Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,156,298 members, 7,829,693 topics. Date: Thursday, 16 May 2024 at 10:36 AM

Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela - Foreign Affairs (8) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Foreign Affairs / Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela (23072 Views)

Charles Antwi Tries To Kill Mahama, Ghanaian President (Photo) / Woman Strips Unclad To Hug Mandela Statue / Nelson Mandela Is Dead (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) ... (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by cap28: 8:40pm On Dec 14, 2013
rudedough:

You can curse Nigeria all you want but believe me Bro, i don't know who the hell Nkrumah Is but Nelson Mandela rings a bell to everyone. Even kids born in the New Millennium.

Please tell us about Nkrumah. Who was he and what did he do for Africans? grin grin Sorry i can't use Google, i want to hear about Nkrumah from the horses mouth.

Thanks

Its very worrying that anyone in Nigeria irrespective of their age can actually make the above statement without feeling embarrassed.

Its a bit like an American saying they don't know who the hell George Washington was.

or a black American saying they don't know who the hell Malcolm X was.
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by adconline(m): 9:05pm On Dec 14, 2013
Nkrumah who wanted to be a life president for life and was a divisive figure. Mandela spent 27yrs of his productive life in jail; came out; unified his country and forgave his oppressors. Nkrumah on the hand, introduced trade union act to crush trade unionists who opposed his policies; introduced detention act- which allowed security forces to detain opposition and trade unionists without trial. He made laws which made his party, the only party in the country and a life president. NKrumah never went to jail but crushed opposition.. Imagine that with Madiba's action of giving his jailers front row seating during his inauguration. Nkumah like Mugabe is the reason why Africa is a dark continent while Mandela is the shining light of what Africa needs to do to lift itself from poverty and underdevelopment
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Nobody: 9:42pm On Dec 14, 2013
cap28:

Its very worrying that anyone in Nigeria irrespective of their age can actually make the above statement without feeling embarrassed.

Its a bit like an American saying they don't know who the hell George Washington was.

or a black American saying they don't know who the hell Malcolm X was.


You should wear your cap of reasoning when you talk next time. Am i a Ghanian? Why in the world should i know about Ghana history? Let's ask Ghanians who Festus Okotie-Eboh is, shall we?
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by cap28: 9:54pm On Dec 14, 2013
rudedough:

You should wear your cap of reasoning when you talk next time. Am i a Ghanian? Why in the world should i know about Ghana history? Let's ask Ghanians who Festus Okotie-Eboh is, shall we?

I am not a Ghanaian either, do you need to be a Ghanaian to know who the founder of the OAU was, aren't you an African?

And please don't compare Okotie-Eboh who was a corrupt looter to Nkrumah.

2 Likes

Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by cap28: 10:31pm On Dec 14, 2013
adconline: Nkrumah who wanted to be a life president for life and was a divisive figure. Mandela spent 27yrs of his productive life in jail; came out; unified his country and forgave his oppressors. Nkrumah on the hand, introduced trade union act to crush trade unionists who opposed his policies; introduced detention act- which allowed security forces to detain opposition and trade unionists without trial. He made laws which made his party, the only party in the country and a life president. NKrumah never went to jail but crushed opposition.. Imagine that with Madiba's action of giving his jailers front row seating during his inauguration. Nkumah like Mugabe is the reason why Africa is a dark continent while Mandela is the shining light of what Africa needs to do to lift itself from poverty and underdevelopment

Where is your evidence that Nkrumah wanted to be a life president?

Why would a divisive person found an organisation which championed the cause of African unity ie the OAU?

The west hated Nkrumah becauase he was trying to elevate the African from a position of subservience, as a result he had many enemies within and outside Ghana and this is why he had to jail his enemies. Many of these people were agents of the west who were trying to remove him from office.

I respect Mandela for his selflessness, perserverance and endurance but I don't think it was right for him to allow a regime of brutal racists get away with the atrocities that they committed against the black people of south Africa. To make matters worse he even allowed them to hold on to everything that they stole from that country - that is no victory my friend.


