₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,119 members, 8,521,196 topics. Date: Thursday, 19 November 2026 at 04:20 AM

Toggle theme

Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer - Politics (4) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer (40842 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 6 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by babajero(m): 12:00am On Aug 18, 2020
ionsman:
He was not disqualified before the election.
Go check again, the man who filed the case at the tribunal was disqualified by inec that was why his name was omitted from the ballot. go and read dissenting verdict of the chairman of the tribunal.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by evil1:
Microfels:
Assuming the judgment is not vacated by the appellate courts APC candidates will still not be able to contest. Lose- lose situation.
Only in a rerun election will APC not be eligible to contest but in a fresh election, its like the previous one never took place. so APC can contest if a fresh election is properly allowed.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by babytoun: 12:19am On Aug 18, 2020
seunmsg:
APC will support another party. Period.
waste of time and money ...no other party can defeat pdp in Bayelsa.....who will even fund the candidate?
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by AmazingELixir: 12:23am On Aug 18, 2020
ionsman:
Okay... In 1999, the election of Muazu was set aside by the tribunal and the appeal court because his deputy governor presented forged certs. A new election was conducted and Muazu participated alongside a new deputy governorship candidate and he won. What’s the difference between then and now?
READ AND BE ENLIGHTENED YOUNGMAN

" Plain Explanation of the differences between Adamu Muazu’s and the Bayelsa Scenario:
(a) Adamu Muazu’s case under reference was an ELECTION PETITION, a Post-Election matter; so the Tribunal had the jurisdiction under section 140(2) Electoral Act (Supra) to NULLIFY the election and order a rerun.
On the other hand, the BAYELSA State CASE (involving David Lyon’s Deputy) was a PRE-ELECTION case; the court had NO jurisdiction (in a pre-election matter) to nullify the entire election or to order a rerun. Only an ELECTION PETITION TRIBUNAL, properly constituted can nullify a general election or order a rerun in a general election. The regular court HAS NO such power.

(b) The ADAMU MUAZU case was an INTER-PARTY CASE (matter between two candidates of different political parties, arising from the general election)
The Election Tribunal in an inter-party perition/case has the power to nullify the general election and order a rerun. On the other hand , the Bayelsa case was an INTRA-PARTY case (a matter that relates entirely to the affairs of ONE political party, and not arising from the general elections). The court in an INTRA-PARTY case DOES NOT HAVE any jurisdiction to nullify a general election or order a rerun.

(c) The ADAMU MUAZU case was a POST-ELECTION matter (a case instituted after the conduct of a general election and relating directly to the GENERAL election) while the Bayelsa case was a PRE-ELECTION matter (a case filed before the conduct of the general elections and not arising from the general elections)

(d) The question relating to whether a candidate is qualified to contest a general election is both a ground for a PRE-ELECTION suit/case and also a ground for an ELECTION PETITION. When raised in a PRE-ELECTION MATTER, it can NEVER lead to nullification of the entire general election; it can only lead to nullification of the candidacy of the affected person. Exactly this is what happened in the Bayelsa case. On the other hand, when raised in an ELECTION PETITION, it can lead to NULLIFICATION of the entire general election; when in an ELECTION PETITION an election tribunal finds that a candidate in a general election or the person who was declared winner of the general election was NOT QUALIFIED to contest the general election, the only order the tribunal can make is to NULLIFY the election and order a rerun —- section 140(2) of the Electoral Act. Exactly this is what had happened in the ADAMU MUAZU case.

