Imagine someone like Prophet Muhammad appearing today, someone who...

1. Came out from a room and claim he's a Prophet with updated revelation

2. Fight wars with unbelievers till they believe

3. Doesn't have scientific knowledge

4. Keep slaves

5. Kill apostates, homosexual, adulterers

6. Talk to animals and fairies, claim to ride on unicorn to Neverland

7. Tell Disney stories and other fairy stories

8. Talk about how you will enjoy in Neverland

9. Tell people to believe in Lord FSM

10. Tell people to come to New York for pilgrimage

11. Tell women to wear PPE everyday even under the sun.

Etc.

Be sincere, will you believe in such Prophet? If yes why, if no why?

You're going nuts already!

AntiChristian:
You're going nuts already!

Yeah, sounds like what you believe in?

AntiChristian:
You're going nuts already!

Youre angry because you knew the life Muhammad lived is not worthy of emulation.

Do you want to be like Muhammad in acts and deeds?

tintingz:


Yeah, sounds like what you believe in?

Pele, frustrated soul! Just don't commit suicide.

AntiChristian:


Pele, frustrated soul! Just don't commit suicide.

Why are you trying so hard to project me badly.

AntiChristian:


Pele, frustrated soul! Just don't commit suicide.

Like Muhammad who wanted to commit suicide by trying to throw himself down a mountain

"Prophet (peace be upon him) became so sad as we have heard(come to know) that he intended several times to throw himself from the tops of high mountains and every time he went up the top of a mountain in order to throw himself down..."
Sahih Bukhari 9:87:111

I will only make sure he is prosecuted for owning black people as slaves if he appears today

#Black Life Matters

The messenger of God, may peace be on him demonstrated qualities and utilized methods that enabled the success of his mission of spreading Islam at the time, first among his close associates, then his tribe, and then the whole Arabian peninsula. If he had been sent in this age, he would have displayed similar characteristics and employed strategies that would ensure the success of his mission.

For example we could also ask: if Alexander the great or Atila the Hun were to campaign in the present era with their horsemen, would they have built empires?
It wouldn't be so hard to follow the messenger in this age as the fundamentals of his character were those of compelling leadership bound to attract followers to fulfil the mission. Indeed the biography of the messenger should be studied along with the religion. How would one resist a man gifted with the most irresistible, charismatic, enigmatic character of his era.

A man most honest amongst his people who came with the message of Truth delivering the people from error and misguidance.
The man of beautiful appearance from the noblest of Arab tribes.
The man of honour imbued with the full complement of leadership qualities. The man of integrity, of honour, of great courage, of compassion, of strength, the man of vision, and matching strategy.

The most eloquent man with clarity of voice and message, speaking just enough words required to transmit the information, not loquacious.
A man of the highest standard of moral character, supremely courageous yet as shy as a young virgin girl. Like prophet Moses exemplary in several spheres of human endeavour; a loyal friend, a successful trader, a caring father, a loving husband, a great military commander. Beloved to muslims across ages ever since, blessed in life, honoured in the hereafter: Mohammed, may the peace and blessings of God be on him. A man with so many virtues except that we were warned to avoid praising him too much lest we fall into the error of raising him to the status of deity.

Clearly, had the messenger been sent in this era he would still have had faithful followers enlisted into the noble eternal truth of Islam.

tintingz:
Imagine someone like Prophet Muhammad appearing today, someone who...

1. Came out from a room and claim he's a Prophet with updated revelation

2. Fight wars with unbelievers till they believe

3. Doesn't have scientific knowledge

4. Keep slaves

5. Kill apostates, homosexual, adulterers

6. Talk to animals and fairies, claim to ride on unicorn to Neverland

7. Tell Disney stories and other fairy stories

8. Talk about how you will enjoy in Neverland

9. Tell people to believe in Lord FSM

10. Tell people to come to New York for pilgrimage

11. Tell women to wear PPE everyday even under the sun.

Etc.

Be sincere, will you believe in such Prophet? If yes why, if no why?

I would rather follow Hitler.

AntiChristian:
You're going nuts already!

He used to be a muslim until he saw the lies in Islam.

advocatejare:

Like Muhammad who wanted to commit suicide by trying to throw himself down a mountain

"Prophet (peace be upon him) became so sad as we have heard(come to know) that he intended several times to throw himself from the tops of high mountains and every time he went up the top of a mountain in order to throw himself down..."
Sahih Bukhari 9:87:111

The suicidal prophet.

true2god:
He used to be a muslim until he saw the lies in Islam.