Mugabe is hated by the west for the same reason that Nkrumah was hated by the west - he refused to be used as a puppet of western multinationals and banking interests.

In as much as Mandela did his best he was unable to deliver victory to his people in the form of jobs, land ownership and decent housing, what is the point of removing apartheid if Africans remain economically excluded?
South Africa today is one of the most unequal societies in the world and that should indicate to you that forgiving your oppressor is not the solution. Mandela did his best but even his best was not enough to overcome the mighty forces of white supremacy and capitalism.

Do you think Europeans would have forgiven Africans for killing thousands of their people? History has shown us that Europeans perpetrate violence against the weak, time and time again and expect the weak to forgive them, this should tell you one thing - only the weak forgive while the powerful abuse and exploit. This is an important lesson that many Africans have refused to learn from and as they say he who does not learn from history is doomed to repeat it .

We Africans are yet to understand that unless you can defend yourself from external aggression you will remain a target for abusers and exploiters.
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by PetroDolla2: 10:34pm On Dec 14, 2013
chucky234: What a clueless deluded discombobulated chronic birdbrain.

Hahahaha who is this disgusting piece of sh1t?

Your country is a giant sh1thole, inhabited by small pieces of sh1t like you, mudder fugger

Nigeria is a dustbin country because of fooools like you, modafaka

Suffering and smiling country omo naija generator republic grin

Is it my fault that 90% of you long-suffering mumus survive on less than $2 a day? Or how is it my fault that nurses in your dilapidated hospitals use light from their mobile phones to deliver babies at night because there is no power? And how is it my fault that your leaders don’t even respect you and treat you people like animals in a zoo?

No wonder your people are trooping to Ghana like Muslims rushing to Mecca

1 Like

Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by PetroDolla2: 10:54pm On Dec 14, 2013
eGuerrilla:

Are you just being deliberately obtuse?
What does it matter who quoted who.

I don't know who PetroDolla2 is, beyond the fact that he comes across as a narrow-minded micro-nationalist. The very antithesis of Nkrumaism. cheesy


Ma guy, just watch that stvpid mouth of yours,huh?

Yes, Nkrumah stood for pan-Africanism, which was a great concept for that era. As at today, pan-Africanism has long lost its appeal, so stop deceiving yourself. Just go through various posts and threads on naiaraland and you’ll be ashamed to be an African, not to talk of a pan Africanist. It is now completely irrelevant. Even the current leaders know that.

Thank God most discerning people see it now as an unrealistic concept. Shine your eyes

1 Like

Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by adconline(m): 10:54pm On Dec 14, 2013
cap28:

Where is your evidence that Nkrumah wanted to be a life president?

Why would a divisive person found an organisation which championed the cause of African unity ie the OAU?

The west hated Nkrumah becauase he was trying to elevate the African from a position of subservience, as a result he had many enemies within and outside Ghana and this is why he had to jail his enemies. Many of these people were agents of the west who were trying to remove him from office.

I respect Mandela for his selflessness, perserverance and endurance but I don't think it was right for him to allow a regime of brutal racists get away with the atrocities that they committed against the black people of south Africa. To make matters worse he even allowed them to hold on to everything that they stole from that country - that is no victory my friend.


Mugabe is hated by the west for the same reason that Nkrumah was hated by the west - he refused to be used as a puppet of western multinationals and banking interests.

In as much as Mandela did his best he was unable to deliver victory to his people in the form of jobs, land ownership and decent housing, what is the point of removing apartheid if Africans remain economically excluded?
South Africa today is one of the most unequal societies in the world and that should indicate to you that forgiving your oppressor is not the solution. Mandela did his best but even his best was not enough to overcome the mighty forces of white supremacy and capitalism.

