Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 7:47pm On Feb 25, 2021 |
shadeyinka: The case of Alamo is a massacre, I do not see any meaningful outcome to those who died horrible deaths in the hands of the Mexicans.
I agree that the finality of death has nothing to do with the nihilistic position. The Nihilist position comprises both when a man is alive and after he dies. The Nihilist doesn't separate between the state of living or dying.
In other words, The Nihilistic position negates meaning, purpose and value both when alive or dead. The battle of the Alamo was not a straight up massacre. The Alamo defenders even though out numbered 6 to 1 repelled 2 attacks and killed 600 of their opponents over the course of under 2weeks while surrounded and cut off from retreat or reinforcement. You asked me if there was any reason to fight even when defeat is guaranteed, the Alamo defenders saw a reason to do so. |
Christianity Etc › Re: End-time Alert: The 5th Seal And Persecution Of Christians by LordReed(m): 5:58pm On Feb 25, 2021 |
Dtruthspeaker: C'mon now, you do not need to be crafty.
I was very clear as to what I said and my words are recorded here. I asked a question do you have an answer or not, calling me crafty doesn't answer the question. Besides do you want us to return our previous aggressive interactions? |
Christianity Etc › Re: End-time Alert: The 5th Seal And Persecution Of Christians by LordReed(m): 5:27pm On Feb 25, 2021 |
Dtruthspeaker: My Bible said obey your earthly Rulers for they Rule for your Good, To Bring You Goods.
But it verily Also said that when they do not Rule for our general and collective good, they will and must be Thrown Out of their Rule! Where did it say that you should disobey earthly rules because you don't like them? |
Christianity Etc › Re: End-time Alert: The 5th Seal And Persecution Of Christians by LordReed(m): 5:16pm On Feb 25, 2021 |
Dtruthspeaker: For LGBTQ, The Law is "Give to each, his due" but however, it is Understandably Reasonable that "No one will reasonably permit or allow a filthily dressed person to enter into their house or office. As soon as he is spotted, he shall be turned away.
That is the Natural Barrier and Resistance already Pre-placed by our Creator and Ruler against the doing of anything that He does not want done.
In fact that is the Fastest Way of Identifying a thing that should not be done.
On Quarantine Laws, the former quarantine laws was sufficient and it did not go against any other Law, but the Remake is Already Unlawful for "A law which unreasonably commands the doing of that which is not good, is No Law" For The Law is Always for the doing of that which is good.
On Disobedience to The Law, your first question should be which Law or Whose Law. Is it The Creator's Law or the law made by your fellow Brother man?
Without having to write a textbook the short answer is All The Creators Laws Are Good, Perfect and All Encompassing, All Embracing and Completely Exhaustive and No One has Any Reasonable Complaint against them, (which Can Not be said about Any man-made law, which is why you all always say, that "the law has loopholes and flawed" ) hence Everyone obeys them and is compelled (bound) to obey them.
Man did not make laws for and over his fellow man neither did he have power or right to do so, (he can only do so for his own creations such as phones, cars, laptops etc) he only needed to find and uncover The Laws which the Creator has Already Pre-Commanded, Pre-Made and Pre-Issued, which is my job and the job of All Lawyers.
And all the good laws that man claimed to have made, contained in your Acts and Laws and Edicts, where Already Pre-Set by God, The Creator of this world and man. So man's repeat of the Laws of God was null and unnecessary.
However, men did a Trick on all the peoples of the world and deceived them, they said and proclaimed that the laws which they had "made" was Complete and Exhaustive and Superior to any other Law in the world, even providing a Difficult Means to Ensure its Alteration is Not Easy, which they called the Constitution, Decree or any other name they so wish to call it!
Then they further secured their deceit in saying that "Anything not contained in the Constitution or their own laws is UNLAWFUL".
This is Not True and therefore this is the weakness of all man made laws in which apart from the fact that his laws have power only over his creations like Toys, cars, phones etc since I am not a creation of man, therefore, No man has power over me (Unless It is The Power of God which means that he is applying and executing God's Laws over me and not his own weak laws)
Therefore, I am Free to Disobey him and his fake laws, where God's Law does not encumber me. Your bible told you to obey your earthly rulers, even your Jesus did so but here you are turning everything on its head. Anyway its not a surprise its you peoples way, you can use the bible to justify anything. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 4:19pm On Feb 25, 2021 |
shadeyinka: I wasn't defining you sir. I was only putting it down the way I understand it. If I misrepresented you, I am sorry - you may correct me if my impression is wrong.
Can we get back at the issue at stake.