(e) It is because the Election Petition Tribunal in the ADAMU MUAZU case had NULLIFIED the General election and ordered a rerun, that was why Mr. ADAMU MUAZU even had the opportunity and LOCUS to approach the Supreme Court before date of the rerun, to BEG the Supreme Court to permit him to nominate another Deputy and still be able to participate as a candidate in the proposed rerun election. On the other hand, in the Bayelsa case, the Supreme Court DID NOT nullify the Bayelsa governorship election and did not order a rerun. So, there is no way David Lyon can have the LOCUS standi to take an application before the Supreme Court asking to be allowed an opportunity to nominate another deputy. The order of the Supreme Court in the bayelsa case leaves no one in doubt: INEC should go and give Certificate of Return as Governor of Bayelsa State, to the next candidate that has the majority of LAWFUL votes and meets the constitutional requirements.” Note that lawful votes must exclude wasted votes. Wasted votes are votes cast for a nonexistent candidate or for an illegal candidate or for a political party that has no candidate or whose candidate is not qualified.

(f) In the ADAMU MUAZU case, the Tribunal (a) disqualified the deputy governor-elect or deputy governor, (b) rightfully nullified the general elections and (c) ordered a rerun. On the other hand, in the Bayesla case, the court, not a tribunal disqualified the deputy governor-elect, but DID NOT (because it could not) nullify the general elections and it DID not order a rerun. In conclusion, on this this point, those who hold the view that the ADAMU MUAZU scenario is SIMILAR or the same as the Bayesla scenario are merely expressing their ignorance of the law. The fact that one is a Post-Election Matter while the other is a Pre-Election Matter leaves a a fundamental distinction between the two."
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Kingspin(m): 12:29am On Aug 18, 2020
Another AA Party loading in Bayelsa
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by smallsmall: 12:30am On Aug 18, 2020
He said the order for a fresh election within 90 days does not translate into beginning the electoral process afresh and for the substitution of candidates.

He argued that the Supreme Court verdict on the APC and its candidates remains binding despite a fresh election being conducted.

“One of the implications of the Judgment of the Bayelsa Governorship Tribunal nullifying the election of Governor Douye Diri assuming if not vacated by the Supreme Court is that in the event of fresh election the APC is still excluded from participating in view of the supreme Judgment declaring their nomination of David Lyon and his deputy as invalid,” the spokesman of the Coalition of United Political Party (CUPP).
Story, Story! Whose Implications? PDP implications? shocked grin grin

This Ikenga Ugochinyere calls himself a "Lawyer" and he does not know the meaning of the phrase FRESH elections? shocked shocked

FYI Mr. Charge and bail Lawyer, "FRESH" means start all over again, cancel what was in place, Bin it and start all over again.
Infact, English users use the phrase "Start Afresh" to show that you go back to basis.


If it is the fact that APC will now be in a position to contest the election that is paining you Mr. lawyer, dont worry, they may still lose but you cant stop APC from participating, just like the Tribunal just said, in the case of the De-registered Parties.. undecided grin grin
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by seunayantokun(m): 12:31am On Aug 18, 2020
seunmsg:
Very correct to the extent that APC cannot participate. However, APC can decide to support the candidate of another party who will then decamp to the party after election. The party may also explore the possibility of getting one of the candidates of the smaller parties to withdraw and then substitute with David Lyon.
A candidate cannot be nominee of two parties. So, your last option is not accommodated in law of Nigeria
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by smallsmall: 12:31am On Aug 18, 2020
All these our Judges sef, they churn out Decisions "in isolation", as if they are drunk or stoned on Sambissa weed. grin
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Wisfem: 12:31am On Aug 18, 2020
LandMann:
If this case gets to supreme court, the supreme court may just want to save face by throwing out the case after robing the people of their democratic rights to elect their leader...

The precedent being set is going to be terrible for our democracy because everybody will start going to court to shop for favourable judgement, making inec's job a mere academic exercise
Whilst what happened in IMO state till today was a total subversion subjugation and maltreatment of the will of the people and disregard to Electoral institution which worked tirelessly to conduct an Election in IMO state only to come back and learnt that their efforts has been rubbished by some rogue drunk men in the name of Justices to foist and imposed an unscrupulous dishonest man on the people.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by smallsmall: 12:40am On Aug 18, 2020
rangerover:
NEVER HAVE I SEEN A JUDICIAL SYSTEM SO TWISTED LIKE THAT OF NIGERIA. FROM IMO TO BAYELSA.
The Judiciary is one of the biggest problem of Nigeria, with the warped Constitution that they operate.
Most of them will be in jail, if we have a body like the FBI which monitors internal criminlaity, in Nigeria.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by ionsman: 12:43am On Aug 18, 2020
babajero:
Go check again, the man who filed the case at the tribunal was disqualified by inec that was why his name was omitted from the ballot. go and read dissenting verdict of the chairman of the tribunal.
Oh! Got you now. Thought you were implying Muazu was disqualified before the election.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Taleheart: 1:09am On Aug 18, 2020
�BREAKING ::