Do you think Europeans would have forgiven Africans for killing thousands of their people? History has shown us that Europeans perpetrate violence against the weak, time and time again and expect the weak to forgive them, this should tell you one thing - only the weak forgive while the powerful abuse and exploit. This is an important lesson that many Africans have refused to learn from and as they say he who does not learn from history is doomed to repeat it .

We Africans are yet to understand that unless you can defend yourself from external aggression you will remain a target for abusers and exploiters.






Revisionist historian. Nkrumah prohibited trade unionism,jailed opposition candidates like J. B. Danquah. He promulgated 2 laws: trade unionist act and detention act. He campaigned and approved a one party state in Ghana, which outlawed other political parties and opposing views.What else do you need to show that he was a typical African megalomaniac? Founding OAU is like IBB/Abacha funding Ecowas/Ecomog even though they stifled and killed opposition members.Madiba is a once in a Millenium politician.
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by PetroDolla2: 11:00pm On Dec 14, 2013
rudedough:

You can curse Nigeria all you want but believe me Bro, i don't know who the hell Nkrumah Is but Nelson Mandela rings a bell to everyone. Even kids born in the New Millennium.

Please tell us about Nkrumah. Who was he and what did he do for Africans? grin grin Sorry i can't use Google, i want to hear about Nkrumah from the horses mouth.

Thanks
hyprocrite. It was convenient for you to refer to my insults and equally convenient for you to ignore the needless insult from your fellow mumugerian.

I only responded appropriately to that nigerian terrorists sh1thead who had the effrontery to attack me. you ignored his insult and dwelt on my justified response, huh? What kind of crap is that? Is that an act of stvpidity or an act of hypocrisy? Fvck ya all!
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Nobody: 11:17pm On Dec 14, 2013
PetroDolla2:

Ma guy, just watch that stvpid mouth of yours,huh?

Yes, Nkrumah stood for pan-Africanism, which was a great concept for that era. As at today, pan-Africanism has long lost its appeal, so stop deceiving yourself. Just go through various posts and threads on naiaraland and you’ll be ashamed to be an African, not to talk of a pan Africanist. It is now completely irrelevant. Even the current leaders know that.

Thank God most discerning people see it now as an unrealistic concept. Shine your eyes


I called you out because I consider you are an uncultured urchin, who has elected to hide behind Nkrumah's achievement to drop the type of cheap darts he (Nkrumah) would have objected to. If you have a problem with my characterization, grow up and lose your hypocritical glad rags!
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Nobody: 11:45pm On Dec 14, 2013
adconline: Nkrumah who wanted to be a life president for life and was a divisive figure. Mandela spent 27yrs of his productive life in jail; came out; unified his country and forgave his oppressors. Nkrumah on the hand, introduced trade union act to crush trade unionists who opposed his policies; introduced detention act- which allowed security forces to detain opposition and trade unionists without trial. He made laws which made his party, the only party in the country and a life president. NKrumah never went to jail but crushed opposition.. Imagine that with Madiba's action of giving his jailers front row seating during his inauguration. Nkumah like Mugabe is the reason why Africa is a dark continent while Mandela is the shining light of what Africa needs to do to lift itself from poverty and underdevelopment

Presented with few stark options by hostile imperial powers, after Ghana gained her independence, like Castro who was never a committed socialist to begin with, Nkrumah sought alliance with the more sympathetic eastern bloc of nations. Your charge about his embrace of a 'one party' government is valid, but needs to be situated within a context of (deadly) cold war politics - during a period where emerging nations in Africa were saddled with competing feudal interests, often at odds with the idea of nationhood.

As I opined in an earlier post, Nkrumah was certainly not without his faults. There were excesses, and he did allow a cult of personality to emerge. However, by viewing the events of that period through rose-tinted lenses which suit a particular narrative only, we ultimately cheapen our own history. This is no way to assess the achievements of complex individual whose pivotal role in the struggle against colonialism in Black Africa should be way beyond contention.

In my opinion, a balanced critique is only possible once one has reconciled local and national events of that period with the foreboding interests of colonial powers, who were bent on shaping our destinies for self-serving purposes.

