James Version (KJV) 16 And the Lord God commanded the man, saying, Of every tree of the garden thou mayest freely eat: 17 But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die. You can see here that there were a lot of trees of which two were named in verse 9:, the tree of life, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. But in verse 17, only the latter was forbidden to be eaten from. Unless you want to add to the scriptures again. ![]() 3. Regarding the fact that Adam was present with Eve while the serpent was speaking to her: Genesis 3:6 King James Version (KJV) 6 And when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to make one wise, she took of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gave also unto her husband with her; and he did eat. The NIV translation writes it as who was with her. It's all clear enough.. Any further confusion? ![]() |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 10:07pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
UceeGod:Absolutely. These people just want to perverse the word even when the writings are clear. Genesis 4:1-2 New International Version (NIV) 1 Adam made love to his wife Eve, and she became pregnant and gave birth to Cain. She said, “With the help of the Lord I have brought forth a man.” 2 Later she gave birth to his brother Abel. Now Abel kept flocks, and Cain worked the soil. Unless some people intend to add to that or ascribe their own interpretations, i honestly do not understand how the gist about satan fathering Cain came about. ![]() Adam and eve did not have sex until they were outside the garden. Offpoint take note ![]() |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by sonmvayina(m): 10:19pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
The story of Adam and eve was adapted from an old Babylonian epic about Adapa.. It tells how man lost the chance of eternal life.. The serpent of the good tree was ninghizhida and the serpent of the evil tree was inanna.. They guided Anu's gate.. It was never a literal Story.... The Torah was written by Ezra.. Possibly with Baruch and some other rabbi.. They are the ones who created Judaism as the National religion of the isrealites... They drew most of their inspiration from Babylonian epics.. Which they incorporated to their Torah.... |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 10:29pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
Muttleylaff Budaatum |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by Ihedinobi3: 10:30pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
missjo:Hello 1. You are right that there was no allegory going on in Genesis. It is also true that all living creatures fed on the trees and herbage in the Garden. There was no meat-eating authorized by the Lord until after the Flood (Genesis 9:3). 2. We all acquired a sin nature through Adam, not through Cain or through Ham. When Adam chose to rebel against God along with his wife, his flesh was corrupted. He was cursed with passing down that corruption to his descendants. Everyone born of male seed has the same corruption in their flesh (Romans 5:12). This is why the Savior Jesus Christ had to be born by a virgin without the involvement of any male agency. Again, there was evil in the world right from the time that Adam sinned. Also, the people who rebelled in the issue of Babel was not just Ham's descendants. It was everyone with the exception of a few believers who are not named (Genesis 11:1-9). It is true that the one who spearheaded that rebellion was Ham's grandson Nimrod, but it wasn't only his grandfather's line that joined him. The entire world then cooperated with him. That was why the Lord created the nations, to prevent such cooperation again until the time would be right for it at the Tribulation. 3. I lack the context of your submission about the apocryphal writings, but I can tell you that there is NO complete collection of them, on account of the fact that there are so many that it is simply impossible to collect them all. As for how the books in the Bible were selected, Scripture has a distinctive quality: it is basically alive. No one who has ever honestly read Scripture could miss its vitality. It is inspired. No other literature is. One may feel the emotion of a writer in some piece that they wrote. Homer can be captivating, for example, although it was written so many years ago. But Scripture is not merely emotionally captivating. It is alive. It is probably impossible to explain it any better. However, it is the presence of that life in it that makes it unmistakable. So, it basically self-selects into the Canon. In other words, there has never been a council whether of Jewish rabbis or of Roman Catholic bishops that selected what belongs in the Canon of the Bible and what doesn't. That such councils existed is not being disputed. That they actually created a true Canon is a fantastic lie. They may have created a Canon that suited their own purposes, but nobody ever put the Bible together. The Bible self-selects. You can see proof of this in Peter's words about Paul's writings: [15]and regard the patience of our Lord as salvation; just as also our beloved brother Paul, according to the wisdom given him, wrote to you, [16]as also in all his letters, speaking in them of these things, in which are some things hard to understand, which the untaught and unstable distort, as they do also the rest of the Scriptures, to their own destruction. 