O! That's why he became a Christian right?

advocatejare:

Like Muhammad who wanted to commit suicide by trying to throw himself down a mountain

"Prophet (peace be upon him) became so sad as we have heard(come to know) that he intended several times to throw himself from the tops of high mountains and every time he went up the top of a mountain in order to throw himself down..."
Sahih Bukhari 9:87:111

See your error in red! What kind of referencing is this for Bukhari? Ignorant ex-Muslim. Better stop bragging that you were once a Muslim. You were largely ignorant. And your ignorance keeps following you.

No, Like your God that sentenced his son to death by crucifixion.

true2god:
The suicidal prophet.

Like Samson right?

But wasn't Jesus too sent to be murdered too? And by his dad?

tintingz:


Yeah, sounds like what you believe in?

Even if your Muslim fams are aggressive that doesn't mean all of us are!

tintingz:

Be sincere, will you believe in such Prophet? If yes why, if no why?

I am amused how you failed to see that the 11 points you state above are what you believe about the Prophet Muhammad. Your misrepresentation shows you lack understanding.

Then you amuse me more by assuming the Prophet Muhammad who appears today will be like the Prophet Muhammad whom you believe appeared in the past, which shows you lack an understanding of time.

Then you ask if we would willingly forget all we have learned since the Prophet Mohammed appeared in the past and become like the people of the past; asking, basically, if we would deevolve.

We are not people of the past, tingz. The people of the past had much less knowledge than we have today and we have evolved in thought too, and a Prophet Muhammad of today would have had to also evolve to be any sort of Prophet at all and will not be like the Prophet Muhammad of the past, and if you bothered to scientifically use your own senses and evolve in understanding you will not misrepresent the Prophet Muhammad as you have in your false claims above.

tintingz:


Why are you trying so hard to project me badly.

You projected bad beliefs of your own first.

budaatum:

You projected bad beliefs of your own first.

You clearly don't know anything about Muhammad.

true2god:
I would rather follow Hitler.

Another worse human.

AntiChristian:


Even if your Muslim fams are aggressive that doesn't mean all of us are!

I simply asked questions, how my family come into this is something you're yet to tell me. If you can't address the topic kindly swerve.

tintingz:


You clearly don't know anything about Muhammad.

I clearly know quite a lot more than you know.

budaatum:

I am amused how you failed to see that the 11 points you state above are what you believe about the Prophet Muhammad. Your misrepresentation shows you lack understanding.

Then you amuse me more by assuming the Prophet Muhammad who appears today will be like the Prophet Muhammad whom you believe appeared in the past, which shows you lack an understanding of time.

Then you ask if we would willingly forget all we have learned since the Prophet Mohammed appeared in the past and become like the people of the past; asking, basically, if we would deevolve.

We are not people of the past, tingz. The people of the past had much less knowledge than we have today and we have evolved in thought too, and a Prophet Muhammad of today would have had to also evolve to be any sort of Prophet at all and will not be like the Prophet Muhammad of the past, and if you bothered to scientifically use your own senses and evolve in understanding you will not misrepresent the Prophet Muhammad as you have in your false claims above.

I clearly said Someone like Prophet Muhammad, that's the character of the person the OP is describing, but for argument sake let's me ask,

Questions,

1. Point out the misunderstanding of Prophet Muhammad in the listed?

2. How did you know such similar Prophet cannot appear today? Atleast Most Prophets have same theme.

3. You can clearly see I was using modern illustrations. Or you didn't see that?

4. Does God work with time? If so, why isn't the Qur'an and Muslims beliefs updated?

budaatum:

I clearly know quite a lot more than you know.

Mention things that prophet Muhammad didn't do in the OP list?

tintingz:


I simply asked questions.

No you didn't!

You set up some straw man then began an ad hominem attack against your own straw.