If you know how the ANC was structured in the 1960s, for instance, you would understand that, at best, it could not have operated any differently from the CCP (Nkrumah's organisation), had the situation been reversed. It is to this extent that I am asking you to look at the bigger picture, bro.

"Colonialism is not satisfied merely with holding a people in its grip and emptying the native’s brain of all form and content. By a kind of perverted logic, it turns to the past of the oppressed people, and distorts, disfigures, and destroys it" ~ Fanon
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Jiggaman101: 12:58am On Dec 15, 2013
While I think they were both great leaders and no need to argue about who is the greatest. Mandela is famous because of the western world, is like the western world thinks for us. You can compare Mandela to MLK because they both forgave the whites after all the atrocities that they did to blacks. If you were to ask most black Americans they will tell you that Malcolm x was the most revered leader of that time.

The question I have for you all that keep saying Mandela is more popular and in the case of USA Martin Luther king.

Did Mandela really free South Africans? Are black South Africans living better than when they were under apartheid. The answer is no to be really free u have to be free, economically,mentally and physical, when u look at both black Americans and South Africans the are slaves because they depend on whites for these things. In the case of black South Africans they don't realize the origin of the problem so attack innocent african migrants.
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by thoth: 2:35am On Dec 15, 2013
drnoel: sometime I wonder how history remembers people. Kwame Nkrumah who was a dictator, wanted to be life president and only left the sit after a coup was used to force him out. Tell me, what dignity did that man have?

Who knows, for all we know history may later remember IBB, Abacha and OBJ as saviours of Nigeria
Nkrumah only served as prime minister for less than 3 years...how you people got to idea of his aspiration to be life president only shows how deep western propaganda has seeped into the african mind, same africans who refuse to write their own history.

1 Like

Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Oluabayomi1(m): 5:04am On Dec 15, 2013
Is nkrumah not d same thing as deaf n dumb in northern Nigeria?
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Nobody: 8:48am On Dec 15, 2013
Jigga_man101: Did Mandela really free South Africans? Are black South Africans living better than when they were under apartheid. The answer is no to be really free u have to be free, economically,mentally and physical, when u look at both black Americans and South Africans the are slaves because they depend on whites for these things. In the case of black South Africans they don't realize the origin of the problem so attack innocent african migrants.
What is it to you what Mandela did or didn't do for his country and people?! And since we are slaves and everyone else in the continent is economically free then the people in red have no business coming to our country seeking greener pastures!!

2 Likes

Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by soilsista(f): 10:42am On Dec 15, 2013
Tumisang: What is it to you what Mandela did or didn't do for his country and people?! And since we are slaves and everyone else in the continent is economically free then the people in red have no business coming to our country seeking greener pastures!!
Ke lame leo!!
Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Khin: 1:46pm On Jul 28, 2014
Mandela maybe have been popular because of the different ERA both lived. Mandela lived in the 21st century were Informations easily spread. Comparing the two I would say Nkrumah did Africa and Africans a great service, Mandela may be the greatest South African but definitely not the greatest African. I really do not know what Mandela did for Africa or Africans as a whole.

1 Like

Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Khin: 2:04pm On Jul 28, 2014
About Nkrumah wanting to be President for life. Even the famous Greek philosopher PLATO once said that DEMOCRACY was doomed and that the STATE should be run by a DICTATOR who has become enlightened through education and experience. Democracy is not for Africa, Countries in Africa should be run by dictators who are educated, enlightened and who has the country at heart.

2 Likes

Re: Ghanaian - Nkrumah Is Greater Than Mandela by Ifeanyi4491(m): 11:36pm On Apr 29
Who later won

(1) (2) (3) ... (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply)

Sam Brinton Accused Of Stealing (Pics) / German Citizens Can Now Change Their Gender & Name Every Year (Photos) / Iran Threatens To ‘review Nuclear Doctrine’ If Israel Attacks

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 59
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.