2 Peter 3:15-16 NASB Clearly, Peter recognized Paul's writings at the time that he wrote them as Scripture. There was no council telling him or anybody else then that Paul's writings were Scripture. The first such council occurred at least a couple hundred years later. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 10:37pm On Sep 29, 2019*. Modified: 11:13pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
sonmvayina:The scrolls were not written by Rabbis, it was compiled by them into what you call the Torah which is a combination of the first five books of the Bible. They could not have drawn their inspiration from anywhere because they did not write anything. The council was formed to gather the scrolls and combine the scriptures into what we now refer to as the bible. You can correct me where i am wrong. And also, anything drawn/adapted from babylonian epics is definitely heresy because Babylon did not exist until about a thousand years (give or take) after the flood. And even at that, it was not referred to as Babylon, but Babel. The location where the tower of Babel was built by Ham's descendants is where Babylon came to exist. You surely do not expect people from this place who tried to mock God, to have an accurate account of creation, do you? ![]() |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 11:00pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
Ihedinobi3:Of course sin came through Adam, I was talking about evil. There is a difference between the sin of Adam which polluted his lineage and the evil that resulted as a consequence. Adam's disobedience = sin Cain killing Abel = Evil You're right about Nimrod, but it was only Ham's descendants who were among those trying to build the tower. I say this because the curse which Noah placed on Ham and his descendants involved them becoming servants to descendants of Shem and Japheth. Nimrod tried to break from that curse by gathering his people (descendants of Ham) and moving far away from the descendants of Shem and Japheth. Nimrod was trying to be a King in his own right and not a servant to anyone as Noah cursed & God sealed. Genesis 11:2-4 King James Version (KJV) 2 And it came to pass, as they (Nimrod and his people) journeyed from the east, that they found a plain in the land of Shinar; and they dwelt there. 3 And they said one to another, Go to, let us make brick, and burn them thoroughly. And they had brick for stone, and slime had they for morter. 4 And they said, Go to, let us build us a city and a tower, whose top may reach unto heaven; and let us make us a name, lest we be scattered abroad upon the face of the whole earth. I do not want to go much into the Council of Rabbis and what they actually did, but if you can just read up on The Rabbinical Council of Jamnia (about A.D 90), it would save my fingers a workout. Lol Thanks for your contributions here, it is appreciated . ![]() |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by MuttleyLaff: 11:19pm On Sep 29, 2019*. Modified: 12:13am On Sep 30, 2019 |
missjo:Sorry, budaatum has hands full at the mo and wouldnt be urgently involved, thats if bud finds the thread to be interested in. missjo:Moses and his ghostwriter, Joshua, where the Rabbis, who did the writing. Combining to form what we know as Bible, happened much much in the future later MuttleyLaff: missjo:[img]https://s0/images/Enki.jpg[/img] MuttleyLaff:Moses effectively, just sat and watched a replay of events, as if he literally was watching a video replay. Something like as if, using Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology used in football/soccer games to review a past moment in the ongoing game. That's how Moses was able to write and put the Torah together. I can guess what next some smarty-pants is going to ask about this |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by MuttleyLaff: 11:41pm On Sep 29, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff: |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by budaatum: 12:50am On Sep 30, 2019 |
You seem to think it is literally and historically true. https://www.nairaland.com/4960881/garden-eden-childs-view#74770060 Don't mention me with that fool again. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by MuttleyLaff: 1:10am On Sep 30, 2019 |
