lolz this question is been around for centuries ..let's Know your thoughts..


Many times when talking with non-believers, they will appeal to some sort of one-liner or meme to render their unbelief a more credible position than the reality of an omnipotent God. Nevertheless, although these one-liners seem credible to the untrained mind, they actually don’t work as arguments. The same goes with this riddle, which basically attempts to pit God against himself in asking, “Can God create a rock so heavy that he cannot lift it?”

so I invite all atheists ( wise ones only and open minded) theist (but not Christians ,)
and interested Christians

Christians friends., how do you Answer this?

Ferisidowu:
Christians friends., how do you Answer this?

i don't know if u mean the question literally or as a figure of speech.. I will answer in the literal sense.. the obvious answer is a "no". Reason being that God is eternal. And eternity breaks the barrier of time, space and matter. Weight/mass is a fraction of matter, lift(change in elevation of the object) is a fraction of space. Since Eternity breaks these three barriers of time, space and matter definitely the eternal God can never be limited by matter or space... QED...

salvation101:
i don't know if u mean the question literally or as a figure of speech.. I will answer in the literal sense.. the obvious answer is a "no". Reason being that God is eternal. And eternity breaks the barrier of time, space and matter. Weight/mass is a fraction of matter, lift(change in elevation of the object) is a fraction of space. Since Eternity breaks these three barriers of time, space and matter definitely the eternal God can never be limited by matter or space... QED...

oh thanks the question is originally mine....
to be sincere the question is foolish and lack logic, it's even contradictory

just that there are foolish atheists That delight in foolish questions lol
although not all :;
some still admit that the question is baseless

I brought it here so as to see how fellow Christians would answer...

thanks for your contribution...

also the question is meant to be taken literally..

lol

The answer is No and I do not mean the Christian idea of God.

ifenes:
The answer is No and I do not mean the Christian idea of God.

explain further please

Ferisidowu:


explain further please

A rock is physical and physical reality is a tiny aspect of existence. No matter how huge the illusionary rock is, it was imagined and cannot be compared to its source- The Mind. Even the Universe is a tiny feature of existence. Existence is all that is. What religion says God is is what existence is. Both are one and the same. If you exist, you aways will and have always existed. The reason why we are all God/Existence. A rock, no matter how big is nothing.

ifenes:


A rock is physical and physical reality is a tiny aspect of existence. No matter how huge the illusionary rock is, it was imagined and cannot be compared to its source- The Mind. Even the Universe is a tiny feature of existence. Existence is all that is. What religion says God is is what existence is. Both are one and the same. If you exist, you aways will and have always existed. The reason why we are all God/Existence. A rock, no matter how big is nothing.

hmm

Ferisidowu:
lolz this question is been around for centuries ..let's Know your thoughts..


Many times when talking with non-believers, they will appeal to some sort of one-liner or meme to render their unbelief a more credible position than the reality of an omnipotent God. Nevertheless, although these one-liners seem credible to the untrained mind, they actually don’t work as arguments. The same goes with this riddle, which basically attempts to pit God against himself in asking, “Can God create a rock so heavy that he cannot lift it?”

so I invite all atheists ( wise ones only and open minded) theist (but not Christians ,)
and interested Christians

This is called the Omnipotence paradox, a nonsensical paradox that shows people the absurdity of nonsensical concepts like Omnipotence

salvation101:
i don't know if u mean the question literally or as a figure of speech.. I will answer in the literal sense.. the obvious answer is a "no". Reason being that God is eternal. And eternity breaks the barrier of time, space and matter. Weight/mass is a fraction of matter, lift(change in elevation of the object) is a fraction of space. Since Eternity breaks these three barriers of time, space and matter definitely the eternal God can never be limited by matter or space... QED...

I think you miss the point of the paradoxical question.

Let me rephrase this question better.

Can God do something that he cannot undo

I think this is a better representation

johnydon22:


I think you miss the point of the paradoxical question.

Let me rephrase this question better.