The Straw Man (also "The Straw Person" ""The Straw Figure" ) : The fallacy of setting up a phony, weak, extreme or ridiculous parody of an opponent's argument and then proceeding to knock it down or reduce it to absurdity with a rhetorical wave of the hand. E.g., "Vegetarians say animals have feelings like you and me. Ever seen a cow laugh at a Shakespeare comedy? Vegetarianism is nonsense!" Or, "Pro-choicers hate babies and want to kill them!" Or, "Pro-lifers hate women and want them to spend their lives barefoot, pregnant and chained to the kitchen stove!" A too-common example of this fallacy is that of highlighting the most absurd, offensive, silly or violent examples in a mass movement or demonstration, e.g. "Tree huggers" for environmentalists, "bra burners" for feminists, or "rioters" when there are a dozen violent crazies in a peaceful, disciplined demonstration of thousands or tens of thousands, and then falsely portraying these extreme examples as typical of the entire movement in order to condemn it with a wave of the hand. See also Olfactory Rhetoric.

tintingz:

Questions,

1. Point out the misunderstanding of Prophet Muhammad in the listed?

All of them are a misunderstanding of the teachings of tge Prophet Muhammad, and if you really want to know, I suggest you go read your Quran, after removing the ignorant bias that appears to blind you to understanding.

tintingz:
2. How did you know such similar Prophet cannot appear today? Atleast Most Prophets have same theme.

I do not know where you listen to your prophets that have "same theme" or any prophets at all to be honest, but in my own opinion, it is very unlikely that anyone with a brain in their heads would call anyone with "same theme", a prophet, so, I strongly suggest you change prophets or change brains.

tintingz:
3. You can clearly see I was using modern illustrations. Or you didn't see that?

Your "modern illustrations" show a lack of understanding of the original teachings of the Prophet Muhammed.

tintingz:
4. Does God work with time? If so, why isn't the Qur'an and Muslims beliefs updated?

Listen to your ignorance! Did not the second day follow the first and the sabbath come after the sixth day?

Are the "Qur'an and Muslims beliefs" God?

budaatum:

No you didn't!

You set up some straw man then began an ad hominem attack against your own straw.


The Straw Man (also "The Straw Person" ""The Straw Figure" ) : The fallacy of setting up a phony, weak, extreme or ridiculous parody of an opponent's argument and then proceeding to knock it down or reduce it to absurdity with a rhetorical wave of the hand. E.g., "Vegetarians say animals have feelings like you and me. Ever seen a cow laugh at a Shakespeare comedy? Vegetarianism is nonsense!" Or, "Pro-choicers hate babies and want to kill them!" Or, "Pro-lifers hate women and want them to spend their lives barefoot, pregnant and chained to the kitchen stove!" A too-common example of this fallacy is that of highlighting the most absurd, offensive, silly or violent examples in a mass movement or demonstration, e.g. "Tree huggers" for environmentalists, "bra burners" for feminists, or "rioters" when there are a dozen violent crazies in a peaceful, disciplined demonstration of thousands or tens of thousands, and then falsely portraying these extreme examples as typical of the entire movement in order to condemn it with a wave of the hand. See also Olfactory Rhetoric.

Not even close to strawman, again it was a question and I didn't posited to it. Everything listed was what Muhammad did, so if such person existed today, would you follow such person? It's a simple yes and no and also give your reasons, it's an open question!

tintingz:


Everything listed was what Muhammad did,

Everything listed was what you believe Muhammad did because you lack understanding.

budaatum:

All of them are a misunderstanding of the teachings of tge Prophet Muhammad, and if you really want to know, I suggest you go read your Quran, after removing the ignorant bias that appears to blind you to understanding.

Mention them.

I do not know where you listen to your prophets that have "same theme" or any prophets at all to be honest, but in my own opinion, it is very unlikely that anyone with a brain in their heads would call anyone with "same theme", a prophet, so, I strongly suggest you change prophets or change brains.

Prophets call themselves Prophet. So if someone as mentioned in the OP appear today that he's a Prophet would you follow him?

Your "modern illustrations" show a lack of understanding of the original teachings of the Prophet Muhammed.

Tell us what you know?

Listen to your ignorance! Did not the second day follow the first and the sabbath come after the sixth day?

Are the "Qur'an and Muslims beliefs" God?

Is Qur'an not the word of God?

budaatum:


Everything listed was what you believe Muhammad did because you lack understanding.

Ok, make me understand, tell me what he didn't do as mentioned in OP?

tintingz:


Ok, make me understand, tell me what he didn't do as mentioned in OP?

No tingz. Islam does not teach messianism. Islam teaches self salvation, so I will not waste my time telling you anything of the sort.

You will go pick up your Quran and read it to understand if you really want to know. You must do the work to get the gains is the lesson being taught with "neverland".

tintingz:


Prophets call themselves Prophet. So if someone as mentioned in the OP appear today that he's a Prophet would you follow him?

Am I to understand that you would allow a self certified surgeon perform surgery on you?

Or is it your claim that others would, or should?

tintingz:
Is Qur'an not the word of God?

Do you really expect that I would bother to take you up the mountain again, tingz?