APC's Fate In Bayelsa �

Section 33 And 35 Of The Electoral Act Clearly States That The APC Can Contest In The Fresh Elections. APC Deputy Governorship Candidate In Bayelsa Can Withdraw His Nomination At least 45 Days Before The Elections. The Court Ordered A Fresh Elections Conducted In 90 Days.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Emyogalanya: 2:46am On Aug 18, 2020
seunmsg:
The party may also explore the possibility of getting one of the candidates of the smaller parties to withdraw and then substitute with David Lyon.
this is just what the lawyer explained which you agreed and yet you contradict it again in one single post. The ruling does not allow for withdrawal and subtitution. Did you miss it out?
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by galaxy2020(m): 4:30am On Aug 18, 2020
You want this govt to still borrow from China to organise another election? Buhari will not like it, though ugochinyere is right.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Validated: 4:37am On Aug 18, 2020
evil1:
Only in a fresh election will APC not be eligible to contest but in a fresh election, its like the previous one never took place. so APC can contest if a fresh election is properly allowed.
With who as deputy governor? disqualified one or INEC will revert to nomination? Stupid analysis. APC is not contesting again, just stop giving yourselves FALSE hope!
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Validated: 4:44am On Aug 18, 2020
ionsman:
You’re very stup1d! Who’re you calling young man? You must be a halfwit.
See sefia pain ooo. Is Lyon your brother? Sorry!
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Endurance28: 5:35am On Aug 18, 2020
APC's Fate In Bayelsa �

Section 33 And 35 Of The Electoral Act Clearly States That The APC Can Contest In The Fresh Elections. APC Deputy Governorship Candidate In Bayelsa Can Withdraw His Nomination At least 45 Days Before The Elections. The Court Ordered A Fresh Elections Conducted In 90 Days.




backbone503:
Thats his own side of the story. There are always 3 sides (interpretations) to every legal issue. The one that favours you, the one that dosent, and what the law actually says.

If/when the Apex court finally affirms the Tribunal's verdict, APC will know what to do. Diri is enjoying a stolen mandate, and it can be reclaimed, either via the main door, back door or window.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Endurance28: 5:36am On Aug 18, 2020
APC's Fate In Bayelsa �

Section 33 And 35 Of The Electoral Act Clearly States That The APC Can Contest In The Fresh Elections. APC Deputy Governorship Candidate In Bayelsa Can Withdraw His Nomination At least 45 Days Before The Elections. The Court Ordered A Fresh Elections Conducted In 90 Days.



simigold:
I disagree Mr lawyer. The only implication is that the legal tussle will start afresh. This means all parties will participate in the election with their respective candidates including APC and the disqualified deputy. By virtue of the judgement, all parties maintain status quo. If APC wins again, then the legal battle to disqualify the deputy starts afresh. QED
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by kahal29: 5:37am On Aug 18, 2020
garfield1:
To the extent that it is a pre election issue.if qualification issue can be post election,why not exclusion? By my own understanding, all matters that arose after primaries can be taken to a tribunal
That's the position of the law

Section 138 (d)

Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by backbone503(m): 5:55am On Aug 18, 2020
Endurance28:
APC's Fate In Bayelsa �

