Abuzola says true Muslims don't celebrate their  birthdays  and that of their prophet yet Muslims all over the world celebrate the birthday of their prophet Mohammed.
It's even a public holiday in Nigeria (because of the Muslims there) and in most Muslim countries  known as Eidl Mulud (sp)
so are Nigerian Muslims and those who do this infidel Muslims and heretics ?

abuzola says

I told you those who do it are herectic like you miserable cross worshippers

 
What is the opinion of other Muslims on this forum?

Yeah i said so

$osisi:

Abuzola says true Muslims don't celebrate their birthdays and that of their prophet yet Muslims all over the world celebrate the birthday of their prophet Mohammed.
It's even a public holiday in Nigeria (because of the Muslims there) and in most Muslim countries known as Eidl Mulud (sp)
so are Nigerian Muslims and those who do this infidel Muslims and heretics ?

abuzola says

What is the opinion of other Muslims on this forum?

my advise to you is dont believe anything Abuzola Alzakawi says when it come to religion, he's looking forward to hell fire, beware.

birthdays are not events to be celebrated. Celebrate major achievements like when he/she says Laa ilaha ilallahu Muhammadanr Rasulullah (AS), etc, etc!

olabowale:

birthdays are not events to be celebrated. Celebrate major achievements like when he/she says Laa ilaha ilallahu Muhammadanr Rasulullah (AS), etc, etc!

Pathetic and very sad to hear a grown man think this way

whats pathetic about speaking the bitter truth? skyone, I hope you are okay?

Bismillahir-Rahmanir-Raheem.

Simply take it: celebrating birthdays is a bidi'a. What then is bidi'ah?

The word Bid'ah in Arabic is taken from ‘Al-Bada', that is to create something without precedence. Allah says in the Qur'aan, which translated means: “Badei' (the Originator) of the heavens and the earth.” (2: 117)

This means that Allah created the heavens and the earth without precedence. He also said: “Say (O Muhammad (sallallhu alahi wa-sallam): I am not Bid'an (a new thing) among the Messengers.” (46: 9)

This means: 'I am not the first of Allah's Prophets to His slaves, many (Prophets) preceded me.’ When it is said that a person has performed a Bid'ah, this means that he has innovated a new thing without precedence.

Bid'ahs in the matters of life, like the new scientific inventions are permissible because originally, what is a matter of life or habit is permissible. The prohibited Bid'ah is to innovate in the religion. This is because the religion is 'Tawqifiyah' which means that religion can only be revealed by Allah and He has completely revealed His religion. Consequently, there is no room for any innovation. As will be manifest and clear from the context of celebrating birthdays.

In short, its undoubtedly an act of imitating the kuffar (i.e. pagans, as shown any historical fact). And an authentic Hadeeth strongly denounces such practices.

Abu Waqid Al-Laithi (r.a) said: “We were still new Muslims when we went to the battle of Hunain with the Prophet (sallallhu alahi wa-sallam). We found that the Mushrikeen had a tree, called ‘That Anwar’, which they revered and on which they hanged their weapons on. When we passed by a similar Sidrah we said: “O Messenger of Allah (sallallhu alahi wa-sallam), make for us ‘That Anwar’ as they have, Prophet (sallallahu alahi wa-sallam) said: “Allahu Akbar! It is the Sunnan (traditions of the Mushrikeen). You said by He Who has my soul in His Hand, what the children of Israel said to Moses: “Make for us gods as they have gods. He said: 'Verily! You are a people who know not.” [7:138] and he (sallallahu alahi wa-sallam) said: You will follow the traditions of those before you (Jews and Christians)” [at-Tirmidhee]

In this hadeeth, we find that imitating the Kuffar (non-believers) is what drove Jews (before them), and some of the companions (radhi allahu anhu), to ask for this ugly matter. They wanted gods to worship and revere other than Allah. This is the case with the majority of Muslims today, imitating the disbelievers, which is an opening to ruthless Bid'ahs in Islam.

We can therefore draw a simple conclusion that Abuzola's assertion is apt and right.

and regarding Eid-Maulud and declaration of public holiday in Nigeria; you know the heterogeneity of the country, not doing so could cause bitter complains from some Muslims who do it. But that balances the equation. Period!

And Allah, the Exalted, knows best

I guess most of the most Muslims are fake then since they celebrate Mohammeds birthdays and theirs

sisi naija one of the ways for you to trim wasteful spending, and spend even more in more truly rewarding things, when you don on the hijab, down the road. the issue of prudency is addressed, subtlely without being over bearing.

