Obinoscopy's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Obinoscopy's Profile › Obinoscopy's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 (of 479 pages)
Peck and hug Takes away the knife |
Katsumoto: Nations that fought for their independence along ethnic lines tend to be more stable than nations that were forced into a union.Source please. A study need to be done to confirm this. |
Iaz93: Obinoscopy ur presentation was cool...katsumoto u'r good..Thanks laz, thats the beauty of nairaland. A place where great minds meet |
coded guy: Even though I already felt that the amalgamation was a mistake before the debate started I duff my heart for Obinoscopy. At a point he was already convincing me but the point where Katsumotu highlited the fact that as a result of the amalgamation there were too many diverse interest as per religion, ethnicity, political ambitions won it for me.So I almost convinced you ![]() Thanks, I must say I learnt a lot from my opponent and the audience as well. Thats the beauty of a constructive debate. I however still stand on my ground ![]() |
proudlyafrican: [b][/b]Very true. That was the point I was trying to make |
coogar: i was quite impressed too.....Thanks coogar, and you were right about Katsumoto, he's truly a rebel ![]() Well I knew most Nigerians are of the view that the amalgamation was a mistake thus I knew I had to be more persuasive, but I evidently dwelt more on persuasiveness to the detriment of the other factors to be considered in the debate |
Jarus: Obinoscopy, very great account of yourself. You surpassed my expectation. For an argument nobody gave you a chance and against an almighty Katz for that matter.Yeah, I knew I chose a difficult side. But I must admit Kats is good and might still even if we switched sides |
dayokanu: I must say I was impressed by the way Obinoscopy handled the topic, He picked a topic thats considered a poisoned chalice and he delivered with itThanks ![]() |
Kudos to everyone. I really learnt a lot. Katsumoto is really a scholar, I'm humbled by his wealth of knowledge |
nex: @CrazyManYou have my vote too ![]() Remember to share the money once you get the mantle of leadership ![]() |
Seriously sure ![]() Xion |
I beleive the debate thread on the amalgamation will be unlocked at a later date. We can continue with the argument there when the time comes ![]() |
My friend will you leave here now. Or do you want to pee on this thread? |
Katsumoto: You didn't answer his question.You don't seem to get me. I was refering to the natives. The natives had no such desires just like Nigerians never also had any desire (I'm happy you used that word Nigeria) |
[quote author=Malcolm-X]Why should national interests outweigh the people's interests? Don't you think you need to put your house in order before thinking about your community?[/quote]So would you put your house in order by dividing them or by calling an internal family meeting? |
Dede1: @ObinoscopyIts a pity I'm no longer using my laptop but my phone so I'll be brief The similarities is that of an abinitio selfish interest. The annexation in US was not to help the natives per se but to facilitate revenue generation for them. The north was annexed to the south so that trade could get to the north. Agricultural produce and mineral resources from the north could be exported via the ports and thereby generate revenue. |
[quote author=Malcolm-X]While I agree that the balkanization of USSR brought more grassroot developments, good governance, wealth etc.. to the new nations created from the old soviet bloc. The power the USSR commanded in world politics is unrivalled by none of the countries that emerged from the balkanization of USSR. Don't you think the balkanization has made almost all the old soviet bloc countries(except Russia) irrelevant in world politics?[/quote]Even Russia has lost its grip on international politics as it would have under the USSR |
Katsumoto: Are you suggesting that balkanization was bad?Do you think USSR liked the fact that they were balkanised? They never did, rather their major enemy, the USA where the one's jubilating |
Katsumoto: I have given examples from all over the world to demonstrate why amalgamation was bad. You failed to present any countries that were forcefully amalgamated and which are doing well today, economically and without ethnic issues. I am waiting.I gave you the example of the US. |
Katsumoto: Nigerian regions traded commodities in that era. In the early 70s, commodity prices went down except for oil. But commodity prices rebounded by the early 80s. But did their revenues rebound in Nigeria? A big no. Is Nigeria a big exporter of rubber, palm oil, groundnuts today? We all know the answer to that question.We are no longer exporters of such commodities becaucse our corrupt leaders were content with the abundant revenues from crude oil |
cowgurl: Am feeling the dimension of this debate, so well done to the organizers.Yes O, I must win ![]() |
Katsumoto: I urge you to read my original posts again. It appears you did not really read them.There is no country that has an homogenous ethnic group. Show me a country and I will show you 2 or more ethnic group. And its okay for each ethnic group to have their own agendas, the most important thing is the ability for these agendas to be harmonised and a common point agreed upon |
[quote author=Malcolm-X]Another question for you: Do people have to be from the same country just because a few individuals inter-marry, or help individuals across the different ethnic groups; when the union of the ethnic groups has stagnated growth due to tribalism and nepotism? If so, don't you think Nigeria and Ghana, or other Western countries Nigerians inter-marry with should also be amalgamated?[/quote]The point I was trying to raise here is that the Igbos and the Yorubas can live together as one |
And if I may ask, after the division along the Northern and Southern Protectorates, what next? Do you think the SW won't want to divide from the SS and SE. Even within the SS, they'll want to divide along their ethnic lines vis a vis the Ijaw nation, the Itsekiri nation, the Urhobo nation, etc. Even the North will be futher partitioned as the NC don't see themselves as homogenous with the Hausa. Even hostilities exist between the Hausas and the Fulanis |
Katsumoto: But sharia is at odds with the constitution and it shouldn't be so. The way the country is structured, there can't be different rules for different people.The constitution was made for Nigerians and not the other way round. The constitution is really flawed as our leaders failed to realise the need to hold a consultative meeting with all Nigerians to fashion out a constitution that will favor everyone. This can be done without the need for us to divide |
Katsumoto: Why should revenue from Bayelsea be sent to Zamfara if Zamfara believes that it can enact its own laws which are at variance with the Nigerian consitution. You can't eat your cake and have it.Again, you've just indirectly exposed the inadequacy of our leaders. They've failed to diversify our economy. Our present president if from Bayelsa, why don't he seek to commercialise the minerals from Zamfara and accrue the revenue into the federal account so that they don't milk Bayelsa dry? |
[quote author=Mynd_44]Are you sure?[/quote]Yes because I casted my vote there in his vault ![]() |
Katsumoto: If each region was responsible for its revenue and only contributed a small fraction to the center, then the center wouldn't be so attractive.Even if the centre is not attractive, what is the guarantee that those regions will use the money judiciously and accountably? Thats the point! Good governace is the issue not amalgamation |
Katsumoto: What comes first, the cause or the effect. Address the root cause and some of the problems go away. Corruption can never be eradicated. It is the degree to which it is killing Nigeria that is the problem.The people wouldn't be concerned about Zamfara if their Governor can create Jobs for them with the 'meagre' resources accrued to them. If the Governor can build infrastructures with his lean purse, if he can build hospitals and schools. If he does that, I can bet with you that the peopl will not even remember that Zamfara exist. |
[quote author=uj_sizzle]I-hate-you-for-rejecting-me Slap[/quote]Sowwy, dearie. I never rejected u ![]() *A I-Am-Sorry Kiss* |
Demdem: na wa ooo. i didnt envisaged this. No yawa, will read sha.Abeg try read everything |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 (of 479 pages)