Section 33 And 35 Of The Electoral Act Clearly States That The APC Can Contest In The Fresh Elections. APC Deputy Governorship Candidate In Bayelsa Can Withdraw His Nomination At least 45 Days Before The Elections. The Court Ordered A Fresh Elections Conducted In 90 Days.
We just hope that the Supreme court gets to uphold the Tribunal's decision. And also that the ANDP's candidate and his legal team don't get pressured to compromise their case.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by seunmsg(m): 6:35am On Aug 18, 2020
seunayantokun:
A candidate cannot be nominee of two parties. So, your last option is not accommodated in law of Nigeria
David Lyon was never nominated by any party. APC never participated in the election at all as far as the election is concerned.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by seunmsg(m): 6:40am On Aug 18, 2020
Emyogalanya:
this is just what the lawyer explained which you agreed and yet you contradict it again in one single post. The ruling does not allow for withdrawal and subtitution. Did you miss it out?
Go back and read my post clearly. I agree with the lawyer that APC cannot participate in the election under any condition. However, it is wrong to conclude blankly that substitution can no longer be done. Unforeseen circumstances can still allow parties to substitute candidates. It happened in 2007 when AD was allowed to change its presidential candidate and also in Kogi in 2015 when Audu was substituted with Yahaya Bello even after commencement of the election.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by garfield1: 6:41am On Aug 18, 2020
kahal29:
That's the position of the law

Section 138 (d)
Kahal,thank you.fergie,once again kahal has finished the matter.I told you to end the matter.section 138 d clearly shows that the matter is a post election matter and the tribunal had jurisdiction. I didn't even have to look at any law but simply used commonsense before this law vindicated me.
The next matter is whether inec had the power to disq or not
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by rolams(m): 6:58am On Aug 18, 2020
seunmsg:
Can you explain the basis upon which the chairman of the tribunal based his minority judgement on?
INEC expunged the party because the party nominated a 34 years old candidate as deputy governo and INEC has forwarded a letter to the party in respect to this. No changes was made by the party before the substitutional time frame lapsed.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by AAA593: 7:02am On Aug 18, 2020
Appeal Court dismisses suits seeking to nullify Bayelsa, Kogi gov elections
Published

‌
Ihuoma Chiedozie, Abuja


The Court of Appeal in Abuja has dismissed the case brought by the Action Peoples Party challenging the propriety of the last governorship elections held in Bayelsa and Kogi states.

The court dismissed the case shortly before hearing the applications by interested parties, who sought to be made parties in the case.

The parties who sought to be joined include the Bayelsa State Governor, Douye Diri; his deputy, Lawrence Ewhrudjakpo; their party, the Peoples Democratic Party; the Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello and his party, the All Progressives Congress.


The applicants, who sought to be made parties in the appeal by the APP are the current beneficiaries of the elections, who would have been affected by the outcome of the case.

The APP had dragged the Independent National Electoral Commission before the Federal High Court, Abuja, querying the exclusion of its candidates.

In the suit marked: FHC/ABJ/CS/1163/2019, the party claimed that INEC prevented it from replacing its candidates earlier disqualified by the electoral umpire.


It particularly prayed the court to among others, declare that any subsequent conduct of the 2019 Kogi and Bayelsa states’ governorship election without the replaced candidates of the plaintiff, is null and void by reason of such exclusion.

The Abuja FHC gave its judgment against the APP, and proceeded to uphold the decision by INEC to reject the candidates’ replacement list submitted to it by the party on the grounds that the list was brought outside the stipulated time.


Justice Ijeoma Ojukwu, in the judgment delivered on February 21, 2020, maintained that INEC was right to have excluded candidates of the party (APP) from participating in the governorship election in Kogi and Bayelsa states in 2019.

Ojukwu was of the view that the APP replaced its withdrawn candidates outside the statutory period of 45 days to the date of the 2019 Kogi and Bayelsa states’ governorship election.

Disputing the Abuja FHC ruling, the APP appealed to the Court of Appeal, Abuja.


The appeal was however dismissed in a ruling by a three-member panel led by the Acting President of the court, Justice Monica Dongban-Mensem.


The court had scheduled hearing for Thursday on all pending applications and the substantive appeal.