budaatum:kkins25, fyi, notice bud fooling about. Smh I was rubbing eyes, not believing what I was reading. I apologise for bud behaving badly at below link: https://www.nairaland.com/5443357/allegory-garden-eden-account-fall/3#82692936 |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by budaatum: 2:07am On Sep 30, 2019 |
MuttleyLaff:The fact that I mentioned him is not fyi enough for you you had to do your evil thing muttley? Smh. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by MuttleyLaff: 2:17am On Sep 30, 2019 |
budaatum:Did jesusjnr peradventure, give you his dealer's number? I smelled something and its wasnt smelling fishy |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by budaatum: 2:22am On Sep 30, 2019 |
You have no shame. You see when he does it yet go about doing the exact same thing he does and are now trying to make out the stink is not from you! Please go and find something productive to do muttley and stop needlessly mentioning me. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by MuttleyLaff: 2:33am On Sep 30, 2019 |
Has 99 problems already, I am not going make "his" 100 problems list |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by Ihedinobi3: 4:54pm On Sep 30, 2019 |
missjo:I'm afraid I don't see this difference you mean. Adam's eating of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was indeed disobedience to God, since the act violated God's Will. The same is true of Cain's murder of Abel. Both are disobedience, and both are sin. But I believe you are pointing out the difference in seriousness or degree, that would make sense. Eating a fruit against God's Will is a sin punishable by the Lake of Fire as much as murder is, but murder is a more wicked sin, obviously. My point, however, is that the biblical position is that whatever may be considered sin or evil came into the world through Adam's disobedience. Of course, each of Adam's descendants has gone on to disobey in a way that is perhaps unique to them, with someone like Cain turning to murder, and Nimrod using politics to try to wipe out Faith in the Lord later on. But it is all sin, it is all evil, it is all rebellion. And it all has its roots in the sin nature that we acquired from Adam. About Nimrod, I also don't quite see what you say in the Bible. The Scripture seems rather unmistakable about the fact that it was the whole world that united in the matter of Babel. Otherwise, who did God turn into nations? If it was only Ham's descendants who fomented that rebellion, are they the only ones that God created the nations out of? In fact, Genesis 10:32 and 11:1 stoutly refutes this. It was the whole world that rebelled, and they were the ones out of whom the Lord separated out the nations to prevent such madness until the time of the Antichrist. As for the Council of Jamnia, I'm not sure what your argument here might be, but it seems clear to me that nobody could possibly decide what is Scripture and what is not. If they could, well, how on earth could anyone be sure what God is saying and what He is not? Scripture identifies itself. Not only does the Bible teach that, but it makes sense that it should. In fact, I thought that you might be saying that, so my comment was to support you and strengthen your argument, but perhaps I was wrong. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 8:59pm On Sep 30, 2019 |
Ihedinobi3:Lol you were not wrong. I appreciate your responses |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 9:08pm On Sep 30, 2019 |
budaatum:Do you have an alternative explanation to the mystery of how humans and animals came to exist? With evidence of course. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by budaatum: 9:26pm On Sep 30, 2019 |
missjo:There is no evidence that I can give you missjo that you can not find out for yourself, everyone knows in their own heart how much evidence they themselves have witnessed or studied or know of. But I am an advocate of evolution, the gradual coming into being over time. A thread has been provided with very useful contributions if you don't mind digging through our usual nairaland bad behaviour. Warning, understand! Evolution 101
|
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 7:06am On Oct 01, 2019 |
budaatum:Lol,i know about the theory of evolution and have read a bit about darwinism before now. Which is why i added 'with evidence'. It is scientific mumbo jumbo. The same scientific world that could not agree on an explanation as to how the universe, galaxies, and solar systems came to exist suddenly can explain human evolution. Think about it budatuum, nothing creates itself. If cellular form is indeed the beginning of human & animal evolution, who or what created these cells? |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by budaatum: 9:40am On Oct 01, 2019 |
