beautiful liar hu has heard it and wah u think of it
i think beyonce killed the video (in a good way) and she is better than shakira in dancing

http://www./video/x1bwkq_shakira-beyonce-beautiful-liar

i think das why did a video togther

jus to show
that am better than U
but on da real shakira moves her hips betta

ooh am not feelin da song though

WOW i reallyy like d song & da video
am sure d guys would have really liked more waist winding and more booty shaking though
these 2 women r really cool

The best duet as far as I'm concerned
check it out on yahoo! music
and tell what you think

hu do u reckon is better and hu dances better

not bad sha

wow the song and the clip is of the hook. they did a bang up job. Although beyonce was trying to overreact as ussual,  like trying to move them hips in her own way and trying to be better although she is not. But well what can we do beyonce will always be like that. Trying to be better than everyone.  Trying to sound like Mariah although she aint got no high voice or trying to dance like ciara although she aint got the moves. All the same shakira was natural and the song was cool. Bee tried also.  so hands up!!!

Bee and Shak

Stupid retarded song. Almost puked when i saw the video.

Queen B:

wow the song and the clip is of the hook. they did a bang up job. Although beyonce was trying to overreact as ussual, like trying to move them hips in her own way and trying to be better although she is not. But well what can we do beyonce will always be like that. Trying to be better than everyone. Trying to sound like Mariah although she aint got no high voice or trying to dance like ciara although she aint got the moves. All the same shakira was natural and the song was cool. Bee tried also. so hands up!!!

exuuuuuuse me beyonce aint trying to copy no one man she is been herself shes been singing when she was little how can u say she is trying to copy ciaria in dancing when she started the music industry and satarted dancing before ciaira came into the industry and besides they are do diffrent type of dancing ciaria is sort of a hip hop street dancer why beyonce is like them botty shakers and besides in the video beyonce but more enery to make the dance look good not just been sluggish if both of them where doing the same thing it would be shit trust so allow it man

song was nice, but who noticed that beyonce almost broke her waist when the song was about to end. plus check out her upgrade you video thot she danced alot better there its off the hook.

u just hating on her @ queenb & get a friggn life @ gbade.x! daT song is 'IT'

I loved the song so much, but since after seeing the video I kind[size=1pt].[/size]a lost interest. The video is rather boring.

cock teasing video and the last scene was totally not needed

Just too drab. There wasn't real colourfulness in the video.
For God's sake, why would I have to be looking at only two of them throughout the video?

well beyonce danced wicked she is the best

shakiRA IS BETTER off bey tried copying shakiras style through out u need 2 check out d making

wat r u saying b aint copying anyone she was just doing shakiras thing innit not copying her like saying she was begging it or sumthin' be is better man i dnt know why there is sooo much hate on her

honey let the haters hate ok, they know the truth they're all in denial,
everyone knows that B rocks!

yer innit haterz

i believe we all in-title to an opinion

wasn't dat supposed 2 be "entitled"?

duuuh she was doing shakiras thing that is why she had shakira in the video she wasnt copying she was just doing her thing that is why she had her in the video and they made it together leave b alone haterz!! get ur own life

choongtin:

duuuh she was doing shakiras thing that is why she had shakira in the video she wasnt copying she was just doing her thing that is why she had her in the video and they made it together leave b alone haterz!! get your own life

true talk ohhhh, so now haters stop hating

Can't Beyonce ever do something real? Always trying to exaggerate whatever she's doing._{*roll eyes*} I won't be surprised if she had a hip fracture after the video. Shakira was so cool in the video but just check out the way B was catwalking there

Seriously, I like B's songs but definitely can't stand her. She always wants to be seen and heard._{*roll eyes*} Y'all lovers of her please advise her to take it easy. She got talent but she gotta take the pace slowly and still do her thang! Aight?


Shakira is forever a better dancer! And a very cool person and down to earth. B is too fake and forceful! Tell her I said that

wasn't that supposed 2 be "entitled"?

thnk U gem87

that was da word i was lookin 4



yea beyonce
was tryin really hard at da end of da video
i tot she was gon break her hip dayumm

u're welcum

I think i love shakira and her music hips dont lie

the combination was ok but i think beyonce put shakira in this video becoz she toknowthat sheis as good as shakira in both singing and dancing. don't get me wrong she knows how to do them things but i thing shakira is better

bigbaby:

don't get me wrong she knows how to do them things but i thing shakira is better

Ouch!!!

i don't think there's anything "ouchy" abt dat,
it's a personal choice.

if u can do better than b then take a video of ur self dancing and put it on you tube then give us the link and we shall see but if u cant but ur head up ur arse and stop hating


hold tite b and her fans