Politics › Re: Supreme Court To Hear David Lyon Appeal On Tuesday - The Cable News. by Dansuqi: 11:52pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
blasted12: I agree but why didn't his lawyers point that out in the original suit? They did but the judges discountenanced them |
Politics › Re: Supreme Court To Hear David Lyon Appeal On Tuesday - The Cable News. by Dansuqi: 11:51pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
tinsel: Lyon has a better chance. I am sure the deputy will present fresh evidence that he did not forge those documents. The same supreme court ruled that Mohammed is same as Mohammedu in the case of Buhari. The same supreme court ruled in the case of Adamu Muazu in 1999. Yes,with the way the high court rushed judgment,he can also claim that he was denied fair hearing and not given enough time to prove himself |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 11:45pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
mushystuff: Standard of proof is beyond reasonable doubt. PDP achieved that by showing the oddity of different names on different certificates yet claimed by one man and failure to use proper procedure for effecting corrections if names are claimed to have been mistaken.
Degi and his team were not able to disprove those facts and they are bound by them. The court is therefore convinced beyond all reasonable doubt that the certificates bear evidence of forgery. So that is the only evidence that can prove or satisfy the clause beyond reasonable doubt? |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 11:20pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
mushystuff: Discrepancies of such a fundamental nature amount to fraud and forgery. Why are you very careful in making sure that your name appears as is in your passport especially when you apply for a Visa? What does the constitution and evidence act provides for as the standard for proving forgery |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 11:12pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: I think they were charmed.
Apologies to stupid people, they can't even do something as silly as this. That is why i blamed the apc hierarchy.dropping ssce alone would have stopped all these |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:54pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
cckalima: i think that the court should start looking at sanctioning inec for not disqualifying that deputy abinitio,i suspect inec ploted the apc fall Inec lacks disqualification powers. |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:41pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
mushystuff: They proved their allegation by pointing out the discrepancies in the names on all certificates compared to his current name as deputy governorship candidate, the irregularities of using mere affidavits and a faceless, unknown notary public. That was the issue and not whether he got them from any institution or not. Is discrepancies now a crime or fundamental enough to prove forgery? Is pointing out same as proving beyond reasonable doubt |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:39pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: When they call for review....will they call the exam bodies? Will they also call the faceless Notary Public whatever?
Will he also justify why he had two affidavits in a day?
Drop it bro.... Yes,they can allow him to |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:26pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
cckalima: on the contrary you are missing a point here. to forge a certificate is to provide one for yourself where it does not exist in reality but here this man may have impersonated someone but again certificates are signed for before collection, has it been proved that he didnt finish from those institutions?if it was issued in proxy who collected it, are there no photograhs used in the registaration of these exams he wrote, its not fair to say he bought certificates when there are no proves. i think the defense tean didnt do s good job I align with you.that is why i said that the proofs were not conclusive.adeleke and lalong had same cases and won. I also blame the defense team,rookie lawyers going agsinst a seasoned san.lyon should have gotten at least yusuf alli,awomolo,akintola,dodo,Chris uche etc |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:24pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
Caseless: You have to give to Wole anyway. He earned my respect on rivers and akwa ibom elections in 2015. The same argument he pushed in rivers case was the argument he defeated in in akwa ibom case...and he won both cases. He lost in akwa ibom,he reprezwnted apc.he's the greatest lawyer on election cases |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:23pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
mushystuff: Actually, if there was any need to call the institution, that would have been APC's responsibility. However PDP was not arguing the authenticity or otherwise of those certificates, rather ownership was the crux of the matter because the name of the deputy Gov candidate did not match the documents he tendered at INEC. I hope you can see the difference? Pdp alleged so needed to proof.see atiku vs buhari 2019 supra. You need both documentary and verbal evidences.your arguments is the same thing,if there is discrepancies in names,it means that he may not be the owner. |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:20pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
maasoap: Upon all that, did any institution claim that they didn't know him? The answer is no. That's why we said that the man was merely punished for being irresponsible with names. The judge knew that those certificates were genuine and belonged to him. That is just it,this is crucial.forgery is a criminal case and must be proven beyond reasonable doubt.i think they have enough grounds to call for a review |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:06pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: Absolutely... You saw them even in osun and buhari vs gej 2011 supra |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:05pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: Imo....at worse a run-off..which I doubt.
I have the judgement but haven't read it.
But this one.....if you go further....you will expose Degi more, tbh.
How would you feel yourself, going to school....changing your names (for whatever reason), and yet you can't defend it? Let's be frank, the man don't have those papers....Oshiomhole knew but he felt "Insurance" cover them for Supreme Court and he didn't want to offend Sylva. We dont know if he has those papers or not.a good lawyer as i earlier said would have filled in the gaps and looked for technicalities to kill it. You are right,imo a total runoff in the interest of justice.you need to read that judgment including the minority judgment of fred oho.immediately i read it,i knew ihedioha was in trouble |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:03pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
mushystuff: So how do you reconcile the fact that there are now more votes than accredited voters? Because inec refused to add the accredited votes from those disputed units |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:02pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: Wrong....Ignorance is no excuse in the court of law....You and I know that. Pdp were supposed to call those authorities that issued the certificstes to testify |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 10:01pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: I would have expected that you guys must have tied Degi to a stake right now.