Is a war meaningful or purposeful if I am guaranteed victory in the the first hundred battles but assured of ultimately loosing the war!? First off the finality of death has nothing to do with the nihilistic position. The Nihilistic position negates meaning, purpose and value, the finality of death does not negate any of the 3. Yes war can be meaningful even if the outcome is a guaranteed loss. Remember the Alamo. |
Food › Re: Cook In Your Kitchen, Take Pictures And Post It Here. SIMPLE! by LordReed(m): 4:03pm On Feb 25, 2021 |
mariahAngel: Fresh ginger and garlic?
Your taste bud is so brave! Yep. LoL. I do like trying out new culinary tastes. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 9:34am On Feb 25, 2021 |
shadeyinka: I know that the OP, HellVictorinho, LordReed are not comfortable with (and reject) the label Nihilist even though the position of atheism naturally gravitate towards it. It's like me rejecting the thought of me dieing someday. It must happen, my refection not withstanding! When you look the totality of existence from an atheists mind, Nihilism is the conclusion. However, when you narrow existence down to the microlevel of day to day choices, an atheist like you want to see it as meaningful, purposeful.
If unfortunately, it's like winning the small battles but ultimately loosing the war. I will rather loose 1000 battles but win the war.
That's why I said: Even if you don't like the idea (and ultimately it's a paradox), shouldn't all men be Nihilists?
I like to define Nihilism as: The basic idea of nihilism is that life ultimately has no purpose or meaning.
I see it like playing an indefinite Russian Roulette were with each round of success, you are paid $1 million. If perchance you survive till the 100th round (with $100 million credit) and the 101th bullet is live, is such a game of any advantage to the player!
Of course, no intellegent person likes the idea of Nihilism. Would I have missed anything in life if shadeyinka died at 1year 2 months? So what am I gaining that I have lived into adulthood?
I understand you position: An atheist like you would not want to allow the Nihilist philosophy from defining your total living existence (it is fatalistic): but separate day today positive choices you make as meaningful You don't get to be in my head and define me. I am the one to tell you what I think and to define myself to you. If you persist in trying to tell me what I think then we can end the conversation. I do not discuss with people who do that. |
Food › Re: Cook In Your Kitchen, Take Pictures And Post It Here. SIMPLE! by LordReed(m): 9:00am On Feb 25, 2021 |
mariahAngel: Hahahahahahahaha
If you scoop out your avocado (in a little bowl), then squeeze in some lime or lemon juice (half or whole) with a little salt, you'll enjoy it with bread.
The last one I did, I added fresh tomatoes...I surfard while eating it  The one I did had lemon, onions, garlic, ginger, turmeric, pepper and salt. Used it for bread and rice, delicious. |
Christianity Etc › Re: End-time Alert: The 5th Seal And Persecution Of Christians by LordReed(m): 8:47am On Feb 25, 2021 |
Dtruthspeaker: Though he said evil laws are targeted at Christians and their so called churches, which is not the whole truth but I do add that it is targeted at all.
I hate seeing them and I do not immediately recall any of them but as it is said "In order to boil a frog, it is put in a pot of cold water and the pot put on the fire".
That is what is happening to the people of the earth.
Eg Promotion and Sanction for any State which does not support homosex, transgender and all those things which used to be abhorred.
Visa refusal for being against these kinds of persons.
The law of Unreasonable Imprisonment for 30days on a mere allegation of offence/crime in opposition to the Natural Law of Presumption of innocence and Freedom, after all the accused can be ordered to appear at the investigative offices to answer any question they need cleared.
One state in the east passed a law that you can be imprisoned at the pleasure of the governor, The Quarantine law has been amended to include punitive conditions rather than do it's job of bringing healing to the sick, this and many other new laws have been created which did not exist before. Why do you want to discriminate against LGBTQ folk? Why do you want to break quarantine? Is not in your bible that the law is for those who hate or are disobedient? |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:41am On Feb 25, 2021 |
shadeyinka: All these arguments came about because I said that :
All atheists should naturally gravitate toward Nihilism LordReed ,HellVictorinho and probably even you Buda protested.
And I said, if man is star dusts and he returns to s[quote author=shadeyinka post=99401156]Eccl 2:11: "And I looked upon all my works my hands made, and upon the labor I labored to do, and behold, all vanity and striving of the spirit, and no profit under the sun."
If life ends here on earth, shadeyinka also gain nothing after death!
Even if you don't like the idea (and ultimately it's a paradox), shouldn't all men be Nihilists? tar dust, what has he truely gained? I used the analogy of the lottery t illustrate:It is like a man who won hundreds of millions in several lotteries only to loose the whole money in one single day!