@post :

Muslims think like psychotic donkeys. Why will you celebrate Muhammeds birthday (The Mafian boss) and not yours ?

Who is Muhammed anyway ? He is not a prophet in the first place.

Historically: according to the Quran, Ahadith, Arab & Islamic records, the spread of Muhammadan Islam in the Jazeera al Arabia - the Arabian Peninsula - was achieved by the shedding of a sea of Arabian blood to start with, followed later on with the Arabian conquests through the shedding of an ocean of blood of the conquered and subjugated peoples.

birthday is invalid,ignorance and blind followership leads to hereticism

t.truth:

@post :

Muslims think like psychotic donkeys. Why will you celebrate Muhammeds birthday (The Mafian boss) and not yours ?

Who is Muhammed anyway ? He is not a prophet in the first place.
Historically: according to the Quran, Ahadith, Arab & Islamic records, the spread of Muhammadan Islam in the Jazeera al Arabia - the Arabian Peninsula - was achieved by the shedding of a sea of Arabian blood to start with, followed later on with the Arabian conquests through the shedding of an ocean of blood of the conquered and subjugated peoples.

how is this warranted?

it is this kind of unguided utterance - provocation - that causes promblems if said to people who can't handle it.

One can imagine what a people with a hot temperament could do in the face of such unwarranted provocation.

, and then we wonder why there are many violent altercations in the north of Nigeria

a misguided provocation, a reaction (probably over-reaction), a counter (retaliation), on and on,

then we turn round and heap all the blame on the hot tempered people, the initial provocation all conviniently forgotten.

t.truth:

@post :

Muslims think like psychotic donkeys. Why will you celebrate Muhammeds birthday (The Mafian boss) and not yours ?

Who is Muhammed anyway ? He is not a prophet in the first place.

Historically: according to the Quran, Ahadith, Arab & Islamic records, the spread of Muhammadan Islam in the Jazeera al Arabia - the Arabian Peninsula - was achieved by the shedding of a sea of Arabian blood to start with, followed later on with the Arabian conquests through the shedding of an ocean of blood of the conquered and subjugated peoples.

A very provocating post,am very sure if this is done by a muslim the hypocrites will start shouting muslims are this and that.

t.tuth lemme tell u what u dont know what ever u say here on earth will surely be tied to ur neck on d judgement day, so u can continue with ur ignorant posts

@t.truth

Really i have read many of your contribution in the Religion section and truly i believe now that you are a Toddler and you need to Grow Up.

justfash50:

@t.truth

Really i have read many of your contribution in the Religion section and truly i believe now that you are a Toddler and you need to Grow Up.

Between me and you, who is a toddler ? You are an embryo

Arrow

JUST CONFINRMED . say whatever it has been confirmed

justfash50:

JUST CONFINRMED . say whatever it has been confirmed

Thanks for confirming that you are an embryo

:-x :p

@t.truth
I think this thread is for muslims only why do you have to intrude by posting? from your post I know you're not a muslim, then why do you have to cause chaos. I' m sure its your type that trigger religion crisis

As for me,i am a muslim and i dont see anything wrong in thanking Allah for making you witness a special day in your life and praying to him to witness more of the day to come. Moreover,to me, celebrating birthday is more like given sadaqah. on my bday, i prayed, give out food and snacks expecially to small children and i do same for my son ,so i dont see anything wrong in that.

Aolly:

As for me,i am a muslim and i dont see anything wrong in thanking Allah for making you witness a special day in your life and praying to him to witness more of the day to come. Moreover,to me, celebrating birthday is more like given sadaqah. on my bday, i prayed, give out food and snacks expecially to small children and i do same for my son ,so i dont see anything wrong in that.

If birthdays are to be celebrated, they should be celebrated with praises to Allah and sadaqah to the less privileged. It should not be spent wasting resources.

As fo that of the Prophet, it should be spent remembering his mission on earth ans thanking Allah for His mercies

Birthdays are usually celebrated according to the gregorian calendar which is not islamic. That could also be a way of acting like the unbelievers and this is strongly forbidden in Islam.

As salam to all my brothers and sisters
Some people are better left blabbing than been answered. . .
It's better you just let go of some cowards, one of these days, they might come to realize it.
Masallam!