Can God do something that he cannot undo

I think this is a better representation

he already answered dat d question was meant to be in the literal sense

Ferisidowu:


oh thanks the question is originally mine....
to be sincere the question is foolish and lack logic, it's even contradictory

just that there are foolish atheists That delight in foolish questions lol
although not all :;
some still admit that the question is baseless

I brought it here so as to see how fellow Christians would answer...

thanks for your contribution...

also the question is meant to be taken literally..

lol

Whatever you think you are doing is unfair.

rejosom:

Whatever you think you are doing is unfair.

how sir

johnydon22:


This is called the Omnipotence paradox, a nonsensical paradox that shows people the absurdity of nonsensical concepts like Omnipotence

oh really, let me hear more from you,><tell me more..

Ferisidowu:


how sir

The dribbling for that your comment dey excess...

The question is originally yours...

The question is a foolish one...

The question is baseless...

And now the question is to be taken literally.

salvation101:
he already answered dat d question was meant to be in the literal sense

Nope, the name of this exercise is the omnipotence paradox, the answered post picked a literal meaning to answer can only result in literal flaws even at that i can still juggle that literal answer to demonstrate the whole point of the exercise.

I only chose to rephrase the question so anyone who wish to answer will understand the actual meaning behind the question.

salvation101:
i don't know if u mean the question literally or as a figure of speech.. I will answer in the literal sense.. the obvious answer is a "no". Reason being that God is eternal. And eternity breaks the barrier of time, space and matter. Weight/mass is a fraction of matter, lift(change in elevation of the object) is a fraction of space. Since Eternity breaks these three barriers of time, space and matter definitely the eternal God can never be limited by matter or space... QED...

Then he is not all powerful!

rejosom:

The dribbling for that your comment dey excess...
The question is originally yours...
The question is a foolish one...
The question is baseless...
And now the question is to be taken literally.

thank you sir

johnydon22:


Nope, the name of this exercise is the omnipotence paradox, the answered post picked a literal meaning to answer can only result in literal flaws even at that i can still juggle that literal answer to demonstrate the whole point of the exercise.

I only chose to rephrase the question so anyone who wish to answer will understand the actual meaning behind the question.

r u more knowledgeable dan d examiner? D person who posted the question knew wat he wanted and made it clear here dat he meant it in d literal sense

salvation101:
r u more knowledgeable dan d examiner? D person who posted the question knew wat he wanted and made it clear here dat he meant it in d literal sense

lolx don't mind him

Ferisidowu:
lolz this question is been around for centuries ..let's Know your thoughts..


Many times when talking with non-believers, they will appeal to some sort of one-liner or meme to render their unbelief a more credible position than the reality of an omnipotent God. Nevertheless, although these one-liners seem credible to the untrained mind, they actually don’t work as arguments. The same goes with this riddle, which basically attempts to pit God against himself in asking, “Can God create a rock so heavy that he cannot lift it?”

so I invite all atheists ( wise ones only and open minded) theist (but not Christians ,)
and interested Christians

Can God become human?

tartar9:

Can God become human?

John chapter 1

Ferisidowu:
John chapter 1

YES or NO

tartar9:
YES or NO

what does John 1 say..
really disappointed, you... read John 1

Ferisidowu:


what does John 1 say..

really disappointed, you... read John 1

OK

John 1: When men strive together one with another, and the
wife of the one draweth near for to deliver her husband out of the hand of
him that smiteth him, and putteth forth her hand, and taketh him by the
secrets: 12 Then thou shalt cut off her hand, thine eye shall not pity her

tartar9:

OK

John 1: When men strive together one with another, and the
wife of the one draweth near for to deliver her husband out of the hand of
him that smiteth him, and putteth forth her hand, and taketh him by the
secrets: 12 Then thou shalt cut off her hand, thine eye shall not pity her

lolz can't you see it.... you are deluded FOOL

Ferisidowu:

lolz can't you see it.... you are deluded FOOL

You don't even know your bible..what a shame

tartar9:
You don't even know your bible..what a shame

thanks...

Ferisidowu:


thanks...

For telling you how the bible orders you to treat your wife or for not answering my simple question.No where in John is Jesus described as God or external with God

tartar9:

For telling you how the bible orders you to treat your wife or for not answering my simple question.No where in John is Jesus described as God or external with God

lolz you just a bag of problems....

I don't want to discuss with you... thanks

1Sharon:

Then he is not all powerful!

really?

1Sharon:

Then he is not all powerful!

really?