Has such a man really gained anything? Other than for those who believe in resurrection, Shouldn't ALL men (irrespective of their religious inclination) be Nihilist?My argument is that you can't choose to be the kind of Nihilist you desire to be (cosmic Nihilist , moral Nihilist , Existencial Nihilist or another type). It's either one is a Nihilist or NotThe OP himself in his opening said: The OP apparent solution (to the paradox of Nihilism) was to say: My solution to this paradox is to separate the meaninglessness on a universal level from the logic that exists in the reasoning of the individual human life. Emotions asides: why should a man be a non Nihilist if like a candle he end up still loosing his greatest asset in the bet to continue LIVING?[/quote]There no where were it is stated that all atheists must be Nihilists. In fact most atheists I have heard speak reject Nihilism. Unless you don't understand that Nihilism is the negation of purpose, value and meaning then I don't see why you think the finality of death is a Nihilistic position. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 5:58am On Feb 25, 2021 |
HellVictorinho: Even shadeyinka gains nothing after death. Seems he imagines he does. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 5:55am On Feb 25, 2021 |
budaatum: My Lordreed, is this person ono and co who despite all the evidence are shouting kraken?
He sure argues like them! Indeed my dear buda. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 10:33pm On Feb 24, 2021 |
shadeyinka: Oh I see why you mix things up. There is a difference between 1. You having a purpose on earth as a living system and 2. You making a purpose
You have spoken of you creating a purpose BUT I ask you for your own purpose as a living system.
Is your purpose to generate CO2 for plants? Is your purpose to reproduce?
My question is, if you then have to die and become star dusts once again, what have you gained? As far as I am concerned there is no grand purpose for me as an individual. My purpose as I create it for myself is made up of lots of limited purposes. I don't gain anything. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Comet Ison Is Approaching by LordReed(m): 6:09pm On Feb 24, 2021 |
MrPresident1: Protect your skull What are you protecting in that empty skull of yours? |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 4:24pm On Feb 24, 2021 |
budaatum: I had a purpose to sleep at some point and have since become the beneficiary of that purpose. They are so focused on miracles they miss the ones right in front of them. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 10:35am On Feb 24, 2021 |
shadeyinka: If the purpose of an engine is not to consume fuel, how then can the purpose of man be to eat?
Actually , it's the reverse! The purpose of food is to fuel the body of man! The purpose of our teeth is to masticate hard food for easy digestion.
What then really do you think is the purpose of man if he is just star dust and will return into becoming star dust? You are only focused on some grand purpose. Purpose does not have to be grand, you can have several limited purposes. I have a purpose this morning of attending a meeting, once that meeting is over that purpose ends. Same with eating, it ends once hunger is satisfied. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 9:27am On Feb 24, 2021 |
shadeyinka: Is the purpose of an engine to consume fuel and lubricants? No but it has components which have that purpose. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 9:09am On Feb 24, 2021 |
shadeyinka: Humans are the ultimate beneficiary of crankshafts.
You don't need to see the crankshaft as long as it does it's purpose of converting linear motion of the piston to rotary motion! Even then, that is the purpose it was engineered for by its designer, usually humans don't care as long as the final engine fulfill its purpose! Even if there is no human there to see or benefit from the crankshaft it will do what it does. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 9:01am On Feb 24, 2021 |
shadeyinka: It is impossible for a Tree to know it's purpose because it doesn't benefit directly from its own existence. But without the Tree, carbon cycle, oxygen cycle, food chain ceases to exist. On the earth, the trees purpose is to convert the solar radiation to food and oxygen for life to exist.
A crankshaft has a purpose within a crankcase of an engine. It's purpose is to translate the linear motion of the piston into rotational motion.
Purpose is thus a fallacy without at least one beneficiary of the system! If you are not there to see the crankshaft does it still have purpose? |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:56am On Feb 24, 2021 |
JackBizzle: Nice.
Here are some of my counter points to you and sochaux.
1. One needs to define nihilism and the type of nihilism to be addressed before discussing nihilism.
2. Cosmic nihilism is what I am talking about and I like the definition given in one of your links
that there is no benevolent God watching over humanity, and that, in the vast scheme of the cosmos, stretching out to infinity, humanity and the individual are less than insignificant; indeed, nearly unnoticeable and invisible.
3. Regarding point number 2, I separate the cosmic level from the individual level. There is meaning in the individual level because we as humans have reasoning and can create our own meaning.
4 Just like the cosmic level, the quantum level has no meaning. At the quantum level, your fingers can't really touch anything. Things pop in and out of existence. A microuniverse that is indifferent and uncaring to everything we think we know.
In summary, we both agree about the individual being able to create meaning. I am not a moral nihilist or epistemological or existential nihilist.
Where we disagree is in the universal level. And l echo Sochaux in saying it doesn't matter. As long as you agree that the individual can create meaning then the cosmic level is subsumed in the individual purpose. The cosmic level doesn't and can't give meaning so there no point in looking out there for it. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:52am On Feb 24, 2021 |
shadeyinka: The examples of Eating, growing, reproduction are NOT purposes. The purpose of a diesel generator is not to drink engine oil and consume fuel. The purpose is to generate electricity!
Purpose and benefits cannot be disconnected from one another.