Shortly after the appeal was called and lawyers to parties announced their appearances, the appellant’s lawyer, Obed Agwu, announced his intention to withdraw the appeal.

Agwu said, “The appellant is desirous to withdraw the appeal against the respondent.


“We have filed a notice of withdrawal of the appeal, in accordance with Order 11, Rule 1 of Court of Appeal Rules, 2016.

“The said notice of withdrawal is dated and filed on April 14, 2020.”

Counsel to INEC, Alhassan Umar, SAN, said he was served with the said notice of withdrawal in the court, adding that his client ‎will be asking for a cost of N3m.

Justice Dongban-Mensem relied on Order 11 Rule 5 of the Court of Appeal Rules to dismiss the appeal.

However, Dongban-Mensem rejected the respondents’ prayer for cost against the appellant.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/punchng.com/appeal-court-dismisses-suits-seeking-to-nullify-bayelsa-kogi-gov-elections/%3famp=1
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by rolams(m): 7:02am On Aug 18, 2020
Endurance28:
APC's Fate In Bayelsa �

Section 33 And 35 Of The Electoral Act Clearly States That The APC Can Contest In The Fresh Elections. APC Deputy Governorship Candidate In Bayelsa Can Withdraw His Nomination At least 45 Days Before The Elections. The Court Ordered A Fresh Elections Conducted In 90 Days.
Not possible, a candidate that has been disqualified by the Apex court? He has no chance again because he had already taken part in the previous one!
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by rolams(m): 7:14am On Aug 18, 2020
Taleheart:
�BREAKING ::

APC's Fate In Bayelsa �

Section 33 And 35 Of The Electoral Act Clearly States That The APC Can Contest In The Fresh Elections. APC Deputy Governorship Candidate In Bayelsa Can Withdraw His Nomination At least 45 Days Before The Elections. The Court Ordered A Fresh Elections Conducted In 90 Days.
Wrong interpretation! The deputy had been involved in the election before, he got disqualified by the Apex court. So, why are you bringing this. The deputy did not die, got sicked or any appointment greater than that he was vying for but got disqualified. Stop giving APC a wrong hope.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by seunmsg(m): 7:15am On Aug 18, 2020
rolams:
INEC expunged the party because the party nominated a 34 years old candidate as deputy governo and INEC has forwarded a letter to the party in respect to this. No changes was made by the party before the substitutional time frame lapsed.
From what I read, the party forwarded a replacement to INEC immediately they got a letter from the commission that the initial VP nominee was not eligible. INEC still went ahead to disqualify the party despite the replacement. Two members of the tribunal disagreed with INEC’s decision and hence concluded that the party was unfairly excluded. There is also an existing court judgement that only the court can disqualify a candidate and not INEC.
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by AAA593: 7:21am On Aug 18, 2020
seunmsg:
From what I read, the party forwarded a replacement to INEC immediately they got a letter from the commission that the initial VP nominee was not eligible. INEC still went ahead to disqualify the party despite the replacement. Two members of the tribunal disagreed with INEC’s decision and hence concluded that the party was unfairly excluded. There is also an existing court judgement that only the court can disqualify a candidate and not INEC.
The replacement was out of time according to inec's time table
Re: Why APC Can’t Take Part In Fresh Bayelsa Poll - Lawyer by Akaujaa(m): 7:39am On Aug 18, 2020
How can a lawyer talk without quoting a single section of the constitution to support or back his claims?
1 2 3 4 5 6 Reply

Bayelsa Poll: I Would Have Relocated My Mother To Abuja If Diri Had Lost – GEJ • Bayelsa Poll: INEC Conducted One Of The Best Elections Ever, Says Gov Diri • Bayelsa Poll: INEC Restores Sylva’s Name On Candidates’ List • 2 • 3 • 4

Sambo Dasuki Wins FG At ECOWAS Court • FFK Disobeys Court Order Granting Precious Chikwendu Access To Her Kids (Photos) • Restructuring: Where Will The Extra South East State Come From? - Buhari