missjo:I somehow doubt you know about evolution or read any Darwin missjo and how science works, or you would not be refering to it as "mumbo jumbo", nor would you describe evolution as "creating itself". But, that's ok. You think what suits you. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by herakles: 9:45am On Oct 01, 2019 |
missjo:should I say this is ignorance?! interpret the Bible literally at your own peril! you will only stumble and be derailed from the truth |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 10:24am On Oct 01, 2019 |
herakles:Blessed be the fruit |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by missjo(op): 10:42am On Oct 01, 2019 |
budaatum:Lol,okay |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by budaatum: 3:25pm On Oct 01, 2019 |
|
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by Ihedinobi3: 5:39pm On Oct 02, 2019 |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by olaboy33(m): 11:29am On Oct 08, 2019 |
missjo:This is what happens when we attribute the works of man to the supreme being. Confusion! as against the perfection of the supreme being. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by Babacele: 10:53am On May 31, 2020 |
budaatum:Darwin was a genius but far ahead of a religiously opiated world and material science. God bless the masters who through that wonderful Rosicrucian, Blavatsky, opened the curtain of unblemished truth in' Isis unveiled'. A special portrait of Blavatsky must adorn my bedroom very soon. Let the world be fooling until the realities of time shocks it into sense. For example, when many gays ,from nature's genetic pool, are being given birth to into pastors home, gleefully would I await their reactions and action vis a VI's their present stands. |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by RuggedSniper: 5:47pm On Jul 05, 2020*. Modified: 12:35am On Jul 06, 2020 |
sonmvayina:^^WORD! PLAGIARIZED FROM THE 'EPIC OF GILGAMESH' AND OTHER ANCIENT SOURCES. I HAVE KNOWN ABOUT THIS SINCE THE 1990s. Cyrus the Great of Persia (and the anointed of the bible god)... who was a Zoroastrian and the 'King of Kings' in the book of Ezra, created Judaism via Ezra a Persian Magi... an agent of Cyrus. Magis are the chief priests of the Zoroastrian religion of PERSIA. Ezra is the allegorical Moses! The use of burnt clay tablets by the Moses is anacronistic and only used by the Babylonians, Sumerians, Persian Empire...(Egyptians used papyrus not burnt clay tablets) Pharisees is the main branch of Judaism derived from the word Parsi or Persia or Iran!Cyrus Cylinder burnt clay wordings are very similar to the book of Ezra. Iran is the origin of Judaism. Why did the bible God refer to Cyrus 'as my anointed?' Because Judaism is an imperfect copy of the Zoroastrian religion of Cyrus who was the colonial master of the ancient Israelites who worshipped many Gods. 'El' originally means many Gods NOT one God which was introduced by the Persians. The journey from Egypt and the 40 years in the wilderness never took place. NO grand kingdom of David or the walls of Jericho according to Prof. Ze'ev Hertzog an Israeli archaeologist... Neil Silberman in the book he co-wrote entitled: (The Bible Unearthed) also said the same and MORE! I Hope this helps everyone reading this. Cc: missjo, budaatum. @Kobojunkie... Why was there a resistance to the building of a new temple in Jerusalem by some people during the time of Ezra and the Persian Empire conquest? Because they were bringing a new religion or doctrine from Persia, even t though there was propaganda talk of restoring the religions of the conquered peoples. This is a reply to the question you asked me on page 2 nof this thread today. Again many similarities between the Zoroastrian and Jewish doctrines exist and the old testament reeks of this! Esther's uncle was a cup bearer for the king of Persia. Only ZOROASTRIAN Magis or Priests can act as a cup bearers. Rabbis and Magis also dressed alike. Pharisee is derived from the word Parsi (Persia or modern Iran). |
| Re: A Response To The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden's Account Of The Fall by sonmvayina(m): 6:54pm On Jul 05, 2020 |
RuggedSniper:Exactly what I have been teaching.. Research they will not, they will use small data to come here and use the rest to watch porn.. |
10 Things You Should Know About The Garden Of Eden • See The Country Where Garden Of Eden Is Located... (photos) • The Allegory In The Garden Of Eden Account Of The Fall Of Man By Reno Omokri • 2 • 3 • 4
Shiloh 2020 : Turnaround Encounters Dec 8-13th • Receiving Revelation In The Word Of God • The Truth Most Christians Dont Know




in there
interpret the Bible literally at your own peril! you will only stumble and be derailed from the truth