I asked, But shouldn't atheism necessarily gravitate towards nihilism? They are purposes even though they are limited in scope. Once you have eaten and are satisfied you have fulfilled that purpose until you need to eat again. Asked and answered. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:43am On Feb 24, 2021 |
IamPlato: we are talking about humans not other stuff. But who told you a cotton bud is not significant? Have you heard of the butterfly effect Then accordingly nothing is insignicant therefore the label significant is unnecessary. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:40am On Feb 24, 2021 |
shadeyinka: I think all systems have their purposes whether we are beneficiaries or not of the system. Do you agree with this?
Then, I think a way of looking at it purely from intellectual point of view is to ask the question:
1. Can a system which operates in a self fulfilling cycle be purposeless? 2. Can we agree that for there to be a purpose of a system, there must be a beneficiary!
Three questions sir!
Cc: LordReed 1. Purpose is a concept held in conscious minds. It describes something that is happening. The thing it is describing exists whether or not there is someone there to describe it. 2. See 1 above. As budaatum alluded to before a tree falling in the forest makes noise whether or not someone is there to hear it. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:35am On Feb 24, 2021 |
IamPlato: if you are an evolutionist then you believe that something creates man... There is a starting point, in your own belief where is the starting point for man That is not the position of evolution. Evolution says nothing about creation. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:35am On Feb 24, 2021 |
JackBizzle: Reread the comment again. I did, that's why I can't figure out why you think I must wear the nihilist label. I don't support the nihilistic position of the negation of mean, purpose and value, the lack of inherence not withstanding. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:32am On Feb 24, 2021 |
shadeyinka: But shouldn't atheism necessarily gravitate towards nihilism?
If all we do is be born, eat, grow, reproduce and die. Is there really a purpose for human existence.
If we are just star dust, could there be a purpose to us? Not if you want to enjoy your life and have less mental anguish. Eat, grow, reproduce are all purposes so you may be contradicting yourself. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:30am On Feb 24, 2021 |
JackBizzle: You gave the wrong link and I just took a quote from there. Budaatum put the right link and I have read it now.
Why not posit something yourself? Why must I respond to Sochaux? Or even at least, take a quote from him and explain it yourself? Intellectually lazy.
Nevertheless, Sochaux engaged in using strawmen. He debated against 5 responses that he assumed nihilists would give if questioned.
Another response on that same quora link stated that one should get a meaning of nihilism or pick the type of nihilism before discussing nihilism.
Guy, I can't respond to everything Sochaux said because many are strawmen, if you are really interested in discussion, pick one thing and lets talk I didn't ask you to respond to Sochaux, I said we should discuss after you've read his response. I did so because he more eloquently speaks about some of what I tried to say and more than adequately deconstructs some of the flaws of the nihilistic position. The way he deconstructed the nihilistic position that value is a meaningless thing is one of the ways Sochaux echoes my thoughts. That somethings ends does not make it valueless. Another thing I would like to add is purpose, meaning and value are all concepts that can only be held in conscious minds. The universe is not conscious so to expect it to have these things is absurd, this however doesn't mean these concepts cannot be had or held. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 8:04am On Feb 24, 2021 |
IamPlato: imagine you were the first man with the first woman and the question "why are you here" drops in your head, what will be your answer?
will you say you are here to survive? bro surviving is not a purpose, a purpose is meant to be significant or remarkable or a land mark.
if surviving is a purpose then the purpose is never achieved because no man survives, every one dies.
take the first man and first woman for example, their purpose is to reproduce and explore and educate the children created from reproduction, that is what you call a purpose.
they can choose to stay without doing all these and stay without giving a meaning to their existence. Purpose doesn’t have to be significant. A cotton bud for instance is insignificant and so is its purpose. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 6:02am On Feb 24, 2021 |
JackBizzle: My point exactly- Then why persistent with labeling me a nihilist when I am clearly not one. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 5:59am On Feb 24, 2021 |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 1:40am On Feb 24, 2021*. Modified: 2:04am On Feb 24, 2021 |
JackBizzle: From your Sochaux-
Cosmicism states that there is no benevolent God watching over humanity, and that, in the vast scheme of the cosmos, stretching out to infinity, humanity and the individual are less than insignificant; indeed, nearly unnoticeable and invisible.
Do you not agree with the above sentiment?
If your answer is 'yes', then you are a cosmic nihilist. This is not from Jon's response. Read Jon's response in the linked page then we can discuss. EDITED |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Paradox Of Nihilism- A Problem For Atheists And Humanists by LordReed(m): 10:03pm On Feb 23, 2021 |
JackBizzle: False.
If you are an atheist, you are a cosmic nihilist.
Tell me, do you believe that there is any meaning on the universal level? Do you think we are significant in relation to the size of the universe? Read the response of Jon Sochaux here: https://www.quora.com/What-is-cosmic-nihilism |