The evidence against him was too solid. How will you start defending such madness!? That is where ikpeazu comes in.mind you,there are so many loopholes and ambiguities in our laws that were not even aware of |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:58pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: It's not that....do you think the SC will go back on their Imo judgement? You know that won't happen....
They will find a leeway and heap the fault on Ihedioha's lawyers. They may based on public pressure and again this bayelsa issue.the last time they reviewed their judgment was 1999.maybe its about time |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:56pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
cckalima: my [b]brother even the institution that issued the certificates where not invited to make inputs as to the originality of the certificate. [/b]again before you enrole for any program or exams forms are filled, why didnt the defense team reach for those forms to see if the names on the form submited and receipts issued at point of purchase abinitio were the same. that would have largely proved in each instances that its the same person and that he was just a victim of his recklessness and ignorance I stated this severslly |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:52pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: Great....I gave him the first LIKE That is what I've been saying.the case could have gone either way.perhaps with better lawyers,arguments and facts with a different panel,we might have had another outcome.but based on what apc lawyers presented,ill go with the judges |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:49pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: Stop overhyping Uncle Wole....
Will the CJN disqualify PMB? Even if you lead that case, you will still win it.
Did Wole not represent Faleke...abegi This is wole's strongest points,he's very good when he's part of the defense but poor when he is repping the appellants.you need to study his antecedents |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:47pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
[quote author=AreaFada2 post=86682116]On evidence, they reasoned that someone vying for such a high office should be more consistent and trustworthy. Instead of trying to use various affidavits and unknown/unregistered notary public to justify names on certificates he's about to use at various times. Such discrepancies do not go well with the spirit of the law. He could easily have used a Deed Poll to change his names. That's more authentic as he can then use it to inform civil registry.
Fact is our system is not organised enough. Over 75% of people over 50 are probably guilty of incessant change of name, age declaration and such. If you examined older civil servants carefully, hardly anyone will go Scot free. Too much age reduction to stay longer in office.
[b]Had PDP/Diri just argued that the certificates were not his, they might have lost. But the discrepancies were overwhelming.[/[/b]quote]
I agree.they learn from atiku's mistake.instead of them to argue that buhari forged certificates,they said he had none |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:45pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: No grounds..... I think they are using this case to kill Imo.
Because the pdp is doing same, they want to. They are also citing the case of Adamu Mu'azu in 1999...holds no waters.
I will try to get more facts yet protect the individual. If you what I mean. You cannot compare imo to bayelsa.it see you don't know how bayelsa is even in terms of votes.apc will rather lose the entire nc than lose bayelsa |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:44pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
|
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:42pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
SpecialAgent: Bros, you really don't even need a lawyer to see the forgery here. Too many inconsistencies & the affidavit are all dated 2018!! This man was too careless Buhari had similar issues but wole found a way |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:40pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: What happened?
You are ashamed on behalf of the guy abi?
Don't lie..... Christiannorth summarized everything |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:37pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
ChristianNorth: Wole (father of technicalities) and Ikpeazu would have won this case against Ustadz Usman or at least get something better than this, though they are likely to lose at the trial and lower courts because of our electoral act.
In SC everything is possible because they have the power to set and set aside precedents. All you have to do argue intelligently and use technicalities. While Onnoghen Supreme Court relies mostly on the merit of the matter and natural justice to arrive at their judgement, Tanko's Supreme court is just unpredictable.
They don't know when to use technicalities, precedents and equity.
I have never seen a court so useless.
Anyway, Bayelsa judgement is apt and their finest in recent times. Kai,for the third time i agree with you though its an afterthought.one of the mistakes apc made was to use rookie and inexperienced lawyers to handle such a sensitive and delicate case compared to the veteran ustaz who destroyed atiku at the pept.i wont be surprised if those lawyers are related to degi and lyon.too many mistakes.this was a fifty fifty case,an open one that could go or swing either way.a brilliant and adept lawyer like ikpeazu good at marshalling arguments viva voce would have gained the upper hand |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:31pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
Iamgrey5: I understand your point, but a judge could have easily given another verdict tbh
It's not like the case is extremely solid.
The judgment is based on the discretion of the judge but she chose to resolve the case again the defendant. I agree.its what i have been saying.its just like the tribunal judgment in osun state |
Politics › Re: Full-text of the Supreme Court Judgement on Bayelsa by Dansuqi: 9:24pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: dansuqi garfield1 blindersoff ybalogs Caseless Kai |
Politics › Re: How Imo Governorship Election Verdict Generates Judicial Crisis by Dansuqi: 5:19pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: With all the cash spent....I pity him sha....Just read the full judgement now...the degi guy is a crook. Where can i find it? |
|
Politics › Re: How Imo Governorship Election Verdict Generates Judicial Crisis by Dansuqi: 5:12pm On Feb 15, 2020 |
fergie001: I know. Did you forge your certificate from UNICAL? NO....so why will you want them to forgive APC....they messed up, that's the truth. I know they messed up.its a pity.i wonder how lyon is taking it. |